• We have updated our Community Code of Conduct. Please read through the new rules for the forum that are an integral part of Paradox Interactive’s User Agreement.
Chapter Fifty-Eight: The Caucasian War (Part II)
Chiang Kai-Shek had come to power in China following the death of President Duan Qirui in early 1934, with Chiang’s Kuomintang Faction retaining strong influence there despite the defeat of their military forces whilst under the leadership of Sun Yat-Sen during the early stages of the Warlord Era in China. Duan’s victory in the long civil war had resulted in the destruction and exile or death of most of his rival warlords from within the Beiyang Army, and meant that Chiang’s ascension to power had received little opposition at the time - However, that did not mean that he was especially loved by those in the Chinese military who were suspicious of the Kuomintang’s past support of liberal democracy, and his position had been vulnerable ever since he first took power as a result. This meant that there was already an opposition movement to Chiang forming in China when the Caucasian War had broken out – A movement which was greatly strengthened after an early Chinese offensive into Outer Manchuria met with catastrophic failure at the Battle of Vladivostok in summer 1937. By autumn it was clear the Russian military was vastly outperforming the Chinese forces despite their huge modernisation drives in recent decades, and Chiang’s position therefore began to look more vulnerable as the year went on and the fighting moved onto Chinese soil.

What the Chinese opposition could not necessarily agree on was on who should replace Chiang as leader of China. Nobody wished for a return to the disastrous years of the Warlord Era with different military cliques facing off against one another and renewing the devastation caused by the civil war, so another general seizing power was quickly ruled out. Instead, royalist forces found themselves gaining significant favour from the military as time went by and the military position continued to worsen. The last Qing Emperor, Puyi, had destroyed his reputation during his brief spell as a Japanese puppet emperor in Manchuria before Duan had successfully reannexed the north-eastern province, and though the fact Manchuria was now being invaded by Russian forces could perhaps have earned the Manchu people some sympathy from the rest of China and made a Qing restoration plausible, such a controversial appointment had far too high a risk of backfiring and triggering a period of instability that the army was keen to avoid. The Beiyang generals were also deeply suspicious of Puyi and his family connections with Japan, and so an even more unlikely scenario began to be floated: The restoration of a Han Chinese Emperor for the first time in almost three hundred years.


accf5c77b9bafa381ef9fd9e47263db4.png

Zhao Yuxun, the Marquis of Extended Grace and descendant of the Ming Dynasty
There were two plausible candidates for the position: The senior descendant of Confucius, known as the Duke of Yansheng… And the last descendant of the last Ming Emperor, who held the title of the Marquis of Extended Grace. The Marquis’ had continued to diligently offer sacrifices at the graves of their ancestors throughout the Qing era in China, and this had not been interrupted during the revolution and the civil war, with their title never being abolished. In winter 1937 this position was held by the forty-five year old Zhu Yuxun, who was the twelfth holder of the office since the fall of the Ming Dynasty. Although Zhu Yuxun had been educated alongside the exiled and discredited Puyi, he had remained in Beijing during the latter’s Japanese escapade in Manchukuo, and had managed to win himself some high placed friends during the regime of Duan Qirui. And so in December 1937, with Russian forces occupying swathes of Manchuria and Inner Mongolia and occasional air raids taking place over Beijing itself, the royalist uprising began – Declaring a restoration of the Ming Empire and crowning Zhu Yuxun as the 'Hongxian Emperor'.

The royalists rapidly seized control of Beijing and much of Northern China and took President Chiang into custody, but forces loyal to the Kuomintang continued to fight on across much of the South under the leadership of Chiang’s deputy Zhang Qun. Meanwhile the frontline against the Russians completely imploded through spring 1938 as the Russians were able to march unopposed into Xinjiang, Qinghai, and much of Northern & Western China while the battle for supremacy continued throughout China. The very instability that the army had hoped to avoid was coming to pass, even if Chiang himself had lacked the popularity to engender much support in the north, and Zhang Qun even less so. The royalist forces were clearly winning the war, but it was certainly coming at great cost due to the Russian advance.


0fd346270c7d0e75301bf1d888182906.png

The Ottoman Spring Offensive in Ukraine and Circassia (Spring 1938)

For the Sublime Porte, the Chinese descent into chaos was an unwelcome stream of bad news, but despite the massive Russian victories in the east, it was not one which could fundamentally change the balance of the war. The Russians had been driven out of Ottoman territory in the winter of 1937, and a desperate Russian attempt to defend the city of Odessa led by General Sergei Badanov was crushed by Namik Pasha’s 5th Army in January 1938, leaving the Bessarabian Front wide open to Ottoman forces by February, as the Porte began planning a huge spring offensive to knock the Russians out of the war. In the Caucasian Theatre too, the Russians found themselves being driven back across the front – With the Ottoman armoured formations in Circassia able to cut the Russian supply lines to the mountains, and the French Expeditionary Forces then rounding the remaining Russians units up and forcing them to surrender. Indeed after a Russian counter-attack was repulsed at Chisinau in early February there were almost no Russian forces left against our troops, and the whole of European Russia appeared open and vulnerable to allied forces...

And so the great Ottoman Spring Offensive of 1938 began with the Porte in an upbeat mood, but even the most optimistic of ministers could not have predicted how it would turn out. Russian resistance was crushed in Ukraine in March 1931 and by the end of the month the city of Rostov on the coast of the Sea of Azov had fallen as lightning warfare came to Southern Russia. Grand Vizier Rauf Bey used the occasion to demand the entirety of Circassia, or the Russian state of Ekaterinodar, be ceded to the Porte in any peace deal – enraging the Russian Duma who had sent out peace feelers in the week before this pronouncement. Were the Russians counting on our forces becoming over-extended and allowing them to counter-attack though then they were soon to find themselves extremely disappointed. City after city fell through April and May as Ottoman forces pushed into regions of Russia they hadn’t reached in centuries – and then regions of Russia they had never reached in history at all. Luhansk, Tambov, Ryazan, Voronets, and Tula fell in quick succession as spring went by. The first warning the Russian people would get would be the buzzing of our aircraft as the Basak Sahin divebombers obliterated what little defences they could muster together on the highways, and almost as soon as the air raids were over, Sipahi tanks would roll in and mop up anything that was left over, before the motorised infantry arrived to secure the area. Lightning Warfare had truly arrived, and the Tsar could muster no response to it.


ab025656bbd8e07b62b0cf3fc175da7f.png

The Persian Government surrenders to the Sublime Porte (June 10th 1938)

13b6b16c35277da5a987d3efe8c210aa.png

The Russian counter-attack at Novo Uzensk is defeated (June 1938)

The situation was no different in Persia, where the opposition forces had already been all but eliminated by the end of 1937 and where Ottoman and French forces had seized control of almost the entire country by June 1938. When the Persian government had fled to Russia they had initially refused to surrender, hoping that a Russian counter-attack could yet salvage something from the war, and taking heart from the Russian advances into China. This hope would wear away through 1938 as more and more Russian territory fell into Ottoman hands, and the Persians realised that there would be no escape for them this time. On June 10th 1938, with the writing on the wall for the Russian war-effort – let alone the Persian – the Persian government officially surrendered, signing the Treaty of Tehran while surrounded by Ottoman tanks in the Persian capital itself, and ceding the city of Bushire and the western state of Luristan to the Ottoman Empire, as well as giving an official apology for Persian secret service agents causing the explosion at Bushire Harbour that had triggered the conflict in the first place.

Humiliating though the treaty and the circumstances of its signing had been for the Persians, it was nothing compared to what was facing the Russians. The Great Retreat in Russia had continued apace despite the Duma scraping together what remaining forces it could find to try and stop the Ottoman advance. A last desperate counter-attack by the Russian forces was destroyed at the Battle of Novo Uzensk in early June, and on June 20th 1938 the unthinkable happened: The Ottoman Flag was seen flying over the Kremlin, as Omar Pasha’s 4th Army rolled into Moscow almost without opposition. The Tsar and the government had already fled to Petrograd, but the symbolic moment was unmistakeable nonetheless. Thirty years since Russian forces had briefly occupied Constantinople at the end of the catastrophic First Great War, our great foe had been vanquished and vengeance had been achieved. One week later the Russian surrender was officially accepted (Again taking place in Moscow itself), with Tsar Nikolai III and Prime Minister Noe Zhordiana signing the document in the presence of Sultan Abdulmejid II, Grand Vizier Rauf Bey, Deputy Vizier Mustafa Ismet Pasha, and French War Minister Pierre-Etienne Flandin. The Caucasian War had lasted just over thirteen months, and the allied victory was absolute.


503506bc23aca9f4135112a0ad179ebd.png

Russian defences at the Battle of Moscow (June 1938)

0a76e50714648dac2f519649de36854b.png

The Fall of Moscow leads to the Russian Surrender (June 20th 1938)

When it came to the spoils, many in the Ottoman Parliament had demanded nothing less than the total dismantling of the Russian Empire, with the Young Turks calling for Ottoman control of the entirety of Central Asia and the final achievement of their Pan-Turkic ideals - Something which had never seemed more plausible than now. Sosyal Demokrat Grand Vizier Rauf Bey was however constrained by his coalition with the socialists, who had always been lukewarm about the prospect of the war and for whom continued fighting to enforce such a harsh peace treaty was a completely unacceptable proposal. With the opposition Liberals also opposed to such a gigantic rewriting of the map, and more importantly the French also signalling an opposition to such a drastic change of borders, a more acceptable peace offer was made. In the end, the Porte demanded only the Russian states of Ekaterinodar and North Caucasia as they had previously announced, along with demanding the total withdrawal of Russian forces from occupied China. Circassia was to be Ottoman for the first time in over a century, since the Treaty of Adrianople at the end of the Russo-Turkish War of 1828-29. Victory was ours.

4030524835c9178266aa332d0f39dc94.png

Circassia is restored to Ottoman rule following the Russian Surrender (June 21st 1938)

58725ae60c2c3ef8528bfbe9081068a6.png

The Sublime Porte increases the healthcare budget following our victory in the Caucasian War (June 30th 1938)

The withdrawal of the Russians from China had also cleared the war for the royalist forces to secure complete control of the country and international recognition for the restored Ming Empire swiftly followed - led by the Sublime Porte; as Grand Vizier Rauf Bey was keen to continue and strengthen the Sino-Ottoman Alliance - despite the poor Chinese military performance in the war. Rauf Bey knew that despite the military defeats they had suffered, China had forced the Russians to commit significant numbers to the Far East even as Ottoman forces had approached Moscow, and that without the Chinese sacrifices it would have been many more Ottoman soldiers who would have had to die to make the capture of Moscow and the scale of our victory achievable. Grand Vizier Rauf Bey met with the Hongxian Emperor in Beijing in August 1938 after his coronation to officially renew the friendship between our nations, thanking the Chinese people for their sacrifices in the war and pledging an unprecedented level of Ottoman investment to help China recover from the scars of the war and continue its march toward modernisation. The Emperor himself was very keen to see Ottoman money aid the Chinese recovery after the economic damage inflicted during the Russian occupation and the brief civil war against the Kuomintang Faction, and he was able to strike a strong rapport with the Grand Vizier on a personal level too. Far from the puppet Emperor that the military had initially envisioned, the Hongxian Emperor had quickly gained popularity with the Chinese people at large by dismissing the generals responsible for the poor war effort and instituting a series of laws to increase the size of the Chinese welfare state, with the restored Ming Dynasty centralising power in the bureaucracy in a way that almost suggested the years of revolution had never happened. The Chinese Dragon may have stumbled during this conflict, but its upward trend had surely not been halted.

Meanwhile back in the Empire, the Sublime Porte also passed a new law greatly expanding the Ottoman health service in the aftermath of the war amid jubilations in the street, and 1938 became a year of great celebration across the Empire – With even a brief South German rebellion in Slavonia unable to quell the mood of the populace - or to prevent its swift annihilation by the Ottoman military. Street parties following the Russian surrender had continued throughout the summer and the Porte would be pleased to note a resulting baby boom in the coming months, as victorious soldiers were welcomed home as heroes and lavish ceremonies honouring men both living and dead were carried out. Formation flights over cities struck such popularity that the modern air shows were born in the Empire in the Autumn of 1938 as 'The Magnificent Men' who had so daringly destroyed the Russian air force became people of legend. And so, with both Grand Vizier Rauf Bey and Deputy Vizier Mustafa Ismet Pasha enjoying levels of popularity not seen since the era of Pertev Pasha and the end of the Third Great War, surely nothing could stop these twin political forces from romping to victory in the upcoming elections…


2941c5495215c8120e62f7609793681f.png

The Osmanli Ahali Firkasi becomes engulfed in a political scandal during the election campaign (November 18th 1938)
 
Last edited:
  • 4Like
  • 1Love
Reactions:
How long must we keep refighting this war? If we don't dismantle Russia now Russians and Ottomans will be fighting each other in spaceships and power armor. This is our opportunity to remove the threat to the north forever- I say we take it.

The possibility of going for the total victory and Dismantle Empire CB was one that I strongly considered, but to enforce such a CB requires almost 100% occupation. With the collapse of the Chinese, that would've meant taking the entirety of Siberia by myself... And that would require sending most of my armies a long, long way away - with the Habsburg forces still (as ever) camped on my borders. Had the Chinese been able to occupy the Far East as I had hoped, I might have gone for it - As it is, this is a pretty devastating victory nonetheless :D

It's good to see an update, and a rather dramatic one at that! It seems the Russians have severely underestimated the empire this time around, and they're paying the price for it. The situation in China doesn't bode well though; I can't believe they chose NOW of all times to break apart. I doubt it'll turn the tide of the war, but it's still an inconvenience. Great update, ready for the next one!
Yes, the Chinese certainly timed their gigantic reactionary rebellion to perfection: The fact they restored the Empire in the middle of the war really put the icing on the cake!

Excellent work. What is tk be done about persia?
The Persian performance in the war was abysmal - They simply couldn't compete with us at all and were annihilated extremely early. Luristan was a nice state to take as it's about 50% Kurdish (and Kurds are of course loyal subjects of the Porte) - And it also means that should we have to fight them in future, most of the mountainous provinces are already owned by us, so they shall (hopefully) never be a threat again :p

Armor counts as a kind of artillery in the game, right?
It does indeed, with airplanes counting as cavalry
China :eek:

I also think the Russian empire must be dismantled.

Welcome back again! Sorely missed!

Thank you again! As mentioned above, I considered going for the dismantling, but the Chinese collapse just made it too much of a stretch.

Welcome back! I caught up on this AAR a couple months ago and I'm really excited to see the conclusion.

Thank you! Glad to have you on board :)
Excellent news to see you back.

And some very decent results in Russia. China though ...
Glad to be back! Yes, the war in Russia was quite strange... There was a time when the Russians had started inflicting some serious casualties on me after the initial victories and I thought this was going to become a very long war - And then their army just melted away. Those forces being so far away in Siberia and China cleared the way for me to steamroller my way through empty lands
To my shame I've never found the time to catch up with this. Now that it's back it seems the perfect time to rectify that. I'll try my best to get through everything before it ends! :D
Aha, always happy to see new commentators - Hope you enjoy the catch-up! :D
 
I would call that a satisfying conclusion to the war. Cool to see the Ming back in the driver's seat in China.
 
What stupendous results. And in such a short time, as noted in the update. Russia is on her knees, the ottomans are ascendant in Asia, and the french are clearly doing very well out of all this too.
 
Great result and a great update! I love the Chinese details. Even if the Russian Empire is not dismantled, they are surely bloodied. This has been a good show of muscles.
 
Russia got a right proper thumping.

One does have to wonder, given that scandal though, if the elections might be surprising
 
  • 1
Reactions:
Russia got its teeth kicked in. Very satisfying
 
Now that this AAR is back in business, I guess it's as good a time as any to break cover from lurking and reading. :D

I'd like to echo @Tommy4ever's comments that the updates dealing with first Great War were a rather epic read. An unwelcome and hair-raising development as a player, no doubt—but riveting to the reader. Occasional setbacks make the forward strides more rewarding and significant.

I can't see what could possibly be unsettling about such a gigantic and friendly Porte though ;)

One of the things I find intriguing about the AAR is that it's inadvertently revealed how my own (admittedly slim) knowledge and reading on Ottoman historiography is thoroughly marinated in Victorian perspectives and biases—aka the largely discredited Ottoman decline paradigm. I'm constantly having to remind myself that this is a large and successful multiethnic Ottoman state that has undergone significant liberalisation (in the spirit of the Tanzimat), and that's a scenario I don't encounter a lot of, even in alt-history.
 
Now that this AAR is back in business, I guess it's as good a time as any to break cover from lurking and reading. :D

I'd like to echo @Tommy4ever's comments that the updates dealing with first Great War were a rather epic read. An unwelcome and hair-raising development as a player, no doubt—but riveting to the reader. Occasional setbacks make the forward strides more rewarding and significant.



One of the things I find intriguing about the AAR is that it's inadvertently revealed how my own (admittedly slim) knowledge and reading on Ottoman historiography is thoroughly marinated in Victorian perspectives and biases—aka the largely discredited Ottoman decline paradigm. I'm constantly having to remind myself that this is a large and successful multiethnic Ottoman state that has undergone significant liberalisation (in the spirit of the Tanzimat), and that's a scenario I don't encounter a lot of, even in alt-history.

I for one am delighted that this alt-history played out in such a way that the Middle East and North/East Africa are practically the only stable and prosperous part of the world as Europe and North America tear themselves apart in one war after another.
 
I for one am delighted that this alt-history played out in such a way that the Middle East and North/East Africa are practically the only stable and prosperous part of the world as Europe and North America tear themselves apart in one war after another.

I do enjoy that. Its the rare aar where the ttl timeline is much, much better for people than otl. Especially for everyone in the balkans and middle east.
 
I for one am delighted that this alt-history played out in such a way that the Middle East and North/East Africa are practically the only stable and prosperous part of the world as Europe and North America tear themselves apart in one war after another.
In fairness, Europe isn't too far off from OTL, and in fact better given that Fascism has not risen to power. Russia is hostile but western Europe seems to have settled into an equilibrium.

Still, yes, looking forwards to OTL 2003, when the Ottoman Imperial Army invades the Republic of Texas to overthrow dictator George W. Bush, on suspicions that he is building chemical weapons.
 
I do enjoy that. Its the rare aar where the ttl timeline is much, much better for people than otl. Especially for everyone in the balkans and middle east.
pax turcica baby :cool:
 
Its been a good few years for Turkey in aarland that's for sure.
yeah, I actually find it strange since in real world Turkey's been having more problems than ever since 1920 with other countries. I think it's maybe in Vicky and HoI timeline it's not too big to have the game too easy and not too small to be insignificant so like a sweet spot of challenge.
 
yeah, I actually find it strange since in real world Turkey's been having more problems than ever since 1920 with other countries. I think it's maybe in Vicky and HoI timeline it's not too big to have the game too easy and not too small to be insignificant so like a sweet spot of challenge.

So discussed in TT. It's a really good place for a game. No matter how powerful you get, you have so many borders open to attack. So many problems that you'll never fix. So many things to overcome.

Compelling, varied and replayable. So, very god for a game and an AAR.
 
Catching up now! A restored royalist China is a wonderful sight to see!
 
Chapter Fifty-Nine: The End of an Era (1938-1940)
2941c5495215c8120e62f7609793681f.png

Criminal activity by the Osmanli Ahali Firkasi is revealed by the media, blowing the election campaign wide open (November 18th 1938)

Grand Vizier Rauf Bey and Deputy Vizier Mustafa Ismet Pasha had formed an extremely effective partnership during the coalition since the 1934 election, with their vast political experience helping them to steer through many a crisis, and a strong personal relationship ensuring the coalition remained harmonious even throughout the pressures of the Caucasian War. The Grand Vizier had led the Sosyal Demokrat Firkasi for eighteen years by the time of the 1939 election, and the Deputy Vizier had led the Osmanli Ahali Firkasi for twelve. During their times in charge they had both seemed like immovable objects, leading their parties to new heights and presiding over an era of tranquillity within their parties whilst the Hürriyet ve Itilâf Firkasi had torn itself apart over the Census Affair and the fall of Mustafa Kemal Pasha. So the idea that both of them would have departed the Ottoman political scene within a year of their great triumph in the Caucasian War would have seemed laughable as the electoral campaign kicked off, and both parties looked to make further big gains at the expense of the fractured liberals.

Of course, they were to eventually depart in very differing circumstances. Mustafa Ismet Pasha’s returning to government of the socialist party had been a resounding success, and his land reform proposals had been hugely successful, with standards of living for the working and middle classes having seen significant increases during the government’s tenure amid the immensely popular new social housing scheme. But beneath the surface, the Osmanli Ahali Firkasi’s seemingly triumphant showcasing of democratic socialism had been covering a veneer of disreputable activity. Newspaper reports in October 1938 detailed a litany of union corruption and direct involvement of the socialist party in the blackmailing of business owners who opposed their policies. Mustafa Ismet moved quickly to decry the allegations and purge the perpetrators from his party, claiming they acted alone and without support of the central leadership, but the damage was already done. Public support for the party was battered, and a campaign that began with socialist hopes of winning their first electoral plurality consequently began to fall apart the seams.


9b98f0bd3c52ab76c4407207603e52c5.png

Deputy Vizier Mustafa Ismet Pasha's hopes of electoral victory were battered by the trade union scandal of 1938

The liberal Hürriyet ve Itilâf Firkasi (Freedom and Accord Party) meanwhile were fighting their first election since the fall of Mustafa Kemal Pasha, and his successor Mahmut Celal Pasha was a relative newcomer to the political scene, having first been elected in the 1930 election. The liberals were still heavily divided by factional infighting, and Mahmut Celal enjoyed none of the authority that former leaders Pertev Pasha and Mustafa Kemal had been able to wield. Factions loyal to the disgraced Murat Pasha and his cadre that had been at fault during the previous scandal remained influential in the party, whilst Kemalist loyalists also prevented Celal from being able to set his own path. With such constant factional infighting hamstringing it from the very start, the liberal electoral campaign was therefore very much seen as one of the damage limitation prior to the union scandals emerging - though afterward there were hopes that they might be able to capitalise on their opponents’ troubles and that public attention could now move on from their own failings.

Meanwhile elsewhere in Ottoman politics, the long-suffering Right was sensing a huge opportunity. Enver Pasha had finally stood down from his leadership of the Young Turk affiliated Ittihat ve Terakki Cemiyeti (Committee of Union and Progress) and been replaced by young firebrand Huseyin Nihal Bey, while Kazim Pasha’s leadership of the conservative Osmanli Demokrat Firkasi had also seen their levels of support begin to recover after the repeated electoral maulings they had suffered in the past two decades. The conservatives were hoping to retake the mantle of the lead party of the right from the Young Turks, and both parties could see the blood in the water from the socialists and the liberals. Whilst dreams of a sweeping return to power for the first time since the 1900 elections were deemed unrealistic by all but their most ardent supporters, there was no doubt that the Right was in the ascendancy for the first time in a generation, and taking over the leadership of the opposition was not out of the question. The Young Turks in particular were also buoyed by the crushing victory in the Caucasian War that had seen Ottoman superiority over the Russian Empire spelt out in such bruising terms, and had decried the lenient peace deal signed in its aftermath – During campaigning Nihal Bey even raised the spectre of renewed hostilities to seize the entirety of Central Asia.


8817c5513d80e825db709fb70718ba3c.png

Huseyin Nihal Bey modernised the far right Ittihat ve Terakki Cemiyeti following the resignation of Enver Pasha as party leader in 1938

For the Grand Vizier, however, things remained rosy. The Sosyal Demokrat Firkasi had not been implicated in the socialist scandals and the damage to Mustafa Ismet Pasha’s reputation had only further increased the light of Rauf Bey’s own star. Campaigning on a platform of further integration for the fringes of the Empire and a promise of a continued interventionist approach to the Ottoman economy to combat any spectre of unemployment, the Sosyal Demokrat Firkasi was anticipating a great victory. Some in the party were even dreaming of securing the first parliamentary majority by a single party since the abolition of the old First Past the Post electoral system by the liberals in the early days of the Liberal Dawn after the 1900 Election – Something which would be extra convenient as it would cut out any awkward coalition discussions with their embattled socialist and liberal rivals.


995ce3a0d25191b916d32af4960cb8ab.png

The results of the 1939 Ottoman general election (January 2nd 1939)
And so as the results came in on January 2nd 1939, there were nerves and excitement across the political spectrum, along with large amounts of disappointment for many involved. The Sosyal Demokrat Firkasi unsurprisingly won the election by a huge margin, but the dreams of a majority fell short as they gained a respectable 39 seats to hold 303 of the 850 available. And when it came to negotiating a new coalition, the process was sure to be a much more fraught process than before following major losses for both their prospective partners: The socialist Osmanli Ahali Firkasi losing 49 seats to hold 167 - their lowest total since the 131 they held after the 1910 Election in the aftermath of the First Great War, when there had been 150 less seats available. The liberal Hürriyet ve Itilâf Firkasi suffered even more however, with the relatively light treatment they had received at the previous election before the full extent of the Census Affair had been uncovered now coming back to haunt them with a political battering, as they lost 61 seats to hold just 155 – Firmly relegated to the position of third party.

For the Ottoman Right, the election results signalled their return as a serious political force, but did not yet unveil a clear path to future power. The Young Turks, inspired by the military success and their firebrand new leader, achieved their greatest ever results by some margin to gain 32 seats for a total of 92, whilst Kazim Pasha restored dignity to the conservative Osmanli Demokrat Firkasi with a similarly large gain of 26 seats to hold 72, despite the disappointment of failing to unseat the Ittihat ve Terakki Cemiyeti as the largest party on the right. The ultra-religious Teceddüt Firkasi (Renewal Party) also scored their best results in a generation by gaining 22 seats to hold 38, with the party winning significant support in the rural fringes of the Empire where Islam retained huge importance in daily life despite the triumph of Secularisation. The libertarian Ahrar Firkasi also saw something of a renaissance, gaining 8 seats to hold 13, while the communist Ihtilalci Avam Firkasi were hugely disappointed after losing 17 seats to hold just 10: With their previous electoral breakthrough proving something of a false dawn, amid deep public suspicion of their own links to the trade union corruption scandal.

The electoral results saw the end of Mustafa Ismet Pasha’s leadership of the Osmanli Ahali Firkasi, as he stood down amid the recriminations following the heavy socialist losses. The Deputy Vizier had achieved much of what he set out to when he first entered government however, and in the years that followed his reputation gradually recovered as the leadership of the socialist party rapidly passed between the hands of successive inexperienced newcomers who failed to leave any mark on the party or the wider political situation in the Empire. The Hürriyet ve Itilâf Firkasi also saw further infighting in the aftermath of the result, but Mahmut Celal Pasha was able to cling on to its leadership after initating coalition discussions, with the Murat Pasha supporters having been all but eliminated in the parliamentary losses – Thereby ironically strengthening the base of the leader who had overseen those losses.


3f2f0d9869bf0cc95645c9d96b05a1c1.png

Grand Vizier Rauf Bey shocked the world in the aftermath of his huge electoral victory in 1939

For Rauf Bey, the election was a huge personal triumph. The Sosyal Demokrat Firkasi was now by far the largest party in Ottoman politics, with both of its major rivals having suffered serious setbacks. When the coalition negotiations began, the Sosyal Demokrat Firkasi also held all the cards as it negotiated with both sides, and when the eventual deal was signed with the Hürriyet ve Itilâf Firkasi, the liberals had not succeeded in gaining many significant posts at all. Mahmut Celal Pasha was appointed Deputy Vizier, as was customary, but the liberals had succeeded in gaining control of only the Naval, Agricultural, and Education Ministries in the Cabinet. All the great offices of state were retained by the Sosyal Demokrat Firkasi – The first time one party had achieved this in a generation. The coalition was the cherry on the cake of a long and fruitful career for Rauf Bey, where he had transformed his party from a minor coalition role to a major partner, a leader of government, and finally to total domination of the political scene. And so his announcement on April 17th 1939 that he was standing down as Grand Vizier and leader of the Sosyal Demokrat Firkasi with immediate effect caught the entire nation by surprise.

For the Grand Vizier, the memory of the great Pertev Pasha’s eventual fall from power despite his huge personal popularity had been on his mind after his own great military victory in the Caucasian War. Pertev’s decisive victory in the Third Great War had not been enough to maintain control of his own party in the long run, and Rauf Bey was determined to instead retire on a high; on his own terms. The downfall of Mustafa Kemal Pasha was also likely to have played a large part in this, with Rauf Bey having witnessed his decline up close during his time as Mustafa Kemal’s Deputy Vizier. At the age of 57 he was still a healthy and fit man, and he intended to enjoy his retirement. The stunned establishment in the Sublime Porte were unable to convince him to stay on, and the Ottoman populace’s initial shocked reaction was soon turned into a week of national celebration of Rauf Bey’s achievements by savvy propagandists, who declared a “Farewell Week”, even as the Sosyal Demokrat Firkasi rushed to elect a successor: A battle eventually won by Mehmet Recep Pasha, who had previously held the Health Ministry.


573091fbd7fd7eab2bdcb99db9839a7e.png

The retirements of Rauf Bey and Mustafa Ismet Pasha signalled a true changing of the guard in Ottoman politics in 1939

2a8260df69933624bada3d4359d62974.png

Mehmet Recep Pasha won the race for leadership of the Sosyal Demokrat Firkasi and the Grand Viziership (April 26th 1939)

If Recep Pasha had expected an easy introduction to life in the Sublime Porte however, he was soon to be mistaken. Young Turk supporters had become much more open and public following the election results, with their huge gains legitimising them in a way never seen before, and tensions in the streets had been bubbling on the surface as those on the left who abhorred their new higher profile increasingly protested against them – Leading to a national strike on Labour Day 1939, called by the Osmanli Ahali Firkasi with the ostensible demand of the curtailing of unlimited daily work hours but in reality taking the form of anti-fascist protests and civil disorder attacking prominent Young Turk supporting businesses; something which quickly triggered a response by Huseyin Nihal Bey’s party. Fearing the protests spiralling out of control into an outright revolution, the new Grand Vizier acted quickly and decisively in this early crisis: With the passage of a 12 Hour Maximum Work Day Bill sailing through the Ottoman parliament within days, and a military crackdown on the significantly thinned numbers of protesters who continued the disorder swiftly following. Mustard cut for the new-look Sublime Porte.


b6be0cb77d4966951018a960fe9940e7.png

The 1939 International Workers' Day saw massive protests across the Ottoman Empire welcome the new Grand Vizier into office (May 1st 1939)

ac629138bfa00b74a3a5ae20c158b54b.png

A combination of the 12 Hour Working Day Bill and a military crackdown ended the civil unrest following Labour Day (May 17th 1939)

Meanwhile elsewhere in the world, events were not standing still for the new government. The “American Question” had faded into the background of international politics in the decade since President Theodore G. Bilbo’s Southern Democrat-backed military coup had seized power in the United States, but opposition to his power had begun to grow on both sides of the spectrum. Whilst Bilbo had followed a fiercely segregationist path which had seen non-white American liberties continually curtailed, the US Military under Chief of Staff Douglas MacArthur had constantly prevented the President from restoring the institution of slavery, much to the frustration of many southern landholders. Despite this, many of the Northern states were horrified by the one party dictatorship that the Democratic Party had instituted following the purging of the Northern Democrats, which had banned all other political parties and therefore won all “elections” by default. Whilst initially President Bilbo had achieved a basic level of support by ending the permanent strikes and total public disorder that had characterised 1920s America, as the 1930s went by this had eroded as those memories faded into the background but the curtailing of freedoms continued. Murmurs of secession had been ongoing in a number of northern states, but had they been able to do it without the Southern Landholders moving first is a matter of debate to this day.


68191b71a4050af0c1cf1ab72657ca41.png

A second military coup in America overthrew President Bilbo and replaced him with former Army Chief of Staff Douglas MacArthur (September 29th 1939)

As it was, September 1939 saw the former Confederate states of Virginia, Mississippi, and Nebraska launch an ultimatum for the immediate restoration of slavery, else they would secede from the union and reinstitute it regardless. President Bilbo, hamstrung by a military which was itself in no true shape to fight a civil war but was certainly capable of seizing control of the capital, was unable to meet their demands, and the three states announced the formation of ‘The New Confederacy’ on September 27th as a result - Which immediately restored slavery as public militias were formed to capture those black & Native American citizens unfortunate enough not to have escaped to other states. Whilst the White House decried the illegal secessions, the military had had enough of President Bilbo and a second coup swiftly followed, this time removing the Southern Democrats from key posts as Douglas MacArthur took over the Presidency for himself and a full military dictatorship was instituted. The New Confederacy then mobilised for a new war, and called upon other Southern states to now abandon the Union and once more raise the ‘Bonnie Blue Flag’.

For horrified northerners, this was the final straw – low level Democrats in Midwestern states which had never been hugely supportive of the Bilbo Presidency now took over their state legislatures and ended the local bans on the Socialist & Republican Parties as they looked to begin their own secessions: With the ‘Chicago Convention’ of October 21st 1939 often pinpointed as the day the Second American Civil War in the Disunited States truly began, when Illinois announced its secession to form the “New American Alliance”, although the sparsely populated western state of Colorado had already declared its own secession a few days earlier. The American crisis had also opened the doors to the Fascist Dictatorship of Mexico launching a second (and ultimately successful) attempt to seize control of the Californian Republic whilst the eyes of the world were distracted by other even more unexpected developments [1]. And in the months that followed the Chicago Convention, further states would secede from the Fallen Eagle to join both the Alliance and the Confederacy…


d19864eb7a28796fc74f060523649c72.png

The 1939 Chicago Convention signals the outbreak of the Second American Civil War (October 21st 1939)

[1] – More on that in the next update
 
  • 3Like
Reactions:
I would call that a satisfying conclusion to the war. Cool to see the Ming back in the driver's seat in China.
Indeed, a quite unexpected turn of events over there. I would have liked them to wait until after the war though :D
BASED. the brother Emperors of the Sublime Porte and the Forbidden City shall stand together against the west, this is the best possible result
It was certainly an excellent twist to see restored Chinese monarchy!
What stupendous results. And in such a short time, as noted in the update. Russia is on her knees, the ottomans are ascendant in Asia, and the french are clearly doing very well out of all this too.
Aye the Franco-Ottoman Alliance has some rather unstoppable momentum now - A true superpower
Great result and a great update! I love the Chinese details. Even if the Russian Empire is not dismantled, they are surely bloodied. This has been a good show of muscles.
Holding out on accepting the peace so that I could occupy Moscow first was a very satisfying game moment - True cathartic revenge for the First Great War :p
Russia got a right proper thumping.

One does have to wonder, given that scandal though, if the elections might be surprising
The return of the Right as a serious force instead of a standing joke certainly changes the complexity of Ottoman politics for the future
And so centuries of humiliation are avenged. This was as good an outcome to the war as I could have imagined.
Very much so!
Now that this AAR is back in business, I guess it's as good a time as any to break cover from lurking and reading. :D

I'd like to echo @Tommy4ever's comments that the updates dealing with first Great War were a rather epic read. An unwelcome and hair-raising development as a player, no doubt—but riveting to the reader. Occasional setbacks make the forward strides more rewarding and significant.



One of the things I find intriguing about the AAR is that it's inadvertently revealed how my own (admittedly slim) knowledge and reading on Ottoman historiography is thoroughly marinated in Victorian perspectives and biases—aka the largely discredited Ottoman decline paradigm. I'm constantly having to remind myself that this is a large and successful multiethnic Ottoman state that has undergone significant liberalisation (in the spirit of the Tanzimat), and that's a scenario I don't encounter a lot of, even in alt-history.
Welcome, glad to have you board! The First Great War was certainly one of the highlights to write about in this: A setback of that magnitude made for a great tale, even though at the time I was fearing it would begin an irresistible downward spiral had the Quadruple Entente never broken up

When I first started this AAR I was similarly only aware of certain elements of Ottoman history in the Victorian Era, but I was first inspired when reading some WW1 books that included Turkish sources on the Gallipoli campaign and which seriously challenged the general idea of incompetent Ottomans who only won at Gallipoli because the Brits were even more inept. Reading about the Ottoman's involvement in WW1 really challenged the general Ottoman decline picture I had in the past, as they really vastly outperformed the Austro-Hungarians and given their limitations in equipment and logistics, they performed admirably well in the circumstances.

It's been very interesting to chart the changing state of the Porte from the rather weak initial position through the constitutional era, the success of Tanzimat (as opposed to its real life failure) and the eventual triumph of the Young Ottomans in forging such a uniquely liberal & secular empire, for sure.

In fairness, Europe isn't too far off from OTL, and in fact better given that Fascism has not risen to power. Russia is hostile but western Europe seems to have settled into an equilibrium.

Still, yes, looking forwards to OTL 2003, when the Ottoman Imperial Army invades the Republic of Texas to overthrow dictator George W. Bush, on suspicions that he is building chemical weapons.
Indeed, France has obviously done much better in TTL that OTL, whilst Britain has gone into decline about 40 years earlier (although ironically due to similar circumstances, with exhaustion and the huge manpower losses after their victory in the First Great War really beginning the end of their domination). Germany of course got very similar treatment to OTL but without the Nazis (at least so far!), but the successful renaissance of Austria-Hungary isn't something that happens very often in my V2 games, so that's also been quite cool to see.

And yes, those American barbarians might be the source of world problems for decades to come ;)
So discussed in TT. It's a really good place for a game. No matter how powerful you get, you have so many borders open to attack. So many problems that you'll never fix. So many things to overcome.

Compelling, varied and replayable. So, very god for a game and an AAR.
Agreed, I generally prefer to play countries that have a lot of challenges but also a lot of potential, and the Ottomans are great fun in Vicky 2 for exactly those reasons: There's always a chance that things could fall apart very quickly, and you're likely to get pushed in very different directions in different games.
Catching up now! A restored royalist China is a wonderful sight to see!
Welcome back!

The Ming restoration was very unexpected but I very much enjoy the way it's come about - Especially after Japan had become a republic and the Far East looked to have quietened down and become all respectable :p