Virginia
November 1784
"Sir, I wish it known for the record that I protest this decision in the strongest possible terms!"
Benjamin Lincoln leaned over the map, table and his commander. "You risk bringing unnecessary suffering upon people who have not only caused us no harm, but are our allies, and thus bringing shame to the very institution of the United States Army, not to mention Americans everywhere!"
Major General of the Army Benedict Arnold held his temper in check only by gripping the table very, very hard. He glared at Lincoln, eyes nearly bulging, his face bright red.
"Are you done, sir?" he asked coldly.
Lincoln straightened and saluted, though his left fist clenched involuntarily. "Yes, sir."
"Your objection is noted. Fear not, I have no intent of exposing you to fire."
"Sir!" Lincoln turned first pale, then bright red. "If you think I protest because I am shy, then you are right out! Further, I must ask for an explanation."
"Certainly." Arnold leaned back. "Mobile. Georgia. Savannah." Lincoln commanded the disastrous southern campaign that sent the southern army reeling before General Exeter's relentless advance in the last war. "Defeated repeatedly by a cripple. And now you seek to counsel
me on strategy!? What balls, sir!"
"I don't know what you are insinuating, but I resent it!" Lincoln shouted. "I nearly lost my leg on that campaign, sir! I do not mind telling you, since it is unfortunately obvious to anyone with eyes, that my ankle troubles me
all the time. Further, you do not need to remind me of my failures. I see the faces of those who died under my command most every night. Exeter may have been a cripple, as you say, but he was no fool and harried us relentlessly. I could have gone for reinforcements very easily, but instead I sent my subordinate to safety to raise us a fresh force while I stayed with our men for every single mile of that God damned march! Does that sound like cowardice? You go too far!"
"Perhaps," Arnold admitted grudgingly. "I have, on occasion, flew out." He inhaled. "Have a seat, General."
Lincoln's face stilled and he straightened again. "I'd rather stand, sir."
"Hm."
Well, nothing to be done right now. "Very well, General." He clasped his hands. "As I said, I don't intend to expose you. Take that as a reflection if you wish, but the truth is I am aware of the risks you laid out in angering Virginia, and since this is my decision, it is I who should be in the vanguard if there is trouble."
"And I?"
"I thought to place you in command of the rear, with the Pennsylvania, New Jersey and Virginia men. The Virginians don't need to know we're confronting their own militia, and the others form the bulk of the army. That way if there is trouble you can withdraw north of the Potomac and alert Philadelphia."
"Philadelphia. Sir, if you will not take my counsel will you not listen to Congress? We haven't heard back from them, and..."
"What do a pack of merchants, lawyers and politicians know of war?" retorted Arnold. "No, sir. It is beyond reason that we should not advance because Virginia does not want to get involved. They will stand aside, and we will take care of our business with the Carolinans."
Lincoln shook his head, but remained silent.
"You have your orders, general. Should we succeed, you will form up and join me starting midday tomorrow. Naturally all men are to be reminded these
are nominal allies, and so not to be put upon in any way, shape or form."
"Of course." He saluted, spun on his heel and stalked out.
"You handled that very badly," Arnold told himself as the flap shut.
Well, he can try to put a hole in me later if he wants. After Carolina falls.
He turned to his map, lifted his quill, paused, then smiled.
He can try.
*******
The witching hour found the stealthiest and quickest of the Third Massachusetts trotting through the open fields along the western edge of Colchester, Virginia. A bright harvest moon lit the scene almost as well as dusk, the waving, dried stalks of grass blue-grey under their feet.
The wind hissed, masking their advance as they slid between the wood bars of one fence. It might have masked their scent too, for a dog howled mournfully from one darkened house but offered no pursuit. The air stank of rotting seaweed.
Pretty though, and Sergeant Jared Oakley had smelled far worse raising pigs near Springfield. He breathed easily, used to long runs, and when he looked behind him he saw the dark, bobbing shapes of his men. No one lagging. Good. He could almost be at peace if he didn't know what was coming.
After forty minutes they reached the wooden bridge crossing the Occoquan River. If anyone there challenged them...well, this would get significantly uglier. He held one hand out, palm down, then thrust towards the dirt and his men fell into the grass.
Nothing. No light, no calls. Something splashed into the river. He looked around, but they might have been in their own private dreamscape. Trees, misshapen without their leaves, rustled in the freshening breeze. Behind them the dog howled.
Four men across the bridge at a careful walk, boots echoing despite themselves on the hard wood. Eight more took up positions behind hedges on either side, ready to contest anyone trying to force their way past the last eight. Oakley glanced at the sky, trying to guess how much time had passed. One hour after they left the rest of the army would march along the Cape Fear Road through the middle of Colchester: No sense even trying to hide the advance of several thousand men.
Oakley paced across the bridge to the men guarding their southern flank. "Anything from Woodbridge?" He squinted, trying to see the distant town.
"Nothing, sir. Not a light."
"Good. Keep me informed."
"Rider coming," hissed Nicks on the north end. Oakley could hear it too - rapidly approaching hoofbeats on packed dirt and stepped across.
The rider, cloaked against the night wind and astride a dark horse, galloped towards the bridge but stopped upon seeing eight soldiers standing in front of it. They didn't raise their weapons. No need with the rider covered by their hidden brethren.
"What is the meaning of this?" demanded the rider. A masculine voice, adult but not old. Twenties or thirties, Oakley thought. "Stand aside!"
"Return to your home, sir."
"I have business in Woodbridge! Let me pass!"
Like warning them we're coming? "Not tonight you don't, sir. Return to your home!"
"Ruffians! Think you can just block a road?" He held up his crop. "I'll teach you some manners!"
"Brave words," Oakley replied. "Ready!" He spoke in a conversational tone, but eight muskets immediately flew up to cover the rider.
The rider paused and lowered his weapon.
"The bridge is closed, sir," Oakley said firmly. "Go home."
He snarled and immediately galloped to the west, away from both soldiers and town.
"So is the ferry," he grinned.
*******
Dawn found William Grogan sipping at tea (the only way for any civilized person to wake up) and looking over his fields. The harvest was all but done. Three or four more days hard work and he could settle in,
Rattling from the kitchen told him his young daughter Amelia continued her epic battle to put together a satisfactory breakfast. She came out now, all of six years old in a plain blue smock, holding a bowl of porridge in both hands and over her head as if it were the Holy Grail. His wife stood behind her, smiling.
"What is this now?" he asked, putting down his tea.
"For you, daddy!" piped Amelia. In her excitement her grip wavered and he snatched the bowl away.
"What a good girl," Grogan purred, rubbing her hair. He looked up at the pounding on his door. "Now who the...who on earth can that be?" His wife started towards the door, but he shook his head and stood. If someone was calling for him at dawn then it couldn't be good.
Ban, a thirteen year old barely old enough to be in the militia, jumped as he opened the door. "Master Grogan! The Americans are here!"
"I know. They've been in Colchester for a few days now. Waiting for Philadelphia to send them home, I reckon."
"No, Master Grogan! They're on
our side of the river! There's a million of them!"
"What!?" He stepped outside into the cool, morning mist and squinted. Slightly downhill by the river, flanking the bridge, underneath a handful of proud banners flapping in the orange-grey air. "Lord!"
"Will there be a battle?" Ban demanded excitedly. "Can I come?"
"God forbid, and yes. Wake your pa too, if he isn't up already. Tell everyone to meet me in the green!"
*******
Benedict Arnold squinted through his spyglass at the distant village. Men tumbled out of their houses with muskets and a few hunting rifles. Some wore hats against the chill, few bothered with uniforms. He had nearly two thousand men across, arrayed in a rough semicircle to guard the bridgehead, with more coming all the time.
"Steady, men!" he called, trusting his commanders to relay the message. "Do not fire unless fired upon. I don't care how they provoke us! We don't want a fight here!"
Hopefully they are smarter than they are proud. To his acting adjutant: "Major, let me know when the New York First is completely across. We will parley...no, stay." Arnold shifted his glass to the right, where elements of the Massachusetts Second converged on Woodbridge. Overnight they'd seized Gordon's Ferry and so crossed to flank the town. "Stay. I think we've given them enough to think about."
9:00, 8 November 1784
By now the Virginia militia had more or less formed on the outskirts of town, pivoting slightly to face the new threat. One rider, either on his own initiative or by order, broke and galloped south towards Richmond.
"I suppose that couldn't be helped," Arnold muttered. "Very well. Major? Form an honor guard and come with me."
Twenty men, a large number in case the nervously shifting militiamen should try any mischief or feel unduly outraged, flanked General Arnold as he galloped towards the main Virginian line and stopped just outside comfortable musket range. The Virginians raised their muskets almost to a man, and for one unpleasant moment he thought they might risk the throw anyway.
"What the devil!?" Behind him some fool shouted an order,and the Third Massachusetts surged into motion, a thousand footsteps making the ground vibrate. "Major! Go back there and stop those men!" If the Virginians panicked... "Honor Guard! Stand down. Do not draw your weapons unless attacked!"
After a little over a minute the wayward regiment ground to a halt again, and a tense silence ensued. The wind whistled, teasing Arnold's hair as he studied the militiamen: Farmers most of them, with little training if any. That didn't mean they couldn't shoot, however. Unless one lived in a major city, one pretty much had to be a good shot to survive out here. Nervous, though...
Finally a small party or five men rode out to meet them, one flying the state banner over his head.
"Colors!" Arnold commanded, and the American flag spread, flapping as the breeze freshened.
"William Grogan, Captain, Virginia militia."
"Benedict Arnold, Major General in Command."
They exchanged polite salutes, Grogan a little more coldly. "May I ask your intention for crossing the Occoquan in force?"
"Yes. We are marching through Virginia on the way to North Carolina. We have no intentions regarding Woodbridge or your entire state."
Grogan shook his head. "General, I spoke with who I took to be your adjutant, a Major General Lincoln. I explained to him that my orders from Williamsburg are to bar any passage down the Cape Fear Road by northern militias or the Army. I regret the inconvenience, but..."
"So I was told," Arnold agreed. "Now you may tell Williamsburg that you did your utmost to fulfill your duty. I will testify to that effect. We are coming through."
"With respect, sir, my orders do not permit it."
"Captain, I advise you to look around very carefully. We
are coming through. If you contest it, we will be forced to defend ourselves and neutralize the town. That would be exceptionally unpleasant for both your people and mine. The resulting fight would also cause great suffering and death. So far no one has been hurt. I earnestly want it to remain that way."
Grogan looked around uncertainly. So many guns... "I cannot yield, sir."
Arnold shook his head. "And I will not. Captain, your men are fine fellows I make no doubt, but they are not as well trained as mine. I also see some boys over there who really shouldn't be fighting except to defend their homes. I give you my word, your town does not interest me. We are merely passing through and wish to do so in peace. Withdraw now and you can keep your weapons and your honor."
"This is a very blaggardly thing to be doing, General," Grogan snapped.
"It's a blaggardly world," Arnold replied. "Now, may we pass?"
"I have no choice."