I would not compare to Pirates of the Caribbean. That game was originally going to be Sea Dogs2 before Disney got a hold of it.:wacko: Also POTC came out what 5 or 6 years ago. Compared to today it looks a bit dated but in its day it was pretty cutting edge graphics.
POTC is also an RPG game whose main focus was walking about solving quests. Sailing was not the primary focus. Although the sailing part is what I liked best.

I believe in EIC the only first person activity is Sailing. The original concept for the game had the RPG portion but I believe it was removed. I am guessing that the first person walking about will become their next game "Cutthroats" which appears to build on EIC.
Greg.