Euro caused chaos and generates information.
He also realised that if one of Chill and Yvanoff died and was a goodie rhen dhe survivor would be run up today. So at that point making a tie makes sense.
Was that really so clear cut? I definitely am against repeating lynch cycles, especially early in the game, so I for one would have argued against that.
I think rehashing day 1 is a bad idea. Its often that people look back and think a baddie must have escaped, if two goodies hang day 1. But usually that's not the case.
Most times it's bad to rehash day 1.
This.
You don't want to invest all of the attention and information gathering on a single person. That way you will end up with some people dodging every single lynch cycle.
I don't like the purposeful vagueness of what scan you used, since being vague makes it so that others can't fact check later whether your scan was accurate, because if someone else claims to have scanned him and gotten a baddie result, you can just claim to have used the other scan. In order to encourage you to say which scan was used;
I definitely would like to know as well.
Good job. You succeeded in voting out a brand new player on day 1 because he came in close to deadline. Amazing, really encouraging people to join Werewolf. Don't count on me coming back.
My apologies, this was not my intention.
However: Relax. Dying early in werewolf is a time-honoured tradition. We have to lynch someone, and it rarely makes sense this early.
For me, and probably a lot of others, it's simply impossible to know if someone is brand new or simply someone who joined the roster in the time that I haven't played. (Years).
But what you can do - the very reason why an early death is not actually as terrible as you think - is post "
SUB" in this thread, so you can replace someone. Odds are good someone will forget to vote long enough that you can jump right back into the game.
More importantly than those first votes though, was Wombat's vote seven minutes before first possible deadline. He voted Chill then, hours after Chill had voted, because Chill hadn't responded to a request from Wombat for his thoughts on events so far. Which is just baffling all around. First, what insight do you expect a new player on day 1 to have, that's so important you'll threaten to lynch him for not giving input on it? Second, because of the deadline situation, did you think Chill was going to show up with an in depth analysis of the day in the seven minutes before the possible deadline? Or were you sure the deadline would be over an hour from then?
Seems like a better case than my quick Wagonlitz vote this morning, that's for sure.
And it's not getting any traction either.
Though I still think he's not a terrible candidate. He's one of those people who get very active if they are a wolf, and less so when a villager, so it fits.
Unvote wagonlitz
Vote Team Wombat
Now, does this make Wombat a likely wolf. I'm not sure, but consider that at the time Wombat voted, there was a four way tie at three votes each between Chilldude, Dedonus, Panzer, and hdk. Potentially Wombat might have even thought it was a five way tie also including Yvanoff if he hadn't seen Dedonus' switch from Yvanoff to Lief just prior to his vote. With possibly only seven minutes to deadline, a wolf trying to push up one candidate from that close race to protect a packmate is very possible. This could be any of those at three votes, or even some at two or one, Lief in particular was getting rising attention and Wombat explicitly pushed back against the Lief push. Many possible suspects he could be protecting.
It's not really relevant at this point, is it? Going after the people who move the vote rather than whatever frontrunner might not or might not have been protected usually yields better results, if only because you spread the information out further.
I really can't argue with that. I keep the village ahead of the game, and if you can't see that all I can say is you will.
I don't see it. I mean, sure, it would tell us a lot about the players involved in the lynch, but ..odds are also pretty high you get two dead villagers for the price of one, and is it really worth that?
Finally. Thank you.
Your read of my posts is largely on the nose. I am always trying to prompt action, as the village bullshitter
Fixed.
Seriously though, I appreciate the whole "Let's try to maximise information" thing, but at the same time you are being quite a good scapegoat on top of being a really good suspect.
You missed one thing in your analysis. I specifically called out chilldude 50 minutes before deadline before my vote on him (see below for link), saw the little green thing indicating that he was online, and jumped to the onclusion that he was dodging my question.
Ah, that does explain something.
Though green checkmark doesn't necessarily mean he was reading *this* thread, or even that he was online for longer than a second or two ..
Randakar was the 3rd vote on chilldude (third vote on the first day essentially cements players and lynch contenders), didn't respond to the summons both of us got before deadline indicating chilldude was a villager (admittedly, deadline is terrible for him), and I really dislike his vote on Wagonlitz, who is contributing this game and who attempted a voteswitch off two known villagers. I'm parking my vote on randy for now.
I actually thought I was the fourth. Not sure, though. Don't really care that much, I had to vote someone and most cases were pretty weak.
Depending on when said third party reached out then randy would have had no chance of seeing jt, though.
Deadline is 1 AM Europe time, so no European player can be expected on for the last 2 to 3 hours before deadline.
I only saw it when I woke up this morning, way after the deadline.
Randakar's been too defensive about Caillean imo, but I'm giving him the benefit of the doubt that he isn't just openly packing in public.
Well, I do have this tendency to defend my girlfriend .. dunno why.
But I know her quite well, don't expect her to say much this early in the game. She will probably start talking in a day or two though.
.png){kind=avatar}
.png){kind=avatar}