• We have updated our Community Code of Conduct. Please read through the new rules for the forum that are an integral part of Paradox Interactive’s User Agreement.
I maintain that with the new expansion, a mod centered on a war on the Island of Sodor would be epic, especially since the railway was canonically built to defend the island and the Irish Sea from German attacks, which means there likely are some railway guns hidden somewhere on the island.
 
  • 2Like
Reactions:
I maintain that with the new expansion, a mod centered on a war on the Island of Sodor would be epic, especially since the railway was canonically built to defend the island and the Irish Sea from German attacks, which means there likely are some railway guns hidden somewhere on the island.
To be fair, railway guns are the most powerful and useful weapon in the game right now so a whole war of nothing but in Sodor makes sense...
 
  • 1Like
Reactions:

Basically, each side is going to get each set of generals. There was some bug, and instead of Stalin having his own generals, his general roster was instead just a copy of mine. That led to some awkward moments where i.e Rokossovsky fought in a battle against..Rokossovksy. If that bug is still there and you do a Soviet comedy run that end up in a civil war, I thought it could just add to the comedy.

Germany can indeed be held off by a player, obviously. But its much harder for an AI, from the looks of it.

Indeed, but from my experience that has alwys been the case. In all honesty, from what I see on the forums is that the Soviets has many debuffs at start of the game, and that it takes time to get (insane) buffs and time to industrialize. When you really boil it all down, many are mad they can't do a WC as USSR before 1939. I on the other hand think it is a good addition, as really the USSR did struggle a lot, before making a major comeback. An issue with the USSR as of now, though, is that your army, navy, and airforce is constantly out of supply even when doing nothing, at home, and close to supply hubs and railroads.
 
  • 2Like
Reactions:
Basically, each side is going to get each set of generals. There was some bug, and instead of Stalin having his own generals, his general roster was instead just a copy of mine. That led to some awkward moments where i.e Rokossovsky fought in a battle against..Rokossovksy. If that bug is still there and you do a Soviet comedy run that end up in a civil war, I thought it could just add to the comedy.
Hmm. Sounds like they just decided to simply have a game of Russian roulette decide the fate of them all. Somewhat sensible, under the circumstances.
Indeed, but from my experience that has alwys been the case. In all honesty, from what I see on the forums is that the Soviets has many debuffs at start of the game, and that it takes time to get (insane) buffs and time to industrialize. When you really boil it all down, many are mad they can't do a WC as USSR before 1939. I on the other hand think it is a good addition, as really the USSR did struggle a lot, before making a major comeback. An issue with the USSR as of now, though, is that your army, navy, and airforce is constantly out of supply even when doing nothing, at home, and close to supply hubs and railroads.
Yeah, I think the Soviets should be pretty crap before doing loads and loads of dark shit to boost themselves out of the mess the tsars left the country in, but at the same time also pretty much impossible to actually defeat or invade properly. Then you can have them as the boogeyman for everyone else, without them conquering euripe in 1936, or Germany losing millions of men in France and rhen effortless backhanded stalin all the way to Moscow, and then win cos the russians give up.
 
Just found out there are such things as amphibious harbours, mulberry ports, in the new expansion. This probably makes navies and naval landings a bit more interesting and usable.

Especially as it makes both the UK and the Nazis both stronger and weaker at the same time (in theory).
 
  • 1Like
Reactions:
How essential are railway guns in the new version? I am waiting to try it out until I finish my current AAR, and even then I don't know if I feel like learning a bunch of mechanics yet.
 
How essential are railway guns in the new version? I am waiting to try it out until I finish my current AAR, and even then I don't know if I feel like learning a bunch of mechanics yet.
No idea. But people have conquered France with just rail guns. So...it's possible. And they are very powerful. But they may be fixed before you get round to playing. Online, there does not seem to be much discussion about railway guns aside from the fact that they exist, or from 2016 asking for and being mocked for asking whether they will be added in at some point.

An unintended consequence of railway guns being a thing now is that China's meta just became a race to see who can build the most civilian factories and infrastructure. Cos it's so big and unforgiving a battlefield that railguns will destroy everything else, including super heavy tanks. And because India and Russia have the same issues, just less so, china might actually suddenly vault to the top of the pile in Asia. Just thought about this, so no idea if true or not. But I'm worried it might be...
 
  • 1
Reactions:
Railway guns themselves can't even fight. Their only effect is providing a non-stacking (unless that part is broken or something, which I haven't heard of) penalty to enemy divisions within range. A railway gun caught on its own loses instantly.
 
  • 1
Reactions:
Railway guns themselves can't even fight. Their only effect is providing a non-stacking (unless that part is broken or something, which I haven't heard of) penalty to enemy divisions within range. A railway gun caught on its own loses instantly.
The issue is that shore bombardment penalties can now be applied anywhere, and over an entire front simultaneously, and never let up (provided that the rail network doesn't give out). That is to say, basically western European warfare is going to be very much the domain of the railway gun unless they're ridiculously expensive or have other issues.

Italy might be the worst hit with this, because it means not only shore bombardment but also these things for most provinces.

Then again, looking over the notes for the guns again, I now doubt the AI can properly use them, because it requires them to repair any captured railway lines quickly, which the AI does not do.
 
Overall I would say the review of the dlc is alright. Not as insane or funny as it could have been. Leaves me wanting more. Which is...appropriate I suppose. 8/10.
Apparently the DLC does add in the possibility of Wojak the Bear becoming King of Poland (only after you get the event proving you put a fake Romanov on the throne of Poland) so they were at least trying to be ridiculous in places.

There can't be many (if any) people left who still think HOI4 is a serious simulator of anything, so Paradox should just really lean into the ridiculous. It's the half hearted mix of stupid meme events while pretending to be serious that is at the root of most of the game's problems.
 
  • 1
Reactions:
Apparently the DLC does add in the possibility of Wojak the Bear becoming King of Poland
It does?
(only after you get the event proving you put a fake Romanov on the throne of Poland
...this seems even sillier, to be honest. Which means its probably got a lot least a grain of historical truth to it...
so they were at least trying to be ridiculous in places.
It certainly now means that one could write a Sir Bearington AAR, or a Legacy Secret AAR. Indeed, it means that one can role-play a dynasty of bears from ck2 to hoi4, including a bear restoration if needs be.
There can't be many (if any) people left who still think HOI4 is a serious simulator of anything,
It certainly seems to be a simulator of something.
so Paradox should just really lean into the ridiculous.
CK2 certainly got more fun when that happened. Especially when you could turn all of that stuff off.
It's the half hearted mix of stupid meme events while pretending to be serious that is at the root of most of the game's problems.
The main issue. Impossible to play a serious game because the absurd stuff is included right alongside the quasi attempts at accuracy. Really, they should have a joke team and a normal team (or rather, a normal team and a historical team). And never shall the two contents meet lest the player approves.

Still, all this makes Soviet Comedy a bit easier. Everyone is convinced Poland is being run by a secret Romanov, whilst a few in and outside rhe country are trying to desperately convince everyone else that the king is actually a bear and probably shouldn't be in charge of the most important buffer stare in Eastern Europe...
 
To get King Wojek, you have to have 'anastasia' show up, become queen of Poland, invade and occupy both Iran and Rome, have a specific artillery focus completed, promote wojek from private to corps commander, invade Russia, capture Moscow and, upon discovering that the Queen is a fake, instead crown the bear as king.

Why? No reason given.

Wojek becomes head of state and government, and gets a nice picture of him in the country screen, wearing a little crown around one ear.
 
  • 2
Reactions:
To get King Wojek, you have to have 'anastasia' show up, become queen of Poland, invade and occupy both Iran and Rome, have a specific artillery focus completed, promote wojek from private to corps commander, invade Russia, capture Moscow and, upon discovering that the Queen is a fake, instead crown the bear as king.
That is one of the strangest things I've ever read. Why in the world would Poland invade Rome, let alone Iran? I want whatever drugs Paradox's focus tree guy is on.
 
  • 1Haha
Reactions:
  • 1
Reactions:
I guess maybe I was a little harsh, but it's still pretty silly. I don't think there's any world where it would make sense for Poland to conquer all the way to Iran, and then decide to fight the Soviets. I guess that path is really more of an Easter egg than a legitimate choice.
 
That is one of the strangest things I've ever read. Why in the world would Poland invade Rome, let alone Iran? I want whatever drugs Paradox's focus tree guy is on.
As stated Wojak was brought by a Polish solider at an Iranian railways station while II Corps was in transit from Russia to North Africa, so that is the tenuous Iran link. To round it out the Rome link is because Polish II Corps fought in the Italian campaign and the artillery focus is because Wojtek was listed as being in the 22nd Artillery supply company and was reported as helping by carrying boxes of ammunition around. The entire story of the bear and indeed Polish II Corps/Anders Army is incredible, but that is no excuse for the bear to end up King.

Why this was linked to the Anastasia fraudsters (I guess Anna Anderson who was in Germany and making insane claims around this rime) becoming Queen of Poland and then being replaced by a bear... well that is a mystery known only to Paradox. ;)
 
  • 1
Reactions:
That is one of the strangest things I've ever read. Why in the world would Poland invade Rome, let alone Iran? I want whatever drugs Paradox's focus tree guy is on.
Not even that. If you just fi those things, nothing will happen. You have to also take a specific artillery tree thing first, so the bear has some boxes to move around...
Because historically, the real Wojek the bear was from Iran
Ah. Now it all makes SENSE.
I guess maybe I was a little harsh, but it's still pretty silly. I don't think there's any world where it would make sense for Poland to conquer all the way to Iran, and then decide to fight the Soviets. I guess that path is really more of an Easter egg than a legitimate choice.
No doubt. I think in this case, you really do have a try quire hard to do this by mistake.
The entire story of the bear and indeed Polish II Corps/Anders Army is incredible
And depressing. The Polish uprising happened at the same time.
but that is no excuse for the bear to end up King.
I mean...I don't really mind because there aren't many other good options for the Polish monarchy (as unlikely as it is to be established) but still...
Why this was linked to the Anastasia fraudster
Yes, this is the really odd bit.
becoming Queen of Poland and then being replaced by a bear... well that is a mystery known only to Paradox. ;)
An astonisngly deep call back to CK2, where court members and royals actually could turn into/be replaced by bears randomly?
 
  • 2Like
Reactions:
The entire story of the bear and indeed Polish II Corps/Anders Army is incredible, but that is no excuse for the bear to end up King.
I agree, I was doing some reading on Iran in WWII, and this section of the story was quite amazing! I had missed the bear in the story, but you gents have fixed that for me.
 
I agree, I was doing some reading on Iran in WWII, and this section of the story was quite amazing! I had missed the bear in the story, but you gents have fixed that for me.
Alas in Imperial Cheese, Iran was quite a nasty little war of vassalisation for us, so I do not doubt that the bear, being a brave and stolid sort, met his end fighting us in the trenches and mountains of Iran.

Unless of course, he escaped...
 
  • 2Like
Reactions:
World War Three – Remember the Alamo? Well, it’s back!
World War Three – Remember the Alamo? Well, it’s back!

The last two American commanders in the US looked down at the map they had been using to snort drugs off of.

pmcNMtDpp

“There is not enough Heroin on Earth to make this look good.”

“True, but I’m not going to fight Mexico alone and if we went together, it’d still be a bloodbath. Florida is much nicer.”

The two American officers had bravely decided to not question their orders and stuck to their assignments on very much the wrong side of the continent.

“How far have they managed to get so far?”

“Well,” one of them put down his drink and opened the morning paper, now written in Spanish, “it seems like the Mexican advance is in two very long and concentrated spears. One is hugging the golden coast like a diseased monkey baby and the other is moving through Texas faster than a burrito does my gut. Making a meal out of both of ‘em too, from the looks of things.”

“Any word of anything up north?”

The other chap didn’t bother looking.

pnPi0Z3xp

“Everyone is still dead. Took most of the British with them, fair, but damn it if we aren’t screwed. The Canadians are spilling over in multiple places from what I heard. And they say the news is only this bad and not worse because the trains are so busted that they can’t get into the country fast enough.”

“Is that it then? We lose?”

“Looks like it. I can’t see us replacing the northern army anytime soon. Not with half of Texas gone.”

“We need to do something, Jerry.”

“For god’s sake Tom, are you trying to kill us?”

“Well, at this rate, they’ll be over here soon, and then what?”

The two men looked at each other. Then Jerry sighed and put his trousers on.

“Fuck it, I never wanted to live past thirty anyways.”

pmNLWNSop

They set off later that morning, two divisions and one reinforcement being all that stood between the Mexican army and the rest of the United States.
Meanwhile, over the border in Canada…

“Dash it all Horatio! Why aren’t those damn trains moving?”

“Because some genius decided to tell everyone about the most secret document in the government files.”

“Good lord, not our secret plan to sterilise Europe!”

“Much worse than that, sir.”

“Our nuclear development prototypes?”

“Much more important.”

“…you don’t mean the Sodor Accords?”

“Yup.”

“Fuck.”
Sure enough, outside every rail depo and station in the land…

“Come on lads, surely you don’t need all these things?”

“Need? Fuck no. But if one union managed it, we’re all having it mate. Unlimited downtime, no responsibilities beyond fuelling and watering the trains, snazzy invincible blue uniforms, autonomous self-driving trains which take all the blame and credit, and no night hours beyond special episodes? Fucking sign us up or no trains ever again!”

“Curse you, Toppham Hatt!”
Speaking of, in the woods…

A horde of crazed and bizarrely blank faced men danced and cavorted around a gigantic bonfire made of burning diesel engines. The increased efficiency and modernisation investigative reporter screamed silent screams of terror from his wooden cage and held close his holy book of standard practices. He had already seen two of his order taken away and vanish into the maddening crowd of fanatics.

Suddenly
, the dancers parted and he could see a shadowy figure standing before the burning flames. Many hands grabbed and tugged him from the cage and he was dragged screaming before the Fat Controller of the Imperial Railways. Large and unhallowed slabs of hand rubbed his face and forced his eyes up into the gaze of the monster.

“Oh yes,” the demon rumbled, “I will mind many useful things for you to do.”

The drums sounded and the crowd roared in approval, as the man was carried, kicking and screaming, towards an alter upon which the all-blue uniform of the satanic cult lay.
And now, for something somewhat more normal…

“How goes it, Catastrophe?” said Kaboom, amiably.

pmjzKwpXp

“Not bad, all things considered,” he replied, presumably, from behind a mountain of paperwork. “The African campaign is in clean-up mode, as is the Middle East. We’ve apparently struck oil in a few new places, and people are telling me we are now much better at building things.”

pmWyw0ypp

“Oh?”

pmvx0cHvp
pnz3pujgp

“Indeed. We are also getting even better at grouping various industrial buildings together to maximise efficiency.”

“Not entirely sure what that means, but that’s great, I guess.”

“What’s wrong, you seem understated and deflated. Not like you.”

“I just wish I was in India, killing more people who are trying to fight back. Shooting people with tanks while they run away in terror is just a little bit too tedious for my liking.”

“Mm. Well, let’s have a look at the reports. Ah…not looking too good for our friends over there, is it?”

pmYt2IXup

“They seem to be continuing to die superbly, and Siam is still not dead!”

“I suppose there is that, but at least neither side is seeing such bloodletting as in the Chinese wars. Christ, that was a mess. Here, just a few tens of thousands of people dying on our side. And even the British spread over the whole world have lost only half a million. Probably mostly in Africa. India has been a relatively quiet front, despite all the action happening it seems.”

“Odd, isn’t it?”

“Not compared to Bohemia, which has somehow managed to lose thousands of men despite never actually showing up to fight anywhere. Now that is mismanagement.”

“Terrible. I would kill far more by accident than they seem to have.”

poIzHiOsp

“Yes…anyway, the Emperor will be pleased. Well, sort of. Everything on our end is going swimmingly. Of course, it still seems like we’re going to lose America. The Alamo got obliterated last week, and the Mexicans are showing no signs of slowing down. Thank God something seems to be up with the Canadian supply lines or something. Otherwise, I think the country might have collapsed by now.”
 
  • 5Like
Reactions: