• We have updated our Community Code of Conduct. Please read through the new rules for the forum that are an integral part of Paradox Interactive’s User Agreement.
Intro New

alonsom13

Sergeant
Sep 19, 2021
63
41
Hello and welcome to my first AAR ever. This is a small project in the making, and any comments/suggestions are welcome. I have played EU4 for a long time, being one of my favorite games, but I don’t consider myself an expert. In a game where painting the map is tradition, I have various degrees of success on campaigns, but rarely playing beyond 1600’s. Only a few months ago I completed my first ever world conquest with Timurids -> Mughals.

My style of play is not the usual warmonger, but I do try to be effective when opportunity arises. Conquer one province with a (biggish) deceased tag, release as vassals, re-conquest, diplo-annex is a constant on my runs. Also I like to be efficient with resources (money, mana, time, you name it). I usually play on speed 2, constantly pausing and having pop-up / pause to events. I enjoy the diplo game too. Austria is considered great for that, and I indeed did several runs with as them, forming HRE tag and all.

Being an avid reader of AARs, more than once I thought about doing my own, but never decided to actually do it. While reading the last one from @mackwolfe ‘s (if you haven’t, do yourself a favor and go read them) that had a similar theme of diplomacy, I was encouraged to start one after commenting never having wrote one, and that’s why we are here. So thank you for the push, and hope that being a similar writing style won’t bother / bore the readers. Screenshots to show what is happening will be included, but not detailed too much.

For the AAR itself
I knew from the very beginning it was a going to be a diplomatic run, but I wanted to do a twist. So I looked to have more nations/tags at the same time. And while there are mods like shattered Europa/world, I’m not a fan/user wise to install them. So I did the closest thing I found: run a script to release all tags. And I mean ALL of them, see maps below.

Since it’s a different set-up, I went also with a custom nation, with game’s border for Florence/Firenze, but custom ideas aiming for maximum diplomacy. The goal is that the mainly ways of expanding the nation would be vassalizing/PUing. That’s where the name of “The mightiest pen” came up, since is, in theory at least, mightier than the sword. A few exceptions will be used at the start to consolidate the primary (and only) initial state, but after that, war should only be a last resort, and trying to NOT conquer provinces. (If I had given myself all the Tuscan State provinces, the script would have taken them away, but in hindsight it could had being used for re-conquest if I had cores with less AE, since tags kept their cores after the script, a few can and probably will consolidate pretty fast).

I tried using the most of the 800 points available for a custom nation to be able to be competitive at the start, otherwise this run won’t last long. What’s funny is that even after giving myself a 6/6/6, the moment I run the script, a series of changes in ruler happened (because of the script) so I had like 4-5 rulers on the same day. This will be addressed on the AAR for role-play perspective. The only change I made was giving back 100 legitimacy with console command (from the 20 due to dynasty change), again, to level the field on the diplo scale.

This campaign WILL be a challenge for me, in the sense that it won’t be an iron-man game to be able to run the script, and I will be tempted to save scum. Don’t like to do it, but as a perfectionist, it has happened in the past. That or rage-quit. So I will have to force myself to go whatever happens.

Welcome aboard and I hope you enjoy the ride.
 
Last edited:
  • 1Like
  • 1
Reactions:
welcome to see you try your hand at writing an AAR :)
 
  • 1Like
Reactions:
Chapter 0 – State of the known world New
Europe
1742939068648.png



British Isles
1742939135616.png



Iberia
1742939589473.png



France
1742939603010.png



Italy
1742939617391.png



Scandinavia
1742939631820.png


Eastern Europe
1742939648379.png


Anatolia
1742939662296.png



HRE
1742939689424.png
 

Attachments

  • 1742938914116.png
    1742938914116.png
    1,1 MB · Views: 0
  • 1Like
Reactions:
Chapter 1 - Matters of State New
Chapter 1 - Matters of State

It was early in the afternoon, and newly appointed Duke Manfredo Malpiero was reviewing the status of his dominion. Slightly above average (3/4/4) when compared to the other men, he knew his selection in these turbulent times was completely lucky based, with 4 designations being given and taken away on the very same day by the diet, after the murder of beloved King Gastone Spinola (6/6/6) and his hated Queen. The realm was in uproar for the demotion inside the HRE from kingdom to dukedom, to the point of the Duke having to issue proclaim of peace within the realm. (Firenze has a truce with Firenze until 1449, funny).

Being just, a trait that was evident within a few days in charge, he declared to follow the new traditions for the country chosen by his predecessor, including an effort to optimize and reduce the costs for any and all improvement in the realm, as well as secure the most brilliant and charming diplomats. In the generations to come, diplomacy was expected to be paramount, above any other ideas, including but not limited to fostering relations in quantity and quality, considering even reach the point of making other realms putting themselves under the gracious protection of the dukedom. Then and only then, an inward development would be expected to flourish exponentially.

1742940061784.png


To develop and unlock these ideas, the duke took several decisions on day one. He granted crown land to all the estates in exchange for support (+1 mana Admin/Dip/Mil, will seize land every 5 years until +30% crown land), recovering a bit at the end. Called the diet, gave privileges and chose advisors, securing cheap ones.

1742940135735.png


He immediately proposed a royal marriage to Burgundy, as well as sending a delegation to improve relations with France. But to be taken seriously among his peers, he also declared Bologna, Lucca and Siena as rivals, sending embargoes during his first month as ruler. The diplomacy focus was noted around the HRE, where a couple electors mentioned the duke could be deemed as a potential candidate to lead. (Completed mission Imperial Ambitions, giving an extra Diplomat, immediately put to improve relations with one elector at a time).

Duke Manfredo hired some mercenaries to keep the territory secure, but also with the hope to unify the entire Tuscan state as the foundation of a prosperous peaceful realm. “Si vis pacem para bellum” If you want peace, prepare for war. He also noted the allies of his rivals: Bologna (ally Pope), Lucca (Savoy), and Sienna (Venice). He was shocked when he receive letters from totally different countries being called an enemy of them: Naples, Modena and Corsica. The duke cursed the Neapolitans, since he expected -and was working to- have a royal marriage with them. He decided to move on with his plans.

On January 1445, he secured an alliance with the French right before declaring a war on Bologna to show strength, dragging the Pope. After wiping the Bolognese army on the first days, and with a siege expert (+3) leading the mercenaries, the duke was expecting the city to fall before the papal army could counter-siege Florence.
But in the following 2 months, an unlikely and quickly succession of events shake the duke plans to the core. First, the Poles elect a Jagiellon to lead them, forming a PU with Lithuania (Diplomat sent immediately to increase relations looking to ally/marry/support heir ad infinitum). Then the Burgundians fell to a regency (hoping for the Burgundian succession). Last, but not least, the ruler of Austria suddenly died, and thanks to his superb reputation among the electors, Manfredo Malpiero was chosen as the new Holy Roman Emperor. (what.)

As Emperor, Manfredo dispatched the new acquired diplomat to search for an empress, founding one in Milan. He needed an heir quickly if he wanted to keep the imperial crown on the family. He also sent a royal marriage to France, and accepted one from tiny Spoleto to increase odds of an heir, and hoping the latter to accept a diplomatic vassalization. But after been elevated so high so suddenly, it was deemed that Siena & Lucca were no valid rivals. The emperor also kept a diplomat tied to support someone from the family as heir of Poland + Lithuania.

Finally in December Bologna fell, taking less than a year thanks to the mercenary leader. The army quickly returned to Florence lifting the siege and followed the Papal army to Rome itself. The aim was to peace the Pope for money, but the eternal city was well protected and coastal, the siege expected to take a long time. Once Bologna unconditionally surrendered, the main goal of showing strength is achieved (humiliating for age objectives and mana points) by Firenze and peace is signed.
The need for an heir had precedence over diplomacy on the chambers, and a candidate with enormous potential was introduced to the court. While not fully recognized legitimate at that moment, the Emperor hoped with time he was going to be accepted. (Took the heir, too good not to and need one to be HRE. Legitimacy should go up gradually)

1742940255528.png


Deciding to proceed with the plan to consolidate the state, Manfredo looked again at the map after finally getting a claim on Siena and noticed she allied Naples (plus Savoy). He cursed again the dammed Neapolitans and adopted the strategy to secure alliances with the countries with a royal marriage in place (France, Poland, Burgundy, Milan, Spoleto) expecting to curl favors for help in an eventual attack. Unfortunately for his plans, Milan was on track to fall upon the Savoyard dynasty, grasping the need to break that relation. He also stated spying on Lucca for a rightful claim on the province. The available rivals were Naples & Venice, made him think about try to humiliate the latter in a possible war with Lucca. On the HRE front, he still had a diplomat working with the electors, since his current heir was tied (for the win) with 2 votes should anything happened to him. It was too risky for his taste.

By November of 1447, he was trying to make a decision between warring Lucca/Venice (claim + humiliate) or Siena/Savoy/Naples. The latter alliance was stronger, but the primary concern was a possible Savoyard PU over Milan. The initial idea was to declare on Siena and call Milan with favors to break their alliance. Or at least prevent the PU. He really wanted to call France, at that time tied in a war but that would had join after finishing it, against Siena and big Naples (but no against Lucca).

1742940373160.png


At the end, he went for the easier war with Lucca. Expected to be even easier and faster in September of 1448 when the Military & Diplomatic Technologies 4 were reached, followed by Admin in Jan 1449. After trading favor for trust and activating mission trustworthy allies, Spoleto agreed to become a vassal.

The war with Lucca was going well, the city had fallen, and the Venetians were hiding in their island. But Emperor Manfredo initial plan to give cores from Venice to Milan were put on pause, since there’s was the chance of Burgundy going into a PU under Milan due to their higher development.

1742940491828.png


And on January 1rst, 1450 a new institution called Renaissance spawned in Ferrara. The emperor was waiting for 2 Venetians forts to fall for war score, knowing their capital was unreachable, to ask money and power projection. At the same time, a lot of consolidation was happening around Europe.
1742940573502.png
 
Last edited:
  • 1Like
Reactions:
Comments on the chapter

I am guilty of save scum once, after getting stack wiped in the first war with Bologna by the pope. Since it was so early in the campaign, my thoughts were “this won’t matter, I’m doing it to avoid having to do all the set-up again or run is ruined”. And then Austria dies giving me the emperorship within a year?! My mouth dropped. I was planning to go eventually for the chance of being Emperor for the diplomats and dip reputation, but also was evaluating the option of maybe dismantling it if the occasion arisen, allowing the small princes to consolidate easier and/or vassalize and PU nations left and right, since it’s the goal.

But now, as a blessed run, I can’t temper with it ever again. Or the RNGods will punish me for eternity.

Also, the Neapolitans are doing everything to get on my nerves. First rivaling when I was on track to marry aiming to put dynasty, and then allying my ONLY path of expansion. Can’t wait to punish them for their insolence.
 
Subbed. Great to see you start it and already things are interesting.
Manfredo Malpiero was chosen as the new Holy Roman Emperor. (what.)
I literally said the same thing when reading this. Great stroke of luck . ANy chance of you having to defend members against an attack? with Europe so different form usual setup , not sure if there are any large powers that may attack an HRE minor.
(Took the heir, too good not to and need one to be HRE. Legitimacy should go up gradually)

Agree with that. YOur ruler is very young. plenty of time for legitimacy to improve.
After trading favor for trust and activating mission trustworthy allies, Spoleto agreed to become a vassal.

TIL. I never traded favor for trust to get a vassal done. WIll keep in mind for future. May need in my current run.

since there’s was the chance of Burgundy going into a PU under Milan due to their higher development.

IN the screenshot you have CHarles I as ruler of BUrgundy . Is that *the* Charles whose death triggers Burgundian inheritance incident?
But now, as a blessed run, I can’t temper with it ever again. Or the RNGods will punish me for eternity.
WE all know how fickle they can be.

Great start.


One request: a wide map of Europe at current date ( or near future) to see how things have changed from start ( or mulitple screenshots like you did at start) . I am betting that England will do very well. Unburned by French possessions and relatively monolithic and bigger than neighbors.
 
welcome to see you try your hand at writing an AAR
Thank you. It´s challenging but fun. Hope the first chapter was entertaining. Good to have you here.

Great to see you start it and already things are interesting
They are. And hopefully you will keep seeing that way. Working on the next chapter. Also you are partially to blame for this, with the encouragment.

ANy chance of you having to defend members against an attack?
Not that I can see. Biggest tags outside HRE borders are France & Poland, both allies. I intend to keep it that way.
WIll keep in mind for future. May need in my current run.
It is useful way to spend favors when not needed, higher trust gives reasons to joing wars, and in this case, accept vassalization. sometimes 1-5 reasons is all you need.


Is that *the* Charles whose death triggers Burgundian inheritance incident?
It is. AFAIK as emperor/ally/married I have a huge bonus to get the BI, but there is a chance to go to another RM. I want to minimize any risk.

One request: a wide map of Europe at current date ( or near future) to see how things have changed from start ( or mulitple screenshots like you did at start) . I am betting that England will do very well. Unburned by French possessions and relatively monolithic and bigger than neighbors.
Ask and you shall receive

1742950710353.png
1742950771048.png
1742950792008.png
1742950852260.png
1742950864421.png
1742950948118.png
 
  • 1Like
Reactions:
Chapter 2 - Crossroads New
Chapter 2 - Crossroads

In July 1450 Lucca unconditionally surrendered, but Venice was not ready to give up. Even after Treviso falls, Venice stubbornly wouldn’t accept humiliation (38 WS – Damned Island). With call for peace looming, Emperor Manfredo relents and was satisfied with all their money and war reps from them, and fully annexed of Lucca. There was a bigger fish to fry, and that would needed need lots of troops, own and allied.

Siena, the last province needed to complete the state, was allied to a huge Naples (after conquering Sicily they are 199% WS), Savoy and Urbino. Also, in Trade League with Genoa & Naxos. Calling only 1 or 2 allies was not going to work. Emperor Manfredo knew he could and maybe should bring ALL of them to tip the war. Additionally there was the tempting prospect of being at war with 3 of 10 nations that had to be reined in Italy. Another option was to declare a rivalry war on Naples or using a Spoleto claim, to isolate or even annex Siena in same war (no cobelligerent though), but Naples was allied to Genoa, Ferrara and the Pope (another long war). Fabricate a claim on Savoy was not even remotely considered with them allied to a vast and powerful Castile (big no-no).

1742951384272.png


On the other hand, the succession order in Milan had flipped, and Firenze would get the PU while Savoy contested. The emperor decided to claim on tiny Urbino to bypass Siena alliances and to annex while not co-belligerent, hoping for any Aggressive Expansion (significant due to development) accrued among the Italians to dissipate with time since no more aggressive-conquering wars were on the horizon. He also expected using the time at peace to let war exhaustion decrease before coring expensive Lucca, and do internal maintenance like seizing land for the crown. With no available rivals, Firenze’s power projection would have to be kept up somehow. This was solved partially naming Naples as rival and sending and scornful insult, improving relations at the same time with Neapolitan enemies France and Castile.

Finally, war was declared for “claim” on Urbino on January 1453, with the real target being Siena. Trier was also allied, but that wouldn’t be an issue, thought the Emperor. All forts were sieged systematically, and separate peace treaties signed. Trier was left with only monetary punishment, treasury and war reparations, and canceling her rivals for prestige. Siena was annexed, but the process to be cored was not started, due to its high cost and the aim to unlock a new tech (5) and diplomatic ideas. Urbino was supposed to be treated like Trier, but unexpectedly Perugia declare on them. The Emperor decided an unorthodox approach: to force vassalize Urbino, declaring strong duchies in the realm (with Spoleto to open a diplomatic slot), hoping for the possibly for a royal marriage with the very tough Castile (or another opportunity to spread dynasty, while waiting to fill diplo ideas for less impact on cancelling royal marriages if they were not worthwhile anymore). Perugia was peaced out quickly for money once it fell. After this, the focus was to no declare more aggressive wars, with the only exceptions expected to be either to project power or rein in Italian princes.

By October 1455, the Renaissance is present in all 5 provinces, embracing cost 1 ducat. Administrative technology level 5 was reached, but not its diplomatic equivalent. Instead, diplomatic IDEAS were unlocked, gaining another diplomat and reducing the monetary costs of the diplomatic advisors. The emperor set his focus on improving even more the diplomatic skills of the realm (diplo mana). Another lucky event happened on December, when faceting gems was discovered in Siena. (Too many instances of using the word diplomatic in this paragraph, I recon)

1742951523235.png


And after infinite efforts and convincing due to the Castilian King being infertile, in February 1456 Castile turned friendly, making possible for a Royal Marriage and a chance for a member of the Malipiero family to ascend to the throne.
1742951627950.png

Also reaching 7 out of 7 relations available at that point
1742951704796.png


To tidy Imperial affairs, in April a war was declared on Modena and ally Padua to rein them both in. This was decided to be the first of a few wars with that objective, and only money, no land, was to be taken. The Knights were in, as well as Byzantium with their only province Constantinople, and voices in the diet called about the opportunity to force vassalize them, and from there have a good amount of land being reconquered with minimal AE (cores). The emperor considered, but decided against it, arguing that his hands were tied with too many relationships now. He was probably also taking into consideration having already vassalized Urbino in a war, having seconds thoughts about that, and the emperor was adamant on keep his diplomatic focus. Byzantium would stay independent… for the time being.

To celebrate his decision, in May 1457, Firenze was developed to a large city (30 dev), allowing the emperor to proclaim a golden era for the nation (3rd era objective fulfilled). After satisfying a mission for high income, a round of marketplaces were distributed, and a new idea was reached, bringing another possible relation to the court, complementing the paradoxical national idea to create cheaper ideas in the future, or so said the philosophers.

1742951792495.png


Since Perugia was in the path to being diplo vassalized, a diplomat was sent to improve relations to secure the future relationship. Some cogs were ordered, to be able to rein the islands to the empire. But no new wars were declared, until getting an agreeable peace with Modena, Padua being peace out for money and war reps. The plan was to ally Castile and get favors, since the Portuguese were on the list to get their dynasty on their Iberian neighbors.

A possible problem in the horizon for the HRE was that the 71 old Landshut duke was seemly leaving his realm to an outsider Denmark, while at the same time the heirless Danes could be put under the Swedes and being contested by the Poles. Diplomacy has always been complicated. (And make strange bedfellows.)

The emperor decided to peace out Modena for less money, since he wanted to secure the alliance with the Castilians. After that he was able to also pass an imperial reform but decided to first spend some imperial authority on nations that could and should be reined in by diplomacy, like Saluzzo, who’s only ally was Burgundy and therefore considered impossible to bring in by war due to the implications. Aquileia and Verona were another candidates, after they surprisingly and unannounced joined the HRE on their own.

1742951918453.png


The coring of Siena finally started. And when a government reform was issued, while supporter of limiting nobility privileges, the emperor decided to bring cheaper advisors and make it easier to get favors from other courts.

1742952001012.png


It was not until March 1458 that the Emperor is able to pass the 1rst Imperial reform due to opposition to his over extension (Siena). This is something that should never happen again, he mumbled to himself.
1742952171915.png


To rein Parma & Mantua a new war was started, but again grabbing land was never considered. Ansbach was in the alliance but would be spared for money and war reps as usual. And another idea, bringing in another diplomat, was released in April 1459. With power projection slipping, the emperor decided to cut short the war, white peacing Ansbach and only the Italians paying money. Firenze was rivaled by Portugal, but instead of returning the favor, Venice (again) and Genoa were picked as rivals. After their embargoes, PP rise above 50 again, for some time.

But before ending the decade, the Emperor encountered himself facing a problem. Spoleto was ready to be annexed, but there was no border close enough to core. This delayed the plans and had to adjust the approach. Either working to diplo vassalize Perugia first (being a republic, there is no RM bonus to relations, can take forever) or conquer a border province, options being papal territory, Rome being a direct one, or taking Abruzzi from Naples. Doable but not easy, and not the desirable outcome, conquering territories. The emperor decided to stop to think. (I paused the game here to consider options).



Comments on the chapter:

I screw it up with Spoleto, not realizing the coring problem. Now I have to release them to free a diplo slot, taking forever with Perugia, or conquering a province against my self-imposed rule. I’m inclined to go for the latter, taking from Napoli, just because I am still annoyed for their past actions. Quickest way to keep moving.

1742952313052.png


8 nations to rein in Italy to avoid Shadow Kingdom. All of these wars will be done without conquering, except maybe/probably 1 province from Naples.
  • Have claim on Corsica, allied to Montferrat (1-2)
  • Use Urbino claim of Padua on Verona allied to Aquileia (was going for diplomatic rein, but war is easier/quicker, must insult to reduce relations) (3-4)
  • Urbino claim on Ferrara, ally Naples. (5)
  • Have claim on Genoa, allied to Savoy (and Naples) (6-7)
  • Have own/Urbino claim on Bologna – once truce from 1rst shown strength war ends. (8)
 
Last edited:
Looks interesting so far.

Please remind me - how long before the Shadow Kingdom fires? (once again displaying how long it is since I have actually played EU4)
 
He also expected using the time at peace to let war exhaustion decrease before coring expensive Lucca, a

I am of the opinion that over extension has so many maluses (unrest, AE decay slowdown , trade power loss in overseas provinces etc ) that it is best to core ASAP. The savings in ADM were not worth it.

taking Abruzzi from Naples.

If you annex Abruzzi and give to Spoleto, do they still need to core it before you annex them ? Because if you annex them without a core on it , you can sell back to Naples to stick to your self imposed rule.


Also I have never played HRE that early. Is there a time limit on when shadow kingdom fires? What are the downsides for you other than losing a few members?
 
I’m inclined to go for the latter, taking from Napoli, just because I am still annoyed for their past actions.
It's good that Abruzzi can be taken from Naples, because taking Rome would be so not worth it because of all the penalties holding Rome as a non-Italy/non-Pope Catholic gets.
 
I am of the opinion that over extension has so many maluses (unrest, AE decay slowdown , trade power loss in overseas provinces etc ) that it is best to core ASAP. The savings in ADM were not worth it.
Yep, in my case, diplo rep was affected, and took longer to pass the imperial reform because of it. I was too focused on unlocking ideas that overlooked that.

how long before the Shadow Kingdom fires?
Is there a time limit on when shadow kingdom fires? What are the downsides for you other than losing a few members?
1490, after that italian princes not-reined in either by diplomacy (+150 rel - or - alliance), war (defeated-any peace but white) or being free cities will leave the HRE. Being in Italy gave me plenty of time, and neighbors, to bring them in. Not losing members gives more Imperial Authority, and a extra bonus when clicking the decision button.

Which made me think: I am doing emperor stuff aiming for the diplo rep/diplomats, but I´m not planining to Revoke the Privilegia. Could have started as Austria in that case and save me some trouble. I see 4 possible scenarios:
* Abandon / Dismantle / Not caring about HRE
* Keep it but only pass reforms until the getting diplo rep, any Imperial Autority after that could be used to bestow grace for +relations
* Keep and go DESCENTRALIZED (something new for me, have never gone that route)
* Change religion and see what happens.

For this run, I want to stack as much diplo rep as posible to make it easier to diplo vassalize / spread dinasty / PU / inherit.
And just discovered that Reformed can give you +2 diplo rep. (Also something new for me)
Theory-crafting something along the lines: "What if we go reform, and either let the peace of westphalia happen or help the protestants win while converting others to reform for the chance to be elected back and stack the emperor diplo rep?"
Not sure if I could pull it off, and there is still time to process. Seems like a decentish middle game goal (and how often do you see a reformed emperor?)

Also have to start thinking in next idea group. I know that 3rd one will be Influence. For 2nd I am not so sure. Innovative is a usual opener for me, and has policy for +1 diplo rep with Diplomatic. Other options could be Infrastructure (also policy +1 rep with diplo) while also helping to build tall since we are not expanding military, or even Religious if I were to either play the curia game or the reform switch. Quantity and Offensive also have policies for +1 rep if I want to use mil points.
I´m starting to suffer the burden of strategizing for an AAR. My admiration goes to the writers.

Is not even 1460 and I´m planning for the next 50 years. And that´s the easy part.

If you annex Abruzzi and give to Spoleto, do they still need to core it before you annex them ? Because if you annex them without a core on it , you can sell back to Naples to stick to your self imposed rule.
I am grateful for a simple, elegant and yet effective solution. I was overthinking to the point of looking how to "pay" for my "sin". Ha! I should even be able to take it myself, start the annex, and give it back once started. Will have to try when I go back to the game. Thanks.


It's good that Abruzzi can be taken from Naples, because taking Rome would be so not worth it because of all the penalties holding Rome as a non-Italy/non-Pope Catholic gets.
Agreed 100%. I mentioned Rome because it was the "direct" route (sharing borders). There are 2 other papal provinces (Terracina & Ancona) that could do the trick, but I´m not planning on angering His Holyness. I want to use the papal influence for a bit. Also, welcome aboard.
 
  • 1Like
Reactions:
Also have to start thinking in next idea group. I know that 3rd one will be Influence. For 2nd I am not so sure. Innovative is a usual opener for me

I have never taken innovative in any run. Interested to see how you use it in your own run ( assuming you decide to take it ) .

"What if we go reform, and either let the peace of westphalia happen or help the protestants win while converting others to reform for the chance to be elected back and stack the emperor diplo rep?"
A Reformed Emperor would be interesting indeed and rarely seen. Peace of WEstphalia can be tricky to pull off if one side turns out to be much stronger than the other. It is a good mid-game goal.
 
Chapter 3 – One rein to rule them all New
Chapter 3 – One rein to rule them all

To try to salvage the Spoleto problem, Emperor Manfredo decided to bite an arrow (bullets weren’t invented yet) and grab Abruzzi from Naples –on a temporary basis, a solution advised from the council- until the vassal could be peacefully annexed. There were several paths to achieve this goal: Attacking directly Naples (allies Ferrara, Genoa, Pope) would had potentially allowed a humiliation and avoided spending diplomatic points for the province. Using Genoa as war target (Naples, Savoy, Naxos, Geneva, Cyprus) meant conflict with 2 Italian princes that could be reined, which was also in his plans, while having the opportunity to humiliate the trade republic as well. At the end, the emperor decided to keep it simple and easy by using Urbino’s claim on Ferrara (Naples, Pope).

However, he had to wait for a little while to allow the mercenary army return from the forests in middle Germany. He used this time to provoke a revolt among Sienese rebels and increase the regular army. Finally, in June 1459 war was declared on Ferrara, while calling the only ally willing to join, Burgundy. A swift attack to the enemy’s capital allowed to eradicate completely the Ferranese forces in 2 weeks, left a token regiment there and proceed to focus on the other participants.

The emperor started to improve relations with nations that could potentially become vassals in the near future, like Corfu (small, relatively close, outside of the HRE) knowing that the process would take a while. Regrettably to his cause, a temporary diplomat was permanently lost (one gained from first mission). A set back that was partially saved when a young member on the forces was sent to Rome to increase the influence with the Curia. (AE impact was nice, but with only 1 province to conquer -and return-, and 1 diplo slot free, decided to go with the +20 papal influence, spending some for a chance to become curia controller, for its bonuses.)

1743266427332.png


Then, in January of 1460 what first started as rumors heard between some of the Italian princes, regarding them feeling to be part of nothing but a shadow kingdom, grew louder. The imperial diet was summoned by the emperor to vote on the stance.

1743266694409.png


At the beginning of the negotiations, it was quickly noticed the vote was a split decision, with around 60 percent of the princes -including 2 electors- favoring to let the Italians go. Emperor Manfredo recalled every diplomat at his disposal, and sent them to try to convince some of the defectors about changing their point of view. “There is time, plenty of it” said the emperor.
1743266737250.png


Back to the war, Naples’ capital fell in June, and due to so much existing animosity between the combatants, the sack of the city started. The emperor heart was ferociously calling to let the army devastate completely the province, an action that would increase the treasury. But his cold mind convinced him to curb the excesses, aiming for a more disciplined and professional army. As emperor, the manpower pool at his disposal seemed endless, but even though Tuscany was a rich state, the funds would be better used through a small yet efficient army. He had to take a loan as reprimand for this decision. (No good deed goes unpunished)
1743266776329.png


The monetary situation improved momentarily, when the capital of Christendom surrendered (not sacking though) and the Pope signed a peace treaty, giving money, war reparations, transfer trade power & annul alliance with Naples. A new diplomatic idea was reached in December, improving the reputation of the realm and its ruler (+2 rep).

After this upgrading, the Emperor arranged a royal marriage with the very old and heirless duke of Landshut, convinced that that alone would make the latter to name a member of the Malipiero family as a successor. But the emperor was erroneous, since the duke still favoured his own dynasty on his throne. The emperor could defy that decision, but would been seen as the aggressor. (From roleplaying perspective, I would been “defending” the integrity of the empire, unsure if this can be considered diplomatic though)

1743266819072.png


Finally, the Shadow Kingdom incident as it was called, ended with a victory for the Emperor’s side, giving him less than 30 years to secure the Italian princes into the fold. Manfredo told himself and the diet he would do it. Still, relations with those who opposed this decision soured for some time.
1743266893092.png


Auspiciously, the Emperor observed how his named heir Alessio reached not only adulthood, but also was a recognized scholar among his peers, and his legitimacy was considered stronger than ever. (I’m more and more in love with this heir, hunting is forbidden)
1743266916323.png


War was still ravaging the Neapolitan provinces. The emperor’s main problem was lacking a proper navy to challenge the allies’ galleys. The Florentine ports were busy assembling cogs, but this construction was slow, taking a year for each. The only way to reduce her rival’s will for a proper treaty was to take the last bastion, which was on the island of Sicily. The army waited for months for an opportunity to cross the straits, which were protected by the galleys. The emperor moved his early ships between ports trying to lure the enemy. The plan worked after several attempts. This maneuver demoralized enough the Neapolitans to cede Abruzzi, giving their treasury and war reparations. (Wanted to humiliate, but Messina fort could take another year to fall with no navy, can always return later.)
1743266950500.png


When Ferrara’s capital fell a few days later, peace was signed for what was considered the common standard practice: money, reparations of war, trade power, but also annulled a rivalry to increase prestige. No land was taken. Nonetheless it did had to consequence of reining the Ferranese to the empire. (1 down, 7 to go). Since a few more wars were expected in the name of HRE unity, or as the emperor called them “aggressive negotiations”, the accumulated splendor permitted to improve taxation during conflicts for the following years.
1743266984382.png


But at the end of this war, in shocking news to Emperor Manfredo, what he considered a cunning plan from the council came to naught. Even when Abruzzi was only conquered to allow the annexation of Spoleto, he found out that the new province had to be cored to even start the process. In dismay, he ordered for it to be transferred to Spoleto, who had claim, knowing that it would allow for a quicker coring. Once that was done, he could integrate both provinces, and then most likely return Abruzzi to Naples, as repayment for sacking and devastating the city. (This was a bummer, but satisfies rule and roleplaying, the trait of my ruler is Just after all).

The emperor used the recent acquired wealth to finish the construction of temples in every province. He also thought about improving the trade center in the capital, but he waited for the opportunity to expand the great project of Santa Maria di Fiore. He sent a diplomat to improve relations with Landshut still hoping for a diplomatic transition, noticing that the duke had voted for abandoning Italy, and therefore against the emperor design, which still was resented.
1743267037151.png


Emperor Manfredo used this time of peace to seize land for the crown, reaching a healthy distribution (>30%) for the first time since his first day in office, which prevented some maluses in taxing and vassal relations. He was tempted to sell some back to the estates for money to keep expanding buildings, but he relented.

Even after completing a mission that gave extreme standing (+3 rep) and hiring a Stateman (+1) reaching unseen levels of admiration, the succession order in Castile (getting a Portuguese de Avis) and Landshut (falling on a PU under Denmark) remained unchanged. (It seems size matters, developing wise). Emperor Manfredo decided to continue in his efforts to rein in the Italians.
1743267069175.png


In August, Verona and ally Aquileia faced the emperor’s army (Urbino claim). The time he spent improving relations with other princes during the Shadow Kingdom incident has let the emperor almost forgot the polish election for their next monarch, and saw that while his candidate was still leading, others had come close. He dispatched a diplomat to rectify this situation and maintain the lead, even through his cousin was older than the current Polish king. As luck would have it, his impressive reputation attracted support beyond belief. (62% chance of increase, I have never seen anything like that before, not even as Austria).

By May 1462 both capitals in the war had fallen, and equally peace agreements were signed: money, war reparations, and transferring trade power. The emperor thought for a moment about releasing Padua from Verona, but he expected that the former would become another possible prince to rein and decided against it, for now. (3 down, 5 to go). He did remember to put Spoleto on scutage, to avoid calling them in future wars, since their coring of Abruzzi was expected to end soon, and the emperor was anxious to start the legal annexation and release of what he saw as illegal occupation.

In June Bologna shadowed the same handling than Verona. They had attacked friendless Ferrara, and the emperor still was undecided between allowing consolidation in the HRE or kept as many princes as possible for the authority increase. But since Ferrara had accepted the imperial mantle, Emperor Manfredo believe they could be saved. And for the surprise of everyone inside the realm and beyond the borders, news arrived that the Landshut duke had an heir. (At 76. Go, duke, go!). The Emperor hoped to complete his diplomatic ideas as soon as possible so he could abolish the unfruitful marriage with the old duke without serious repercussions. In the Castilian front, they were to fall under Portuguese direct rule, not dynasty, and France was expected to contest it. (Maybe I should had rivaled back Portugal. Still, what I really need to do is to grow in size ASAP to be taken seriously).

A new idea was unlocked in October, which in principle would have allowed to conquer more provinces had the emperor pursued a military approach. But more importantly, inspired the opening of a Secretary for Foreign Affairs, providing more relations with countries without overextending the current office. (+2 relations, 10 total). With Abruzzi coring done, the annexation of Spoleto started right away, and a royal marriage was proposed to Perugia, while rejecting one received from Bosnia. The small duchy next door was willing to be diplo vassalized, so the emperor was preparing the process for a smooth transition. (Perugia is a republic but did accepted RM after all, Bosnia is outside vassalization territory at the moment)

1743267131275.png


The annexation of Spoleto was expected to last less than a year due to the Emperor’s incredible diplomatic standing, but after unlocking the last idea, the diplomatic reserves were low and predicted to deplete during the takeover procedure. The emperor promoted his level 2 stateman twice (1 mis click) accomplishing a balance between incoming and outgoing resources. Spoleto would become part of the realm by April of next year. (Remembered to activate mission Acquire subjects + Nobility privilege to reduce annexation costs)

With Bologna signing the standard peace treaty, the Emperor saw that Savoy was not keen to defend Genoa in a war, and at the same time they were ready to accept an alliance, another way to retain the Italians in the HRE. Having an open position for a relation, Emperor Manfredo agreed. (5 down, 3 to go). Corsica was close to accept vassalisation, but the emperor hesitated, since to complete reining the princes, the easy way for bring in Montserrat was trough war with the mediterranean island. Before hostilities were declared, Genoa acknowledged Firenze as a rival. The emperor vowed publicly to teach the trade republic a lesson. This tarnished the emperor´s reputation, who ordered the guilty party executed, accepting a lost in stability (Need the diplo points to catch up in tech).
1743267298143.png


Spoleto was finally annexed in April, but when Emperor Manfredo went to return Abruzzi to Naples, we found that selling was not an option. And to return it he had to be at peace, likewise, to ally and vassalize Perugia. He decided to end quickly the war with Montferrat and Corsica.
1743267341788.png


During these times some news arrived in that Naples was considered a great power between the nations. Emperor Manfredo could only laugh to the insolent proclaim and expected to remediate it soon. He also observed that saving Ferrara from Bologna caused the former to fully annexed the latter. And his ally and royal consort’s country Milan embraced a horrific form of government.
1743267373521.png


Montferrat fell in October and signed the standard treaty. But Corsica´s coastal castle would take a long time to share the same fate, and the emperor hoped to use his charm to vassalize them eventually. He signed a settlement asking only for war reps. (7 down, 1 to go)

During peace time, an alliance was signed with Perugia, and they agree to become a vassal a month later. But when the emperor went to finally get rid of the troublesome province of Abruzzi, he found yet another problem, since would not become Neapolitan, but instead revive the country of Spoleto. (I clicked it, a promise is a promise. Guess I can try to vassalize and annex them again? ETA: Never mind, I have one core of them…)
1743267400701.png


Finally, war was declared on Genoa, and Savoy (expected) and Naples (unexpected) didn´t answered the call. The Savoyard ruler was malevolent, and the Neapolitan were over indebted. With Geneva & Cyprus as members of the trade league, Emperor Manfredo was not preoccupied. But instead of citing conquest, he declared humiliation casus belli. (Thought of show strength again for mana)

In January 1464, a new administrative technology (6) was unlocked, 2 full years ahead of time paying a small penalty in resources, since the Emperor was aiming to maintain the highest innovativeness. (Cheaper future tech & ideas). Workshops were built in every Tuscan province. When the Diplomatic ideas were fully completed in April, Emperor Manfredo canceled the royal marriage with Landshut with only a prestige hit, and started the process he called “fishing”, sending multiple proposals to countries with an old ruler and no heir, out of several options. Holstein and Brittany were selected, and after the wedding ceremonies both realms were candidates to fall in a personal union, with the latter could be contested by Provance.

1743267436694.png


When the Milanese declared a republic, the Emperor foresaw another aggressive negotiation that could be pursued, but the alliance was kept for HRE unity in mind. (Needed to complete rein in Italy, but since the game gave it, I suppose it wont break the rule).
1743267465744.png


The currying favors efforts in the Castilian court aiming to introduce a Malipiero heir turned to ashes when they fell under Portuguese rule, an action that was contested by the French, who were already at war with Provence. A royal marriage with an Irish country in the “fishing” strategy of the Emperor resulted in a possible dynasty spread on the Emerald Isle.
1743267603172.png


On Jan 1rst, 1465 another improvement in Military technology was achieved (6), with the resulting innovativeness being conserved. Diplomatic tech also progressed (5). These advancements had the expected consequence of eliminating Venice from the pool of valid rivals for Firenze.

After another long year waiting for their will to reach low levels, in July 1466 Genoa surrendered at last, giving away their treasury and accepts a humiliating peace. (8 down, 0 to go). The emperor decided money now was better than money later and ordered the upgrading of Firenze and Lucca trade centers. This resulted in all the Italian princes, one way or the other, to submitted to the Holy Roman Emperor will. The Shadow Kingdom prevented, boosted the imperial authority.

1743267712896.png


A couple moths later it was enough to pass another reform, which brought additional renown for Emperor Manfredo. To celebrate, he commanded the annexation of Urbino.
1743267737895.png


1743267758446.png


At the same time kept close watch of the problematic province of Abruzzi, which seemed destined to be the cause for never ending conflict. Spoleto ceased to exist (again) in the hands of Naples, and this caused a boundary dispute with the Emperor.
1743267788624.png


In the horizon appeared another opportunity and possible cause of problems, when a new imperial incident loomed like the sword of Damocles.
1743267843082.png
 

Attachments

  • 1743267486773.png
    1743267486773.png
    257,8 KB · Views: 0
Last edited:
Comments on the chapter

I want to achieve some kind of balance on the run. I am already limiting myself a lot by not conquering provinces that I could, but if the game gives me a chance to vassalize with a proper CB, should I go for it? Same as PU, if I can contest it, would it be allowed to? I haven’t made up my mind, but I´m inclined to yes to both. Especially because I lost the race for the Castilian throne mainly to having less development it seems, with prestige, diplo rep and relations through the roof. I need to grow fast to have a chance on the bigger boys. And maybe allow myself me attack countries to release smaller and vassalizable tags. Is that diplomatic?

For those interested
1743268169408.png
1743268188490.png
1743268200757.png
1743268208837.png
1743268217301.png
1743268225737.png
 
  • 1Like
Reactions:
(I’m more and more in love with this heir, hunting is forbidden)
Don't worry, the game will find some other way to get rid of him!
 
  • 1Like
Reactions:
Well, not that I know what I am talking about anymore but it does seem like matters are proceeding in the correct direction.

Comments on the chapter

I want to achieve some kind of balance on the run. I am already limiting myself a lot by not conquering provinces that I could, but if the game gives me a chance to vassalize with a proper CB, should I go for it? Same as PU, if I can contest it, would it be allowed to? I haven’t made up my mind, but I´m inclined to yes to both. Especially because I lost the race for the Castilian throne mainly to having less development it seems, with prestige, diplo rep and relations through the roof. I need to grow fast to have a chance on the bigger boys. And maybe allow myself me attack countries to release smaller and vassalizable tags. Is that diplomatic?

Seems perfectly reasonable
 
But his cold mind convinced him to curb the excesses, aiming for a more disciplined and professional army.
That implies you are not planning on hiring mercs going forward? I find mercs helpful for tall play when you can make more money than manpower ( relatively).

In dismay, he ordered for it to be transferred to Spoleto, who had claim, knowing that it would allow for a quicker coring
I guess their core has to next to your core to get annexed. I thought you could annex if their province was next to your core. My bad.
the succession order in Castile (getting a Portuguese de Avis) and Landshut (falling on a PU under Denmark) remained unchanged. (It seems size matters, developing wise)

THat is my understanding as well.

he found yet another problem, since would not become Neapolitan, but instead revive the country of Spoleto.
The interesting trek of Spoletans from the mountains to the coast. Too bad they got snuffed by Naples.
n the horizon appeared another opportunity and possible cause of problems, when a new imperial incident loomed like the sword of Damocles.

Never seen that incident in a run before. I look forward to see what you decide.

but if the game gives me a chance to vassalize with a proper CB, should I go for it?
I say yes. Carpe diem.
 
Don't worry, the game will find some other way to get rid of him!
Don´t you dare to jinx it... if something happens to him, his ghost will pull your legs in your sleep.

Well, not that I know what I am talking about anymore but it does seem like matters are proceeding in the correct direction.
So far yes, but we´ll see how the story develops. Stay tuned!

That implies you are not planning on hiring mercs going forward? I find mercs helpful for tall play when you can make more money than manpower ( relatively).
I rarely rely on mercs. And by rarely, I mean once per campaing at most, at day one, and only when there is a company with decent siege pips. I try to go for professionalism as fast as possible. I don´t like losing 5% per company hired. We´ll see if this is the right call on the run.

I thought you could annex if their province was next to your core. My bad.
Don´t be, it seemed a reasonable proposal, and proper role-play. I assumed the same. At least the rule was observed. I am at peace with the results.


Too bad they got snuffed by Naples.
It seems that the conflict with Naples will continue for some time. At least their pizza is acceptable.

Never seen that incident in a run before. I look forward to see what you decide.
This will be resolved in the next chapter. Hope it will keep you entertained.

Seems perfectly reasonable
I say yes. Carpe diem.
Now I have the blessing of the council.

Most of the map is familiar. But Novgorod alive and Syria being buffer between Mamluks and Ottomans are interesting changes
Surprised you haven´t collected you bet winnings about England doing well. And with them allied to Portugal-Castile I am expecting France to receive a beating. Don´t know if I´m happy about my ally.
 
  • 1Like
Reactions: