Interlude 6: A Meeting Between an Incoming President and an Outgoing One.
"People ask the difference between a leader and a boss. The leader leads, and the boss drives"
- Theodore Roosevelt.
As every Tuesday, President Landon was having his usual meeting with Robert F. Wagner, Secretary of the Treasury and his closest confidant in the absence of a Vice President, in the Oval Office. The purpose of this meeting? Playing chess and discussing political matters in Washington that couldn't be openly addressed in a cabinet meeting. At that moment, as Landon moved his knight to capture a bishop, he also gazed out the window. Little by little, the capital seemed to be recovering from the destruction of the Second Civil War. Wagner, also somewhat lost in thought, moved a pawn to support his position in the center of the board, where Landon had the advantage.
- They say the city will be fully rebuilt by next year.- Wagner remarked.- Apparently, the use of Syndicalist prisoners has significantly reduced public spending, which is something we need to discuss.
- Are we in the red?
- Quite a bit, as expected. Fortunately, military investments seem to have helped us recover our economy. But now...
- We rely too much on military spending and being at war, I know, Robert. It’s not something I like. But right now, it’s no longer our problem.
Robert smiled with a hint of sadness in his eyes. Landon moved his knight to the left, threatening Wagner's queen, forcing him to retreat it to the back of the board, away from the center of battle.
- You shouldn’t be like this, Landon.
- And how should I be, Robert?- Landon asked angrily.- Happy that everything we’ve fought for over these past two years is about to disappear?
With the initiative on the board, Landon continued pressing Wagner's queen, forcing it to retreat once again.
- You did what you could. People will remember you for that. Besides, we both know that MacArthur will have to deal with a Congress and Senate that aren’t exactly friendly. I doubt he’ll be able to do much.
- That’s what Herbert Hoover thought before they staged the coup...
After that remark, silence fell between them.
- Have you heard anything about...- Robert hesitated.
- Hoover? Yes, we spoke the other day. The poor man is a shadow of himself. He spends his days locked in his house, depressed. I think he’s writing his memoirs.
- Why didn’t he support you at the Convention? His backing would have been invaluable.
- You really are a Democrat, Robert. The party isn’t the same as in the days of Taft and Roosevelt. First, they turned their backs on Hoover in ‘36, and now they’ve done the same to me. With luck, they’ll do the same to MacArthur soon enough.
- Did you talk to Dewey?
- He’s young and ambitious, far more than I ever was. Right now, the liberal Republicans are backing MacArthur.
- For the moment. And I don’t think Taft will be too pleased either. No matter how much he’s been forced to support his boss, I doubt he’s happy. Besides, I highly doubt our new Vice President will agree to an increase in spending, even if it’s military.
As they spoke, Landon had continued using his knight and pawns to force Wagner to give up ground in the center of the board. Finally, Wagner fell into his trap and was forced to leave his queen exposed. Landon captured it shortly after.
- Well played there.
At that moment, an aide rushed into the Oval Office and whispered something into the President’s ear. Landon looked at Wagner in surprise. Wagner, having heard enough, began gathering the chess pieces—he knew the President didn’t want him there. Moments later, Landon opened the door to the Oval Office to let in President-elect Douglas MacArthur. Landon sat on one of the sofas, but MacArthur preferred to sit at the desk. Landon, with nothing to lose, was blunt.
- The desk isn’t yours, Douglas. I still have a couple of months here.
- Of course you do. Who said otherwise?
- I’m quite busy, in case you hadn’t noticed.
- Busy doing what, Mr. President? Packing your bags and looking for a job in the private sector?
Landon glared at him with contempt.
- Did you come here just to mock me, or do you actually have something to say?
- I have plenty to say, ‘Alf.’ We have a long history together, and I didn’t want you to leave without saying goodbye.
- I still have 1 month left.
- I don’t doubt it. But even so, I wanted to stop by. Look at us now. We’ve been President and Vice President. President and Chief of Staff. Rivals for the Republican nomination. And now, an outgoing President and an incoming one.
- Is that all you came here to tell me?
MacArthur smirked arrogantly.
-´No. I’m telling you this because I would never be here if it weren’t for you. If you had been a puppet, if you hadn’t resisted, we could have worked together—you handling domestic policy, while I took care of foreign affairs. But you decided to play with the grown-ups. You risked your presidency not only by freeing Marshall and the Pacific traitors, but also by trying to limit the FBI and the military.
- And that made you angry?
- Yes. But then you started doing things right again. We liberated Canada. We helped in the Caribbean and the East Indies. I thought we could continue working well together. Your mistake was the invasion of the Azores.
- The Joint Chiefs approved it, MacArthur!
- Of course they did!” MacArthur shouted, standing up. However, you promised me we wouldn’t have to go to Africa. You broke your word—to me, your cabinet, and the American people.
- It was the next logical step!- Landon shouted, also standing up and stepping toward MacArthur.- The French refused to negotiate, and we needed to pressure them.
- You played into the hands of the Internationale, Landon!
- Me? You were part of that too, you idiot!
Both men now stood face to face, furious, sweat running down their faces. After a few seconds, MacArthur smirked and stepped away, turning to look closely at the portrait of Washington hanging in the room.
- You’re right, Landon. I was part of it. But does it even matter now? I won. I returned to the White House with the support of 55% of Americans. And this time, I’m back with big plans.
- I’m happy for you, Douglas. -Landon said, calming down but with clear sarcasm.- Not my problem anymore.
- No, it isn’t. However, you’re right again. I overstepped, Landon. I came to make you an offer.
The President couldn’t hide his surprise and had to sit down.
- I’m listening.
- All of us live for one thing—our legacy. I’m offering you the chance to end your presidency on a high note.
- How?
- As you well know, a large part of the government and the armed forces are loyal to me and despise you.
- I’m aware.
- I’m willing to give you access to information and resources that have been denied to you until now. I offer you a presidency free of internal problems until the very end. And most importantly, I offer you the chance to negotiate peace with the Entente and end the war in less than a week.
Landon was bewildered.
- How?
- I’ll only tell you if you make a deal with me.
- And what do you get out of this?
MacArthur, now wearing his characteristic smirk, turned away from the portrait.
- It’s simple. While you’re not bad at domestic affairs, you’re terrible at foreign policy. And I need this war to end before my presidency begins. So, if you agree, we will hold a joint conference where we will present the American people with a unified plan to resolve the war. Everyone wins! The party sees us united, we both gain popularity and prestige, and you get to be the first President in decades to sign a peace treaty.”
- I need time to think about it.
- I don’t have time, Landon. You’re either in or you’re out.
Landon, the 31st President of the United States, didn’t need much time to think.
- I’m in, MacArthur. Where do we start?
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
That House Majority isn't as strong than at first glance when taking into account the MacArthur-aligned, Taft-aligned, and Dewey-aligned factions of the Republican Party. If anything, the House Majority (and a divided opposition) could encourage infighting...
If we had problems with Landon in Congress and the Senate, with MacArthur, we're going to be in for a shock. Although, thanks to Hearst and others, he has managed to form a faction within Congress (not a very large one), in the Senate, the Republican majority consists of conservatives aligned with Taft—a Taft who is increasingly at odds with MacArthur and could cause significant problems for the MacArthur Administration.
Sounds like the average tabletop miniature lore. Seriously. Something like Combat Mission set in this universe would be rad.
(OK, we need some sort of HOI4/The Operational Art of War mixture for dedicated "operational" nerds to wargame out the intricacies of operational art, HOI4 is just too "arcade-y" at times. )
I hope so! Besides, we’ve still seen very little of what the battlefields might have in store for us. And I agree with you. Sometimes, I feel like HoI4 is very arcade-like, but at the same time, other games are just too complicated.
And btw mind showing how the US army is structured in this timeline? Entente is a lost cause at this rate. Portugal and Africa are of dubious value (I'd even call them brazen military adventurism). I'd even call for "super monroe doctrine" for US defense policy in this timeline. But right now what is done cannot be redone.
Although I’d like to analyze the Army in more depth later (probably after the war ends), here’s a brief summary. There’s the Regular Army, composed of the 4 Armies. Then there’s the Navy, which has two fleets: the large one (with about 7 or 8 aircraft carriers) under Halsey, currently in the Atlantic, and Chester Nimitz’s fleet (mainly submarines) operating in the waters around Hawaii.
As for the Air Force, it’s quite limited (around 300 fighters) and, for now, remains under Army jurisdiction. Lastly, there are the Marines (which in my game are more like space marines, with 52,000 men per division, tank support, engineers, and LOTS of artillery). The Marines were separated from the Navy during and after the Civil War, becoming an independent corps. But we’ll talk more about this later—MacArthur is going to make a lot of changes...
We’ll talk about Africa and Portugal once we sit down at the negotiating table with Pétain. According to MacArthur, that will happen very soon. And of course, don’t worry about our US defense policy —soon we’ll have the MacArthur Doctrine.
But term limits haven't been established yet. MacArthur can keep going as much as he wants. At least he has the other branches to worry about. It won't be easy. And I don't think it would be acceptable if MacArthur uses executive orders for everything.
Exactly! Term limits were established in 1952 in OTL, so in theory, MacArthur can run for election indefinitely.But as you said, what Eisenhower meant is that they are no longer in a state of war and Congress is no longer in disarray. Now, MacArthur will have to fight in the legislative branch and in Frankfurter’s judiciary.
Sounds true to type. The game is dangerous though, not just for his opponents. One day he may press someone too hard who has the means and motivation to simply kill him off if they’re worried enough by an existential threat.
Hoover is playing a very dangerous game that could cost him dearly. On one hand, he and MacArthur maintain good relations and share objectives. But at the same time, he is aware that the Triumvirate could also be beneficial to him. Hoover is only loyal to himself.