• We have updated our Community Code of Conduct. Please read through the new rules for the forum that are an integral part of Paradox Interactive’s User Agreement.

Tinto Talks #70 - 2nd of July 2025

Hello, and welcome to another Tinto Talks, the happy Wednesdays where we talk about Europa Universalis V!

Today, we will talk about another very impactful early-game situation: the Hundred Years’ War!

Historically, the war started when, in May 1337, Philip VI confiscated the Duchy of Aquitaine from Edward III of England, for the reason of breaching his obligations as a vassal, which was responded to by Edward III claiming the throne of France by the rights of his mother, Isabella of France - the situation was way more complicated than this, so let’s leave the historical events here.

In our game, a couple of months after the start of the game (so, in June 1337), this event will trigger to France:
1. Robert de Artois.jpg

2. Robert de Artois.jpg

3. Robert de Artois.jpg

While this is the English point of view:
4. Robert de Artois.jpg

5. Robert de Artois.jpg

6. Robert de Artois.jpg

If the historical options are followed (which is set to always happen to AI countries), this will happen:
The Crown of France.jpg

And it will also trigger the situation:
HYW TT.jpg

HYW Panel.jpg

HYW Map.jpg

The starting situation of the Hundred Years’ War, with the French and English subjects. You can notice the striped vassals, which mean that these are disloyal subjects.

As you see, each contender has its own set of objectives:
English Victory Conditions.png

French Victory Conditions.jpg

You can also see that there’s a Strength comparison:
England Strength.jpg

France Strength.jpg

Note: Numbers are a matter of balance, so please consider them WIP.

With the situation and claims in place, it’s just a matter of time before one of the sides declares war on the other:
The Throne of France.png

CB Defenf the Throne of France.jpg

War Declaration.jpg

Something interesting is that each war is considered a ‘phase’ of the situation, so until it ends, any war between France and England will be considered ‘the 1st Phase’, ‘the 2nd Phase’, and so on:
Phases.jpg

The Situation panel will also refresh when the war starts, so you can quickly check there everything related to it:
War Panel.jpg

Let’s talk now about the actions. There’s a common action that any of the sides can do, if the war has lasted for longer than 4 years, that requests the Pope to enforce a white peace among the contenders:
Request Papal Delegates.jpg

The most important are those related to the French subjects; the objective for France will be to rein them in and have them contribute to the war effort in the conflict phases, while for England, it will be about convincing them to abandon the French king in the peace phases:
Grant Subject Titles.jpg


Influence French Subject.jpg

The French subjects have their own gameplay and actions, related to their relationship with the French sovereign, and if they stay loyal to them, or not:
Subject Actions1.jpg

Subject Actions2.jpg

Subject Actions3.jpg

Subject Actions4.jpg

Subject Actions5.jpg

So, at the end of the day, one of the contenders will probably be strong enough to defeat the other. In the case of France, it’s straightforward: No more independent English presence in the continent. In the case of England, beside pure conquest, the ‘Claim of Throne of France’ peace goal requests:
  • England (or their subjects) must control more than 15% of the ownable locations in the French Region
  • England must control the capital of France
The cost of this treaty also depends on 2 factors:
  • A base cost
  • A fluctuating cost based entirely on the relative strength between the two countries. So, a stronger England would inevitably make this peace treaty option somewhat cheaper.

And that’s it on the mechanical part of the situation; but there are also a bunch of events, both random and historical, that are dependent on it:
Scots King.jpg

Mercenaries.png

Jacquerie.png

Jeanne dArc.png

Jeanne dArc2.png

And that’s all for today! We will come back on Friday, as we will talk in Tinto Flavour about France!

And also remember, you can wishlist Europa Universalis V now! Cheers!
 
  • 106Love
  • 96Like
  • 2
  • 2
  • 1
Reactions:
Hello !

First of all : Finally ! The tinto talks on the Hundreds Years War was the thing I anticipated the most since we learned what is the starting date !

I have a question concerning a report one of the content creator that had access to the game made on his video on France. He said that sometimes the english ai doesnt even try to land on France, and since the war-goal is to win battle, even if France occupy the continental english territory, they wouldnt really gain lot of war score. Was that corrected ? Also, it seem that, on his video atleast, it was pretty easy for france to land in england. I hope the English AI will use his navy to protect the seas around the island actively... Also, he let the Aquitaine territory to the english on purpose when he did peace to be able to declare war with the situation again to take territory on the english territory directly. I don't know if that's something that should stay... I don't really have a solution, but I find it weird that the situation stay if France take a territory in the main land. I feel like, if France is able to control a territory on the main land, then that should trigger the end of the situation, because I think that if France is able to land and take a province in the peace deal on the main land, then England doesn't have any chance left to win and should put an end to the conflict.
But maybe that's just me.

In any case, keep up the good work, I'm really really hype for this game, I can't wait anymore haha. Already wishlisted and will pre-order it as soon as it's possible !
 
  • 2Like
Reactions:
England going to have any incentive to fight this out if they wanted to mainly do a "historical" GB colonial campaign?
I don't really understand your question.

If they want to do a historical campaign, fighting it out was the historical thing the English did (and they fought tooth and nail), so you would want to do it, yes.
If you want a colonial campaign, this whole ordeal happens before the age of discovery (when colonialism becomes a reasonably achievable option), so it doesn't interrupt your colonization process anyway, and besides, colonies are expensive to create and maintain, so it is only logical to try to get hold of France before it, so you'd have double the tax base and triple the population and have an easier time colonizing later.
 
  • 3
Reactions:
I don't really understand your question.

If they want to do a historical campaign, fighting it out was the historical thing the English did (and they fought tooth and nail), so you would want to do it, yes.
If you want a colonial campaign, this whole ordeal happens before the age of discovery (when colonialism becomes a reasonably achievable option), so it doesn't interrupt your colonization process anyway, and besides, colonies are expensive to create and maintain, so it is only logical to try to get hold of France before it, so you'd have double the tax base and triple the population and have an easier time colonizing later.
Yeah in principle i don’t understand the original question.

Like even if you only focus on an English colonial campaign.

Fighting it and winning should 100% your priority.

In theory at least England winning against France would mean that:

1. More french pops than english pops died.
2. France cannot colonize.
3. You have unaccepted pops you can deport.
4. Bigger economy so making colonies is relatively cheaper.

No matter how you look at it Winning against France is a great deal.

Not to mention in many aspects the hexagon is a pretty defensible region.
 
  • 2
  • 1Like
Reactions:
r/EU5 - Scorland 3 Pak of Normandy Anjou Prove Ross Scotland Pale Mareh England Munstcr Francc Pc:h Brittany 1 Navarre Mallorca

Why aren't Anjou and Normandy part of the royal domains, yet La Marche and Marsan are when they were not? Why are Brittany, Alencon, Evreux, Artois, Flanders, Blois, Rethel, Nevers, Bourbon, Forez, La Marche, Armagnac, Foix, and Comminges disloyal? Why aren't Mann, Ulster, Kildare, Ormond, Desmond, Mayo, Clanricarde, and Clanwilliam considered subjects of England? And why aren't Navarre and Andorra subjects of France

Anjou had reverted to the royal crown in 1325, Phillip the Fortunate's son and heir Jean was made Duke of Normandy in 1332, Phillip III and his wife Joan II of Navarre, Evreux and Angouleme, Odo IV of Burgundy and his wife Joan III of Artois, Louis I of Flanders, Rethel and Nevers, Guy I of Blois, Louis I of Bourbon and La Marche, Guigues VII of Forez, Roger-Bernard of Perigord, Jean I of Armagnac, and Gaston II of Foix, Marsan, and Andorra were loyal, having reinforced Tournai in 1337, become part of Phillip the fortunate's inner circle, fought his people for pro-French policy, fought in the early stages of the Hundred Years War, backed Phillip the fourtunate's accession to the throne, fought in Flanders, was attacked by the English, provided 6000 troops to the french army, and fought Gascon noble who fought for England respectively?

Louis I of Bourbon was the count of la Marche, and Gaston II was the count of Marsan.

William I of Mann fought for England in the Hundred Years War; Elizabeth of Ulster, Maurice of Kildare, James of Ormond, Maurice of Desmond, Edmond of Mayo, Ulick of Clanricarde, and Edmond of Clanwilliam were subjects of England.

Phillip III of Navarre and Gaston II of Andorra had French holdings in the same vein as Edward III
 
Last edited:
  • 1
  • 1Like
Reactions:
1) Whats the max of stability if you can get +7?
2) Can we expect some more content with Jeanne D'arc even if not historical?
 
That's on any English player to decide, not on us. :)
Please tell me if theres any angevin content, I get its ahistorical but I also think it would just be weird to leave England in a PU with france and have no special flags or cultures, partially because of the decent chance of an English win occuring in our timeline. It's kinda like the Roman Empire based around Constantinople, one of the few country's you guys stated there was a focus on alt history since it was semi plausable.
 
  • 1
  • 1Like
Reactions:
Bonjour, hello developers,

Please could you pay attention to the French language for more linguistic immersion:

It is Robert D'ARTOIS, not "DE ARTOIS"..as seen on one of your screenshots.


Plus... Apanage word as an historical priviledge has only one "P" in french if you mean to employ it only into the French Kingdom political mechanics.

Cheers
 
  • 1
  • 1Like
Reactions: