“This was a war where men perished. And for what? Glory? Territory? Such things are fleeting. This was a needless waste of life.” - Memoirs of Cnaive Vulturreno
The Umbrian War is largely accepted as the war that set the foundation for the later emergence of Etrusca as a major power in Europe. It marked Etrusca’s first large expansion since its founding.
Despite the importance that modern historians often place on it, however, few people cared about it when it was fought. According to many portrayals of the time period contemporary to it, almost everybody cares about, or is at least aware of, the war. This is blatantly untrue. The reason why many historians find this war important is because we know of the Etruscan rise to power that followed it.
In addition, despite the attention the war receives, no one is sure why it was fought. Some accounts speak of the Etruscans wanting revenge for Umbria’s support of Elbio during his revolt. Others speak of the Etruscans as warmongers, attacking Umbria for no reason. Still other sources speak of Etruscan cities demanding Etrusca liberate them from Umbrian oppression.
What is known is that, in September 457 AUC, Etrusca sent a letter demanding that Umbria hand over some border cities. Umbria refused, and war began.
Initially, the war went well for Etrusca. They captured the land that they wanted while losing no land of their own. Cnaeve Vulturreno, the current leader of Etrusca, sent a demand for peace to the Umbrians. While some Senators were against this, most were satisfied with their gains. Cnaeve, himself, was a member of Etrusca’s Mercantile Faction. As such, he despised war, as it was bad for business.
Almost everybody believed that the war was over then, but it was not. The Umbrians refused Cnaeve’s peace offer. The war would go on.
The Umbrians were in an alliance with both the Senones and the Sabines at the time. These three tribes combined all of their fighting men into an army 10,000 men strong. This matched the army that the Etruscans had managed to raise.
As the war raged on, many Senators were worried about the fate of their cities. Many of the cities were weakly defended, and they could easily be sacked. As such, the Senate began a great defensive building project in April 458 AUC. Many cities would gain walls. Ultimately, this didn’t affect the outcome of the Umbrian War, but it would prove to be immensely useful to Etrusca in the future.
Few men were left to defend the cities the war was being fought over, as the army was moved into indisputably Etruscan lands. It was theorized that the Umbrians would seek to force a quick end to the war in a decisive battle.
In May 458 AUC, they would find that decisive battle. The two armies met at Curtun. Ultimately, the Etruscans would be the first to retreat. However, the Umbrians had not won. They had underestimated Etruscan willingness to fight.
Image of the Battle of Curtun
Cnaeve hired mercenaries to keep the war going. Many of these would prove to be incompetent, but some were actually good soldiers. The incompetent mercenaries were quickly either fired or killed.
These mercenaries would join the main Etruscan force. This force would meet the Umbrian army at Saina on June 2, 459 AUC. Ultimately, they would inflict more casualties on their opponents than they suffered, but they were forced to give up the field. The First Battle of Saina is the origin of the term “Etruscan Victory”, or a victory won at too great a cost.
However, the army would quickly realize that they didn’t need to hold the field. All they needed to do was inflict casualties. Their strategy changed. Instead of fighting pitched battles, they would move to attack Saina, which the Umbrians were besieging and would not abandon.
They would inflict casualties at Saina. Then, they would retreat, before returning to Saina to inflict more casualties. They planned to bleed the allied army dry.
The strategy at the battles of Saina. Red lines indicate retreat routes.
This strategy would work for many months. The enemy troops managed to capture most of eastern Etrusca. In addition, they liberated their own territory. The strategy was working, yes, but it would only continue to work if Etrusca remained at war.
In 460 AUC, Lucius Bellius Porcius was elected the new Consul of the Etruscan Republic. He served the Civic Faction, but the majority of the Senate still supported the war.
Ultimately, however, the allied troops would retreat from Etrusca entirely. The Etruscan army gradually freed Etrusca. Then, they advanced into Plestia, the main city in the disputed territory. It was undefended. On July 27, 463 AUC, the disputed territory was taken.
Soon, the reason why the alliance had retreated became clear. They were fighting the Romans. Seeing an opportunity, the troops captured more territory in Umbria.
In the end, most of Western Umbria was ceded to Etrusca. On March 18, 465 AUC, the Etruscans had won the war. Despite this, the war had shown Etrusca how weak they were. They began preparing for war, raising new troops, in order to ensure a disaster like the beginning of the Umbrian War never occurred again.
Map of Etrusca and its troops after the Umbrian War