Chapter Eighty: The Jakowski Review
(1-11 August 1946)
British troops disembark in Archangelsk in an initially unopposed surprise landing in mid-July 1946. The landings were kept so quiet by the British that the Polish Government did not become aware of them until the end of the month!
=
==
==
==
Archangelsk
The surprise British landings on the White Sea coast in northern Russia took place in around mid-July, though the Poles did not become aware of them until a low-key cable from their Embassy in London communicated the existence of the new front after being informed by the British at midnight on 31 July. A report was provided showing how the lodgement had expanded unopposed by 22 July
[my previous game save], but no more details than that were forthcoming. It was seen as a typically Churchillian amphibious scheme 'at the periphery'.
By the end of July, the landing zone had expanded a little with an overland drive to the south-east, but by then Soviet units – including a number of tank divisions – had begun to arrive along its western edge to begin the job of containing the unexpected new front.
The Jakowski Review
With Allied prospects in Iran, the Middle East and central Asia steadily deteriorating while the lull in heavy fighting on the Eastern Front continued (perhaps explained by the Soviet focus on Iran, the Middle East and now the diversion in Archangelsk), Poland decided it was time for a thorough review of its force structure, research and industrial priorities. The other driver was re-gearing Army Group East and the Air Force to be ready for the coming offensive that was planned to coincide with the long-planned coup in Belarus.
To help them with this daunting task, the services of respected Polish military thinker Władisław Jakowski
[aka @jak7139 – thanks so much mate!] were called upon to provide recommendations and advice in many areas of Polish strategy, industry and military organisation. This produced the 7,139-page Jakowski Review, most of which began to be implemented from midnight on 31 July onwards.
A quickly adopted recommendation related to the Navy’s use of outdated ship designs. New hull types had been developed in recent years but never completed with the required modules to allow construction of them to commence. For example, the 1944 submarine hull needed a minimum of torpedo tubes to be included, while the new 1940 destroyer hull required at least a gun battery to be installed.
With only limited Naval effort available for this work
[ie 35 design points total], it was decided that for now a minimum would be done to make the new subs seaworthy. The main effort would go into making a credible destroyer design, as they were seen as more likely to be of use in the future for escort and ASW work. The last of each of the old vessels would be completed during August and would be replaced by the new ones when the time came.
Next came a change to the standard infantry division template. To help save on equipment requirements and erase the AT gun deficit – and be able to suspend their further production to consolidate industrial effort – the AT battalions in the first brigade of each division would be replaced with a support AT company at divisional level, leaving hundreds of spare AT guns available. The field hospital and logistics companies were removed, with an engineer company brought in to aid with the defence, the support AT company taking the other slot. However, more infantry equipment would be needed, leading to a temporary shortage.
Another idea that the general staff and been mulling over was the creation of cavalry divisions, to give them more punch and durability. At Jakowski’s recommendation, the new template did away with the recon detachments.
[Cavalry brigade template duplicated then the extra four cav brigades added, to save some design points].
The first new cavalry division was created with two co-located brigades in northern Poland straight away. The rest would be completed in a similar fashion as they were brought together behind the lines during coming days and weeks.
Note the wide range of old and new Polish and borrowed equipment in use.
In all, the ten Polish cavalry brigades would be consolidated into five divisions. Most would assemble behind the lines on the Eastern Front and combine one by one when gathered.
The KBK, currently in Birjand with 4th Army, was put on trains for Bandar e’Abbas from where they would take ship back home after years away fighting in China and Iran. As they headed back home, so the mountain troops of 50 DPG took ship from Athens to Beirut, on transfer to the 4th Army in the Middle East and Iran.
Another Jakowski recommendation saw the last three divisions of the 6th Army Sinkiang also transferred to the 4th under its temporary commander Haller, freeing up the experienced General Marian Kukiel for a new job when the time came. The two infantry divisions were sent on to Iran, leaving just the one division of mountain troops to assist with the defence of Yarkand.
This was the cue for the much-awaited broader reorganisation of Field Marshal Sikorski’s Army Group East to begin.
By its end, the four armies in Army Group East were organised into three different types. 1st Army, already with a majority of the mobile units, would become Poland’s fully mobile force, designed for exploitation of any breakthrough that might be made. General Roman Abraham, imbued with the offensive spirit, would remain in charge. It now contained all the light armoured and new motorised divisions, the four newly reorganised cavalry divisions, plus the one armoured and two cavalry formations the Czechs had provided as EFs.
The 2nd Army, under Władysław Anders, contained the four ‘heavy’ divisions (which included the heavy infantry support tanks but were essentially leg-infantry formations despite the symbol) and 20 regular infantry divisions. It would provide the backbone of the defence in coming months and would be called upon to fight the expected grinding breakthrough battles for 1st Army to exploit in the offensive. 3rd Army (Sosnkowski) and 5th Army (Kowalski) were the lighter line armies. Each had seven regular divisions each at their corps, supported by a mix of the Polish militia divisions (more like reinforced brigades) and lighter Latvian or Czech EF infantry formations to bring both up to 21 divisions.
The idea was that 3rd and 5th Armies would be evenly distributed along the line to provide the base of the defence. As the offensive came close, the plan was as many as possible of 1st and 2nd Armies would be held back and fully prepared for the offensive. If that induced an exhausting attack by the Soviets that could then be exploited by a counter-offensive, then all the better. 2nd Army would then launch in to crack the Soviet line in at least two places if possible, hopefully exploiting the pro-Polish Byelorussian uprising, allowing 1st Army to breakthrough and conduct ‘lightning war encirclements’ if at all possible.
Field Marshal Rydz-Śmigly’s Expeditionary Army Group was now roughly in its settled form, barring a few planned adjustments along the way.
Largely in accordance with Jakowski’s advice
[any changes or omissions are my responsibility], production priorities would be progressively adjusted in coming days. For now, the one factory allocated to Light SP artillery (of which there was enough in stockpile) was re-tasked to AA production. Other changes would follow.
For some time, the equipment for a proposed mechanised division (medium tanks, mechanised infantry and medium SP Artillery - not part of the Jakowski Review) had been under production with no template provided. There was now almost enough to fit out a prototype division that would eventually be allocated to 1st Army. Its initial template would be added to as time went by (and more equipment was produced). It was uncertain whether it would be ready to deploy as part of the proposed winter offensive of 1946.
Its main tank was the 14TP, but a range of German and Italian lend-lease vehicle helped make up its numbers. Similarly, there was some German SP artillery and the usual mix of Polish and borrowed infantry equipment, but all the personnel carriers were of the Polish C7P design. It was still awaiting delivery of support equipment, AA and trucks.
The Air Force was also subject to some consolidation. The Pustułka Mk1 interceptor would continue production as the main fighter type. Production of the Lis (Fox) Mk1 heavy fighter would be discontinued: its main role was to provide escort to Poland’s tactical bombers on any longer-range missions and it was considered there was now enough of these for that job.
A similar process was applied to the bomber arm: Jakowski had recommended discontinuing TAC production to concentrate on the cheaper Okoń (Perch) CAS aircraft, but the Air Force brass wanted to also retain a deeper range and more multi-purpose (though more slowly built) tactical bomber force, so the Dzik (Boar) TAC was retained. The three freed factories went to building more Lis, Dzik and AA (not shown).
The 73 remaining stockpiled Lis heavy fighters and 39 Okoń CAS were added into new or existing wings in Lwów. The stockpiled fighters were all older models (some inter-war vintage) so were left as ‘emergency spares’.
Building the lagging industrial base was also given higher priority, with new military and civilian factories programmed and sent to the top of the construction queue, being built in the provinces with the best infrastructure.
The Americas - Mexico
The responsibility for commanding the German Expeditionary Corps in Mexico (dubbed the 7th Army) meant there was now some direct Polish interest and involvement at the tactical level. General Sosabowski – a special forces operator – looked to use his commando and camouflage skills to help his men if they found themselves lacking supply and to protect them from US CAS attacks. One of his divisions – stuck down on the Yucatan Peninsula – was however ordered to head across the Atlantic for Beirut, where it was planned they would join the 4th Army in the Middle East.
On 1 August, 2 Pz. and 340. Inf Divs still found themselves somewhat exposed in north-western Mexico by the enemy’s advances there. Both were ordered to withdraw to Hermosillo but were delayed twice that day by enemy holding attacks: both won by 2000hrs that night, with time being the only cost incurred.
At the same time, 198. Inf was ordered north to see if it could establish a strong river defence and firm base for their retreat, plugging a dangerous gap in the Allied line.
The next day, further north just over the border in Arizona (the last little foothold on US territory), the Anglo-German defenders risked isolation and encirclement. They had managed a strong defensive victory that morning but were under attack again two hours later, where the Polish-commanded Germans had just had to brush off another delaying attack in Sonora.
In the east, the Allied pocket trapped on the Gulf Coast had been whittled down to three divisions and looked to be on their last legs. They retained supply as they were actually in a port, but it seemed unclear if any of their comrades had escaped to sea: none had yet been observed getting away.
[Question, when attacked in such situations and forced to retreat, are units usually destroyed? Do they ever escape to sea?]
2 Pz. Div reached Hermosillo at 1100hrs on 2 August and started digging in, to provide a safe base for 340. Inf (and any other Allied units to the north) to retreat through. Early the next morning, the 340th had to defeat yet another delaying attack (25 German, 357 US casualties) and were still some way of reaching safety.
They completed their long, harried march to Hermosillo on the night of 4 August. A day later and they were ordered to keep heading south-east to join 198. Inf in their defensive line. With its extra speed, 2 Pz. Div would be able to withdraw if necessary, so stayed in the screening position at Hermosillo. By then, the pocket in the east had been eliminated, with Polish observers not seeing any indications of the troops escaping to sea.
By the night of 6 August, the Allied line in northern Mexico again seemed to have stabilised. And the US seemed to have significantly thinned their lines across the front, especially in the far south-east, where a surprising gap had been left along the Texan border. Conversely, the Allies had also been thinning their lines, with a lot of units seen crossing back over the Atlantic: perhaps to Europe and/or the Middle East. As for where the US divisions had gone, there was no indication, with no big increase seen in eastern Canada or anywhere else – yet, anyway.
By 9 August, the Allies had successfully evacuated their men from Arizona, 198. Inf had reached their defensive assignment and been joined by a British division as 340. Inf still marched towards them from Hermosillo. The two other Polish-commanded German divisions to the east also held firm while the front remained fairly quiet.
Little would change over the next few days, similarly in Canada, where no significant developments had occurred.
=======
Georgia
To the surprise of many, the perimeter around Batumi remained firm by 5 August, with the Soviets either unable or unwilling to wipe it out, despite a number of previous attempts.
The perimeter would remain intact for the rest of the period until the end of 11 August.
=======
Asia and the Middle East
The Soviets continued to heavily dominate the skies over Iran, with over 1,200 aircraft (of all types) operating there on 1 August 1946, and only 200 RAF bombers contesting. It was here that the vast majority of Polish casualties from air strikes were being suffered and there was virtually nothing the Poles could do to alleviate this, other than continue to increase the spread of AA guns through their divisions.
By the evening of 2 August, two Polish divisions had (after being delayed a number of times by Soviet holding attacks) almost reached Ahvaz from the east, where an Anglo-German force was still holding on grimly. Another Polish division was almost at the port to its south, where it would try to aid the Allied defence of the last land connection to the rest of the Middle East should Ahvaz fall, as seemed likely.
16 and 29 DPs arrived in Ahvaz early on the 3rd, already somewhat disorganised after their fights to get there. Even with their arrival (in reserve for now) the defence was in big trouble, with the Anglo-German divisions having apparently been forced or pulled out and just one Iraqi division holding the line against 8 Soviet attackers. There was only one way this combat was likely to end.
At this point 1 and 15 DPs also began heading west, following 26 DP to the head of the Persian Gulf, to avoid being stranded in Iran if at all possible. At 1300hr that day the Iraqi defence of Ahvaz folded without the Polish division being engaged: they were forced to join the retreat to Basrah, but at least they had been spared a mauling at the hands of superior Soviet firepower.
By early on 5 August, they were in place behind the Shatt Al Arab waterway, which should afford a decent defensive boost. 26 DP was starting to dig in to the east, but 1 and 15 DPs had been detained by a Soviet spoiling attack on the sole British division left to defend while all the other Allied formations were either counter-attacking Ahvaz or (like the Poles) trying to move elsewhere.
By that night, the Poles (though still well enough organised) had been caught up in a general confused withdrawal, their march west abandoned as they were instead made to retreat south-east to Shiraz. The Allied grip in the sector was rapidly slipping.
At this juncture, 50 DPG arrived in Beirut with the mountain troops still being sent by train across to Kuwait City, where it was envisaged they would be shipped across the Gulf to help the defence of mountainous Iran.
The Soviets had pushed through to the Gulf and thus isolated Iran from the rest of the Middle East by the evening of 8 August. 1 and 15 DPs had just arrived in Shiraz, leaving the large body of Allied troops gathered there to head south to secure Bushehr – one of the remaining Iranian ports and a possible exit point should a general Polish withdrawal from Iran be ordered.
The next day, 26 DP was ordered out of Iran to join their comrades in Basrah, as the Soviets tried to cross the Tigris River at three different points, with the key city of Baghdad under severe threat, one crossing to its south an even-money bet and the third attempt north of Basrah being resisted more strongly. The worried Poles sent a message strongly urging the Allies to hold Baghdad as a high priority.
From 9-10 August, the strong Polish defence of hard-won Birjand started to come under increased Soviet pressure. A particularly heavy battle was won late on the 9th and another smaller attack defeated the following morning. The three infantry divisions were starting to fell the effects but still held strong.
10 and 17 DPs arrived in Iranshah from Yarkand on the morning of the 10th and were ordered to continue their train trip to Bushehr. Birjand was under determined attack again, which would be defeated the following evening.
Iran was edging closer to surrender, while the MAB kept up the pressure in Western China and Tibet with another front-wide offensive.
On the evening of the 11th, the situation in Iraq had stabilised a little. Baghdad had been reinforced and was now holding, as was the middle crossing attempt of the Tigris, while the southern one had been defeated.
The Pacific
While the US remained contained in Indonesia, the latest Japanese invasion of New Guinea had fanned out by 10 August as the Australians and their allies tried to contain the breakout.
The Eastern Front
Despite its reorganisation and the deployment of new aircraft mentioned earlier, the Polish Air Force was not yet ready to commit to the contested air zones in the East. They would be preserved for the decisive moment (either in a desperate defence or, as hoped, for the winter offensive). But for now, with the front quiet few if any casualties were being taken there from enemy air action.
In any case, the Ukraine was too heavily controlled by the Soviets, though Belarus was being more evenly contested by the RAF. The PAF could muster around 900 fighters of all types at that point. Other Allied air forces were present but not too active for now, with Nowogródek somewhat overcrowded.
By 3 August all remained quiet on the Eastern Front, with no battles in progress from Estonia to the Romanian border. The situation was little changed by the 9th, so it was deemed timely for General Kukiel – a highly skilled defensive commander returning from previous injury and then brief service in Sinkiang – to take over 5th Army in eastern Poland.
Up in northern Russia, the British Archangelsk landing were being more fully sealed off by the Soviets with further progress curtailed and counter-attacks begun. The British did not seem to have reinforced the sector: perhaps it was intended more as a diversion than a serious assault?
Industry, Research and Reorganisation
After the initial adjustments of the Jakowski Review, on 1 August the military production allocations were as follows:
Infantry equipment, TAC, interceptors and AA production had all been increased, though it would take a while for efficiency to raise output to the maximum level. Medium tank and SP artillery plus mechanised carriers were kept going to help fit out the new mechanised division. AT production was kept ticking along for now until the recent reorganisation had shaken out and the new requirements were clearer.
On 3 August, AT production was cancelled with 353 guns now in stockpile after the reorganisation with the spare factory temporarily allocated to medium SP artillery production to speed the equipment provision for the mech div. Apart from the AA rollout (-1,000), the other current deficiency was in infantry equipment (-369), needed for new units and replacements, hence its ramping up previously.
There was big news on 4 August when Poland’s first operational jet fighter – the PZL.71 Orzeł (Eagle) – design was completed. The first production model would have extended range (to match the current Pustułka Mk1 piston-engine interceptor) and an improved engine (all that could be afforded in design points).
Due to initial start-up inefficiencies production was scaled down from 8 to 5 factories when the Pustułka (Kestrel) was discontinued. The saved effort from that and ramping back on artillery production was sunk into AA and more infantry equipment: if all that extra manpower was going to be used for new divisions (or supplementing the current militia establishment) then a lot more of that was going to be needed.
On the 5th, on Jakowski’s advice, the Governments-in-Exile of Pakistan and China were both tapped for manpower support, ostensibly for the garrisons Poland had to maintain in Byelorussia and Romania, effectively adding 113,000 to the Polish reserve pool.
The current artillery surplus allowed for a battalion of field artillery to be added to all 20 militia divisions the same day, with the rollout starting immediately, beefing up those formations for the demands ahead.
And that evening the KBK took ship in Bandar e’Abbas for the long voyage around Arabia and through the Suez to Athens for their return home. By 8 August, the new mountain division – 113 DPG – had all its equipment issued and had finished 41% of its training, due to deploy in late October.