• We have updated our Community Code of Conduct. Please read through the new rules for the forum that are an integral part of Paradox Interactive’s User Agreement.
That was the day that made me think you weren't the seer.

Statements like these confuse me. As far as I can tell, I always act the same way. At the very least, I try to act the same regardless of my role. What tipped you off to my non-seerishness?

EURO's plan, but we all thought it would work.

Damn, Slinky was right about that too.

Yes it was all planned ahead of time, but was it that obvious?

It was to Slinky. I considered it, but it seemed like too much to swallow.

Last night (before the call for the TIE) I PM'd Slinky with some stuff I "left-out" of my analysis that I posted here, so that I "didn't give the wolves any ideas about who the seer was". I believe Slinky saw right through that ploy.

Damn that Slinky!

Oh, EURO was in contact with Punkbob during and after day 3. Jester was supposed to sacrifice himself so that we could get one more day of possible "seer-blocking".

Well, he's definitely player of the game now.

...

Until your PM, he suspected Exadus more than he did you, and he wanted me to scan AVN (I didn't see the use, I advocated just lynching him unscanned). It's not like Slink was right about everything. :p
 
@Thistletooth: your analysis set me on the right path and you made some bald decisions that I probably wouldn't have taken. You have certainly earned your first seer victory :)
 
Howso and what?

Well, you definately set me on the right path regarding AVN and that put the game in another perspective. Also your decision not to scan AVN and lynching him was the correct one. Of course the going for the TIE thing was also good, I don't think I would have done that so early.

Though I didn't listen when you suggested I could use Exadus as the mouthpiece. I thought it would hurt our chances, since Exadus might get suspicious after my history of pretence and certainly in this game, where it was used by the wolves. Instead I thought to use their own ploy against them and pretend to have been contacted, like we were planning to do with Exadus.
 
Official GM Vote Count
Time until deadline: ~1.5 hours

Lord Strange: 3
-Slinky[486], Exadus[510], Lord Strange[553]

OrangeYoshi: 3
-jonti-h[508], Teep[515], Thistletooth[552]

jonti-h: 1
-Polar Mongoose[563]

Not voted: 1
-OrangeYoshi
 
Last edited:

well it's not like something is goining to change the GM can better end this :)

Unless Lord Strange is not really a wolf and is siding with them because he subbed into a losing position.
 
Statements like these confuse me. As far as I can tell, I always act the same way. At the very least, I try to act the same regardless of my role. What tipped you off to my non-seerishness?

Even though we all try and use our "poker faces", sometimes things happen that shows what we are really doing. I tried not to mention talking to anyone outside of the thread, but you guys were suspicious of our day 3 voting.

On day 2, if I were to get lynched, you would've been next in line for your backing of me. If I were the seer, I don't know that I would've been willing to put myself out there like that. There was alot of risk involved with backing anyone that early as a seer.
 
Official GM Vote Count
Day 6

Lord Strange: 3
-Slinky[486], Exadus[510], Lord Strange[553]

OrangeYoshi: 3
-jonti-h[508], Teep[515], Thistletooth[552]

jonti-h: 1
-Polar Mongoose[563]

Not voted: 1
-OrangeYoshi
 
Day 6

The jig was up. Labour used the extensive surveillance systems around the country to spy on the Conservatives and find out which ones were infiltrating the party. Lord Strange and OrangeYoshi the Conservative MPs were caught and expelled from the Labour Party.

You lynched Lord Strange the werewolf
You lynched OrangeYoshi the werewolf



Game Winners:


-Thistletooth the Seer
-jonti-h the villager
-Exadus the villager
-Polar Mongoose the villager
-Teep the villager
-Slinky the villager


Congratulations to the village, and thanks to everyone for playing!
 
Just for the record, I would have never hunted TT unless he really acted like the seer or there were two people left, and the other was a wolf.
 
Even though we all try and use our "poker faces", sometimes things happen that shows what we are really doing. I tried not to mention talking to anyone outside of the thread, but you guys were suspicious of our day 3 voting.

On day 2, if I were to get lynched, you would've been next in line for your backing of me. If I were the seer, I don't know that I would've been willing to put myself out there like that. There was alot of risk involved with backing anyone that early as a seer.

I make it a point to play a decisive role in the game regardless of what I am. I'm here, I'd might as well do something. If you go back to my previous games, you'll see that I defend people all the time. I don't care. Right, (usually) wrong, it's something. And as a seer or villager, I'm far more afraid of the hunt than of the lynch, and as a wolf, I'm afraid of the scan and of losing allies. Regardless of my role, I'm generally convinced that I can do anything I want within reason and not get lynched for it (or at least the odds lean that way, and I'm a slave to the odds), but as a seer, I have the option of declaring myself scanned, or sending a scanner villager off on a guess. I just don't like hiding. If I hadn't been waiting for a seer victory for so long, I would have been far more public than I was in this game. I probably would have outed myself with two wolves still alive, to draw the hunt away from my allies.
 
Thanks for GMing Jingles. :D
 
Day 6

The jig was up. Labour used the extensive surveillance systems around the country to spy on the Conservatives and find out which ones were infiltrating the party. Lord Strange and OrangeYoshi the Conservative MPs were caught and expelled from the Labour Party.

You lynched Lord Strange the werewolf
You lynched OrangeYoshi the werewolf

I'd like to thank the loyal opposition for not trying to drag me down with them. In the best spirit of boring gentlemanly British politics, I hereby order you all pardoned, so long as you've learned your lesson. Thankfully no one was hurt in this whole sad little mess.
 
I make it a point to play a decisive role in the game regardless of what I am. I'm here, I'd might as well do something. If you go back to my previous games, you'll see that I defend people all the time. I don't care. Right, (usually) wrong, it's something. And as a seer or villager, I'm far more afraid of the hunt than of the lynch, and as a wolf, I'm afraid of the scan and of losing allies. Regardless of my role, I'm generally convinced that I can do anything I want within reason and not get lynched for it (or at least the odds lean that way, and I'm a slave to the odds), but as a seer, I have the option of declaring myself scanned, or sending a scanner villager off on a guess. I just don't like hiding. If I hadn't been waiting for a seer victory for so long, I would have been far more public than I was in this game. I probably would have outed myself with two wolves still alive, to draw the hunt away from my allies.
If you go back to "Werewolves on Holiday", several people were surprised that I turned out to be a wolf. They were surprised that I did so much vote analysis even though it might hurt the baddies. As far as I know, I've acted the same way in all 4 games I've played, including the one where I wasn't a wolf.

I too never want to be inactive, but I just don't know if I would risk putting such a big target on my back if I was wrong.

@ Jingles: Good game, thanks for the excellent GM-ship. At least you haven't disappeared!