• We have updated our Community Code of Conduct. Please read through the new rules for the forum that are an integral part of Paradox Interactive’s User Agreement.

unmerged(275742)

Corporal
7 Badges
Feb 27, 2011
29
0
  • Crusader Kings II
  • Europa Universalis III
  • Europa Universalis III Complete
  • Divine Wind
  • Hearts of Iron III
  • Heir to the Throne
  • Europa Universalis: Rome
up1-1.jpg


Do not always judge the power or influence of a state by it's size, sometimes these looks deceive. Here on the river Main lies the Free Imperial City of Frankfurt. From the ancient times of the Merovingians and the Carolingians through to the formation of the Holy Roman Empire and to the present, Frankfurt has known mostly peace, growth, and freedom in a world defined by rapacious power struggles and perpetual destitution. Frankfurt's power, and survival, has come from its status as a chief financial center of Europe and it will likely guide it's future.

up1-2.jpg


By October of 1399, Frankfurt's councilors had become absolutely determined to see their city's treasury reserves strengthened, and it was apparent that Stadtholder Michael Alfter's political survival depended on his ability to fulfill this ambition. Although such things as "political survival" rarely seemed to truly influence Alfter. He was a dangerous combination of a man, not simply for his gifted administrative abilities and shrewd political instincts, but for his clear sense of civil duty. In a continent where nobles would launch brutal wars amongst even their own family for meer parcels of land at the remorseless expense of peasants, Alfter stood out as a living paradox of the times; determined to improve the lives of his citizens and to see his lovely Frankfurt flourish.

Frankfurt already had a minor established trade presence in Antwerpen and Lubeck but Alfter was convinced that Frankfurt's trade not only held potential to be strengthened but critically needed strengthening for the city to have true strength and security. This fearful motive drove Alfter's political actions, and he wasted no time acting. He had managed to negotiate an increase in minting with Frankfurt's petty bankers which, while it would lead to some inflation, would help finance an effort to establish a strong trade presence in the wealthy Lubeck markets.

up1-3.jpg


By the summer of 1400, Lubeck was thoroughly dominated by Frankfurt's traders and merchants. Alfter, already by autumn, was contemplating financing new trade expeditions. The stunning successes of his trade push into the Lubeck markets had left him, for the first time, unsure how to proceed. Just how far could the tentacles of Frankfurt's trade reach? How strong was his little Frankfurt? Maybe it was possible to become the strongest trade presence in all northern Europe?

up1-4.jpg


Whatever the answer was, he had decided he would not do it alone. He had arranged a meeting with Edmund Cromwell, one of the prominent traders in Europe. Cromwell had fallen out of favor with many mercantile and noble factions in England and exiled himself to the European mainland. He had actively watched Frankfurt's power play in the Baltic markets and became immediately intrigued by the city. Cromwell and Alfter had had similar thoughts; Cromwell too thought Frankfurt could achieve supremacy over the northern markets. But Cromwell went farther yet. He believed if Frankfurt could succeed in controlling the northern trade, it could just as well begin to establish itself in the lucrative mercantilist markets of Italy. Alfter's credibility was regarded highly by the traders, bankers, and people of Frankfurt and he had little trouble subsidizing a merchants' venture into the Dutch markets in Antwerpen.

up1-5.jpg


The beginning of the year 1401 saw Frankfurters dominating the Baltic and Dutch markets, bringing substantial new revenue to the city-state. However,even with that new revenue, Alfter's expensive trade initiatives were taking substantial bites out of the treasury. He had convinced the bankers of Frankfurt to mint even more money but he would still have to scale down his push into France's Parisian markets, and even then the treasury would be almost completely dry. Nevertheless he pushed forward inspired by the previous triumphs and created incentive for a market push into Paris in the summer of 1401.

up1-6.jpg


The winter brought disaster. The costly trade initiative had almost completely failed to establish any Frankfurtian financial presence in Paris. The war between the Holy Roman Emperor and the King of France was wrecking the Parisian economy and with the successful capture of the entire northern coast of France, Paris itself was severely threatened and unlikely to withstand an assault from the Emperor's armies. Alfter was shaken. He had subsidized an expensive failure, left Frankfurt with no reserves for the near future, and his mandate to create a strong reserve was going to fail and likely lead to deposition. Edmund Cromwell was not as gloomy as Alfter. Perhaps because it was not his own political office or home city that was in question, or maybe it was simply because he was experienced. He offered a simple solution.

up1-7.jpg


Cromwell knew that the reputation of Frankfurt's traders and bankers and the city's treasury itself was still strong and he could easily secure any kind of loan available in Europe. Alfter could not only fund more trading with a good loan, he could also set aside enough for the substantial reserve that the electorate had mandated. The revenue from the growing trade in the meantime would easily fund the interest payments and the final sum of the loan in 5 years.

up1-8.jpg


France's armies had miraculously succeeded in defending Paris and began dislodging the Holy Roman Emperor from Caux in the spring of 1402. There was a change in the environment in Paris, a sense of security finally, and Frankfurters now found it easier to do business than before. By summer's end, Paris's markets were run by Frankfurtian companies and trade families. More importantly, all the major trade centers of Northern Europe were firmly in Frankfurt's control. Alfter had successfully secured a sizable treasury reserve for Frankfurt and the city council was beginning to trust utterly in their statdholder. But, as with any political assembly, the city council's motives were not always driven by caution or reason. The city council mandated that Alfter use Frankfurt's deep pockets to expand the size of the army so that it was larger than it's neighbor Mainz. It was clearly a jingoistic demand, more likely driven by the need to fill the councilors vote rolls than a desire to preserve Frankfurt's independence. Frankfurt was at the height of peace and prosperity, Alfter decided he would have nothing to do with any such effort, and simply left the council resolution sitting on his table, unopened.

up1-9.jpg


The winter of 1402 proved to be one of the most productive in recent times. Frankfurt's seemingly unstoppable ability to bring in new trade revenues and reliability in the loan markets made it a hotspot for Europe's financiers. With a vote of confidence from his trusted adviser Cromwell and the guaranteed support of the city council, Alfter established Frankfurt's first national bank, greatly empowering Frankfurt's ability to finance it's trade and augment inflation. The complete domination of the northern markets was acknowledged internationally when The Hansa formally invited Frankfurt into their trade league. Perhaps the next year would have finally been a year of rest and relief for Alfter were it not for the other things on his mind.

up1-10.jpg
 
Nice writing here, although it's a bit weird that some German guy is called the 'Stadtholder', a Dutch title, but I understand that's just the name of the ruler of whatever republic type Frankfurt is.
 
Nice writing here, although it's a bit weird that some German guy is called the 'Stadtholder', a Dutch title, but I understand that's just the name of the ruler of whatever republic type Frankfurt is.

It's a bit weird actually because that's NOT the title. Upon playing some more I noticed that the title of all 3 German adm. rep. minors was now "Syndic" and not "stadtholder", I'm not sure if it was just a bug (because I can clearly recall playing multiple Switzerland DW games with "stadtholder") but I will use "syndic" from now on.
 
up2-1_zps65f926ee.jpg


In his first term, Michael Alfter had orchestrated an ambitious assault on several major European markets with remarkable success. But the richest, and the most stubborn, markets were the powerful Italian markets in Venezia and Liguria. Alfter had no illusion of repeating the Lubeck takeover in these markets. Italian markets were highly protective and had well-established merchant clans and families. His advantage was that he would have 4 more years to accomplish this task. Frankfurt successes, or failures, in the Italian markets would not be known until atleast early June, while the elections were to be held in early May; and he had no serious challengers. By February of 1403, Alfter had secured commissions for several merchants to pry into the stronger of the two Italian markets, Venezia.

up2-2_zps487a8d31.jpg


His re-election had never been in question; regardless, Alfter was joyous to see his administration validated by vote. A good leader he was, but also a smart politician. His earlier calculation had proven skilled when the news came in June that only 1 merchant had succeeded to establish his trade in Venezia, a fact that may have changed the atmosphere of the election. The news did not affect Alfter in the least, he knew it was only a matter of time, and that was something he now had.

up2-3_zps8d501150.jpg


A year to the day of Alfter's election, it was clear Frankfurters had gripped the Venetian markets and were rivalled only by the merchants of Venice themselves. Control of the Ligurian markets would leave Frankfurt the masters of not only the Italian trade, but likely all Western European trade. Alfter had mastered Frankfurt's economic dilemnas but bigger distractions were beginning to emerge.

up2-4_zps366185cc.jpg


Frankfurt's southern neighbor, Mainz, had become embroiled in a war in the summer of 1404 that had left it besieged by The Palatinate's Rupert III von Wittelsbach and his 7,000 men. War was on Frankfurt's borders for the first time in years, and a feeling of unease had crept into the proud little city: a rude awakening that the power of trade might not be strong enough to repel 7,000 armed men.

up2-5_zpsf776e32a.jpg


What little military Mainz had, was quickly destroyed and the city council was now chiefly concerned with ensuring Frankfurt paid off it's debt in 1407. Alfter fumed at The Palatinate's invasion of Mainz and the threat it represented to Frankfurt, but he was a level-headed and calculating man. He would not see Frankfurt's trade empire climb such heights only to stop and lose everything under the weight of forming a bloated military driven by fear and paranoia.

up2-6_zpsc9deae6d.jpg


With no rest after New Years, Alfter began January of 1405 with a determination to finally secure Ligurian markets. Liguria would prove to be the most difficult nut to crack to date, but ultimately no market could protect itself from Frankfurt's merchants and companies.

up2-7_zps4a90b7d4.jpg


By October of 1406, Frankfurters were in control of every market they could reach. Many other markets surely existed farther away but they were too far to reach, even for Frankfurt. Perhaps in the future.

up2-8_zps3d25cf77.jpg


The amount of money that was going through Frankfurt and going through Frankfurter hands in foreign lands, was something that had been unimaginable in Alfter's father and grandfather's lifetime. Many key financiers and treasurers of Europe believed that Frankfurt was likely the strongest concentration of wealth in all Europe. Alfter had also finally paid off Frankfurt's loan in 1407. The city council was again trying to politically influence an enlargement of Frankfurt's army, but the truth was that Alfter was at the top of the political hierarchy in Frankfurt and almost untouchable. He feared what a military force could do to his rich and powerful, yet small and vulnerable, city-state; and he swore he would never enlarge it until the most dire circumstances dictated it.

up2-9_zpsc26a9229.jpg


The establishment of the Frankfurt National Bank years earlier had centralized the minting capabilites of the city. And it was none other than Alfter's nephew, Wenzel Alfter, that had become the master of the mint years ago. Alfter had forced a Frankfurtian trade empire unto Europe but his overall economic plan was not completed by this alone. Alfter's nephew, as an adviser, would help secure Frankfurt's domestic minting capabilities, and the economy of Frankfurt with it. It was easy to believe Alfter was a great leader after everything he had done, but as valiantly as he fought to empower Frankfurt's economy, he had done almost nothing to address the political and diplomatic developments that were occurring right outside the city walls.

up2-10_zps7401f9f8.jpg


Mainz had been aggressively annexed and The Palatinate now found itself in a war with Bavaria over its most eastern possessions. It had been dreadful enough to see Rupert III's 7,000 man army make a power-play on the city's southern borders, let alone thousands of Bavarian soldiers flooding the lands south of Frankfurt. In October of 1407,elections were held, and there was little doubt who the citizens would entrust to guide their city into the days ahead.

up2-11_zps08b4112b.jpg
 
Nice update! You're making a great income from trade, and your expenses must be fairly minimal just now so technological progress will be rapid. I'd like to see the rise of a military candidate, will someone be brave enough to attempt to take advantage of the Palatinate while they are distracted?
 
Wow this is actually.. really interesting. I'm duly impressed. Great to see a trading AAR that isn't Holland or Navarre for once, especially with such good narrative. You've got yourself a reader, sir.
 
Now that Frankfurt is financially stable, what is the next step? Also, what are your rules in terms of territorial expansion?

Good luck to you and your republic :) .
 
up3-1.jpg


Michael Alfter had won his third term in October of 1407. His first two terms had been spectacularly successful at stabilizing Frankfurt's economic footing for the better. He had made Frankfurt a capital of European trade, but sometimes a great strength has a way of exposing an even greater weakness. Frankfurt, for all the gold in it's coffers, did not have true security. The army of Frankfurt was a mere 1,000 men, the smallest of all it's neighbors. The diplomatic situations of Europe were deteriorating by the day. And on a continent where the perpetual chaos of wars rule the day, peaceful little Frankfurt, was dangerously ignorant and inexperienced.

up3-2.jpg


Over the summer of 1408 The Palatinate's conquest of Mainz would ultimately prove a failure as did their war against Bavaria. Mainz was again an independent state. The City Council had challenged Alfter to atleast match the military strength of little Cleves but Alfter refused and the challenge was rendered redundant when little Cleves' army was annahilated. This had the effect of politically validating Alfter's military policy to Frankfurters. Alfter had always been far more comfortable with diplomacy and the every-day duties of an administrator, than warfare and petty intrigues. The weary city council was beginning to understand they would not be able to deal with their external affairs militarily, atleast while Alfter was the Syndic. Alfter and the city council seemed to be finally finding agreements in their need for diplomatic initiatives and dealings. The city council had made it a priority that Alfter should improve Frankfurtian ties with their new neighbor: the once-again independent Mainz.

up3-3.jpg


The years of his third term were the hallmarks of Alfter's efficient administrating. The massive revenues from Frankfurt's trade had created a powerful Frankfurtian loan market, that was proving extremely profitable. Alfter's career had early on been built on trying to find ways to empower Frankfurt economically and he was still finding ways years later.

up3-4.jpg


Gerhard Storck had been one of the great Frankfurt success stories of Alfter's political career. Storck had started as a local shopkeeper and transformed into an internationally renown merchant. He had been one of the few men in Frankfurt who had had the financial ability to mint coins prior to the establishment of the National Bank. Storck was an ambitious merchant but his motivations as a man were clearly much deeper than simple greed, he was a wanderer and a traveller. Nothing fulfilled him more than visiting new lands and meeting foreign people. Storck boasted he could take Frankfurt's trade far beyond the near markets of Western Europe. Alfter was one of the people that believed his claim, and brought him into his administration in the summer of 1410.

up3-5.jpg


Alfter had began commissioning improvements in Frankfurt's infrastructure and over the next year new roads and buildings rose across the city. Alfter had also succeeded in the diplomatic realm, and relations between Frankfurt and Mainz had never been better. But again the political pressure for growing Frankfurt's army weighed down on Alfter. In the summer of 1411, only months away from the election, the city council passed an official resolution demanding Alfter increase the military capacity of their city-state. Alfter's opposition in the city council had been counting on their calculation of Alfter's usual knee-jerk reaction, the elections were nearing and the military was the strongest argument against Alfter's re-election. His solution to this political problem would be simple and elegant: lie.

up3-6.jpg


Alfter had spent over a decade as Frankfurt's Syndic and he knew how to play politics. His message to the voters was that he would indeed enlarge the army, but it could not be done until winter. A clear bold-faced lie, but a clever one that led the voters to a radically different approach to their electoral decision: who now, was the candidate most trustworthy with the task of expansion? And Alfter's reputation, and there his re-election, was never in serious question afterwards. In October of 1411, Michael Alfter was re-elected to his fourth term.

up3-7.jpg


By Spring of 1412, Alfter was losing popularity. His lie was now obvious to most voters and he found himself questioning his actions. He had never before had to rely on such a blatant lie in an election. He hadn't believed in enlarging the army. The votes should have decided the validity of his political steering not the cheap political trickery he used on his own fellow Frankfurters. Why did he lie? He toured his city one day and realized that the citizens were fatter than he remembered. They had grown lazier. This was not the old vibrant city pouring in money from foreign trade. It was a city of decadent oligarchs spoiled by an ever increasing horde of wealth. He lied because he had become lazy and cared only to make sure he won re-election, even if it meant lying. Frankfurt needed a shake up. Frankfurt needed an army.

up3-8.jpg


By Fall of 1412, the army of Frankfurt stood at 3,000 men. Alfter had succeeded in recruiting two entire regiments over the Summer and construction was underway for a massive armory in Frankfurt. The action was a complete political surprise to anyone in Frankfurt, but one that was greeted unanimously well. It was a small army, but it was modern by anyone's standards. What few poor and desolate and homeless people had lived in Frankfurt were now living in army camps making respectable salaries. Even for a gifted administrator, the logistical nightmare of recruiting, organizing, and arming an armed force of 3,000 men, takes it's toll. Alfter had grown noticeably thinner and grayer and he was desperate to find someway back into the world of trading affairs. His adviser Storck had pushed for Frankfurt to begin attempts to trade in the far-away Eastern European city of Novgorod, and Alfter eagerly accepted the plan and began making preparations.

up3-9.jpg


Within days, Alfter had several Frankfurtian merchants leaving the gates and headed east on carts loaded with goods and gold. The merchants would not reach their destination for several months and Alfter was impatiently eager to see what wonders and goods were to be found in the most eastern reaches of Europe. He laid in his bed smiling and fell asleep wondering, and never woke up.

up3-10.jpg
 
Well, first off congratulations on a good AAR, I really like that you have choosen the tiny city state of frankfurt and gone to a trade empire but i have to agree with a few people here right now and I believe it is time for you to expand, you will ahve enough money to fabricate claims on other provinces so that you can expand, unluckily you will have the unlawlful province modifier for that so I don't actully know if I should advice for a path that will take you to those settings.

Anyway a nice AAR and I like it!
 
Unlawful province isn't so bad tbh as long as you only have one of them. In terms of infamy, one province is completely counteracted just by having Imperial Integrity. The negative modifiers go away after it's cored, which is only 50 years.

Unless you're scared of the emperor coming after you for the province, in which case, it might just be better to make vassals rather than directly expand into other provinces.
 
Odd, I do the opposite thing when I'm a HRE minor afraid of the emperor stomping me - when the culture group is the same, I make sure I have enogh magistrates, take provinces and remove all cores. Taking vassals in such a situation always leads to emperor demanding to release them. When you're that small in HRE-locked, unlawful territory is a necessity for expansion. Well, it is if you don't feel like conquering the Mamluks instead, that is. :p
 
Odd, I do the opposite thing when I'm a HRE minor afraid of the emperor stomping me - when the culture group is the same, I make sure I have enogh magistrates, take provinces and remove all cores. Taking vassals in such a situation always leads to emperor demanding to release them. When you're that small in HRE-locked, unlawful territory is a necessity for expansion. Well, it is if you don't feel like conquering the Mamluks instead, that is. :p
Mamluks vs. Frankfurt? Hmmm ... 0_0
 
I'll definitely be keeping an eye on this. Where do you plan to expand, if anywhere?
 
I'll definitely be keeping an eye on this. Where do you plan to expand, if anywhere?

This wont be a "OPM takes over the world" type of AAR, the expansion will be driven "naturally" as much as possible but I wont limit myself away from taking non-cores or anything. If I do get missions and events for cores, I will definitely try to act upon them. If the world looks interesting enough by 1821, maybe I'll keep going in Victoria II.