• We have updated our Community Code of Conduct. Please read through the new rules for the forum that are an integral part of Paradox Interactive’s User Agreement.
My apologies, didn't have reception on my phone. I'll have to go back and read everyone's post.

I'll see what people do with a tie.

Vote Grimlock
 
My apologies, didn't have reception on my phone. I'll have to go back and read everyone's post.

I'll see what people do with a tie.

Vote Grimlock
Deadline was 2 minutes ago...
 
Day 1 Final Vote Count:

Alxeu: 3
Sleepyhead [60]
Chieron [65]
Avernite [55 Captain Grimlock -> 78]

Captain Grimlock: 2
ironhide g1 [59]
Dedonus [58 Chieron -> 77]

Dedonus: 2
Alxeu [61]
Arkasas [71]

Arkasas: 1
Aedan [57]

Ironhide G1: 1
Wagonlitz [62]

Avernite: 1
MAWofdoom [65]

Culann: 1
R.Graymarch [72]

Not Voted:
@CaptainGrimlock
@johho888
@Culann
 
It is interesting that Avernite got Alxeu lynched. He and Dedonus seem to have switched votes at more or less the same time to break a threeway tie involving Dedonus, Alxeu, and Grimlock. Dedonus' switch makes sense, he was in the tie, and he switched to Grimlock who hadn't voted, and still is absent. Avernite's decision to switch to Alxeu is easier to question, especially with his role now know, but he was already voting Grimlock, so he only could have broken the tie in favor of Alxeu or Dedonus, and Dedonus was at least on at the time making votecounts. So there are entirely acceptable reasons for villager Avernite to do what he did. But he still did make a voteswitch to save absent unknown Grimlock and kill now known major goodie alxeu. So I suggest keeping an eye on him, even if I'm not going to vote for him right now.

His reasoning for voting Graymarch today is good at least, a late day throwaway vote is always questionable.

Instead I will vote Dedonus. He made his initial vote yesterday without any excuse of a reason, notably the only one to do so. Not necessarily suspicious, but notable. What I find more suspicious is his very active posting of votecounts through the day, even as relatively little changed on the same page. There were two new votes between each time he posted a new votecount. Hardly necessary, but Dedonus knows that being the dedicated votecounter makes people less likely to lynch you, so I think he's overdoing that to protect himself.

The key part that makes this suspicious is the complete lack of any explanation for his actions, either his first vote or switch. The second is easy enough to figure out, but a crucial part of being a goodie is giving information to work with, so the complete lack strikes me as suspicious.

Vote Dedonus
 
This is what happens when I get distracted for a majority of the day. :(
 
Probably for the best, heading out tomorrow. Have fun!
 
  • 1Like
Reactions:
Dedonus' switch makes sense, he was in the tie, and he switched to Grimlock who hadn't voted, and still is absent.

Instead I will vote Dedonus. He made his initial vote yesterday without any excuse of a reason, notably the only one to do so. Not necessarily suspicious, but notable.

The key part that makes this suspicious is the complete lack of any explanation for his actions, either his first vote or switch. The second is easy enough to figure out, but a crucial part of being a goodie is giving information to work with, so the complete lack strikes me as suspicious.
This is an extremely weak argument, especially since you mentioned in the same post that my second vote "ma[d]e sense." There are no real arguments on Day 1 unless the baddies make a critical error. Plus, there were only a few minute until deadline when I switched my vote. I'm sorry I was more focused on preventing a 3-way tie instead of giving a flimsy excuse for an argument. Furthermore, I wasn't the one who pushed the guardian angel into the lead. Instead, I switched my vote to someone who was inactive (more on this later).

What I find more suspicious is his very active posting of votecounts through the day, even as relatively little changed on the same page. There were two new votes between each time he posted a new votecount. Hardly necessary, but Dedonus knows that being the dedicated votecounter makes people less likely to lynch you, so I think he's overdoing that to protect himself.
This just illustrates how inactive the game has been. My three vote counts had 7, 5, and 3 non-voters listed respectively. 2.5 hours elapsed between my first and second vote counts and 4 hours between my second and third. Plus, it isn't unreasonable to make a vote count close to deadline so people know what the vote count is, so that they don't have to do mental math during crunch time.

What I find interesting is that the NIght 0 and Night 1 hunts were the last and penultimate players on the roster list. While it could be a coincidence, I believe this evidence indicates that the werewolves have been using a standing hunt order set as the last player on the roster list. Furthermore, assuming the NIght 0 and Night 1 hunts were standing hunt orders, because the werewolves did not change the hunt to a different individual, I believe this indicates that there probably is at least one werewolf (if not more) among the inactive players from yesterday. They just weren't around to change the hunt order (although it could also indicate that the werewolves didn't have a specific target they wanted to hunt, either).

Of the three people who did not vote on Day 1, Culann was hunted on NIght 1 (but they tried to vote, but was 2 minutes late, which was fortunate, or we would have had a Day 1 tie). I also already voted Grimlock. Therefore, there's only one person left:

VOTE Johho888

Also note that I'm currently the last living player on the roster list. Assuming the village doesn't lynch me, I should be up next if I am correct (and R.Graymarch if I am lynched). While by bringing this up, the werewolves will probably change their hunt, but on the off chance they do hunt me tonight, the village should look at anyone who has been relatively inactive today and yesterday.
 
I note the 180 done by aedan, even though his first comment on the hunt order was confirmed. Frustrated snake worshipper (American) who cannot set the hunt himself? Someone with a Cathay scanning device might want to look into that.

More inclined to listed to Dedonus at this stage as far as the vote is concerned.

Vote johho888
 
Shit, missed day 1.
Ah well, shouldn’t forget the rest of the game, right?
 
Wow that wasn’t a lot to read through. This game really has gone downhill.
(Then again, I’m not one to talk given my absence yesterday.)
Given I was always bad at analysis, then I’ll just have to plead my case.
Assuming Dedonus is correct with their assessment that the wolves are using a standing order to hunt the bottom of the list, then this implies less experienced wolves. And while I was never the best wolf, I’d like to think I’d be smarter than to use such a poor method of choosing a hunt target.
 
Also, I should probably do some RP posts:
”Here at Inverse Ninja airlines, we believe that the fewer planes we use, the better. Therefore we only have one plane. It’s just good business.”
 
Also, I should probably do some RP posts:
”Here at Inverse Ninja airlines, we believe that the fewer planes we use, the better. Therefore we only have one plane. It’s just good business.”
Sounds low budget to me...
 
  • 1Like
Reactions:
Hmm... Not much to say here. The only thing I do see is that, if the standing hunt order was simply the reversed sign up list, then there would have to be few wolves that signed up late, else if the wolves forgot to set a new hunt one of the days and randomly skipped over a single person in the sign up list, said person would immediately be suspicious. This makes it ever so slightly less likely that Dedonus is a wolf, though the hunt list could quite easily be random and just coincidentally have had the last players killed first, making this all meaningless.
In an attempt to not be completely useless for voting purposes as I usually am, I will vote Graymarch. Will this do anything, probably not as not much can cause him to not be incredibly quiet, but perhaps activity can be encouraged yet.
Vote R. Graymarch
 
You know what, sure. Let’s see what happens.

Vote Graymarch
 
Forgive how sloppy this looks, just doing a very brief count

R. Graymarch- 3
johho-2
Dedonus- 1

Not voted- 6 with 3.5 hours to deadline?

I'll do a placeholder vote to see how people react and adjust according a TIE, and Dedonus's reasoning seemed like it's a decent start to a day 2 case.

Vote Johho