• We have updated our Community Code of Conduct. Please read through the new rules for the forum that are an integral part of Paradox Interactive’s User Agreement.
You say the right thing for me to do is admit I made a mistake (which I had already done multiple times) but then say I should not be allowed in the game because I am a total liability (because of a single n00b mistake in my very first round).

* I didn't say you shouldn't be allowed in the game, I said you should be lynched.

* It wan't just a n00b mistake, it was a very serious one, which could have easily been avoided by a couple of quick questions to the GM

* If it is your first game, surely anyone would make damn sure they didn't make the mother of all foulups

* Your reaction was more concern that people knew it was you killing snoop, not that you had done so.

Assuming is bad but branding newcomers to the game "total liabilities" that need to gtfo and not worthy to be kept around is good?

What in the name of Johan's boxer shorts has your newbiness got to do with it? You cocked it up, and I would be saying exactly the same if it was you or AOK.11 who did it.

Offense is the best form of defense - you are making this big ruckus about me likely being a wolf or a terrible gamer or whatever, so that people will be busy discussing ME and not considering for a second that YOU are in fact a wolf. So yeah, there is heat on you from the start of the game if you are - as I and others suspect - one of the werewolves.

:rofl::rofl::rofl:

So yeah, I am such a wolf that I draw all this attention to myself *counts the votes against me on the digit of one hand* when nobody had even noticed me before to go on the defence against what?

Dear lawd, please try doing this against AOK, if you think I'm abrasive, he's hydrochloric acid.
 
''Hey, does this rag smell like chloroform to you?''

Seriously, no one else has seriously accused jonti of lycanthropy so far IIRC, you're clutching at straws here

I thought PM conversations about the game were allowed?
 
That post was before it sunk in for everyone that there may not be any more scanners out there other than another priest (why 2 seers and not 2 priests?).

Check one of my next posts, possibly the very next one. ;)
There were not two seers and one priest. There were one seer, one priest and one van Helsing disguised/posing/working as as a seer. That is already a lot of goodie scanners so I wonder what the baddies got to balance that.
 
What PM conversations? Do share.
I did. :)

EDIT: And yes, PM conversations are allowed.

EDIT2: PM conversations about the game between players and ghost are ofc not. But between players its perfectly okay.

EDIT3: PM conversations between 2 ghost or a ghost and the GM is also okay

EDIT4: Unless they intend to sub ofc!

That should settle it :p
 
Last edited:
If I was a wolf what sense would there be in me having PM conversations with other players about you likely being a wolf? You make no sense. Notice how you are the only one making huge ass posts accusing me of this and that. :rolleyes: I'm new to the game, I made a mistake, both by not reading the rules in-depth enough and not asking before I sent in orders, but I did act in what I thought was the interest of my "side", the goodies, in killing what I had believed to be a baddie. It is what it is, five pages on and you're still making a big deal out of it. Yes I was wrong and I won't do it again, APOLOGIES. geez.

Thanks WD, its what I had thought.
 
If I was a wolf what sense would there be in me having PM conversations with other players about you likely being a wolf? You make no sense. Notice how you are the only one making huge ass posts accusing me of this and that. :rolleyes:

Thanks WD, its what I had thought.

Yeah I can't think of any reason why a wolf would want to try and trick a villager into lynching someone not from their pack at all! ;)
 
If I was a wolf what sense would there be in me having PM conversations with other players about you likely being a wolf?
I just said that you should take a deep breath, don't get too emotional and remember that Jonti is actually a nice guy.
 
If I was a wolf what sense would there be in me having PM conversations with other players about you likely being a wolf?

Because in WW big there is usually more than one pack.


You make no sense.

If the guy who just killed the van helsing and only seems ot care about being caught says I make no sense, I am glad.

Notice how you are the only one making huge ass posts accusing me of this and that. :rolleyes:

And you are the only one making huge posts about my being one :rolleyes:

Except I can build a case against you, while you can't build one against me.
 
not necessarily. I find it odd that Torn was first to defend Velasco. Catching up on the thread just now, I agree w/ jonti that he COULD be playing the "newbie" card. But I do feel he is, actually, a no0b. Torn's defense of him smells of wolf, however. He defends the villager as the villager is set to be lynched. Those accused of trying to lynch the villager are themselves accused of being wolves.

which fits in nicely with the earlier theory of those wanting to lynch Velasco being accused of lycanthropy.

Unvote Velasco the No0b

Vote Tornadoli
This makes sense (and not just because Tornadoli voted me ;)).

OTOH what would a baddie do with three dead goodie scanners after night 2? My guess is he would either lay low or he would try to steer the village, not necessarily jumping the first available bandwagon. Problem is there are a lot of people trying to steer the vote one way or the other just like Tornadoli. WD for example doesn't quite ring true for me.

I also wonder about the night 1 hunt of Lord Strange (right out of retirement). Given how Yakman always bitches about not hunting newbies I'd be really surprised if he is in the night 1 pack. Are there more people like that we can meta reason away with as night 1ers?

Anyway it is nice to see so much activity in the thread.

unvote Velasco, vote Tornadoli
 
I just said that you should take a deep breath, don't get too emotional and remember that Jonti is actually a nice guy.


There are other players, you know? :rofl: gosh
 
I also wonder about the night 1 hunt of Lord Strange (right out of retirement). Given how Yakman always bitches about not hunting newbies I'd be really surprised if he is in the night 1 pack. Are there more people like that we can meta reason away with as night 1ers?

Me. Lord Strange is a Tory and so am I :p