-
We have updated our Community Code of Conduct. Please read through the new rules for the forum that are an integral part of Paradox Interactive’s User Agreement.
Final Day 4 Votecount
Final Day 4 Votecount
Randakar: 6
Cymsdale [425]
Emperor Ike [461]
marty [469]
Flockingbird [473]
Dedonus [474]
aedan [480]
Flockingbird: 4
Culann [429]
beartjah [437]
Randakar [411 cymsdale -> 454]
Wagonlitz [399 randy -> 486]
Emperor Ike: 1
Yakman [398]
Randakar: 6
Cymsdale [425]
Emperor Ike [461]
marty [469]
Flockingbird [473]
Dedonus [474]
aedan [480]
Flockingbird: 4
Culann [429]
beartjah [437]
Randakar [411 cymsdale -> 454]
Wagonlitz [399 randy -> 486]
Emperor Ike: 1
Yakman [398]
Then I was wrong. Ca't win them all.
But I do think that there's a very high chance he is. And if he isn't, then Flock for sure is.
That's why I wanted that tie. Very high chance one of them is, and both might very well be.
Process of elimination.
There only are Randy, Flock, marty, Deo, and bear who really can be wolves. Bear claimed psychic and deo doesn't seem too shady, thoug could still be it.
Now, bear could be furry still too, but less likely than the others.
I maintain that my guess is randy, flock, and marty.
Btw, for the record, then it'd be nice if you could list attempted snipes, that weren't on time.
Most GMs do that, and it really helps with analysis. And imho, it really is sometihng that should be in teh official count, as it was an attempted vote, but wasn't on time, so should be noted.
And at least in teh past it always was noted.
Somethign like:
Ike tried voting Flock in 490, but was too late.
Or somethign like that.
Similarly in games requiring strict unvoting that's listed too, if somebody doens't properly unvote when voting and the vote hence doesn't count.
Ike tried voting Flock in 490, but was too late.
Or somethign like that.
Similarly in games requiring strict unvoting that's listed too, if somebody doens't properly unvote when voting and the vote hence doesn't count.
Also, I just realised that I have almost 25% of the posts in this thread. Lol.
- 1
- 1
No, that's not something for the GM to list.
The GM solely should list official game events.
A non valid vote is an official game event.
What caused it, is not.
Anyway, I'll not deny that I tried to get you to tie, and wanted a tie.
Day 4/Night 4
Day 4
Well, the ring Caillean got to bind two fates together was given to randy. And she is dead. And we've got to make sure the ring's powers are true. Which means it would be a shame if we didn't kill randy. He just wanted to get back home to his honeymoon with his wife? Whoops.
Randakar the formerly blessed villager was lynched
Night 4
None of the adventurers were sure what to make of Gizzo at first. Their racial make up added up to 150% and no one wanted to know how the gelatinous cube part got in the mix. Their penchant for using more violent means to produce their music was also something that sometimes gave their fellow members pause in the beginning. However, like all good D&D players, Gizzo's oddities were what made them a beloved member of the party, to the point when Gizzo composed a tune using nothing but their enemies' screams, the only response by the others was "Oh, that old Gizzo is at it again." This made it a particularly sad day when they had found that they were the next victims of their enemies. Alas, Gizzo's gelatinous cube biology made a resurrection spell impossible.
Cymsdale the villager was hunted
Well, the ring Caillean got to bind two fates together was given to randy. And she is dead. And we've got to make sure the ring's powers are true. Which means it would be a shame if we didn't kill randy. He just wanted to get back home to his honeymoon with his wife? Whoops.
Randakar the formerly blessed villager was lynched
Night 4
None of the adventurers were sure what to make of Gizzo at first. Their racial make up added up to 150% and no one wanted to know how the gelatinous cube part got in the mix. Their penchant for using more violent means to produce their music was also something that sometimes gave their fellow members pause in the beginning. However, like all good D&D players, Gizzo's oddities were what made them a beloved member of the party, to the point when Gizzo composed a tune using nothing but their enemies' screams, the only response by the others was "Oh, that old Gizzo is at it again." This made it a particularly sad day when they had found that they were the next victims of their enemies. Alas, Gizzo's gelatinous cube biology made a resurrection spell impossible.
Cymsdale the villager was hunted
The vote count is a count of votes that, well, count. I commented on the vote's validity in thread prior to doing the count. Most GMs do the count first and then note that the vote is invalid in the count as that's the first time they're commenting on the validity. Analysis is the job of the players.
Bugger. That's not a good result.
Does mean that Bear and Aedan are fully cleared though, I'd say.
That's 5 traitless villagers so far.
(And I'm one as well, btw, for what that matters. So that's at least 6 traitless villagers in a game of 18 players. No way that the wolves get both sorcish and seerish powers, or get psychic, in such a power poor game.)
Also, this means that the spy reports can be fully trusted. I don't see the one on Yak not being very clear about Yak being a villager, likely a traitless one.
So he should be cleared as well.
Also, this clears the no hunt.
Remaining players:
Flock
Wagon
aedan
Culann 2.0
Beartjah
marty
Deo
Ike
Yakman
Of those the following should be cleared:
Yakman
Aedan
Bear
Wagon
Ike almost certianly is too, due to the Maw thing day 2.
Culann 2.0 made a very dangerous vote on Maw day 2.
That leaves:
Flock
Marty
Deo
I'm less sure of who of those three are bad now. Like, if I'm right in the above then all three would be, but I'm worried now that I might be clearing aedan and bear too easily. Claiming seerish and psychic is more or less free.
Though, if they are wolves and lied about their traits, then that means taht this game is extremely trait and role poor. So far we've had 7 dead villagers and only two had traits, and minor ones.
I know I'm traitless and I highly suspect Yakman is as well. That means at least half the players were traitless. If Bear and aedan lies, then that means that either some of the rest have major traits, or the village only got spy and alderman to make up for MAW having sorcly. Whihc can make sense, but then the other wolves shouldn't have much else.
So I do think that it still makes sense that aedan and bear are very likely goodies.
So for now:
Vote Flock
Does mean that Bear and Aedan are fully cleared though, I'd say.
That's 5 traitless villagers so far.
(And I'm one as well, btw, for what that matters. So that's at least 6 traitless villagers in a game of 18 players. No way that the wolves get both sorcish and seerish powers, or get psychic, in such a power poor game.)
Also, this means that the spy reports can be fully trusted. I don't see the one on Yak not being very clear about Yak being a villager, likely a traitless one.
So he should be cleared as well.
Also, this clears the no hunt.
Remaining players:
Flock
Wagon
aedan
Culann 2.0
Beartjah
marty
Deo
Ike
Yakman
Of those the following should be cleared:
Yakman
Aedan
Bear
Wagon
Ike almost certianly is too, due to the Maw thing day 2.
Culann 2.0 made a very dangerous vote on Maw day 2.
That leaves:
Flock
Marty
Deo
I'm less sure of who of those three are bad now. Like, if I'm right in the above then all three would be, but I'm worried now that I might be clearing aedan and bear too easily. Claiming seerish and psychic is more or less free.
Though, if they are wolves and lied about their traits, then that means taht this game is extremely trait and role poor. So far we've had 7 dead villagers and only two had traits, and minor ones.
I know I'm traitless and I highly suspect Yakman is as well. That means at least half the players were traitless. If Bear and aedan lies, then that means that either some of the rest have major traits, or the village only got spy and alderman to make up for MAW having sorcly. Whihc can make sense, but then the other wolves shouldn't have much else.
So I do think that it still makes sense that aedan and bear are very likely goodies.
So for now:
Vote Flock
Yeah, sorry.
You did feel off to me, but must have just been because of just being married. I did consider if that could be the cause, but was too focused on your being wolf.
So yeah, sorry about that. Not my finest hour.
.png){kind=avatar}
I updated & reviewed my vote chart & what I noticed:
Me: placed a vote on a goodie 3 times, unvoted 2; final vote on goodies: 1 which was self-preservation
Wagon: 3 votes on goodies, unvoted 2; final vote on goodies: 1
Aedan: 3 votes on goodies, no unvotes; final v on goodies: 3
Culann/TW: 1 vote on goodies, no unvotes; final v on goodies: 1
Bear: 1 vote on goodies, no unvotes; final vote on goodies: 1
Marty: 2 votes on goodies, no unvotes; final vote on goodies: 2
Dedonus: 3 on goodies, 1 unvote; final vote on goodies: 2
Emp Ike: 3 votes on goodies, no unvotes; final vote on goodies: 3
Yakman: 1 vote on goodie, unvoted, for final vote: 0
Voting for me is another win for the wolves.
Meanwhile, Wagon keeps urging disastrous-to-the-village ties. And I can’t tell if he’s a wolf, or Ike, or anyone else.
Does anyone other than Wagon think some of us are truly cleared? Because we’ve been running up villagers for the last 2 days.
Editing to make final vote on goodies clear
2nd edit: highlighting
Me: placed a vote on a goodie 3 times, unvoted 2; final vote on goodies: 1 which was self-preservation
Wagon: 3 votes on goodies, unvoted 2; final vote on goodies: 1
Aedan: 3 votes on goodies, no unvotes; final v on goodies: 3
Culann/TW: 1 vote on goodies, no unvotes; final v on goodies: 1
Bear: 1 vote on goodies, no unvotes; final vote on goodies: 1
Marty: 2 votes on goodies, no unvotes; final vote on goodies: 2
Dedonus: 3 on goodies, 1 unvote; final vote on goodies: 2
Emp Ike: 3 votes on goodies, no unvotes; final vote on goodies: 3
Yakman: 1 vote on goodie, unvoted, for final vote: 0
Voting for me is another win for the wolves.
Meanwhile, Wagon keeps urging disastrous-to-the-village ties. And I can’t tell if he’s a wolf, or Ike, or anyone else.
Does anyone other than Wagon think some of us are truly cleared? Because we’ve been running up villagers for the last 2 days.
Editing to make final vote on goodies clear
2nd edit: highlighting
Last edited:
You did survive, though.
I don’t know why you’re focused on me. Unlike you, I tried to prevent the first disastrous tie, switched off Randy yesterday (broke the logjam, which saved him that day) while you stayed on him, and voted him today to save myself. I didn’t vote him or anyone earlier because I couldn’t figure out who was a wolf. You look like one to me, but I don’t know. And unless you’re a wolf, you shouldn’t be sure of picking me. I’m a worse pick than you are.
Edit: you’ll notice in this post (473) I was worried that Randy might be a wolf and that my voteswitch would look like a wolf saving a packmate:
Last edited:
That wasn't what I meant...
You and DNFC got married? Grats!
Yeah, as I was wrong aboyt randy. Had I not been, then I'm certain I'd have been hunted. As it stands, I still expect to go, just next night, as I'm seerish scanned.
You were scanned and cleared? By whom?
You mean Aedan who has one of the worst voting records, right along with Ike?
Who cleared Aedan?
Could he and you be wolves? Looks it.
Edit: and I’m still not sure.
2nd edit: could those of you not fighting brain fog consider if Aedan, Ike, and Wagon as the 3 remaining wolves makes sense of this game? it’s not an analysis I can do, and we need to catch a wolf, not another villager.