Werewolf CCLVII: Bloodborne

[randakar]

Nothing in the rules prevents GM's from stacking traits on one person. It's possible, but I don't see it a lot.

 

[Marshmallow Marshall]

I RISE ONCE AGAIN

Aaaand my only read from before my untimely death is dead. RIP Aedan obvtown 2023-2023 :'(

Huh. The interesting people are actually interesting. Nice to see a bit of early commentary, even though it seems mostly filler and banter at present. Like Grimlock's post, dislike Ironhide's vote, but not enough to vote him yet.

Vote Dedonus

I'm voting any currently non-responsive interesting people until they post/vote in thread.

If one thing looked like filler posting, it's this post lol. "Interesting" is literally a meme on my homesite due to its filler nature.
Vote Team Wombat
Preliminary vote in my catchup process so that I don't forget

Buddy, I wrote the book on narcissism, so if you don't like it, write your own and remember to credit me for inspiring you.

@my many haters: I am keeping a list of everything you say and do. If you have something to hide, I will find it and expose you to the village before you can tie the noose of hate around my neck. Long Live the Village!

Hello, Narcissus.

 

[Wagonlitz]

If he had been a hunter villager, i think he would've known because he thought it was a role.



I don't think other goodie roles are accompanied with priestly powers because that would be overpowered, but I might be wrong with that assumption.

Something like hunter with an xly scan is actually quite common.
And hunter is an old trait. Basically assassin and OEO in one. It's rare these days, but still crop up from time to time.

If you didn't read the RP names of rhe various roles it's perfectly possible to think you have the actual hunter trait
Yes, hunter isn't in the game, but lots of people also don't closely read the traits list either.


Your case feels based on a wrong premise.

 

[Eternaly_Lost]

I definitely didn't briefly think I was a Hunter Villager because of the RP role for villager.

I would like to remind people of this very early post in this game thread. Unless someone skipped it because it was a day 0 post, it seems odd that anyone would still be making the mistake about the villager role.

 

[Marshmallow Marshall]

A noob who is a werewolf is gonna post.

@chilldude74 is a noob and he hasn't posted.

ergo, he ain't a werewolf. i'd venture to call him cleared.

I'm not sure I follow the reasoning here. AFK noobs are legion as any alignment, and inactivity DEFINETLY isn't a good way to clear people lol. The post looks serious enough, so it could be worth explaining.

 

[Dedonus]

Vote Count:

Randakar: 3
Culann (400)
marty99 (418)
CaptainGrimlock (426)

Team Wombat: 3
Alxeu (419)
randakar (429)
MarshmallowMarshall (442)

Captain Grimlock: 2
MAWofDoom (401)
Arkasas (437)

Marty99: 2
Caillean (435)
EUROO7 (438)

Yakman: 2
Liefwarrior (398)
the_hdk (399)

Liefwarrior: 1
Yakman (Culann 389 -> 402)

the_hdk: 1
Team Wombat (410)

EUROO7: 1
Ironhide G1 (405)

Wagonlitz: 1
johho888 (384)

Caillean: 1
Dedonus (414)

Not Voted: 4
Nepechri
HistoryDude
Eternaly_Lost
Wagonlizt (MarshmallowMarshall 428 -> no vote 432)

 

[Wagonlitz]

I would like to remind people of this very early post in this game thread. Unless someone skipped it because it was a day 0 post, it seems odd that anyone would still be making the mistake about the villager role.

People forget.
And people don't necessarily read pre game chat. Especially not Marty, who at times hasn't even always read all chat from a day (especially when posting while drunk).
Him not having notices is very much fitting how he plays, just like Yakman is acting like expected and Euro is acting as expected.

 

[alxeu]

DEDONUS IS A SCANNED WOLF

 

[alxeu]

Unvote Team Wombat
Vote Dedonus

 

[alxeu]

If at all possible, I would like GA protection tonight.

 

[Culann]

Unvote Randy
Vote Dedonus

 

[Wagonlitz]

Vote Deo

 

[Marshmallow Marshall]

Hmm...

Like the EURO post from CaptainGrimlock (don't think a baddie Grimlock would put in the effort, regardless of the quality of the analysis), and to a lesser extent MawofDoom's and Yakman's so far have been positive. Euro says Aedan is semi-cleared. Any other votes I missed?

Hate to target a newbie day one, but chilldude74 putting a vote on then frontrunner Dedonus (#194) without any explanation seems a bit sketchy. Worried baddie trying to pile on a frontrunner, perhaps?

@chilldude74 I know it's early, but any thoughts on what has transpired thusfar? I don't like voting newbies early in the game who might be confused about the rules, but any thoughts you might have on the current game state would be appreciated.

This looks much better than Wombat's previous post (see my last post about them), and contributes significantly enough. I especially like that Chilldude is being questioned after being cleared by Yakman.

And um...

DEDONUS IS A SCANNED WOLF

Okay, I guess, but why wait so long before outing it? Deadline is in a few hours, right?
Nevertheless,

Unvote Wombat
Vote Dedonus

 

[Arkasas]

That's a bit early, don't you think?

unvote Grimlock
vote Dedonus

 

[Marshmallow Marshall]

I'm not sure how good the case on randy is. And I don't think euro or yakman acting like they always do is particularly suspicious.

I'd completely forgot Marshall even played. So I think I'll vote him. People flying under the radar like that usually are worth investigating.

Vote Marshall

You don't say. I was literally a corpse (N0 death) and replaced in like... right now.

 

[Dedonus]

Unvote Team Wombat
Vote Dedonus

Why do you have to do such a thing to such a nice person.

 

[Eternaly_Lost]

This looks much better than Wombat's previous post (see my last post about them), and contributes significantly enough. I especially like that Chilldude is being questioned after being cleared by Yakman.

And um...

Okay, I guess, but why wait so long before outing it? Deadline is in a few hours, right?
Nevertheless,

Unvote Wombat
Vote Dedonus

Deadline is in about an hour and 15 minutes or so based on the new deadline time. It little on the early side, but I would consider within an hour of a Deadline to be fine.

Vote Dedonus

 

[Marshmallow Marshall]

If you had been a villager, you should have known villagers are called hunter in this game.



And with this claim there are 3 options.
1. Marty is a wolf with priestly powers
2. Marty is a cultist with priestly powers
3. Marty is lying

So..

Vote Marty

If he had been a hunter villager, i think he would've known because he thought it was a role.



I don't think other goodie roles are accompanied with priestly powers because that would be overpowered, but I might be wrong with that assumption.

Isn't that case a massive gun-jumping, then? The level of conviction you show doesn't seem to quite match the strength of the case (balance is a tricky thing to evaluate, especially in such a big game). Would you be knowing things we do not?

[To Euro]
How on Eaerh is that a decent case, or do you have information to share with regard to why you had Panzer killed?

+1. How do you explain the stuff above, Euro?

 

[Marshmallow Marshall]

Why do you have to do such a thing to such a nice person.

RIP nice person xD. Thank you for confirming that you do indeed belong to the canine genus by not denying the accusations, though. See you in the afterworld

Deadline is in about an hour and 15 minutes or so based on the new deadline time. It little on the early side, but I would consider within an hour of a Deadline to be fine.

Vote Dedonus

...early? Uhm, culture clash, I guess. Where I come from, you out scans - especially red ones - as soon as day starts, or like mid-day maximum if you want to try and find scummates by creating interactions, so that everyone has time to assimilate the info. I guess it's NAI, then.

 

[Wagonlitz]

Okay, I guess, but why wait so long before outing it? Deadline is in a few hours, right?

Never ever do a Comm Cody and out early. That just wastes a day.
Ideally you out with 5 minutes to deadline, but that requires activity. A bit over an hour to deadline is on the early side, but acceptable when there's been as little activity as there has.