Your Favorite stAARs? (the 4 votes poll)

[unmerged(2695)]

My runners up were
Shawng, for his gripping untold tale of the Good Cherokee
Havard, for his multicoloured story of the Knights of St. John
and
Sytass, for his ability to make me green with envy.

But I do feel that MrT is the man to get my vote for Waiting for Todog, the best AAR ever.

 

[Derek Pullem]

Well LD gets my main vote for the sheer volume of high quality writing and the effort to organise some of the independent spirits out there.

Runners up go to Ariel for the EU1 England AAR and spin off threads
Olaf the White for the classic Vinland tales and Pan Zagobla for the Polish ambassador in Ariel's AAR. In particular the vision of a squadron of Polish Winged Hussars assaulting a convent held by battle trained nuns of the inquisition

 

[Lucidor]

2. Hjarg
3. Warspite
4. Lord Durham

 

[Sharur]

Just as a clarification for Hardu, it was actually heagarty who wrote the tale of the Good Cherokee

 

[celedhring]

Hey guys just dropped to see how surprised and overjoyed I am to be at the ballot, although my contribution was so little. Thanks everybody. I am currently retired at the RPG forum, when I can both write and play, but maybe I'll come back with a GH stint when I get EU2, and my job is less pressing. Again, thanks to all, and my votes:

2. Durham
3. Velocyrix
4. Warspite

 

[Norgesvenn]

Choosing between so many talented writers is hard. Very hard. But my number one is Lord Durham, based on the sheer quality of the writing.
2) MrT. There's no escaping this truly original writer. Crazy AARs like "Early Gaelic verse" coupled with a strangely sober king Erik in "The Fellowship of Kings" makes MrT a monumental writer in my book.
3) Now this one's hard, but Honour_Shogun's characters makes reading his AARs screamingly funny.
4) Peter Ebbesen. "The Timurid Scientists" is worthy of a status as a novel. More AARs and he'd be my numero uno. Original and extremely witty.

Those were my four.

 

[Bearnie]

why isn't I one in the list?

ok, I have only written one unfinished AAR, that I stopped doing months ago, but anyway...

 

[unmerged(8394)]

1. Ariel (MY Pole Vote)
2. Durham
3. MrT
4. Warspite