-
We have updated our Community Code of Conduct. Please read through the new rules for the forum that are an integral part of Paradox Interactive’s User Agreement.
My thought there was that if you/sleepy werw the baddies, you could help sleepy build a correct tramp claim with the info from the trait claims. Though that's a fairly moot point by now
(and if we are to take Alynkio's post seriously the warlock and wolf only came in contact last night, so anti-yellow voting record seems a bit of a moot point in whether someone's a warlock, though the Alynkio vote might make a bit less likely yes, assuming the warlock scanned the reds before that day)
Her last online says 14:26. So simply not here I suppose, though she will have seen the last update and part of the discussion.
So... speaking of Aedan, let's take a look at what Aedan was up to before he got hunted.
This is from the day that Hax got lynched (Day 5)
These are both from the day of the Alynkio outing (Day 6), after Sleepyhead claims to have tramp-blocked him.
Now, Aedan was hunted Night 6 and turned out to be a changeling. If what Sleepyhead said is true, then he would have blocked Aedan's changeling orders and he would have learned about his identity. Now, we have two choices, either he saw that Sleepyhead was a tramp and therefore a less likely baddie, and he would have shifted batteries to other targets, or he would have judged Sleepyhead to be a baddie and in that case informing the village of the Tramp trait seems to be the natural choice.
Given that there was no change in the arguments in both days, I am inclined to believe that Sleepyhead's tramp claim is BS and that he is in fact the last yellow wolf, and that he hunted Aedan because he kept voting for him over and over. It would neatly explain things:
1) The first day of voting where Dedonus and Sleepyhead got ran up and Sleepyhead PM'ed Dedonus to bail him out
2) The reluctance of both Sleepyhead and Dedonus in providing explanation to the village about the Day 1 proceedings
3) Dedonus's never explained Onlinegate
4) Choice of hunt targets for yellow wolves - K-59 suspected Sleepyhead and got hunted. OrangeYoshi went after Sleepyhead and got hunted.Aedan also went after Sleepyhead and he got hunted. My own survival in spite of also expressing suspicions on Sleepyhead is quite a surprise, might be due to the fact that I started voting other targets, or that I am typically easier to lynch.
5) Sleepyhead's claims of tramp trait usage going seemingly unnoticed by Aedan the Changeling
In face of such a mountain of evidence, I could not forgive myself if we let Sleepyhead get away with this and win.
This is from the day that Hax got lynched (Day 5)
These are both from the day of the Alynkio outing (Day 6), after Sleepyhead claims to have tramp-blocked him.
Now, Aedan was hunted Night 6 and turned out to be a changeling. If what Sleepyhead said is true, then he would have blocked Aedan's changeling orders and he would have learned about his identity. Now, we have two choices, either he saw that Sleepyhead was a tramp and therefore a less likely baddie, and he would have shifted batteries to other targets, or he would have judged Sleepyhead to be a baddie and in that case informing the village of the Tramp trait seems to be the natural choice.
Given that there was no change in the arguments in both days, I am inclined to believe that Sleepyhead's tramp claim is BS and that he is in fact the last yellow wolf, and that he hunted Aedan because he kept voting for him over and over. It would neatly explain things:
1) The first day of voting where Dedonus and Sleepyhead got ran up and Sleepyhead PM'ed Dedonus to bail him out
2) The reluctance of both Sleepyhead and Dedonus in providing explanation to the village about the Day 1 proceedings
3) Dedonus's never explained Onlinegate
4) Choice of hunt targets for yellow wolves - K-59 suspected Sleepyhead and got hunted. OrangeYoshi went after Sleepyhead and got hunted.Aedan also went after Sleepyhead and he got hunted. My own survival in spite of also expressing suspicions on Sleepyhead is quite a surprise, might be due to the fact that I started voting other targets, or that I am typically easier to lynch.
5) Sleepyhead's claims of tramp trait usage going seemingly unnoticed by Aedan the Changeling
In face of such a mountain of evidence, I could not forgive myself if we let Sleepyhead get away with this and win.
For the record, I'm not surprised that beartjah and reis91 are out to get me today, they are two of the likely remaining baddies and probably thought I'd be an easy lynch, despite the fact that I have recollected for all my actions, repeatedly.
Beartjah has the worst record and his only defence is along the line of "I'm a villager so all accusations are wrong".
reis only has a vote on Dedonus the second time he was run up going for him, which isn't much considering the second run-up would be a good opportunity to alibi vote. Focused on tunnelling me the day Xarkan was lynched, completely ignoring that case.
Caillean hasn't showed up at all and has the voted by Dedonus thing in her defence, which could also be an alibi.
I do agree though that we shouldn't have a spread out vote today with opportunity for the baddies to influence the outcome with traits. I think beartjah is the better lynch due to the obviousness of it all, but will followed bro and Avernite onto another candidate if necessary.
Beartjah has the worst record and his only defence is along the line of "I'm a villager so all accusations are wrong".
reis only has a vote on Dedonus the second time he was run up going for him, which isn't much considering the second run-up would be a good opportunity to alibi vote. Focused on tunnelling me the day Xarkan was lynched, completely ignoring that case.
Caillean hasn't showed up at all and has the voted by Dedonus thing in her defence, which could also be an alibi.
I do agree though that we shouldn't have a spread out vote today with opportunity for the baddies to influence the outcome with traits. I think beartjah is the better lynch due to the obviousness of it all, but will followed bro and Avernite onto another candidate if necessary.
Hmm, could have sworn you did, but it appears you don't. Well, that takes the Aedan part of the case...
Just for the record, my defense was that I fully agreed I'm looking rather badly. I don't really have much of a defense beyond that I migth argue that I was wrong a lot in previous game as well, which isn't exaclty much of a defense...
Literally the only thing that is even slightly in my favour is Xarkan voting on me in this votecount:
Where Xarkan is voting on me, and I was briefly voted by capi putting me on three. But since that vote basically evaporated by the end of the day that doesn't really help me much.
As for beatjah, he has one other thing going out for him that makes him a less likely baddie, which is that he was, if I recall correctly, the first to note that we are one day from parity. Baddies would have some interest in this fact remaining ignored. Not very reliable, but still puts some weight on the goodie side of the scale.
My main point I was trying to make is that you're looking even worse based on the voting records. You're only still here because two wolves voted TFW up on day 1(you may have explained Dedonus, but Xarkan is also at least mildly suspicious I think), your day 2/3 votes relieved pressure from pressured wolves and day 4 was self-preservation.
I may not have been voting yellows, but at least I don't have quite as many suspicious interactions with two wolves. Your votes actively aided/been aided by wolves seems to me to be more suspicious than only just failing to hit the yellows.
And you defended youself with(should've answered this earlier but forgot this answer was a thing. Sorry bout that)
Anyway, 40 minutes left till deadline. We need to start voting. Since the whole "don't vote sleepy" thing seems to be a moot point now, and I still think he's the most likely wolf:
VOTE SLEEPYHEAD
Though I'd be glad to follow Averntie if he has different thoughts, I've been wrong more often than not this game and he seems to have a better idea of what he's doing than me and also seems cleared
I may not have been voting yellows, but at least I don't have quite as many suspicious interactions with two wolves. Your votes actively aided/been aided by wolves seems to me to be more suspicious than only just failing to hit the yellows.
And you defended youself with(should've answered this earlier but forgot this answer was a thing. Sorry bout that
)Misinterpreting the case against Dedonus,
Only gives an explanation that it could be done as villager as well, which I also noted in my case on you.
Dedonus pushed Caillean up to 4 votes, ahead of everyone else. tbf vote 3 on Cai Came in the same minute so he may have thought he was only putting her into the tie, but with Xarkan in the tie as well I think a save attempt seems more likely unless Dedonus thought that Caillean was done for.
Anyway, 40 minutes left till deadline. We need to start voting. Since the whole "don't vote sleepy" thing seems to be a moot point now, and I still think he's the most likely wolf:
VOTE SLEEPYHEAD
Though I'd be glad to follow Averntie if he has different thoughts, I've been wrong more often than not this game and he seems to have a better idea of what he's doing than me and also seems cleared
Official vote count, 38min to deadline
Sleepyhead - 2 - reis91, beartjah
reis91 - 1 - Avernite
beartjah - 1 - Sleepyhead
not voted - 2 - brovahkiin, Caillean
Have I missed some votes?
Sleepyhead - 2 - reis91, beartjah
reis91 - 1 - Avernite
beartjah - 1 - Sleepyhead
not voted - 2 - brovahkiin, Caillean
Have I missed some votes?
Last edited:
There are other puzzling things about Sleepyhead being a tramp. Given his involvement in the events of Day 1, it would make sense for him, if he was a villager tramp, to abstain from using his role because he wasn't going to get hunted anytime soon. Furthermore, a goodie tramp would definitely not want to use his role on the likes of Hax who are heavily suspected of being a baddie, because that would return mixed scans for Hax and himself and he could very well get killed out of it. And using the order on Aedan on a Yellow wolf hunting night would also be pretty reckless given that Aedan had a good record against yellow wolves (voted both Xarkan and Dedonus IIRC)
That identity thing you build this on is just wrong. Then you go back to meta and my thoroughly explained mutually beneficial arrangement with Dedonus.
You seem to have full knowledge on which pack hunted when, how come? As far as I see it, AABB is technically a possibility as the yellows hunted Wagon night 0 and the reds Arkasas night 3. Though you seem awfully sure on who hunted when, as if you have inside information.
tbf though, I think just about everyone thought Hax was a yellow.
Wait, how do we know that was a yellow night?
I was obviously just looking after myself. Hax could've hunted me as a wolf or a village hunter which I wanted to prevent.
Again with the certainty on the hunt nights. You know what, I think you've exposed yourself here.
Unvote beartjah
Vote reis91