• We have updated our Community Code of Conduct. Please read through the new rules for the forum that are an integral part of Paradox Interactive’s User Agreement.
Well, it's a question of better and worse uses for submarines.

Great use: raid convoys

Good use: Sink capital ships, even if they can be replaced (don't discount the psychological effect of losing CVs; a more cautious Pacific Fleet has advantages)

Bad use: Ship supplies to garrisons which are being bypassed anyway while the Allies get closer to Japan.

Except for that insane I400 class. It if had stopped carrying planes and started carrying bullets, it may have been JAP's answer to their freighters getting splattered. Could even have fired a torpedo or two at a convoy after it had dropped off its cargo and was on the way back ;p.
 
Except for that insane I400 class. It if had stopped carrying planes and started carrying bullets, it may have been JAP's answer to their freighters getting splattered. Could even have fired a torpedo or two at a convoy after it had dropped off its cargo and was on the way back ;p.
No not really.

One I-400 could carry 3 x 4 ton planes, so optimistically perhaps 20-30 tons of Cargo extra for removing the planes, and only 3 of these subs were completed near the end of the war for a large cost each.

When Japan entered the war they had a total capacity to carry around 3 million tons of Cargo using their entire merchant marine, normally at least 500-1000 ton or more on each ship. And this was hardly enough to supply all their forces at the height of their expansion even without accounting for losses.


Some numbers on the supply needs of forces:

German armored division:
30 tons per day when inactive
700 tons a day when in heavy fighting

German Infantry divisions:
80 tons per day when inactive
1,100 tons a day in heavy fighting

This meant that even all the three I-400 submarines built had to be able to make a trip each day to be able to supply an inactive Infantry division, so it could not be stationed much further away then 200-300km, or else the submarines won't have enough time to make the trip.
 
Last edited:
I agree supply by sub is impractical, but you should probably remember the Japanese were known for still doing quite well on what I would imagine the Germans would consider an unacceptable supply situation. So quoting German usage isn't that helpful.
 
No not really...

Sorry, I should have made my sarcasm more obvious. I realize the I400 was a bad design, I was trying to mock it, not support it ;p.



Hey, in other news... Alex, you're one of this forum's Aurora 4x specialists, right? Is there, like, a subforum I can ask you questions about it in? (so that I don't end up highjacking this thread)?