Independence Hall
Philadelphia, Pennsylvania
August 1784
"Order!" Thomas Jefferson, President of the United States Congress, beat his gavel on a desk covered with papers. "The delegate from Delaware will please refrain from calling the delegate from New Jersey vulgar names. We are gentlemen!"
"I wasn't referring to my colleague," Eleeazer McComb rasped. "I meant his entire state!"
In the resulting shouts Thomas Heyward leaned towards his lawyer. "I see nothing's changed."
"Politics rarely does," Adams agreed. He stood. "Mister President!"
Jefferson looked at the gallery and beat his desk again. "Order!" Once the shouting died away, he grimaced across the room. "Mister Adams, sir. I was told you would be here, but I did not countenance it. You expressed disgust with the proceedings last time, if I recall."
"I did," Adams replied. He lifted his head and raked the delegates with his gaze as they turned in their chairs. "With all respect to the seat, while I am sure we are all enlightened by Delaware's insight into where the Enemy keeps his chamberpot..."
"On the second floor," Tom said.
"...we come to this Hall on urgent business and request the house be brought to order. If you can, of course." Adams smirked.
"I can," Jefferson retorted. He glanced to the next seat over. "General Heyward. It has been many years since you've graced us with your presence. I wish it were under happier circumstances."
"I'm certain."
"And may I applaud you on your choice of representative? Never was there a man with greater ... persuasive ... skills." Jefferson smiled coldly.
"Oh no, Mister President. I cannot hold a candle to you when it comes to persuading others to do your will, no matter how well advised," Adams returned.
Many of the delegates stared back and forth, amused at their sparring.
The president's smile faded. "General Heyward, you are here because we have heard disturbing rumors about your conduct and hope you can satisfy us. Given your previous time here as well as your rank I've been prevailed upon to ask Congress to investigate this matter directly rather than convene a military tribunal. Do you agree?"
"I will answer your questions," Heyward replied.
"Please step forward and take the oath."
Heyward rose, wearing the full dress uniform of the United States Army: blue, white and red. Without looking at friend or foe he crossed the room, hat tucked under one arm.
Having been sworn in, he sat in a straight backed chair at a small table on the other side of Jefferson from his clerk, a young man with pen nervously squeaking in mad chase of their words. John Adams found a chair with the New York delegation, smiling.
"Very well." Jefferson looked through his notes. "General Heyward, you abandoned your army in Cherokee Country. Why?"
"Don't answer that!" Adams snapped.
Jefferson narrowed his gaze. "Excuse me?"
"Question presupposes General Heyward's guilt! It leads the delegates into a certain way of thinking....unintentionally I'm sure."
"This is my hall," Jefferson warned softly. "Do not think you can sit there... what is it, Mister Jay?"
John Jay, the New York delegate and a judge, rose. "While no law seeks to control the direction of a judge's questioning, perhaps Mister Adams is right and a more neutral tone should be sought."
"While we're at it, perhaps it's inappropriate for Mister Jefferson to ask questions," Adams continued.
Jefferson glowered. Even Jay arched his eyebrows. The lawyer smiled. "Withdrawn."
"Mister...General Heyward," Jefferson murmured, still looking at Adams. "Records suggest you left your army. Is this true?"
All eyes turned to Adams, who sat back and stared at his client.
"Yes."
"Are you getting this?" Jefferson asked his clerk.
"Yes, sir!" the young man piped, still writing.
"Alright, General Heyward. Yet it was 'your' army, meaning you were assigned overall command?"
"Ye..."
"Mister President!"
"Yes, Mister Adams?" Jefferson growled.
"I would like the record to reflect General Heyward was given command by Mister Edward Rutledge, God rest his soul, who lacked the authority to appoint command above a regimental level?"
"You are not here to give testimony, Mister Adams!"
"No, sir. I am here to protect my client!"
"Mister Adams, you will have the opportunity to question your client when I am through!"
Adams sat back and grinned. He turned to Heyward. "You commanded?"
"Yes."
"Why did you leave?"
"It was necessary."
Adams leaned forward. Delegates frowned.
Jefferson paused, then turned. "The chair recognizes North Carolina."
Richard Spaight stood. "What possible reason could you have for abandoning our boys, sir?"
"There was danger."
Adams's jaw dropped. Delegates stared in horror.
"You ran away from danger? You, sir, are a coward!" Spaight spat.
"No!" Heyward snarled, life flowing into him for the first time. "I ran towards it, you simple minded heathen! The trouble is in Charleston, not some God forsaken mountain fighting people we have no quarrel with..."
"Sir," Jefferson interrupted, "John Rutledge is the one who petitioned Congress for action following numerous raids..."
"He lied, or someone lied to him!" Heyward retorted. "There were no raids!"
"That's not what my principals say," Spaight said stiffly.
"Then your principals are deceived. The South Carolina border is stable, or it was before
we went in!"
Jefferson held up his hand. "Mister Pinckney, can you comment?"
Pinckney frowned. "General Heyward is mistaken, your honor. South Carolina experienced considerable trouble in the last few years."
Philip Waymouth glanced at him. "You personally saw this?"
"No, sir, but I saw the prisoners from these raids."
"Prisoners we captured," Tom retorted.
"General Heyward!" Adams interrupted. "So there was danger towards home. Did you tell anyone you were leaving?"
Jefferson opened his mouth, but decided to let the question go. It would help focus the room.
Heyward answered in a monotone. "Yes."
"Who?"
"General Allen. I left him in command."
The room relaxed. This was a little better anyway.
Jefferson continued. "If you felt the need to go home, why didn't you ask for leave?"
"Why should I?"
"Because a general can't decide he's tired and wants to go home!" Spaight snapped.
"Mister President!"
Jefferson spun. "If you're going to testify for your client again, I will throw you in irons right now!"
Adams opened his mouth, shut it and sat.
Tom looked up. "The only one I could have asked would have been Rutledge. I went to confront him. That made asking for leave impossible."
Waymouth reluctantly shook his head. Jefferson caught the motion. "Massachusetts?" Adams shot him a look.
"That isn't quite true, sir," Waymouth said slowly. "There was always General Arnold. He
is our Commander in Chief."