• We have updated our Community Code of Conduct. Please read through the new rules for the forum that are an integral part of Paradox Interactive’s User Agreement.
Ah, the old demand unlawful territory. If you give in the the Emperor every time, you will never expand inside the HRE. Last time I played Brandenburg, I pretty much ignored him.

And yes, pay off those loans. The interest payment is never good. Especially when you are trying to hire good advisors. Every ducat counts.

Huzzah for a cog!! :D

I definitely have some balancing to do and gosh I hate balancing. :D

My ballots for both the YAYA's and Q4 Awards are being worked on. I should be able to get them in before the deadline, I just don't like posting things before they're ready.

Awesome! Thank you and everybody else for getting your ballots ready for the 2023 YAYAs! That's The 2023 Yearly AARland Year-end AwAARds,

Ticking off the Emperor and the Pope, a bold strategy! ;) Although I guess their demands are mostly bluster? As someone who never learned the ropes of EU4, I'm even more in the dark than you as to how things will shake out. Keeps it exciting!

I'm enjoying learning by proxy, both through the gameplay and the insightful comments from the EU4 vets here in the thread.

Yeah - in the same update! :D But yes, it's been apparent for a while that some of these powers have less power than they pretend to. But then there's the day when they decide THEY have had enough of YOU. Hmm...

Great to hear you're enjoying it! Now go tell us what Capt. Picard is up to in your AAR! :p

And yes, it's great to have good detailed comments from others. I learn, you folks may learn stuff, and it's great exchange.

Thanks everybody! I'll try to get an update going in the next couple of weeks.

Rensslaer
 
  • 2Haha
  • 1Like
Reactions:
Well, what does it mean when they go republic and then adopt feudalism? Does that make it not a republic? Or just a weird republic? haha - sounds contradictory.
Feudalism and being a republic are not mutually exclusive in this. Feudalism, as the game defines it, is an institution. Institutions will spawn throughout the game and give maluses to tech cost if you don't embrace them. Rugen's province probably already had Feudalism unlocked, but the newly released country needed to embrace the institution.
Btw my parents and coworkers in Denver are suffering some pretty extreme temperatures this week/weekend, so I'm imagining that Idaho must be pretty frigid also? Denver is below zero fahrenheit Saturday through Monday I think.
It's anywhere from a few degrees below freezing to a few above. And it's snowed every night since Sunday. The NWS says there's going to be a storm from tonight until Saturday. Denver is at higher elevation, so it's probably much colder than here atm.
 
  • 1Like
Reactions:
It hasn't been that long since I did feedback response, but it seems like there's alot to catch up on!
A nice ‘problem’ to have! ;)

ps: one of the cooler summers we’ve had in a while so far. Very wet and temps not getting above the mid-30s Celsius. Quite a bit of flooding all along the eastern seaboard. Unusual for an El Niño year, which this is meant to be, which would be extreme heat, drought and bushfires.
 
Last edited:
  • 2Like
  • 1
Reactions:
Feudalism and being a republic are not mutually exclusive in this. Feudalism, as the game defines it, is an institution. Institutions will spawn throughout the game and give maluses to tech cost if you don't embrace them. Rugen's province probably already had Feudalism unlocked, but the newly released country needed to embrace the institution.

It's anywhere from a few degrees below freezing to a few above. And it's snowed every night since Sunday. The NWS says there's going to be a storm from tonight until Saturday. Denver is at higher elevation, so it's probably much colder than here atm.

@jak7139 That makes sense, then about Feudalism. I hadn't really thought of Denver's elevation having much to do with it, but of course it would. I know Washington state is warmer much of the year than Denver, despite being further north. It had never occurred to me that Idaho might be also. Obviously alot of Idaho is probably NOT at a lower elevation than Denver, but where the cities are... :D

A nice ‘problem’ to have! ;)

ps: one of the cooler summers we’ve had in a while so far. Very wet and temps not getting above the mid-30s Celsius. Quite a bit of flooding all along the eastern seaboard. Unusual for an El Niño year, which this is meant to be, which would be extreme heat, drought and bushfires.

@Bullfilter I started doing some quick figuring when you were talking about El Nino and the Eastern Seaboard. I had thought you were an Aussie, but I now live along the US Eastern Seaboard, and we talk about El Nino alot. But then again El Nino affects all the weather, and of course Australia has an Eastern Seaboard, and extreme heat, drought and brushfires sounds like California, not the US Eastern Seaboard. And after your mention of your service I figured the Leopard tank was probably used by the Royal Australian Armored Corps, but just to make sure, I looked it up and so it was (which I found very interesting to know!). Of course you mentioned summer too. Anyway, where in Australia are you?

I ran into an Aussie tank guy here in Georgia last year, and started a conversation with him. He said they're using M1s these days. In another conversation I initiated with a US armored veteran (can you tell I love talking about tanks? :D) I found he used to serve in the Patton tanks, and I was proud of myself for remembering those were the M48s.

Thanks!

Rensslaer
 
Last edited:
  • 2Like
  • 1
Reactions:
Let's hope that Austria doesn't feel the need to enforce their unlawful territory complaints. That does have a bit of basis in OTL, although the emperor often had allies (notably the Swabian League). The Reformation kind of killed that for a while, though.

As for Rugen, could the republican government be due to the Hanseatic League? That's my best guess for why it would be a republic.

It's nice to see this back!
I had thought that holding unlawful territory meant an immediate declaration of war from the Emperor. Seems like I was incorrect?

Looks like you can have unlawful territory and not immediately get an unwinnable war declared on you? (though you'd still get the other penalties)
 
  • 2Like
Reactions:
I had thought that holding unlawful territory meant an immediate declaration of war from the Emperor. Seems like I was incorrect?

Looks like you can have unlawful territory and not immediately get an unwinnable war declared on you? (though you'd still get the other penalties)
@Black Watch And all this time Nusantara could have been diplo-annexing HRE territory and you could have gotten away with it! :D

Rensslaer
 
  • 3Haha
Reactions:
Okay @Historywhiz this sounds like a good story, if you want to tell it! :D I haven't played far enough to have experienced trouble, but I can imagine, now that I think about it, I'll want that territory back eventually.
And spoil the surprise? Nah, I’ll let you find out the hard way why Rügen is only released if you have no Baltic coast and hate everyone that does.
 
  • 3Haha
Reactions:
@jak7139 That makes sense, then about Feudalism. I hadn't really thought of Denver's elevation having much to do with it, but of course it would. I know Washington state is warmer much of the year than Denver, despite being further north. It had never occurred to me that Idaho might be also. Obviously alot of Idaho is probably NOT at a lower elevation than Denver, but where the cities are... :D



@Bullfilter I started doing some quick figuring when you were talking about El Nino and the Eastern Seaboard. I had thought you were an Aussie, but I now live along the US Eastern Seaboard, and we talk about El Nino alot. But then again El Nino affects all the weather, and of course Australia has an Eastern Seaboard, and extreme heat, drought and brushfires sounds like California, not the US Eastern Seaboard. And after your mention of your service I figured the Leopard tank was probably used by the Royal Australian Armored Corps, but just to make sure, I looked it up and so it was (which I found very interesting to know!). Of course you mentioned summer too. Anyway, where in Australia are you?

I ran into an Aussie tank guy here in Georgia last year, and started a conversation with him. He said they're using M1s these days. In another conversation I initiated with a US armored veteran (can you tell I love talking about tanks? :D) I found he used to serve in the Patton tanks, and I was proud of myself for remembering those were the M48s.

Thanks!

Rensslaer
Yes, Canberra, the national capital. M48s!? That’s a while back! The M60 was the one in between them and the current M1 of course, with a similar development period to the Leopard 1. El Niño/La Nina is pretty much the major determinant for eastern Australian weather patterns and is a big thing over here.

When I was at the Regiment, we saw a promo video for the then XM1. It was priceless, with iirc mil jargon catch phrases such as “when servicing targets within the weapons envelope” on a “typical mission profile day” and the classic euphemism “should the turret suffer ballistic overmatch” (ie a sabot round has just ripped through the turret into the fighting compartment) when discussing the onboard fire suppression system. :D We used to joke you’d be able to just hose it out, patch the hole and slip a new crew in, too easy! Naturally, humour tended to be rather dark about such things: early 80s, when we all assumed WW3 was just around the corner. Tanks appealed as they offered more protection than a green shirt when the artillery was falling and if you were going to have a glorious death in battle you may as well drive to it than have to trudge all that way for the privilege.
 
  • 1Haha
  • 1Like
  • 1
Reactions:
@Bullfilter That's engineer wonk talk there! lol "when servicing targets" (aka "when blowing stuff up") and "ballistic overmatch". Wow.

I was never in the military, but I have always studied military equipment and history, and I was in Civil Air Patrol, which is kind of like "air scouts" for the teenagers, and also does alot of search & rescue. I did search & rescue between ages 16-20 about, and it was really busy back then in Colorado (those mountains catch planes). We had our own aspects of military-esque. I was appointed as ACO (Acronym Control Officer), and we had gallows humor, too, such as "Bad pilots are a self-correcting problem." :)

Oh! And I was reminded to mention this because of an explosion in the distance. Now that I've moved to Savannah, I live a couple of miles away from the Ft. Stewart M1 exercise and live fire range. We regularly have our windows shaken by tremendous booms. :D The base entrance, if I wanted to go on base without wire clippers, is about 45 minutes away. But yeah it extends practically to my house.

Rensslaer
 
Last edited:
  • 1Love
  • 1Like
  • 1
Reactions:
@Black Watch And all this time Nusantara could have been diplo-annexing HRE territory and you could have gotten away with it! :D

Rensslaer

Darn *snaps fingers*, what a wasted opportunity for Nusantara! Just imagine all those Malays from Southeast Asia going to Europe, diplo-annexing HRE territory, and eventually becoming Holy Roman Emperor! :D:p

I wish I could say something relevant to the campaign or offer advice, but I have never played inside the HRE, and only twice in Europe (one game as Spain and one as the Ottomans).

This is proving very educational for me, though.
 
  • 3Like
Reactions:
Obviously alot of Idaho is probably NOT at a lower elevation than Denver, but where the cities are... :D
Very true. Idaho follows the same example as humans throughout history: settle by the rivers. The rivers naturally have cut away the mountains, making those places flatter than the rest.
 
  • 1
Reactions:
Friends, another update is in process. I kind of hope that after this update I can start playing again and putting your good advice to work! :)

So.... I started playing in September, I believe. And I'm using the subscription service where I get all the DLCs so long as I'm paying. Do I need to be careful, as I continue to play, not to have new DLCs showing up because it'll break saves? Anyone recall if there are any new DLCs since September?

Also, this... The first screenshot of my update I'm spending Splendor. Honestly I don’t know what Splendor is. I even tried to look it up and didn’t get good answers. Something to do with purchasing abilities, which are specific to each “age” (of history), but I don’t even know where my amount of Splendor is shown! Thoughts? Assistance?

Rensslaer
 
  • 3Like
Reactions:
Quick answer re dlc: I don’t get the sub but have two long-running games where a patch broke the saves. I then just rolled back to the previous version and played with the beta to keep going. I guess the choice then is to either keep to that and freeze your dlc progress for the duration of the AAR or, if that’s too long and you play games separate to the AAR one, fast track the AAR game, bank the saves and resume to the updated version? If the sub set up allows that.

There’s an icon somewhere on the screen, up the top iirc (on my iPad atm) that you can click on that shows all the age objectives (rather like missions) and also how much splendour you have and the bonuses you can spend it on. one of my Frisia AAR chapters has screenshots of the Age display. If you can’t find it I’ll take some shots for you next time I’m on the computer.
 
  • 2
  • 1Like
Reactions:
So.... I started playing in September, I believe. And I'm using the subscription service where I get all the DLCs so long as I'm paying. Do I need to be careful, as I continue to play, not to have new DLCs showing up because it'll break saves? Anyone recall if there are any new DLCs since September?
There's been one new patch/DLC since September. I think it should still be fine as long as you didn't click the checkbox for Ironman.
Also, this... The first screenshot of my update I'm spending Splendor. Honestly I don’t know what Splendor is. I even tried to look it up and didn’t get good answers. Something to do with purchasing abilities, which are specific to each “age” (of history), but I don’t even know where my amount of Splendor is shown! Thoughts? Assistance?
Splendor (link to the wiki article on Splendor/Ages) can be spent on certain buffs for each Age (you are currently in the Age of Discovery). The Ages will progress throughout the game when certain criteria are met (like the Reformation, or certain Institutions becoming unlocked). You get a base amount of splendor growth, and can gain more through certain ideas or completing certain objectives during each Age. If you can complete three objectives in an Age, you can enact a nonce-per-game "Golden Era" which lasts fifty years and provides you with some bonuses.

(Ignore the fact that the screenshots below are from a mod, it still applies to vanilla).

Screenshot (6531).png


Screenshot (6532).png
 
  • 1Like
  • 1
  • 1
Reactions:
Patches and DLC always breaks AAR games. In fact, AAR games break anyway. For any reason.

I really enjoy playing Lancaster in CK2 but every single version I have attempted to write up (and there are 5 recorded on this bloody site) has been destroyed by mysterious forces.

In the end, it did lead to me writing my first madcap comedy, but I also think CK2 being 'finished' is just a trap baited for me to write version 6 so they can break it again.
 
  • 3Haha
  • 1Like
Reactions:
Patches and DLC always breaks AAR games. In fact, AAR games break anyway. For any reason.

I really enjoy playing Lancaster in CK2 but every single version I have attempted to write up (and there are 5 recorded on this bloody site) has been destroyed by mysterious forces.

In the end, it did lead to me writing my first madcap comedy, but I also think CK2 being 'finished' is just a trap baited for me to write version 6 so they can break it again.
Yeah, my CK2 game was broken, but I did find using a recent (uncorrupted) save (even though it was ironman, I'd made periodic save copies just in case) and sticking to a non-updating beta version saved it. Even if I could no longer get ironman achievements (which I didn't really care about anyway). Started in Sep 17 and still going fine ... it helps that I'm not playing other side-games and getting 'itchy' about using older versions.
 
  • 1
Reactions:
Friends, another update is in process. I kind of hope that after this update I can start playing again and putting your good advice to work! :)

So.... I started playing in September, I believe. And I'm using the subscription service where I get all the DLCs so long as I'm paying. Do I need to be careful, as I continue to play, not to have new DLCs showing up because it'll break saves? Anyone recall if there are any new DLCs since September?

Also, this... The first screenshot of my update I'm spending Splendor. Honestly I don’t know what Splendor is. I even tried to look it up and didn’t get good answers. Something to do with purchasing abilities, which are specific to each “age” (of history), but I don’t even know where my amount of Splendor is shown! Thoughts? Assistance?

Rensslaer
Splendor is used to gain bonuses in each of the four Ages of EU4, and at the start of each new age the Splendor counter resets, you lose the abilities from the previous age, and new ones become available.

All countries gain a small amount of Splendor every month, but you gain more by completing age goals listed in the Eras tab, as long as the goals are fulfilled.

In addition to the era abilities all nations can unlock, in each era there are four abilities unique to countries that were historically powerful in that time period. For example, there's a powerful navy-related bonus that only Great Britain can get (they still need to meet the Splendor requirement.)
 
  • 2
  • 1Like
  • 1
Reactions:




As we enter into 1453 we’re given the opportunity to host a joust! I kind of like the idea of increasing the Morale of Brandenburg’s armies by 10% for 20 years, increasing Army Tradition, and increasing yearly Prestige.



We couldn’t easily afford the 21 ducats, and from what you’ve been saying I’m not so sure about the Admin Power. But it seemed worth it to get the improvements to my military, considering I intend to be at war from time to time and there are some empires around me that aren’t exactly slouches.

Honestly I had to ask you what the Splendor is. I understand it is gained over time, I think boosted depending on achieving missions(?), and can be used to purchase perks, which are specific to each “age” (of history). Maybe I’ll get to use some more Splendor and purchase something-or-other in the next couple of updates.

Speaking of not-slouches, Behemoth Lithuania is there, and we decide to improve relations with them to head off any unforeseen troubles in the future.

In 1454 the now tiny little Wolgast allies with Brunswick, one of my rivals. That could prove an irritation if/when we go to war with Brunswick. It could also prove quite handy in rounding out Brandenburg’s northern coastlines.



Charles I comes to power in a goodly portion of Europe relatively nearby to me. Burgundy isn’t a major concern for me right now, or so I think, but it bears minding. We begin improving relations with Burgundy.

And we get a new Pope in September 1454. Clemens VII issues a Papal Bull to increase liberality. The Renaissance begins to spread more quickly, and Florence embraces it. It’ll take a while to migrate north.



In November I decided to rebalance the Crown Lands, and ticked a lot of folks off. Most notably the Clergy, and this precipitated a revolt (which I had expected and prepared for). The rebels were quickly put down.

During 1455 Friedrich II did make some efforts toward improving the economy, and by the end of the year our monthly income had increased to a more comfortable level. The younger Friedrich, the Crown Prince, also acquired the Strict trait, improving Bandenburg’s Discipline for once he takes power.

The Pope excommunicated the ruler of Venice, but we barely took notice…

In 1456 there was a silly revolt that caused us a fair amount of trouble, but which was eventually resolved. Also in that year Denmark annexed Holstein, which didn’t make Friedrich II particularly happy.





Also that year Friedrich II resolved that he was going to undertake some diplomatic ventures with regard to the Holy Roman Empire. For the next couple of years (and beyond?) Brandenburg sent envoys to improve relations with each of the HRE Electors, in hopes of someday having more influence with regard to the Emperor.

In 1456 Castile conquers Granada, evicting the Mohammedans from the Iberian Peninsula.



And Brandenburg adds a second +1 advisor, improving Administration this time.

In 1457 Austria embraces the Renaissance, first, and later Sweden. It’s coming to Brandenburg too, but slowly.

That same year Friedrich II decides to accept an alliance with Wurttemberg, thinking that it might come in handy. There was another annoying rebellion – this time in Stralsund – killing more of my soldiers and taking some time to put down.



Many of you had advised a race to improve tech levels, and this was one that I had pursued prior to your advice. But in the future I will be more deliberate about chasing these jewels. I’ve always understood how important technology improvements are in Paradox games, but for some reason I allowed myself to get distracted by the many other uses of Power Points. In 1457 we may be a little late for acquiring Pike Squares, but I still think I’m ahead of almost everyone.

Our pursuit of better relations with HRE Electors is coming along well. By the beginning of 1458 we have 166 relations with the Palatinate, second only to the current Emperor’s Austria. We’re at 171 with Trier – only 34 points behind Austria. We’re Cologne’s 3rd choice, but still very respectable.

The Iberian Wedding occurs, and Castile enters a Personal Union with Aragon and Navarre. It had briefly fallen out of Great Power status, but now regains its place.



And meanwhile a new Pope (again!) is elected – Innocentius VIII.

As time wore on toward the final quarter of 1458, Friedrich II started to feel like it was time to test out his army and their new Pike Squares in combat. It had been 7 years since the war with Wolgast. Friedrich had been itching to take Rostock, Brandenburg’s core within the Kingdom of Mecklenburg.



But Mecklenburg had friends. Luneburg (meh) and Scotland (hmm) and Poland (Hmmm…). And, of course, it appeared that Poland would take their side if there were conflict, and not ours (Brandenburg also having a current alliance with Poland).

Then there was another possibility. Stettin was an irritating enclave into otherwise Prussian territory…

 
  • 1Like
  • 1Love
  • 1
Reactions:
The Iberian Wedding occurs, and Castile enters a Personal Union with Aragon and Navarre. It had briefly fallen out of Great Power status, but now regains its place.

Mm. Should be the richest and most powerful country soon then, if it keeps the union.

Speaking of that screenshot...


England has already nearly conquered Ireland and still has all their starting lands in France. Potentially looking at a very powerful England, meaning Scotland wasting time on a foreign war would make GB more likely to happen sooner.

Both strong castile and England are good for Brandenburg now though, because it means France and Austria have far bigger problems than Germany.
 
  • 1Like
  • 1
  • 1
Reactions:
But it seemed worth it to get the improvements to my military, considering I intend to be at war from time to time and there are some empires around me that aren’t exactly slouches.
The Last Jousting Tournament is always a no-brainer decision for me. The cost is cheap and the bonuses are powerful.
In November I decided to rebalance the Crown Lands, and ticked a lot of folks off. Most notably the Clergy, and this precipitated a revolt (which I had expected and prepared for). The rebels were quickly put down.
I like to seize land whenever possible so that the estates remain weak, the crown remains strong, and more privileges can be handed out. The "sell titles" button next to that can give you some cash for war or paying down loans.
we may be a little late for acquiring Pike Squares, but I still think I’m ahead of almost everyone.
The early game mil techs are really strong. And the difference between having it and not can decide wars (something to look out for if any of your rivals don't have tech 4/5/6 yet). There's also a page in the ledger, "nation's technologies", that just lists what everyone has.
And, of course, it appeared that Poland would take their side if there were conflict, and not ours (Brandenburg also having a current alliance with Poland).
Defensive calls-to-arms always apply first. So yes, Poland would join against you. However, if you can build up enough favors with Poland, you can have them break their alliance with someone. You can also call Poland into some other war, then declare on Mecklenburg. Since Poland is already on your side in the first war, they can't join against you in a different war (just make sure you finish the Mecklenburg war before the first war, because Poland can still join once they aren't helping you).
 
  • 2
Reactions: