• We have updated our Community Code of Conduct. Please read through the new rules for the forum that are an integral part of Paradox Interactive’s User Agreement.
Catching up again after my long break (mainly travelling), will turn to writing up the second part of this month's global warfare now. First, a bit more comment feedback.
An unending tale of misery with no Easter miracle! Thanks
No, just more of the same old grind!
Your focus on the casualties is appreciated in this chapter. Such huge losses. Seems you are exceeding the original timeline WWII totals. This doesn't add in those lost in Mexico City from the use of atomics either.
That's right. Nor, as mentioned, the earlier war against the Fascists! With years apparently to go on a larger scale than before, with the 4thInt in it now.
On a much less important side note, wanted to call out the shot of the tank with a cactus. Marvelous.
Glad you liked it.
Some hard lessons here, I think. As Polish industry now looks to be having difficulty replacing combat losses, maybe the air force can only be used very selectively and the tempo of ground operations may need to be reduced?
Yes, this is the plan now. That was a brief 'testing the air' exercise and it showed we currently need Allied support to sustain air ops on the Eastern Front. We'll keep trying to build and improve our fighter force.
Nice! All help is very welcome.
Yes, nice to have them under direct command. I'm thinking in HOI4 that we supply them with the basics but they get their personnel and weapons from the donor?
I also find it a little concerning that the Soviets are able to sustain these heavy offensives and are even threatening to break through the Polish defences.
Yes, though I guess it's only to be expected. To be fair, the small losses taken were in exposed occupied territory rather than the more heavily fortified Polish frontier. Though we may need to start fortifying the more long-term possessions we've taken in order to make them harder to crack and inflict heavier enemy casualties/allow us to thin divisions a little for reallocation.
Poland's casualties thankfully remain comparatively light but it's easy to see from the failed offensive in Salihorsk how those numbers could mount up very quickly - and doubtless it's outcomes like this that explain the AI's truly horrendous manpower losses!
Very much. At least we terminate attacks before they are exhausted when the odds turn. Still, the Soviets for now have the numbers to throw at us, especially while we find in very hard to make any encirclements on the thickly occupied Eastern Front.
Considering how long the Allies have been the MAB, I find it more than a little surprising how many losses have been sustained fighting against the US. It could all be down to the earlier Allied disaster in Canada... or maybe the American divisions and the USAAF have more firepower?
Probably a bit of a mixture, but mainly those big encirclements in Canada and a few in Mexico. Also, many of the earlier encircled losses in China were incurred against the Fascists rather than the MAB. But the impending losses in Manchuria could start to make up the difference a bit.
That was indeed quite grim. A policy of baiting the US into making naval invasions and then crushing them before they can retreat could work for a human, potentially an efficient way to destroy whole units, but that clearly isn't what is happening here.
It's been fairly even there, given it's AIvAI, which is fair enough. Many of the landings have been destroyed eventually, but the ones to retake LA were done fairly effectively.
I'd be interested to see what would happen if a human player did take over the UK at this point, I reckon it could just be turned around. Because at the moment this is just a very slow motion defeat for the Allied side.
Oh, it's a bit of a temptation, but only so many hours in the day!
I don't think there's anything you can do, other than have enough manpower/equipment for your garrisons. There should be an alert that pops up if you're missing any required materiel.
Yes, it's just a handful of AA guns needed: a bit of an irony considering its meant to be for countering guerrillas?
Consolidation is good. Hopefully this new, river-based line will help.
That one never looked like it would be sustainable - we went in basically to see if we could help the other Allies hold their gain.
An important chokepoint.
It had been in Soviet hands for a long time. I actually set it as a defensive ping earlier: I wonder if that actually worked!?
What is the Polish Command's thinking here? Will you use them against Russia, China, or somewhere else?
Partly for experimentation, but envisaged for use on the Eastern Front if we manage to get on the offensive in the future. Say, to maybe land in the Byelorussian rear and take a key VP town to make them surrender, or if we manage a later-game operational breakout, etc.
The US and Allies should really be at peace. But that's just not how things worked out.
Indeed. It certainly evened the game up, that's for sure.
That is a common and very effective tactic.
Nice to see the AI using it against another AI.
Whew! I've finally finished reading through this and caught up to the present, and I've got to say, what wild ride. A lot of very unexpected turns from how I would've expected an Poland playthrough to go. Polish expeditionary forces fighting in Sinkiang, for example, is probably the last thing I would have ever predicted. This AAR has been an absolute showcase of how wacky and unpredictable HOI4's ahistorical setting can get.
Thanks so much for that big effort. It's kind of like an alt-KR thing where many of the old verities are turned on their head. Yes, Poles fighting simultaneously in Sinkiang and Indochina is a bit of a turn-up, alongside German allies, is not necessarily what I was expecting at the start!
I'm impressed by the ability of the Allies to fight a truly global, multi-front war for years on end, even if the decision to be involved in some of those fronts at all is a bit baffling; apparently no one ever told the AI not to fight a land war in Asia. I'm distinctly less impressed in the non-Allied belligerents. The USA and USR, in particular, seem to have really failed to take advantage of their advantages. When the US knocked Canada out of the war fairly quickly and Mexico went through the regime change, I thought for sure the Allies were about to expelled from the rest of North America in short order, but instead the AI seemed happy to fritter away the opportunity doing who-knows-what. I guess I'll chalk that one up to the malign influence of Wilkie.
The Allies have had a large industry and fielded manpower advantage for a long time, but the entry of first the US, then the Japan-China communist alliance in the east and now the USR has really evened things up. I could never really work out what the US was up to after the collapse of the massive Allied armies in Canada. First, I thought they were going to push the US over, then after they were destroyed the US would do the same to them in Mexico. But it all worked out very differently.
Not to take away from your own accomplishments! You've certainly done a good with Poland, but there's a quote dancing at the edge of my brain about the best skill being to pick incompetent adversaries.
Haha, all AI adversaries can be incompetent! Though as a medium power up against far bigger ones, it limits my ability to wreak human-player havoc. Which is of course why I picked them in the first place. I actually thought the AAR was likely to be over by 1940, but ructions in Germany then Russia sure changed that equation!
There are two ways to be outstanding in your chosen field;
1. Hard graft and dedication OR
2. Ensure the rest of the field are idiots
Best to combine, or course.
 
  • 1
Reactions:
Chapter Seventy-five: Switching Tracks (April 1946 – Eastern Hemisphere)
Chapter Seventy-five: Switching Tracks
(April 1946 – Eastern Hemisphere)

AuthAAR’s Note: After reviewing the Eastern Front and the Americas last time, we round out the April 1946 reports with the Middle East (mainly Iran and Georgia) and Asia.

DA6Pmj.jpg

Polish troops operating in the harsh hills and mountains of eastern Iran, April 1.


=======​

Iran and the Caucasus: 1-17 April 1946

As March 1946 ended, another new rail project was commenced in Iran – a branch line to supply front line troops in Kerman.

aIlHav.jpg

The last Polish division to pull out of Indochina – the seasoned veterans of 16 DP – made port in Kota Bharu safely late on 2 April. They would head across country to Kuala Lumpur to evade the most dangerous waters around Malaya and resume their voyage to Iran from there.

4tsosn.jpg

And in north-western Iran, the British defence of Yasuj was in a bad way by the morning of 5 April and other Allied defences looked a bit thin.

UNzcuK.jpg

Yasuj would fall to the Soviets two days later, on 7 April. At that time, three more Polish divisions had arrived from Western China and had recovered enough organisation to begin heading to the front in Kerman.

By the beginning of 9 April, the loss of Yasuj had helped push Iran even closer to capitulation [74%]. Later that day, 16 DP set sail from Kuala Lumpur, making to the head of the Persian Gulf.

In Georgia, the Allies had expanded their Black Sea beachhead by 10 April and were advancing north and east as the scarce Georgian SSR and Soviet forces were pushed back.

qaWc9F.jpg

By 13 April, the Poles were ready for their next attack in eastern Iran. This quick attack would last just three hours before the weakened Soviet defences crumbled. Better generalship, tactics and poor Soviet supply were enough to outweigh the enemy’s air sup[port advantage. Though not before the attacking Poles lost a couple of hundred men.

4BmKsK.jpg

Years of fighting in Western China had ensured General Żeligowski was an adaptable commander and an expert mountain fighter well suited to leading in the current conditions.

Another attack would be required a day later as the Soviets slipped another division into the north of Kerman, delaying Polish occupation of the tough terrain.

Up in Georgia, more Allied troops had arrived in Batumi by the 15th, as the enemy also started to muster thin defensive lines to the east and west of the bridgehead.

KWZDEf.jpg

While in Armenia the long-surrounded Allied army in Yerevan was still holding out quite strongly, while simultaneously trying to break out to the east.

By that time, the first four divisions of the previous Polish ‘Indochina Corps’ had arrived at the head of the Persian Gulf, just south of Ahvaz, and were part way through their post-voyage reorganisation. Two days later they were ‘ready enough’ to be sent up to the beleaguered Allied front, where the Soviets were pushing on Ahvaz from the north and had secured Yasuj.

Qdi8Vh.jpg


=======​

Asia: April 1946

Poland’s involvement in Western China had now been significantly scaled back but other events there were still being tracked. By 9 April, the Allied forced trapped in central Manchuria were being compressed and the Manchurian Federated State was on the brink of capitulation [89%].

By 12 April, the PLA had advanced to the outskirts of Dalian, the last mainland Manchurian port in Allied hands. There was now a significant risk that even the Allied troops in the smaller coastal pocket would be isolated without hope of evacuation.

DQ86Ag.jpg

To the north, the larger Hsinking Pocket was being constricted by the PLA from the west and the Soviets from the east. It was now just a matter of time before they were destroyed or captured.

oEkCOH.jpg

On Okinawa however (a Manchurian outpost) the Allies were trying - with difficulty - to force the Japanese landing back north.

JdRSK8.jpg

And in Indochina, the Allied line in central Vietnam had collapsed, with MAB forces advancing south on a wide front while the only delay was being imposed by British and German troops on the Laotian border.

fdu22x.jpg

Dalian had fallen by the end of 14 April, with an Allied counter-attack trying to regain it from the advance guard the of tired PLA troops that had just occupied it. The PLA would ultimately push more troops into Dalian and the Allied attack would fail; and with it their last hopes of evacuation.

jDcDKk.jpg

After Hsinking fell on 18 April, the Manchurians initiated separate peace talks with the PRC and surrendered just after midnight. This further depleted and isolated the three Allied troop pockets making their forlorn last stands.

lqTvF0.jpg

The Manchurians had lost over 400,000 men in this latest war, principally to the PRC and USR. A total of over 30 Allied divisions remained trapped in the Manchurian pockets. Later that day, all southern pockets in Manchuria had been eliminated and only the northern one remained.

Nvatbg.jpg

In Sinkiang, resistance remained strong as the Poles and Britain continued to resist large enemy attacks in Yarkand, inflicting heavy casualties on the Soviets during two major (and a few smaller) battles in April.

K10yYu.jpg

By the afternoon of 21 April, the perimeter in the last Allied pocket in Manchuria had been reduced to a single province, with a number of British divisions trying to retreat into it.

IEGeS1.jpg

This resistance would not last must longer and the last Allied troops in Manchuria would surrender shortly afterwards.

Whereas in Sinkiang and north-western China the Allies were in a far stronger position.

ys7d6a.jpg

At month’s end, the PRC, USR and Mongolia had divided up their occupation zones in Manchuria. The Allies continued to resist with mixed success in Western China and held strong and were even attacking in places in the north-west.

w5CWbA.jpg

The situation in Indochina continued to deteriorate.

oL4xp4.jpg

Okinawa had been cleared of the last Japanese and remained under the control of the Manchurian government in exile, where the Manchurian (ex-Kwantung, ex-Japanese) fleet was also holed up.

jQXLXr.jpg

But an earlier Japanese invasion of Taiwan had progressed rapidly and its armies were now approaching the undefended Manchurian provisional capital of Taipei.

=======​

Iran and the Caucasus: 18-30 April 1946

The Poles were in position to counter-attack the Soviets in Khuzestan by 19 April and had inflicted a sharp defeat on them by early non the 20th. That afternoon, they were advancing to reoccupy the province, while their comrades to the south were advancing the support the Allied defence of the southern approaches to Yasuj.

NfWr32.jpg

In Georgia, the Allies had expanded their beachhead a little and landed five more divisions in Batumi but the Soviets were beginning to muster more forces to scramble a defensive line. This would no doubt start to slow the Allied advance but it was clearly diverting troops from other fronts, which was something useful.

In eastern Iran, the new Polish-funded rail link was finished in Kerman and a new short branch line was being laid to support the Allied advance northwards.

CjefFu.jpg

With fresh divisions beginning to reach the front, the Poles attacked again in Kerman on the morning of 21 April and had defeated the defenders after a five-hour skirmish. A few hours later, they had repelled the Soviet attack this spoiling assault was aimed at.

W0PipV.jpg

South-east Khuzestan was retaken the same day and a hasty Soviet counter-attack defeated by the afternoon. The arrival of the Poles south of Yasuj had also ended the Soviet attack there.

NvYkD7.jpg

The Caucasus remained prominent, with a temporary status quo in Georgia and the ongoing defence of the Allied forces surrounded in Yerevan, which was tying up at least 8 4thInt divisions.

Jvh6MI.jpg

The attack on Yasuj was ready by late morning on the 23rd with all four Polish divisions participating. It would succeed after a day of heavy fighting.

fxvtzp.jpg

As had happened a number of times in the past, in Kerman the KBK had outrun its infantry support in taking the recently won ground there and were under strong Soviet counter-attack by early on the 24th. They were withdrawn soon afterwards rather than suffer further drastic casualties.

tO7rln.jpg

At that time, supply was good in the west around Ahvaz but still poor to the east.

Yasuj had been retaken and a Soviet attack defeated by the afternoon of 28 April. Earlier that day, 1 and 26 DPs (which had not advanced into Yasuj) had mounted a new attack west of Isfahan earlier that day, with victory coming at midday and reoccupation two days later. The impact of the four veteran Polish divisions in this sector had been telling so far.

waYYFN.jpg

In the east, the follow-up Polish infantry divisions had secured the newly one ground in Kerman by that time. Recently arrived Polish divisions to their east had launched a new attack on the regional town of Birjand at 0500hr on the 28th.

JR0NZM.jpg

That attack would succeed by mid-afternoon, the victory coming at the same time as a defence of south-western Kerman.

As April ended, 16 DP was approaching the entrance to the Persian Gulf on its long and uneventful voyage from Kuala Lumpur. More widely, the European and Middle Eastern fronts remained broadly balanced in an operational sense.

V0TfDG.jpg

The air situation in the theatre showed the 4thInt had air superiority in the Caucasus and supremacy over Iran at present.

nrYypY.jpg

The Allies had further widened their beachhead and seemed to still be shipping in reinforcements to Batumi, but heavy Soviet forces were now gathering to the north.

WSefXm.jpg

The situation around Yerevan and northern Kurdistan was getting tricky as supply ran out for the surrounded Allies and no relief effort seemed to be near to reaching them.

n8lNk0.jpg

In Iran, the Polish interventions were having perceptible outcomes. In the west, the dangerous advance on Ahvaz had been halted, Yasuj retaken and, if the current Soviet attacks could be well defeated, the retaking of Isfahan might even be on the cards in May.

S85nEK.jpg

And in the east, a slow pushback in Kerman was showing promising signs, with Birjand on the point of liberation. While Iran now hovered near the edge of capitulation, there remained some hope they could be saved from Communist takeover.
 
  • 2Like
  • 2Love
Reactions:
In Georgia, the Allies had expanded their Black Sea beachhead by 10 April and were advancing north and east as the scarce Georgian SSR and Soviet forces were pushed back.

At this point the Allied landing in Georgia looked like it might be a useful distraction but by the end of the month it had developed into a significant new front. The only problem is it looks like the whole operation depends on a single port for its supply?

Years of fighting in Western China had ensured General Żeligowski was an adaptable commander and an expert mountain fighter well suited to leading in the current conditions.

Definitely the right man for the job! Given the expeditionary force has done most of Poland's war-fighting, I'm guessing he's comfortably the best you've got?

And in Indochina, the Allied line in central Vietnam had collapsed, with MAB forces advancing south on a wide front while the only delay was being imposed by British and German troops on the Laotian border.

And not a Frenchman in sight!

Dalian had fallen by the end of 14 April, with an Allied counter-attack trying to regain it from the advance guard the of tired PLA troops that had just occupied it. The PLA would ultimately push more troops into Dalian and the Allied attack would fail; and with it their last hopes of evacuation.

The Manchurians had lost over 400,000 men in this latest war, principally to the PRC and USR. A total of over 30 Allied divisions remained trapped in the Manchurian pockets. Later that day, all southern pockets in Manchuria had been eliminated and only the northern one remained.

Well that ended badly, and the final collapse came far more sooner than I'd hoped.

The impact of the four veteran Polish divisions in this sector had been telling so far.

A very timely Polish intervention that should keep Iran in the war and avert another Allied disaster!
 
  • 2
  • 1Like
Reactions:
That opening photo of the Polish troops in Iran tells many tales.
 
  • 2
  • 1Like
Reactions:
In Georgia, the Allies had expanded their Black Sea beachhead by 10 April and were advancing north and east as the scarce Georgian SSR and Soviet forces were pushed back.
This new Georgian front looks like its going well.
And in Indochina, the Allied line in central Vietnam had collapsed, with MAB forces advancing south on a wide front while the only delay was being imposed by British and German troops on the Laotian border.
It's a shame this front is collapsing so quickly. It could've been held with Allied support, but instead it becomes another PRC victory.
Okinawa had been cleared of the last Japanese and remained under the control of the Manchurian government in exile, where the Manchurian (ex-Kwantung, ex-Japanese) fleet was also holed up.
Keeping the fleet is nice. At least it maintains Allied superiority on the waves.
The Caucasus remained prominent, with a temporary status quo in Georgia and the ongoing defence of the Allied forces surrounded in Yerevan, which was tying up at least 8 4thInt divisions.
The lack of Soviet divisions in Georgia makes me think the Russians are nearing their limit of the number of fronts they can hold. Unfortunately, more divisions will probably come from the now defeated Manchuria. But, if Iran is retaken, the Caucasus could be the soft underbelly for an Allied invasion.
 
  • 2
Reactions:
Well that was mostly disastrous, the Polish success in the Caucasus in no way compensating for the catastrophe out East. Overall another significant step towards the increasingly inevitable looking Allied defeat.
 
  • 2Like
Reactions:
So, after a number of RL distractions and diversions (mostly good ones), the next session has been played and chapter written up: it will focus solely on Caucasus/Iraq/Kurdistan/Iran, with the second for May 1946 to cover the Eastern Front and the rest of the world. Mainly because there was a lot of Polish operational action in Iran this month. So the storytelling focus is there, even if it is comparatively 'small bananas' compared to the scale of action on the Eastern Front, where there are some very big battles but not a lot of territorial change (lots of WW1-style meat-grinding).
At this point the Allied landing in Georgia looked like it might be a useful distraction but by the end of the month it had developed into a significant new front. The only problem is it looks like the whole operation depends on a single port for its supply?
There will be more on Georgia in the forthcoming chapter, so I won't spoil. Yes, one port of entry for supply, but more access options (I'm assuming here that MA through a neutral country doesn't confer supply routes as well, but if they do it changes the equation).
Definitely the right man for the job! Given the expeditionary force has done most of Poland's war-fighting, I'm guessing he's comfortably the best you've got?
Yes, he may be Old Guard but is very seasoned now. Though the Eastern Front action will now be sharpening up those generals too.
And not a Frenchman in sight!
Sacre bleu! :D
Well that ended badly, and the final collapse came far more sooner than I'd hoped.
Yes, another nasty Allied collapse and mass surrender :(
A very timely Polish intervention that should keep Iran in the war and avert another Allied disaster!
Per above, big concentration on Iran in the next episode - small but operationally important battles and moves.
That opening photo of the Polish troops in Iran tells many tales.
Yes, and a big theme for the next while - like the jungles of Indochina and the mountains and harsh lands of Western China were earlier.
This new Georgian front looks like its going well.
It's started well enough and the Allies do seem to be supporting it with reinforcements, though theb Soviets are (of course) reacting: It Is The Way. :D An update on it soon.
It's a shame this front is collapsing so quickly. It could've been held with Allied support, but instead it becomes another PRC victory.
The chapter after next will show what happens there next expect the unexpected, followed by the expected! o_O:p
Keeping the fleet is nice. At least it maintains Allied superiority on the waves.
I suppose so, though there's not much evidence of it having done anything for a long time.
The lack of Soviet divisions in Georgia makes me think the Russians are nearing their limit of the number of fronts they can hold. Unfortunately, more divisions will probably come from the now defeated Manchuria. But, if Iran is retaken, the Caucasus could be the soft underbelly for an Allied invasion.
Or it's just taking them time to react ... and yes, there will presumably be some more diverted now from the Far East. Poland is trying to push in Iran, but only around 3 corps there, the impact has its limitations. :-/
Iran/Caucasus looks good. The Far East, the less said the better. Can the PRC win their objectives and end their involvement? Thanks
So far, yes. But as this war has shown time and again, on both sides, the balance is often quite even and things swing one way and then the next, before reaching equilibrium for a while. Followed by and Allied collapse, stranding and surrender!b :D:rolleyes:
It's going to be a long, long road to peace yet.
Aye, very true. :(
Well that was mostly disastrous, the Polish success in the Caucasus in no way compensating for the catastrophe out East. Overall another significant step towards the increasingly inevitable looking Allied defeat.
Yes, disastrous (in an overall sense) in a rather slow motion train wreck kind of way. Hmm, is that a log placed along the tracks in the distance? Oh no, apply the breaks before it's too (crunch, screech, fade to black).
 
  • 2
Reactions:
Chapter Seventy-six: Iran Away (May 1946 – Iran, Iraq, Kurdistan and the Caucasus)
Chapter Seventy-six: Iran All Month
(May 1946 – Iran, Iraq, Kurdistan and the Caucasus)

AuthAAR’s Note: With a large and active Polish commitment in Iran in May 1946, we will focus in on that theatre for this episode, with the Eastern Front and the rest of the world to be covered in the second May instalment. Note: AI-generated images this time from my first use of Playground AI.

1N9Mps.jpg

Polish troops found themselves fighting in the deserts, hills and mountains of Iran all through May 1946.


=======​

The Siege of Yerevan

A large Allied force had punched through to take Yerevan some weeks before, but it had become isolated by a 4thInt encirclement and by the end of April 1946 was in dire straits as supplies dwindled and repeated enemy attacks were fought off, the latest placing the beleaguered garrison in a very difficult situation.

EdUm9E.jpg

By early on 1 May, just one of the seven Allied defenders was resisting effectively – but Allied troops were either coming from or had retreated to Turkish territory over the border to the west. This meant the survival of the Allied garrison was perhaps not as perilous as had been feared. Indeed, by 1400hr that day, Yerevan was still holding in Allied hands though the latest battle for it had been lost.

Late that night, it seems the German 208 Div had slipped into Yerevan from the west to prolong its defence: this must have been the reason it had managed to hold on for so long.

g0DB8l.jpg

But by 0700hr the next morning, the latest 4thInt attack seemed to have succeeded, though Yerevan had not yet fallen into their hands.

However, 10 enemy divisions had secured it by the morning of 4 May, with a lone (and doomed) German counter-attack by the Panzer-Lehr Division in progress. Diplomats confirmed that a range of Allied countries had been given military access to Turkey by that point.

LruYsH.jpg


=======​

Georgia, Turkey and Kurdistan

The Allied advance in Georgia had continued to expand through April 1946 and, despite strengthening Soviet containment lines surrounding the lodgement, the Allies had continued to reinforce the original Dutch landings at Batumi. By 4 May almost all of western Georgia had been occupied, while the Allies absorbed major Soviet counter-attacks all around the perimeter.

aWfdrq.jpg


M4qquw.jpg

More Dutch troops disembarking at Batumi, 8 May 1946.

By 12 May, though Yerevan had been retaken by the 4thInt, there was a considerable number of Allied divisions traversing neutral Turkey towards the fronts, in addition to Batumi via the Black Sea.

rCtqOd.jpg

However, by the end of the month the tide seemed to have turned in Georgia after Soviet attacks had compressed the Allied enclave in the north and east.

SAQVJb.jpg


=======​

Iraq and Iran: 1-8 May

The most intense period of Polish manoeuvre in Iran came in the first eight days of the month, as forces in both the west (the former ‘Indochina Corps’ of the Polish 4th Army) and the east (redeployed from the Western China-Sinkiang theatre) sought to retake a few key Iranian cities to keep them in the war.

On 1 May, Polish forces were still advancing to occupy Birjand [1 VP] in the east, while the Soviets were attacking at four points on the Iranian front from there to the west around Isfahan and Yasuj.

hFHVei.jpg

In western Iran, on 2 May the Poles spoiled an attack to the west of Isfahan by attacking the city directly from Yasuj once the latest Soviet attack there ended. Within three hours, both battles had been won.

T8a47w.jpg

Later that day, 1 DP continued to resist in west Isfahan after 26 DP had been forced to retreat in the face of new attack that evening.

guLXBB.jpg

In the east, as the Poles raced to occupy Birjand, supply remained patchy, so an expansion of rail supply lines from Bandar e’Abbas was started and given top priority on 3 May.

CPndK7.jpg

Two hours later, the Soviets slipped an infantry division into Birjand, requiring another attack by the Poles advancing on it. That quick attack succeeded and 32 DP was the first to arrive in the provincial city [1 VP] at midnight, coming under immediate counter-attack by a Soviet mechanised division with air support.

FGpS4N.jpg

Both 32 and 18 DPs would fold under the pressure of that attack by 0500hr on 5 May, but the arrival of 8 DP later that day meant Birjand still held and would find the victory the following morning.

5vZdCn.jpg

A similar issue was being encountered in Isfahan, where a fresh Soviet division had arrived and required another attack from the tiring 15 and 29 DPs early on the 5th.

EQhQ2e.jpg

To the east, an Iranian division liberated Yazd that evening as the Soviets counter-attacked them.

vmunEq.jpg

A day later and the fight for Isfahan had been won and the other two battles continued, as 8 DP in Birjand hung on desperately as it awaited more Polish reinforcements. They would win this fight early on the 7th, without their colleagues having arrived yet.

uA9Qcj.jpg

On the afternoon of the 7th, Isfahan was taken by an exhausted Polish advance guard only to be swiftly defeated by the Soviets, who retook the key city a day later.

J95x4S.jpg

With Birjand holding on for now, the Polish rail crews were sent north on 8 May under enemy fire with the task of extending the rail line into the tough mountain terrain to improve the poor supply situation.

fRBosp.jpg


WcuV4l.jpg

Polish rail crews had to extend the line to Birjand first through desert of Kerman to the mountains around Birjand, see above in the distance.

While the Soviets retook Isfahan and started attacking again in that sector, they were gradually pushing the Allies back in Iraq towards Baghdad, indirectly threatening the head of the Persian Gulf. By that time, 16 DP (the last to arrive from Indochina) had arrived and was reorganising.

hpbi2d.jpg

At the same time in the east, 8 DP’s defence of Birjand failed – only for the lightly armed but faster KBK to arrive in time to claim the ground while their infantry colleagues approached from the south-west.

xRgw12.jpg

The last Polish division in west Isfahan was by then retreating, with the UK defence there also failing. It seemed the recent gains made in the sector were not going to be sustainable under Soviet counter-attack.

6BrNEd.jpg


=======​

Iraq and Iran: 9-31 May

The battle for west Isfahan was lost on the night of 9 May, with the Soviets attacking Yasuj where the Yugoslavian 65th Division was trying to hold on: both Polish divisions in the vicinity had been forced to retreat to reorganise.

r77c5M.jpg

Five days later, the Soviets were trying to force their way out of west Isfahan towards the Ahvaz oilfields and Yasuj, where 1 DP had in the meantime reinforced to try to hold the city, was under heavy pressure. The partly recovered 15 and 29 DPs were sent back into the fight, to be followed up by the now reorganised 16 DP.

uaE37F.jpg

They would indeed arrive in time to allow the Allies to be holding in Yasuj by the afternoon of 15 May, but Yazd had fallen and Birjand was under attack again. Supply remained difficult at the front throughout Iran.

16fSBG.jpg

By 16 May all three Polish divisions and a British division trying to hold Birjand had been forced to retreat after an expensive defeat. The city would fall to the Soviet early on 18 May.

jHqCfQ.jpg

However, by the morning of the 18th two more ‘recycled’ Polish divisions would end up arriving in time to retake it – and safeguard the recently finished rail head.

During that time, the Soviets were prosecuting a dangerous offensive south towards Ahvaz and Basrah, driving the screening British divisions back. This threatened to cut the now narrow corridor from the Middle East to the main Iranian front.

NpN092.jpg

As noted above, it was 7 and 32 DPs that managed to successfully counter-attack Birjand early on 18 May as the Soviet advance guard proved to exhausted to retain their prize.

iZRaMz.jpg

By the end of the 19th, it was just 7 DP holding onto Birjand as it once again changed hands.: they remained low on organisation and supplies and were in a precarious position.

3rWvOL.jpg

Nonetheless, Polish rail crews sought to extend branch supply lines to the south-west of Birjand to see if those provinces could be better supported, whether for defence, recovery of later attacks.

NyHac6.jpg

And by the end of 23 May all this additional rail work this seemed to be reaping some benefits as Allied supply in western Iran improved markedly – though it remained poor in the east, most likely due to the effects of fighting and enemy air action. Birjand held on strongly under another attack against two Polish divisions there and Yasuj clung on in the east, though once more the Poles there had been forced out.

FMXQLm.jpg

But by 24 May, Yasuj was failing (now only being held by another recently arrived Polish division) and the Soviets were pushing on Baghdad and had taken a key province in Khuzestan, north-west of Yasuj.

3AcbnQ.jpg

That defence by 26 DP finally failed at 1600hr on 29 May – only for Yasuj to be retained due to the arrival of 29 DP and the British 108th Div just in time to prevent its fall.

d2UUkS.jpg

As May ended, Iran still hovered close to capitulation, with losses in the north and east of Kurdistan putting them under political pressure too. Yasuj and Birjand both still held on, thanks to further Polish reinforcements cycling through. But in overall terms, it had been a somewhat disappointing month for the Allies across the theatre.

spX8i7.jpg

Yerevan had been lost, the tide seemed to have turned in Georgia after early gains, the 4thInt was advancing again in Kurdistan and Iraq and Ahvaz was under threat. The Allies had briefly gained but been unable to hold Isfahan and Yazd. The only positive note had been the taking and (after to to-and-fro) holding of Birjand in the west under great Soviet pressure.

In the next chapter, we will ‘pan out’ somewhat to take in some high intensity defensive operations on the Eastern Front and the bigger global strategic picture.
 
  • 2Like
  • 2Love
  • 1
Reactions:
Yes, one port of entry for supply, but more access options (I'm assuming here that MA through a neutral country doesn't confer supply routes as well, but if they do it changes the equation).
You don't get supply through neutral nations, but it does allow you to retreat and not get encircled. A good thing for the Allies given everything else.
While the Soviets retook Isfahan and started attacking again in that sector, they were gradually pushing the Allies back in Iraq towards Baghdad, indirectly threatening the head of the Persian Gulf.
Time will tell if you can take land in Iran faster than the Soviets take land in Iraq, but it's not looking good. I hope Turkey joins your side at some point.
Supply remained difficult at the front throughout Iran.
Where are the Supply Hubs in Iran? Could it be worth building one?
However, by the end of the month the tide seemed to have turned in Georgia after Soviet attacks had compressed the Allied enclave in the north and east.
But in overall terms, it had been a somewhat disappointing month for the Allies across the theatre.
Disappointing and unfortunate are the two words that describe the Allies this month. Despite all your help, they are being pushed back.
 
  • 2
  • 1
Reactions:
This is definitely a discouraging update, with some of this front's back and forth a reminder of how some cities are taken and then retaken in the current conflict with Russia.

AI-generated images this time from my first use of Playground AI.
They are looking great. I see no change in the usual high-level quality. Glad you are experimenting with a new platform.
 
  • 2Like
  • 1
Reactions:
WcuV4l.jpg

Polish rail crews had to extend the line to Birjand first through desert of Kerman to the mountains around Birjand, see above in the distance.
"Jan, what the hell are you doing?!"
"What do you mean?"
"You've only laid one track!"
"That was what the orders said - extend the rail line. If the high command wanted two they should have asked for lines"

I do not know which is gloomier this or Talking Turkey. Thanks
I am noticing a pattern developing here.
 
  • 3Haha
Reactions:
But by 0700hr the next morning, the latest 4thInt attack seemed to have succeeded, though Yerevan had not yet fallen into their hands.

At least it seems the Allied divisions were able to retreat from Yerevan into Turkey, so that's something. :)

However, by the end of the month the tide seemed to have turned in Georgia after Soviet attacks had compressed the Allied enclave in the north and east.

Disappointing, to be honest. I thought this venture was going to give the Soviets a much bigger headache!

As May ended, Iran still hovered close to capitulation, with losses in the north and east of Kurdistan putting them under political pressure too. Yasuj and Birjand both still held on, thanks to further Polish reinforcements cycling through. But in overall terms, it had been a somewhat disappointing month for the Allies across the theatre.

A difficult month. I get the feeling the Polish intervention is just about managing to keep the Allies alive in this theatre, whereas we had been hoping for a successful counter-offensive. Is it just my perception or have the Polish divisions been struggling here? We've seen a lot of exhausted divisions forced to retreat. :eek:
 
  • 2
  • 1
Reactions:
Second May update now in production. Some comment feedback:
Is there a May European update for a little good news? I do not know which is gloomier this or Talking Turkey. Thanks
It's on the way, but I must give no comment on whether the news is good, bad or indifferent ;) The gloom depends on one's in-game perspective, I suppose :D Still, was OTL history much less gloomy than either of these altiverses? o_O
This is not going well.
Nup. No disaster for Poland, but the Allies in general just can't seem to move the dial in their favour. :-/
You don't get supply through neutral nations, but it does allow you to retreat and not get encircled. A good thing for the Allies given everything else.
Thanks for confirming - makes sense.
Time will tell if you can take land in Iran faster than the Soviets take land in Iraq, but it's not looking good. I hope Turkey joins your side at some point.
In the nature of the game so far, Turkey joining would probably bring on some favourable moves but the front would then move into a general stalemate with the Allies getting pushed back very slowly! :confused:
Where are the Supply Hubs in Iran? Could it be worth building one?
Here's a supply screenshot from the last update, modified to highlight the available supply sources in or near Iran: they seem pretty reasonable, I think it's just a matter of throughput.

JgkORE.jpg
Disappointing and unfortunate are the two words that describe the Allies this month. Despite all your help, they are being pushed back.
True. It's a long, slow wave goodbye at the moment. Even worse than WW1 in some ways! :(
This is definitely a discouraging update, with some of this front's back and forth a reminder of how some cities are taken and then retaken in the current conflict with Russia.
Very much so. Rather sad, really.
They are looking great. I see no change in the usual high-level quality. Glad you are experimenting with a new platform.
Thanks! They still have their idiosyncrasies and shortfalls, but Playground can do a few things Bing DALL-e can't.
"Jan, what the hell are you doing?!"
"What do you mean?"
"You've only laid one track!"
"That was what the orders said - extend the rail line. If the high command wanted two they should have asked for lines"
Gotta love AI generation. I thought something like that myself but just went ahead using it anyway! :D
I am noticing a pattern developing here.
In these two pieces, anyway. It is just what the games were giving me ;) And I wasn't going to make it gratuitously happy, either. Though TBC is stuck in the Ninth Circle of Hell in his Divine ComAARdy! It could be worse, y'know! :D
At least it seems the Allied divisions were able to retreat from Yerevan into Turkey, so that's something. :)
Indeed, far better than I had been expecting.
Disappointing, to be honest. I thought this venture was going to give the Soviets a much bigger headache!
Same here. It is reverting to type: early promise, stalemate, gradual decline with ebbs and flows along the way.
A difficult month. I get the feeling the Polish intervention is just about managing to keep the Allies alive in this theatre, whereas we had been hoping for a successful counter-offensive. Is it just my perception or have the Polish divisions been struggling here? We've seen a lot of exhausted divisions forced to retreat. :eek:
An accurate summary of my own feelings and read of the current state of play. Will keep trying to look for some significant blow I can strike, but it's looking difficult to do anything much on a scale sufficient to turn the strategic situation around.

Thanks all for the continued support - Poland will not give up the fight until the death ... who's ever that might be!
 
  • 1
Reactions:
Chapter Seventy-seven: A Bitter Spring (May 1946 – The Eastern Front and the Rest of the World)
Chapter Seventy-seven: A Bitter Spring
(May 1946 – The Eastern Front and the Rest of the World)

AuthAAR’s Note: With Iran and the Middle East covered in the last update, we will focus the Eastern Front and the rest of the world in this second May instalment. After this, I’ll be looking to consolidate back to integrated monthly chapters if possible, unless something worthy of a deeper dive happens. A couple of Bing DALL-e images in this chapter.

LSwZJi.jpg

Polish troops dug in in south-west Khmelnytskyi prepare themselves for the next Soviet onslaught during a bloody and far from merry month of May 1946.


=======​

The Americas

By 12 May, the situation in eastern Canada had not changed appreciably with neither side attempting any significant pushes. In Mexico, the US and Mexico had initiated a major front-wide offensive.

LsSFnB.jpg

The Americans had widened the perimeter around regained Los Angeles by the 18th and Tijuana had been linked in to US supply and a mix of US and partner divisions provided a strong garrison for the returned Mexican government-in-exile.

Sd3ovl.jpg

In Canada, the Allies were conducting an offensive that seemed to be making a little headway, while the bulk of deployed Allied divisions continued to sit back doing nothing.

mQ6Znu.jpg

But no territorial headway had been there before the end of the month.

zzFN1F.jpg

The general situation in Mexico had deteriorated in the last 12 days, including an enemy advance along Baja California and new US landings in Yucatan.

lDp2km.jpg

A small part of south-west Texas remained in Allied hands, where mainly Anglo-German forces continued to defend doggedly.

Hf7qdt.jpg

In the west, the enemy had broken out of Tijuana and were advancing south against light and frail resistance. Allied efforts were more formidable, north and east of there with the small lodgement in US territory still maintained.

u5lz5R.jpg

The US were ashore in Yucatan and another landing to the south-west in some strength and were trying to seize vital port facilities. It was another headache and diversion the Allies could ill afford as they clung onto their positions in this important front that had long occupied US attentions.

uIVWtF.jpg

The stalemate in Guyana continued, with both sides having drawn down their forces there over May.

cOiXHb.jpg


=======​

Asia

The fighting in Asia went on much as it had the previous month. In Indochina, by 21 May the MAB had advanced to the outskirts of Saigon, where it appeared a sizeable Allied force was attempting to mount a defence. To the west, the MAB was advancing into Cambodia with little opposition, though Allied divisions, including armour, were assembling in Phnom Penh.

aMvcDu.jpg

However, the Allied effort in Saigon had collapsed (it was unknown whether the divisions there had evacuated by sea or been destroyed) and it had been occupied by the 29th as a rearguard action was fought in Cambodia, where Phnom Penh still held but the MAB had advanced up to the Mekong River to its east.

C1bTdf.jpg

On the morning of the 30th, one more division was withdrawn from Sinkiang, where 28 DP had been providing a depth garrison in Urumqi and sent to the Iranian Front.

At the end of the month, Phnom Penh was under attack but still held, but the flanks of the Allied defence were open on either side.

8xPKJU.jpg

In Western China, the Soviets had made a series of heavy but futile attacks on the Polish and British divisions holding Yarkand in western Sinkiang in the second half of the month. Elsewhere, the Allies were fighting a steady defence of Western China against MAB and 4thInt forces to its east and north.

q9wMj1.jpg


=======​

The Eastern Front

By far the most important and bloody fight for the Poles was of course the Eastern Front, where Soviet and 4thInt pressure was exerted in waves during the month, as it had in April. Many small to medium sized battles were waged during the month, only the largest (in terms of lives lost) will be noted below.

In the north, a massive Soviet attack continued from April was defeated in Wilejka on the evening of May. Wilejka came under repeated heavy Soviet attack from 11 May onwards but these were repelled more easily, with relatively few Allied casualties – the Poles receiving Czech, Yugoslavian and German assistance. In these larger battles alone, the enemy took around 35,000 casualties in May in Wilejka.

uZm9uS.jpg

Soon after the initial victory in Wilejka, Yugoslavia and Czechoslovakia (who between them now fielded around as many divisions on the Eastern Front as Poland) launched a combined offensive across the entire front on 3 May, though most of these attacks were clearly destined to fail.

qRy2Qo.jpg

However, some were making some progress – but not enough to persuade the Poles to join in, given their recent experiences and the continuing heavy assault on south-west Khmelnytskyi also carried over from April. Where on 7 May it was decided to start building fixed fortification for the first time, even as it remained under enemy fire.

By 12 May, all four main Eurasian theatres were seeing heavy combat. In Poland-Byelorussia, it was the Soviets now on the offensive after the brave but doomed Allied effort of the previous days.

P8Qtg7.jpg

Supply for both sides was difficult in south-west Khmelnytskyi as the great battle there dragged on – seemingly interminably, with no early end in sight.

v1lQq5.jpg

A few days later, the Yugoslavs and Czech were grimly trying to hold onto a small slice of ground they had taken in their earlier offensive, under enormous odds. Despite the seemingly impossible, reinforcements would arrive and they would still hold it by the end of the month. But the Poles would not commit their own troops to this costly fight: they hoped the other Allies would take this one on.

3RvlO7.jpg

With no Polish general offensive anticipated for the coming weeks, the main construction effort was directed to building new fixed land fortifications along critical parts of the Eastern Front, including forward positions occupied in Byelorussia and Ukraine.

53samK.jpg

Indeed, south-west Khmelnytskyi was coming under increasing pressure by mid-May, as a number of Polish divisions had been forced to retreat to recuperate from the meatgrinder. One of the Czech EF divisions was sent back into the fight, along with a returning Polish motorised division as General Abraham warned his defence was beginning to fail.

xXrNHQ.jpg


rMw526.jpg

Polish officers plan their move to return to the front in the bloody fields of south-west Khmelnytskyi, 15 May 1946.

The reinforcements and now Soviet exhaustion saw the tide of the battle turned by the following morning, as western Khmelnytskyi also came under heavy pressure again.

sGAoTJ.jpg

Other major defensive battles fought in this period came in central and southern Byelorussian sector, with major victories in eastern Polesie and Minsk itself from 17-25 May, as heavy fighting also continued (as noted previously) in the north at Wilejka.

eyFq2i.jpg

The latest massive battle for south-west Khmelnytskyi swung decisively in the Allies favour on the morning of 21 May and finally ended just before midnight. More men from both sides perished in this battle than for any previously experienced by the Poles: 35,000 in total.

jxDQ95.jpg


W9Sh0T.jpg

General Roman Abraham (on horseback) accompanies President Ignacy Mościcki’s car as they conduct a review of troops recently withdrawn from the font in a parade at Cernăuti on 22 May 1946 to celebrate the great victory. Even as the review took place (for the propaganda cameras) another vicious battle had begun there as the Soviets tried to retake their border province.

Of course, the Soviets did not let up for long in this fiercely contested sector. Two more major defensive victories were won there and just to the north between 26-28 May after which the Soviets once more attacked in strength towards the end of the month. And once more, the tired troops defending south-west Khmelnytskyi were in need of immediate reinforcement.

AgfeVZ.jpg

It was also noticed that poor Allied supply in the area was being exacerbated by the lack of transport infrastructure in the occupied province. Engineers were sent in on 29 May to commence emergency railway works to south-west Khmelnytskyi.

aED7Nt.jpg

By the evening of 31 May the defences of south-west Khmelnytskyi were holding with the battle’s odds still in the balance. Yet more Polish and Czech EF divisions were ordered back into the fight from their R&R just behind the lines.

gSURN0.jpg

As the month ended, a British armoured division had reinforced the line in addition to the latest Polish relief force. This put British General Claude Auchinleck in charge of the battle and had once more swung the battle in the Allies’ favour.

U4EWW2.jpg

Across the front, the Soviets were still attacking but the Allies were holding. The only ground to change hands during the month was the single province taken by the Czechs and Yugoslavs just south of Minsk in the earlier offensive.

lsIphD.jpg


=======​

Defence Industry and General War Casualties

A new military factory came on line on 3 May (making 33 Polish military factories and 12 dockyards). It was used to bolster tactical bomber production (now three, currently producing 2.32 bombers per week).

With resource usage increasing, Poland had finally turned to improving extraction efficiency, the first iteration completed on 13 May. Rubber production was the next research project undertaken.

p1CwK4.jpg

Poland allies also helped sporadically with the ongoing shortages of AA and artillery pieces through welcome lend-lease pledges.

X5bito.jpg

A new shortage in replacement light SP artillery had to be addressed with one factory being switched to those vehicles the same day.

At month’s end, the next German election was now just three months off. The Communists were still ahead in the polls, with the Polish-supported DNVP in second place and the current governing Zentrum a distant third. Would the Communists take over or a centre-right coalition prevail?

OApjYS.jpg

In the current war (excluding the previous fighting against the Fascists) total military deaths were now estimated to have climbed to over 25 million. For Poland, around 182,000 of their total 191,000 battle casualties had occurred over the last 12 months, with losses to the Soviets making the bulk of these, now far ahead of those lost to the MAB. The Poles had lost another 26,870 men in May, despite being largely on the defensive. They retained manpower reserves of over 700,000: they planned on having to sustain an even longer war.

0KbZzO.jpg

They had in turn inflicted more casualties on the Soviets – around 863,700 – than any other power. They remained a significant but second tier contributor to PRC losses over the years, lessening proportionally as they continued to disengage from Asia.
 
Last edited:
  • 3Like
  • 2Love
Reactions:
The Americans had widened the perimeter around regained Los Angeles by the 18th and Tijuana had a been linked in to US supply and a mix of US and partner divisions provided a strong garrison for the returned Mexican government-in-exile.
The Allied position in Mexico is in a bad spot. Baja could be cut off so easily, and the US seems to have advantage in terms of supply.
the bulk of deployed Allied divisions continued to sit back doing nothing.
I wonder what their thinking is here. :shrugs:
where it appeared a sizeable Allied force was attempting to mount a defence. To the west, the MAB was advancing into Cambodia with little opposition, though Allied divisions, including armour, were assembling in Phnom Penh.
Those Allied defenses look to be too late. Indochina is gone.
However, some were making some progress – but not enough to persuade the Poles to join in, given their recent experiences
Defense is your best option at this point. The Soviets will lose lots of equipment and men with their attacks.
By 12 May, all four main Eurasian theatres were seeing heavy combat.
Iran seems to be holding well in this image. Hopefully, it continues to distract the USR.
It was also noticed that poor Allied supply in the area was being exacerbated by the lack of transport infrastructure in the occupied province.
I forget, did you switch your generals to using motorized supplies instead of horses? It will help when you're far away from any hubs.
33 Polish military factories
More factories are definitely needed to keep up with equipment losses.

I was wondering, do you have a copy of the save? I'd like to be able to tag around and see how the Allies and MAB are doing with industry, research, etc.
 
  • 2
  • 1Like
Reactions: