• We have updated our Community Code of Conduct. Please read through the new rules for the forum that are an integral part of Paradox Interactive’s User Agreement.

Riaelyn

Captain
73 Badges
May 12, 2014
306
222
  • Crusader Kings II: Charlemagne
  • Crusader Kings II: Monks and Mystics
  • Stellaris - Path to Destruction bundle
  • Europa Universalis IV: Mare Nostrum
  • Stellaris: Synthetic Dawn
  • Europa Universalis IV: Pre-order
  • Victoria 2: Heart of Darkness
  • Victoria 2: A House Divided
  • Semper Fi
  • Europa Universalis IV: Res Publica
  • Hearts of Iron III: Their Finest Hour
  • Hearts of Iron III
  • For the Motherland
  • Europa Universalis IV: Call to arms event
  • Crusader Kings II: Sons of Abraham
  • Crusader Kings II: The Old Gods
  • Crusader Kings II: Legacy of Rome
  • Crusader Kings II: Rajas of India
  • Crusader Kings II: The Republic
  • Crusader Kings II: Sunset Invasion
  • Europa Universalis IV: Wealth of Nations
  • Crusader Kings II: Sword of Islam
  • Darkest Hour
  • Crusader Kings II
  • Europa Universalis IV: Art of War
  • Europa Universalis IV: Conquest of Paradise
  • Europa Universalis IV: Rights of Man
  • Stellaris: Digital Anniversary Edition
  • Stellaris: Leviathans Story Pack
  • Hearts of Iron IV: Expansion Pass
  • Steel Division: Normandy 44
  • Europa Universalis IV: Mandate of Heaven
  • Hearts of Iron 4: Arms Against Tyranny
  • Hearts of Iron IV: Death or Dishonor
  • Age of Wonders III
  • Europa Universalis IV: Cradle of Civilization
  • Stellaris: Humanoids Species Pack
  • Crusader Kings II: Reapers Due
  • Hearts of Iron IV: Field Marshal
  • Hearts of Iron IV: Colonel
  • Hearts of Iron IV: Cadet
  • Hearts of Iron IV Sign-up
  • Stellaris
  • Crusader Kings II: Conclave
  • Europa Universalis IV: Cossacks
  • Crusader Kings II: Horse Lords
  • Europa Universalis IV: Common Sense
  • Crusader Kings II: Way of Life
  • Europa Universalis IV: El Dorado
  • Victoria 2
I'll be firing up the summaries again for our multiplayer series. Between graduating from law school and studying for the bar, I didn't have time to provide updates last series (Mk. VII) like I had done before in Mk. V and Mk. VI. I find this highly regrettable as there was some extremely nutty builds and some serious seesawing on different fronts, but so be it.

As always, my posts will focus on the factual happenings. Strategy will only be discussed when it is painfully apparently and in the open to both sides as to what is going on in a situation. I give the baseline of what happens each session and a general overview while letting other members come in for the finer details and specifics of the theaters they are involved in. I culminate each series in a final, massive, wall of text post in which I review the saves extensively, flip over all cards, conduct a massive numerical analysis if necessary, and lay out the key moments/ decisions that shaped the outcome of the game.

The structure of our group is roughly 1/2 Germans and the other half representing a mix of different nations. This series is a rather large break from how we normally have assigned players to countries in the past. The Germans have generally been placed on land combat heavy countries in the past (Germany and USSR) while the non-Germans generally duked it out in naval warfare. To convince the Germans to do this I told them just to imagine ships as floating panzers. They seem to have embraced this concept for now. Although if they do continue with this line of thought we run the risk of nothing but fleets of super heavy battleships trying to encircle one another on the Pacific.

As far as the first session, there isn't much to report because this is a multiplayer group. We enforce historical war dates and the session ended shortly after the Marco Polo bridge incident. The most important thing from the session is the build order and tech priorities of countries but that is secret for now.
 
  • 1
Reactions:
Summary of Session II
Dates: Middle of '37- Sept 1, 1939

This will be the second Mickey Mouse post before the war action picks up and I begin doing summaries of real consequence. Once again, the most important information to share is build orders and tech priorities, but that is still top secret because this is a multiplayer game in progress and I'm writing these summaries as the game goes along.

Japan v. Nat. China:
Japan has beaten Nat. China (AI controlled) and used the seize the coast war goal (house rule mandated). No large surprises here.

Future of Europe:
We sit on the declaration of war by Germany (we use historical dates for the major declarations of war, minor declarations of war may only use a year or be optional). Thus, Germany's first move will be to whack Poland (AI controlled). Germany is only allowed to declare war on BeNeLux in '40 and Switzerland can never be declared on by any faction (both per house rules), thus, Germany's entry point into France is through the Maginot Line. While Germany may make a few probing attacks against the Maginot, it is highly unlikely that the invasion of France will begin in earnest until '40. The big decision for the Axis will be to decide when Italy enters the war. Our only real rule is that basically Italy needs to pop in just before France falls/ Paris taken. Italy will naturally hope to use this surprise timing and unleash hell on some (normally British) target somewhere. Germany must also use the historical peace decision and set up Vichy France.

Interesting to note is that we relaxed our rules about minors joining into factions. I believe all of the Axis minors are already in the Axis, thus this may put them at war. The Axis minors or Allies may not have prepared for this and it could prove to be a factor.

Also of note is that in some of our series, the Axis have contested North Africa hotly, while in other series the Axis have abandoned North Africa without a shot fired. What the Axis choose this time around remains to be seen.

Key Points for Next Sesssion:
1. Poland dies. (It's Poland, sorry Mr. B. We'll hold a moment of silence for kurwas and zlotys).
2. Invasion of France. While France is certainly not expected to hold out and win (we have house rules greatly limiting UK ground involvement) it will be interesting to see if it can pull off any upset victories or drain a fair amount of manpower from Germany).
3. Will Maestor's wooden shoes stop making constant clinking sounds over Teamspeak when he paces around nervously? Like seriously, the guy lives in a windmill, rides a bike everywhere, and loves his tulip garden. It's hard to get more Dutch than he is.
 
  • 1
Reactions:
To convince the Germans to do this I told them just to imagine ships as floating panzers. They seem to have embraced this concept for now. Although if they do continue with this line of thought we run the risk of nothing but fleets of super heavy battleships trying to encircle one another on the Pacific.

You cannot imagine how hard it was to convince Karsten not to build armor with Japan. Even now I do not dare skip a session for fear he will build armor.

3. Will Maestor's wooden shoes stop making constant clinking sounds over Teamspeak when he paces around nervously? Like seriously, the guy lives in a windmill, rides a bike everywhere, and loves his tulip garden. It's hard to get more Dutch than he is.

It's nice to finally be recognized as a separate nationality rather than being counted as one of those bike-thieving Germans. I may now consider regarding you as something other than rebel Englishmen.
 
  • 2
Reactions:
Summary of Session III
Dates: Sept 1, 1939- April 5, 1940

German Invasion Edition

This session featured many of the usual early German invasions.

In Poland: The Polish AI fell in about 2-3 weeks. In an unorthodox move, Germany fielded only panzer divisions against the Polish. This led to a slight gap in the line where the Poles were actually pushing towards Berlin for quite a bit. The Poles never seized any provinces of value and Poland was defeated.

In Denmark: Shortly after entering 1940, the Germans went after Denmark. British ships were contesting the Oresund but there was no naval battle. A pair of fallschrimjager parachuted next to Copenhagen but were defeated due to the British blockade cutting off any reinforcements to them. After this, the tide turned and Germany seized Denmark. As I'm currently on a un-aligned country, I was not able to see what caused the shift, nor what defeated the paratroopers.

In BeNeLux: Germany seized up these territories rather quickly. I believe Germany started the invasion of these countries sometime in February. Germany made it across all river crossings which could have posed issues rather quickly.

In France: Germany entered France through the usual route through the low countries. I believe that France held most (if not all) of their divisions within France proper for their defense. I regrettably had to leave at this point, but I left my game running, so I was able to pick up a save.

In Greece: Italy has conquered Greece.

In North Africa: Italy has joined the war and advanced towards Egypt however they have now backed off. As this happened when I was gone, I'm not sure if contact was made or Italy was merely investigating the British defenses in Egypt.

As for the next part, it is worthy of its own section.
I am going to have a hard time trying to convey the hilarity of the upcoming situation, but here goes:
So when I left, France was fully intact and Germany was just starting to make its advance into France. Now, Karsten and I have German lessons throughout the week, as I speak German flawlessly, and he is quite rusty. So to practice, we were discussing the savegame. I was talking about the small encirclement of Paris. Karsten fervently began insisting that it wasn't a small encirclement, but a "groß kessel". Now I know that all of the Germans are obsessed with kesseling things, so I assume he is merely exaggerating. But Karsten continues to insist that he can "smell the groß kessel with his nose", which I found absolutely ridiculous. I mean how could someone smell an encirclement with his nose? Thus, I had to investigate. As I looked at France, I could only see about 6 French divisions defending Paris. However, when I clicked on it, there's a full 35ish combat French divisons holding in there with a 87.5% overstacking penalty.

And thus, I have learned two things:
1. The French can mount one hell of a defense of Paris.
2. Never doubt a German when it comes to smelling a groß kessel.

And thus, that is where our session ended. With the greatest defense of Paris that I have ever seen. While the Baguettes will almost assuredly be worn down and lose, it wasn't for lack of trying.

Looking forward to next session, it is quite up in the air as to what the Axis will attempt. The usual suspects are normally convoy raiding, air wars, or invasions of North Africa. With both Germany and Italy now at war, the Axis could certainly try to turn the Mediterranean into a true battlefield. Also worthy to mention is that the minors for both the Axis and the Allies will be able to get involved shortly with the Battle of France drawing to a close.

As always, I encourage my fellow group mates to add in their experiences and fill in some of the holes.
And with that, session III is over and we look forward to next week week which is sure to be quite volatile with tons of strategic decisions to be made by both sides.
 
  • 1
Reactions:
1 weak Ger division was defending Stetin - in port was Ger fleet - UK fleet (much stronger) was waiting on the sea - polish troops were advancing to stetin. Imagine what would happend if AI PL get stettin - Ger fleet forced to go out and get destroyed by UK :)

Germany lost 2 paratroper divs in Denmark = UK lost 2 tank divs in France.
 
Haha, yes the Polish divisions managed to get within 150 km of Berlin, it was quite funny :p. I toyed with the idea of using paratroopers to force the German fleet out as the harbour was practically undefended, but it was deemed too gamey. With me having no further business in the baltic as I was unable to destroy the German fleet by port bombing due to the heroic german air defence everywhere I pulled out my infantry, ships and planes and focussed on France. Danish troops were no match for the German onslought and copenhagen quickly fell after.

In Egypt Italy scouted out the British defences and retreated before contact was made.
 
I like the humorous touch to your summaries Riaelyn:)

In regards to the defence of France I already mentioned that I wasn't expecting the germans to advance so quickly over the Ardenne!
Barely had time to position all of my troops behind the usual rivers due to the late DOW on Belgium. Great play right there by Germany!

Also thanx to Hakkelo that gave it all in order to provide some support on the ground, with his armoured corp, and in the Air over the Maginot line and else where needed.
 
Current Naval Loses
UK Loses
CV 1
BB 4
CA 2
CL 12
SS 7
TP 10

Italian Loses
BB 1
CA 2
CL 9
DD 6
SS 1

French Loses
BB 1
CA 2
CL 1
DD 3

German Loses
SS 6
 
Last edited:
Egypt 1.png
 
Summaries of Session IV and V
Dates: April 5, 1940- November 23, 1940

Overview: The tone of the last two sessions has basically been the same. The Axis continue to advance and the Allies play defense. The action was heavily centered around the Med, Middle East, Africa, and the skies over Germany.

In Egypt and the Middle East: German and Italian forces have taken Egypt following an amphibious invasion of Tel Aviv. One force advanced from Tel Aviv towards Alexandria. This linked up with Axis forces advancing from Italian Libya. The Axis took Egypt and some British divisions were lost in the process. Afterwards, the Axis advanced into Iraq but was halted. The British counterattacked causing the loss of 1-2 Italian divisions but I believe then lost one of their own. Paratroopers were also used by both the British and German and I believe both 1-2 divisions of paratroopers each. The British seem to still have some momentum and are pressing forward from Iraq towards the mandate of Palestine.

In Ethiopia: The Brits control Ethiopia (as a puppet) and hold the southern port. The Italians control the northern port following a successful amphibious invasion and are poised to possibly push into Ethiopia proper and take control of their former puppet.

Off the coast of Ethiopia: Serious naval engagements between the British and Italian navies have been repeatedly happening. The Italian are sporting fleets of modern heavy cruisers and light cruisers. The Brits use much more varied fleet mixes from carriers fleets to battleship fleets, to their own heavy cruisers and battlecruisers. The Italians were able to successfully secure the island of Socotra.

In the skies over Germany: British strat bombers hit IC centers and British/ Canadian interceptors continue to battle German interceptors. German interceptors do make contact with British bombers sometimes.

In the Atlantic: Germany has sent it submarines out into the Atlantic and begun convoy raiding again.

In British India: The Italians attempted a naval invasion of Karachi but a British fleet intercepted and sunk the invasion transports and the 1-2 (est.) divisions on board.

In the Mediterranean: Greece is controlled by Italy and the Axis own all of the Med except for Malta and Gibraltar. The siege of Malta continues with it being bombed regularly by the Axis but still holding out and making repairs.

Other areas of interest: Denmark is owned by Germany. Norway remains independent and neutral. All other conquests are historical unless noted above.

Analysis: There are some weeks where the game runs flawlessly and there are few interruptions from bugs and crashes. Then there is last week. Last week was crash-a-palooza, CrashCon2015, Krashkrieg (the Germans like this one), whatever you want to call it. I was keeping a count of the number of crashes and I believe we hit 8. As one might imagine, needing to restart the game rather repeatedly may slow down the advance of the game time just a wee bit.

Looking at the actual game itself, the momentum is with the Axis. Both sides are taking losses but the Axis are moving forward. The UK might be approaching a turning point soon. They were able to fend off the Axis invasion of Iraq and may move back into the mandate of Palestine. They also prevented an Italian invasion into Karachi. Of course the most important question is "who can handle these losses better?" but only time will answer that.

Naval action: This game has featured a sizable amount of naval action. In previous games we've not had an Italy as dedicated to a naval build as this game. It's hard to get a true gauge as to who is winning and by how much but Italy seems to be ahead in the Indian Ocean/ Gulf of Aden area. Germany also just started to convoy raid the Atlantic again at the end of last session. So far, no German subs have been sunk and are inflicting convoy kills. The UK will of course need to put a stop to the convoy raiding as soon as possible and look at retaking the Gulf of Aden. Both sides appear to still have plenty to throw into the fight even though losses have been sustained by both sides. It's hard for me to convey how many naval actions there were but there was quite a lot. To back this up, I'm providing the statistics from the ships sunk tab.

Naval losses:
Germany: 6 SS
Italy: 1 SS, 2 TP, 4 DD, 13 CL, 5 CA, 1 BB
U.K.: 7 SS, 13 TP, 7 DD, 17 CL, 5 CA, 6 BB, 1 BC, 1 CV

Perhaps the biggest question I have as to what started the Axis' Middle East campaign centers around their original landing at Tel Aviv. As I'm on the Soviets, I can't see what is going on. I can only review the saves and listen in on TS to hear the action of what others are calling out. Thus, I'm not sure if the Axis landing at Tel Aviv was contested or simply ungarrisoned. Of course, the easiest way to stop a naval invasion is to sink the entire transport fleet (as what was done in Kashmir). As the Italians are not using marines but only regular infantry for their landings, there might have been a significant missed opportunity of halting the Italian amphibious invasion of Tel Aviv. However, hindsight is always beautiful and without another member of our group filling it in, I'm unsure.

Looking towards the future: We still have just over half of a year until Barbarossa. Both the Soviet and German armies will need to be primed and ready to go on June 22, 1941. Japan and the U.S. will enter the picture on December 7, 1941.

Keys to next session:
1. Convoy raiding: The UK needs to stop the Germans and the Germans need to keep it going. If Germany can get to a point where it starves the UK of almost all convoys it will greatly aid Italy in its conquest of India and the Indian Ocean. If the UK can halt it, it can transfer additional ships from the home waters to help in the fight against the Italian navy.

2. Indian Ocean conflict: While there were several engagements, I blew the UK drew relatively even on the first one but then the Italians slaughtered a fleet of older ships. While it is unknown how many naval assets both sides still have in the Indian Ocean, both sides will likely be looking to reinforce/ repair their fleets and then go on the offensive. Any invasion of India will be harder for the Axis because they will be working outside the range of their airfields nor do they have carriers. The Axis will likely need to seize an airfield quickly then transfer over planes to be able to contest the skies.

3. Missing players: Stewart sadly had to miss the session which was a great loss to the Axis. Stewart was busy getting married to his wonderful girlfriend of 4 years: April. I've seen some pictures and they had a traditional American wedding featuring everyone sporting camouflage clothing and the firing of high-caliber, automatic weapons into the air instead of throwing rice. It must have been beautiful and it brings a single tear to my eye just thinking about it. Further, Matthias and Patrick were reportedly last seen in a bar drinking "bier". It's quite believable because if the Germans aren't talking about "kessling" things they're always talking about drinking "bier". Such as it is dealing with Germans.

And thus ends session IV and V. Next week we look forward towards fun as always.
 
  • 1
Reactions: