• We have updated our Community Code of Conduct. Please read through the new rules for the forum that are an integral part of Paradox Interactive’s User Agreement.
The vale has it on good information that it was this tyrion lannister that the king on the iron throne holds so high who murdered by beloved husband, and whose blade was used in the attempted murder of nephew and the maiming of my dear sister,

when brought into the custody of the vale, he demanded trial by combat, yet was to craven to fight in his own name but instead hired a common brigand to kill the noble ser Vardis Egen through trickery and deceit. the seven did not give him the strength of innocence, in this was only the low cunning that is to be expected of dwarves

the murder of my husband was far from his only crime, when allowed to leave the vale in peace despite his treachery (let it never be said that i am not merciful) he joined forces with the raiders in the mountains with whom he must share some dire kinship and gathered them to further attacks on the vale and its people. by giving these wildmen steel he has cost the lives of many good men of the vale and he must answer for their deaths.

the vale is not unreasonable however, and holds no grudge against his house and family. the actions of the halfman were his alone and we wish no quarrel with his renowned father nor his grace joffery of the iron throne. there needs be no blood be shed for this cause but the halfmans, and the vale does not wish for conflict on his behalf. a lannister pays his debts, and a debt of blood is owed to the vale that must be repaid, the vale's honor demands it.

as to lord leytons insistance that we join renlys cause we hold to our previous statement of neutrality as there is no compelling reason for us to side with any of the 4 legitimate kings nor any threat to the people of the vale once stannis has been pacified.


if the bards need a song i would suggest this composition that marrilion is fond of (courtesy of a wiki of ice and fire) :
He rode through the streets of the city,
down from his hill on high,
O'er the wynds and the steps and the cobbles,
he rode to a woman's sigh.
For she was his secret treasure,
she was his shame and his bliss.
And a chain and a keep are nothing,
compared to a woman's kiss

For hands of gold are always cold, but a woman's hands are warm...
(yes i know that marrilion didnt write it in cannon but its concivable that he could have)

lady lysa arryn, regent of the vale,warden of the east

ooc: in short the vale requests that the halfman be brought to justice and awaits a responce to this and the accusations of jofferys legitimacy from the lannisters while keeping its policy of remaining neutral toward the 4 legitimate kings

new ooc: i was drafting this when the battle of the vale event was posted, i will do an ic responce soon although i question how a force blockading the blackwater and in the narrow sea could protect dragonstone from the north east
 
Last edited:
new ooc: i was drafting this when the battle of the vale event was posted, i will do an ic responce soon although i question how a force blockading the blackwater and in the narrow sea could protect dragonstone from the north east

((Dragonstone is IN the Blackwater AND the Narrow Sea. More importantly, no way in hell they'd reach Dragonstone and capture it without the nearby Stannis Doomfleet not noticing.))
 
ooc: darn i was hoping i would take dragonstone then have my ships flee leaving the doomfleet unable to retake it without an army,
 
((Dragonstone is IN the Blackwater AND the Narrow Sea. More importantly, no way in hell they'd reach Dragonstone and capture it without the nearby Stannis Doomfleet not noticing.))

OOC: Not entirely impossible, if Stannis was closely blockading the city, and the Vale fleet made a quick passage around Crackclaw point. That would put Dragonstone between the two fleets. In that case, the Vale fleet would be at Dragonstone before they were likely to be sighted by Stannis's fleet.

However, even moderately unfavorable winds, say from the south or southeast, would make it possible for word of the fleet to spread to Stannis's fleet in plenty of time for them to respond.
 
OOC: Not entirely impossible, if Stannis was closely blockading the city, and the Vale fleet made a quick passage around Crackclaw point. That would put Dragonstone between the two fleets. In that case, the Vale fleet would be at Dragonstone before they were likely to be sighted by Stannis's fleet.

However, even moderately unfavorable winds, say from the south or southeast, would make it possible for word of the fleet to spread to Stannis's fleet in plenty of time for them to respond.

((True, but even assuming Dragonstone is taken, the Vale army would be surrounded by Stannis's fleet. And once they had been starved out for a while they would surrender, or at least consider it, to King Stannis's larger force once it returned. And that's still assuming that the old men and children left in Dragonstone don't lock the gates before the Valemen get up the beachhead.

The assumption I made, however, was that the Royal Fleet was blockading from the mouth of the Blackwater basin.))
 
((True, but even assuming Dragonstone is taken, the Vale army would be surrounded by Stannis's fleet. And once they had been starved out for a while they would surrender, or at least consider it, to King Stannis's larger force once it returned. And that's still assuming that the old men and children left in Dragonstone don't lock the gates before the Valemen get up the beachhead..))

OOC: It's equally true that Stannis's fleet would now be without a harbor to base from. And of course most of his army is far away in the North, and who says they will survive long enough to be rescued by his doomfleet? Southerners don't do well up North.

ICThe North grieves for the Vale's losses. Their forces attempted to live up to the obligation of House Arryn to defend the realm as Wardens of the East. The plan was audacious and brave, despite the outcome.

I promise that captives taken in our campaign against Stannis' invasion of White Harbor will be exchanged for the release of Arryn troops held at Dragonstone.
 
Last edited:
the Vale hopes that King Stannis will Spare the Brave knights of the Vale and remember when he once chose to side with his brother Robert over his Leige and sailed for dragonstone for that purpose long ago, as we to were split between kin and duty.


lady Lysa arryn of the vale, regent of the vale, and warden of the east
 
Rumours abound that upon hearing of the Vale's defeat at Blackwater, Lord Sumner laughed, saying "Now if only these rebels and cowards continue to kill each other, and save us the trouble."
 
(OOC: stannis willing no men will be lost, only 10 ships, which can and will be rebuilt)
 
House_Lannister.pngTyrion_Lannister_personal_arms.png

I too find it curious that Lord Renly would speak of defiling the Iron Throne, when he himself has readily forgotten what a line of succession is! As the former Master of Laws, surely he would understand how ridiculous his claim is when two living male heirs stand before him.

I would also thank the Lord Paramount of the Stormlands in wishing me well on my new post. I too would like to extend my congratulations to Lord Renly on his recent union to Lady Margaery Tyrell and eagerly await the news of her pregnancy. Perhaps the Lord of the Stormlands is not too busy poking swords with his so called Kingsguard as to spend some time with his new bride?

As to the Lady Lysa of the Vale, I need no longer profess my innocence as the Seven have already proven it so. It was the Crone who gave your sister, Lady Catelyn Tully the foresight to bring me and my Champion Bronn to the Vale and it was the Warrior who gave my champion the strength to win my innocence. The Father gave me divine judgement, even if you refuse to hear them and had the Stranger sought my life that day, surely I would have perished in your Sky Cells.

You also seek to call the wildmen uncivilised and that they have taken good men of the Vale. What good men do you speak of my Lady? During my unwelcomed stay, I faced nothing but hostility and lack of hospitality. The Eyrie is a dire place wrought with base born barbarity that even a dwarf such as myself cannot imagine. Tell me, which is it, the high altitude or the solitude seclusion, that has muddled your brains?


~ Tyrion Lannister, Acting Hand of the King
 
Flaming-Stag.png



Some would say that our clear victory against the Vale´s ships is just a strike of luck. Some other would affirm that it´s just another proof of Stannis skills, who never lost a single battle. Even some would argue that it was only a matter of time that Lady Arryn sent her own men to die in a paranoid and unjustified attack.

But we do not say such things. Reflect upon your sins, Lady Arryn; perhaps you wll find why your false gods have failed to protect your ships and your men.

Now a messenger from Lady Arryn has arrived to us. We will reflect upon her words and give an addecuate response when we have came to a definitive solution. I give my word that the prisoners won´t be harmed before I give an answer to Lady Arryn.


Stannis Baratheon the First of His Name, King of the Seven Kingdoms and Protector of the Realm, Lord of Dragonstone, Lord of Storm's End, Lord Paramount of the Stormlands, Warrior of Light, The Lord's Chosen and Son of Fire.


OOC: Plank, your inbox is full, could you empty it, please? Thanks!
 
Last edited:
the vale awaits king stannis's response with dread, and is open to a counterproposal that would protect the people of the vale, the knights in stannises care in particular.
this attack was called upon by my duty to family and to the people of the vale, and now we hope to preserve those people once more. Should you be the king in actions as well as name we should have common cause in this, for a just king protects his people and the vale is a part of the realm you hold yourself above as king.

if you should spare the valeman knights and quit the north we have no cause to fight you and may yet find common ground, should you slaughter them you may force us into the hands of another.

-lady lysa arryn, regent of the vale and protector of its people, warden of the east
 
Is the Vale and the Arryns so cowardly that after a single defeat they seek to exit the war?

If so I declare you as cowards. Send your forces West into the Riverlands and fight instead of attempting sneak attacks like cowards.

~ Lord Roose Bolton, Lord of the Dreadfort.
 
the vale suspects that Lord Boltons position would be different had it been lord boltons forces who had been captured, and he held the lives of thousands of his men in his hands. to cast aside their lives in the name of "bravery" or "honor" seems the act of a bloodthirsty madman rather then a just lord.
as to the riverlands, why would i send my forces there when i have no conflict in the region as of yet, i sent my forces southeast to honor my obligation to defend my kin in the north but I have no obligation to join in my nephews offensive wars. i have no quarrel with joffery and the vale can wait for tyrions head
 
250px-House_Hightower.png

House Hightower echoes Lord Bolton's words. You must remain steadfast and decisive, no more prancing about the issue at hand. Either the Vale devotes itself to the war, or you may find yourself a few kinsmen short, falling to the Lannister hordes. While my full confidence rests within victory, blood will be shed, more so if the Vale continues it's current direction. I am nearing the point of exasperation with such cowardice, and I'm sure the sentiment is shared elsewhere.

- Lord Leyton Hightower, Voice of Oldtown, Lord of the Port, Lord of the High Tower, Defender of the Citadel, and Beacon of the South
 
You claim to be helping you kin, attacking Stannis Baratheon on Dragonstone in no way helped the Norths cause.

If you wanted to fight Stannis, take your men north and attack him near White Harbour.

I suppose this is what you get when you breastfeed a eight year old.
~ Lord Roose Bolton, Lord of the Dreadfort.

 
the vale's planned attack was to remove stannises base of power, rob him of his legitimacy in the eyes of the sellswords who serve his army and the sellsails who man his galleys, for a king without a kingdom is no king at all and we aimed to rob him of his legitimacy, although we underestimated the range of his fleet. had this happened it would have forced stannis out of the north and robbed him of a good portion of his strength, more then would have been achieved had we thrown them at the shore of white harbor outnumbered.

the vale does not know of any lannister hordes, and while it requests the head of tyrion lannister for the murder of my husband and the armament of the mountain clans, it has no quarrel with his nephew and sees no reason why there should be war between the houses of arryn and lannister, should the imps head be presented to us then even less so.

we do not understand lord bolton insistence on a policy of aggression when such a policy at this moment may to the execution of 5000 good men, why should we throw more men at stannis when such a policy is what caused the capture in the first place? even if i was inclined to do such an act i would be unable to do such a thing for i lack the ships to go to white harbor and i do not mean to launch another amphibious assault anytime soon.

you call my actions cowardice when all i do is in an attempt to fulfill my duty to the people of the vale, i would be betraying my obligation to them if i tossed their lives away

if the kings of the realm would take action to protect the people of the vale by ensuring the safe return of the expeditionary force they shall have our friendship and loyalty regardless of whoever they may be.

-lady lysa arryn of the vale, regent of the vale, Warden of the east


ooc: why does roose bolton ic know about the condition of robert arryn, he has no reason to know that and it is out of character
 
Last edited:
250px-House_Crakehall.PNG

In light of the attack on White Harbour, and the bumbling counter attack by his allies in the Vale, it is abundantly clear to all of Westeros that the Young Wolf lacks both the strength and the will to defend his own vassals.

~Lord Sumner Crakehall
 
the vale does not swear fealty to Robb stark and our failure does not reflect a lack of competence on his part as king