-
We have updated our Community Code of Conduct. Please read through the new rules for the forum that are an integral part of Paradox Interactive’s User Agreement.
Johho gets goodie points for being the alternate candidate to Alynkio, and I'm pretty sure cultists are attached.
Weak reason to avoid voting Alynkio. May be a packmate, especially since at the time it looked like the lynch could easily go johho, Alynkio, or BlackGriffin, so it could have been key for a packmate to vote a rival candidate.
Weak reason to avoid voting Alynkio. May be a packmate, especially since at the time it looked like the lynch could easily go johho, Alynkio, or BlackGriffin, so it could have been key for a packmate to vote a rival candidate.
Clearly, getting the answer to that question required way more work than I am willing to put into actually reading your roles.
Let's play a little game, shall we? Here's who is left - 18 players remain.
Health is House MD
Arkasas is 19 Kids and Counting: The Duggar Story
BlackCrown is Twitch Livestream of Bob Ross's The Joy of Painting
Claude is How I Met Your Mother
Audren is I Love Lucy reruns
Daleksbane is Dr. Who
Black_Griffin is Mad Men
Sleepyhead is Better Off Ted
Johho is Due South
the_hdk is Firefly
Eternaly Lost is Stargate SG1
[Panzer Commader] Cliges is Buffy the Vampire Slayer
Steed is The Adventures of Black Beauty
[esemesas] Jeray is The Great British Bake-Off
punkbob is The Wire*
DeathByWombat is Burn Notice
Gen. Skobelev is a popular children's show "Nasse-setä"
Beamed is The Americans
Now, each of you are invited to give your gut reaction to each of the players - who is a baddie, who is a goodie, and who is an unknown? Reasoning welcomed, if possible.
Health is House MD
Arkasas is 19 Kids and Counting: The Duggar Story
BlackCrown is Twitch Livestream of Bob Ross's The Joy of Painting
Claude is How I Met Your Mother
Audren is I Love Lucy reruns
Daleksbane is Dr. Who
Black_Griffin is Mad Men
Sleepyhead is Better Off Ted
Johho is Due South
the_hdk is Firefly
Eternaly Lost is Stargate SG1
[Panzer Commader] Cliges is Buffy the Vampire Slayer
Steed is The Adventures of Black Beauty
[esemesas] Jeray is The Great British Bake-Off
punkbob is The Wire*
DeathByWombat is Burn Notice
Gen. Skobelev is a popular children's show "Nasse-setä"
Beamed is The Americans
Now, each of you are invited to give your gut reaction to each of the players - who is a baddie, who is a goodie, and who is an unknown? Reasoning welcomed, if possible.
.png){kind=avatar}
Awesome, I was right about alynkio. Is it time to test my suspected alynkio-Panzer connection? I say ye to ye!
VOTE CLIGES COMMADER
VOTE CLIGES COMMADER
Wonderful. Now 1) why, exactly, is johho your preferred baddie candidate, and 2) There are 17 other players (including yourself). Any thoughts on any of them?
Your nonsense had me lynched the first time.
I am back here to explain that no one should listen to you for the duration of this game.
Will explain in more detail later.
I'm quite put off. I'm done with nonsense. You're dealing with 100% legit Audren here.
Whoa, whatever your lackluster ideas, no one said anything about your parents not being married.
Health is House MD ------------------------------------- Goodie
Arkasas is 19 Kids and Counting: The Duggar Story ------------------------------------- Baddie
BlackCrown is Twitch Livestream of Bob Ross's The Joy of Painting ------------------------------------- Baddie
Claude is How I Met Your Mother ------------------------------------- Goodie
Audren is I Love Lucy reruns ------------------------------------- Goodie
Daleksbane is Dr. Who ------------------------------------- Neutral
Black_Griffin is Mad Men ------------------------------------- Baddie
Sleepyhead is Better Off Ted ------------------------------------- Baddie
Johho is Due South ------------------------------------- Goodie
the_hdk is Firefly ------------------------------------- Neutral
Eternaly Lost is Stargate SG1 ------------------------------------- Neutral
[Panzer Commader] Cliges is Buffy the Vampire Slayer ------------------------------------- Baddie
Steed is The Adventures of Black Beauty ------------------------------------- Neutral
[esemesas] Jeray is The Great British Bake-Off ------------------------------------- Neutral
punkbob is The Wire* ------------------------------------- Neutral
DeathByWombat is Burn Notice ------------------------------------- Goodie
Gen. Skobelev is a popular children's show "Nasse-setä" ------------------------------------- Goodie
Beamed is The Americans ------------------------------------- Goodie
Those are vague feelings and I better not be expected to justify any of them.
Anyways,
Vote Cliges
I meant to do this earlier but forgot to do the vote.
Arkasas is 19 Kids and Counting: The Duggar Story ------------------------------------- Baddie
BlackCrown is Twitch Livestream of Bob Ross's The Joy of Painting ------------------------------------- Baddie
Claude is How I Met Your Mother ------------------------------------- Goodie
Audren is I Love Lucy reruns ------------------------------------- Goodie
Daleksbane is Dr. Who ------------------------------------- Neutral
Black_Griffin is Mad Men ------------------------------------- Baddie
Sleepyhead is Better Off Ted ------------------------------------- Baddie
Johho is Due South ------------------------------------- Goodie
the_hdk is Firefly ------------------------------------- Neutral
Eternaly Lost is Stargate SG1 ------------------------------------- Neutral
[Panzer Commader] Cliges is Buffy the Vampire Slayer ------------------------------------- Baddie
Steed is The Adventures of Black Beauty ------------------------------------- Neutral
[esemesas] Jeray is The Great British Bake-Off ------------------------------------- Neutral
punkbob is The Wire* ------------------------------------- Neutral
DeathByWombat is Burn Notice ------------------------------------- Goodie
Gen. Skobelev is a popular children's show "Nasse-setä" ------------------------------------- Goodie
Beamed is The Americans ------------------------------------- Goodie
Those are vague feelings and I better not be expected to justify any of them.
Anyways,
Vote Cliges
I meant to do this earlier but forgot to do the vote.
Health - spoiling aside, I do find it interesting how he leaked almost all his votes Day 1. Probably not a big deal, but it still leaves me uneasy.
Arkasas - reasonably decisive vote on k-59, so unlikely CU wolf. Otherwise, meh.
BlackCrown - active, which I like. Has had some possibly wolfish behaviour when he got votes, but otherwise I like him. Goodie for me.
Claude - who? what's he done? late vote on alynkio? possible sellout. otherwise practically dead. late vote on k-59 too. probably not CU, but I still feel he's a likely wolf.
Audren - the bestest goodie of them all. for real though, most of my so-called "nonsense" stems from Day 1, where such things are tolerable. don't discount my pushing of alynkio.
Daleksbane - also new, seems too bandwagony for my liking, but no immediate red flags.
Black_Griffin - missed some votes, also bandwagony. feeling not great about him. lean bad.
Sleepyhead - likewise to Health, he leaked all his votes Day 2. This I find more disturbing, though not much more.
Johho - avoided lynch yesterday with upswell of alynkio pressure. could have been supported by whichever pack alynkio wasn't in contact with. Still not really sold on him as a candidate. I'm feeling meh.
the_hdk - ??? early vote on alynkio, for what that's worth. I've no idea.
Eternaly Lost - active, and got pushed against by Jackson. unlikely CU in my eyes
[Panzer Commader] Cliges - Still want to test my theory that he's linked with alynkio, based on Panzer's terrible reasoning for not voting alynkio yesterday. I think this is the natural follow up.
Steed - important vote on k-59, but stuck to johho. if johho was saved, as many of y'all believe, steed is likely goodie. otherwise, could fit with non-CU pack
[esemesas] Jeray - ??? almost literally done nothing. not a bad vote for information sakes alone, though I think we've got better candidates.
punkbob is - had that strange vote on jackson. not sure how that reflects. seems mostly jokey, but he stuck on him. feels like a weird vote to make, but not sure if it fits as a CU packmate.
DeathByWombat - uncertain. his cases don't seem on point (not just because he accused me), but I think this heavy pushing for activity is a villagery trait of wombat's. I'm leaning goodie, but with reservations
Gen. Skobelev - love the votecounts, but he does that regardless of alignment. started cases against k-59 and alynkio. unlikely CU wolf, and depending on alynkio's contact, unlikely wolf.
Beamed - likewise stuck to Jackson yesterday on that weird maybe jokey reasoning. thoughts essentially the same as punkbob. wish both of them were more active, if only to properly fight alongside giants.
Overall, my main candidates are Cliges, Claude, Dalek, and maybe jeray. I'd prefer Cliges and/or Claude to die today.
Arkasas - reasonably decisive vote on k-59, so unlikely CU wolf. Otherwise, meh.
BlackCrown - active, which I like. Has had some possibly wolfish behaviour when he got votes, but otherwise I like him. Goodie for me.
Claude - who? what's he done? late vote on alynkio? possible sellout. otherwise practically dead. late vote on k-59 too. probably not CU, but I still feel he's a likely wolf.
Audren - the bestest goodie of them all. for real though, most of my so-called "nonsense" stems from Day 1, where such things are tolerable. don't discount my pushing of alynkio.
Daleksbane - also new, seems too bandwagony for my liking, but no immediate red flags.
Black_Griffin - missed some votes, also bandwagony. feeling not great about him. lean bad.
Sleepyhead - likewise to Health, he leaked all his votes Day 2. This I find more disturbing, though not much more.
Johho - avoided lynch yesterday with upswell of alynkio pressure. could have been supported by whichever pack alynkio wasn't in contact with. Still not really sold on him as a candidate. I'm feeling meh.
the_hdk - ??? early vote on alynkio, for what that's worth. I've no idea.
Eternaly Lost - active, and got pushed against by Jackson. unlikely CU in my eyes
[Panzer Commader] Cliges - Still want to test my theory that he's linked with alynkio, based on Panzer's terrible reasoning for not voting alynkio yesterday. I think this is the natural follow up.
Steed - important vote on k-59, but stuck to johho. if johho was saved, as many of y'all believe, steed is likely goodie. otherwise, could fit with non-CU pack
[esemesas] Jeray - ??? almost literally done nothing. not a bad vote for information sakes alone, though I think we've got better candidates.
punkbob is - had that strange vote on jackson. not sure how that reflects. seems mostly jokey, but he stuck on him. feels like a weird vote to make, but not sure if it fits as a CU packmate.
DeathByWombat - uncertain. his cases don't seem on point (not just because he accused me), but I think this heavy pushing for activity is a villagery trait of wombat's. I'm leaning goodie, but with reservations
Gen. Skobelev - love the votecounts, but he does that regardless of alignment. started cases against k-59 and alynkio. unlikely CU wolf, and depending on alynkio's contact, unlikely wolf.
Beamed - likewise stuck to Jackson yesterday on that weird maybe jokey reasoning. thoughts essentially the same as punkbob. wish both of them were more active, if only to properly fight alongside giants.
Overall, my main candidates are Cliges, Claude, Dalek, and maybe jeray. I'd prefer Cliges and/or Claude to die today.
Always uncertain. I love it. I call this state of play shadow-walking; it's a mark - no, THE mark - of a excellent baddie player. Players like the SPLIT and my brother are simply too good as villagers to be truly superior wolves. Their analysis suffers noticeably when they can't catch wolves, and they get caught because they aren't catching goodies. You can never really tell with wolf/baddie specialists what exactly they are, because they are just suspicious enough to be untrustworthy, while just sensible enough to be bad lynches.
Aedan is a notoriously superior wolf because he straddles the line between rational and unhelpful well. It's a policy I also try to cultivate, hopefully with some success.
TLDR: To be a great baddie, you pretty much have to play and act in all your games with a measure of undetectability. And it's nigh impossible to play from both sides with equal effectiveness.
Always uncertain. I love it. I call this state of play shadow-walking; it's a mark - no, THE mark - of a excellent baddie player. Players like the SPLIT and my brother are simply too good as villagers to be truly superior wolves. Their analysis suffers noticeably when they can't catch wolves, and they get caught because they aren't catching goodies. You can never really tell with wolf/baddie specialists what exactly they are, because they are just suspicious enough to be untrustworthy, while just sensible enough to be bad lynches.
Aedan is a notoriously superior wolf because he straddles the line between rational and unhelpful well. It's a policy I also try to cultivate, hopefully with some success.
TLDR: To be a great baddie, you pretty much have to play and act in all your games with a measure of undetectability. And it's nigh impossible to play from both sides with equal effectiveness.
... thank you for the not-so-subtle brag? this post feels very strange to me. Not wrong, of course, but weird to say now.
Sorry, I get bored as a goodie, and like going on tangents about game philosophy. I suppose you want my thoughts on wolves.
Note that these are gut reactions only, no posts and no analysis. I'll follow up with selected thoughts on a few, especially on request.
Health is House MD: neutral/baddie
Arkasas is 19 Kids and Counting: The Duggar Story neutral/goodie
BlackCrown is Twitch Livestream of Bob Ross's The Joy of Painting goodie
Claude is How I Met Your Mother goodie
Audren is I Love Lucy reruns neutral
Daleksbane is Dr. Who neutral/goodie
Black_Griffin is Mad Men neutral
Sleepyhead is Better Off Ted neutral/baddie
Johho is Due South neutral/baddie
the_hdk is Firefly neutral/baddie
Eternaly Lost is Stargate SG1 - neutral
[Panzer Commader] Cliges is Buffy the Vampire Slayer neutral/baddie
Steed is The Adventures of Black Beauty goodie
[esemesas] Jeray is The Great British Bake-Off neutral/goodie
punkbob is The Wire* neutral
DeathByWombat is Burn Notice rating yourself is stupid and arrogant
Gen. Skobelev is a popular children's show "Nasse-setä" Lock goodie
Beamed is The Americans neutral
Note that these are gut reactions only, no posts and no analysis. I'll follow up with selected thoughts on a few, especially on request.
Health is House MD: neutral/baddie
Arkasas is 19 Kids and Counting: The Duggar Story neutral/goodie
BlackCrown is Twitch Livestream of Bob Ross's The Joy of Painting goodie
Claude is How I Met Your Mother goodie
Audren is I Love Lucy reruns neutral
Daleksbane is Dr. Who neutral/goodie
Black_Griffin is Mad Men neutral
Sleepyhead is Better Off Ted neutral/baddie
Johho is Due South neutral/baddie
the_hdk is Firefly neutral/baddie
Eternaly Lost is Stargate SG1 - neutral
[Panzer Commader] Cliges is Buffy the Vampire Slayer neutral/baddie
Steed is The Adventures of Black Beauty goodie
[esemesas] Jeray is The Great British Bake-Off neutral/goodie
punkbob is The Wire* neutral
DeathByWombat is Burn Notice rating yourself is stupid and arrogant
Gen. Skobelev is a popular children's show "Nasse-setä" Lock goodie
Beamed is The Americans neutral
I'm a survivor. Posts with a vaguely suspicious nature like my not-so-humble brag make me more suspicious in certain eyes and therefore less "huntable" to baddies who think they might be able to get me lynched (especially since I can't be on deadline on weekdays) lategame, while certainly not being actual grounds for lynching in the minds of smart players. Which means I can work to help the village by encouraging activity and playing the PM game.
there's just something that feels weird about this whole "hey y'all, this is how to be a good werewolf" talk. not suspicious, necessarily, but weird.
Speaking earnestly, not sure what about my reasoning was jokey. People who defend baddies place themselves into suspicion. But my vote was outdone by people who knew better anyway. :shrug: C'est la vie.
Speaking of instinct, I'm moving to vote Johho. If I'm wrong, well..