• We have updated our Community Code of Conduct. Please read through the new rules for the forum that are an integral part of Paradox Interactive’s User Agreement.
At the very least, several other allied countries can move their reserce armies to Russian front or the active war now.
My immediate reaction too. The thin slice of Europe was taking up a lot of attention. And the Czech army itself would also be a welcome addition if it came to it.
Another good addition.
More = merrier.
Ah, a good ally indeed. Though might be too late, as war in Canada seems almost over. Had they started in from the begining, it might have made rhe difference.

Now, I suspect rhey will lose hard.
At least they are in there now, with plenty of Allied help. If Canada can just hold on long enough, defending hard and hoping the US is distracted from finishing them off, all might be well. It also gives another option for possible Polish expeditionary action. Help Canada hold on? Or reinforce Mexico to strengthen the southern offensive? Or let the others handle it while Poland keep watch on the east?
Much to catch up on, all of it to the usual high standards, so I will only detain you with my personal highlights.
Lovely to have you back :). Hope RL didn’t play too roughly with you.
I did warn everyone about him, so I do feel vindicated.
Absolutely right. He’s turned out every bit as unhinged and evil as you predicted.
Clark vs de Gaulle has a very Alien vs Predator feeling, in that you want both of them to lose.
Quite. De Gaulle fighting the Americans on behalf of a Communist France in the Western Pacific is a sentence I wouldn’t normally expect to be writing, but that’s non-historical HOI4 for you!
Good to see HOI4 did accurately model Ernest King as being inept at convoy protection and ASW.
Researchers get something right!? :eek: Stop the presses! :D
I had my suspicions when you set it up, but it was still wonderful to see Mexico finally join the side of justice and truth in fighting against the unspeakable evil of WW's nightmarish regime.
Had to give a little teasing hint, but in game I wasn’t expecting the pleasant surprise quite yet. I think it has set up the American War quite nicely. For some months, I was thinking things weren’t crazy enough. The US entry sparked the zest for zaniness back into things. Now all we need is Trotsky to stop being so timid …
 
  • 1
Reactions:
July/August 1944:

As Allied troops funnelled into Canada from the Atlantic, the US had struck at …
… the small French island outpost of St Pierre and Miquelon!

The AI's choice of target is bewildering - I figured they were going after St. John's... o_O

As the fighting raged on all the major fronts of the war over the next few days, a curious report from Bulgaria made the headlines. There was wild speculation about possible local Bulgarian, German, British or Russian involvement in Tsar Boris III’s purportedly natural death. Whether this would mean anything significant for the former Fascist and now Allied puppet nation remained unclear.

This is Bulgaria you're talking about, so it will probably manage to turn the world on its head... somehow. :eek:

The Allies won the race that evening, with French troops closing the trap: 5 Japanese and 7 PRC divisions surrendered, breaking the back of their resistance in Indochina – for now, until more divisions were no doubt sent to stem the haemorrhage.

That's a big result in Indochina, especially as this is where the MAB appeared to be strongest. :)

The destination of the US invasion fleets was discovered a few days later when they landed in Suriname, spreading the war into South America after the US had island-hopped south to fully occupy French and British islands in the West Indies. An outnumbered French brigade was now trying to hold them off to its east.

The Americans seem to be keen on mopping up all the Allied outposts in the vicinity, which might not be a bad move. What I don't understand is why Mexico hasn't been called into the fray yet?

And as the month ended, a surprise Japanese landing had been reported by the British at Khota Bahru, in northern Malaya, where Chinese and German units were seeking to repel a Japanese assault from the sea.

Erich von Manstein defending British Malaya against the Japanese is not something you see every day!

The only Polish attacks during the whole month had come in north Gansu up to 8 August. Following that, like the other Allies around them, almost all the fighting had been defensive. North-east Golog and then later central Gannan had held out well against repeated probes, as had north Gannan, the last battle being a heavy NAB defeat. But the areas gained the month before, stretching from east Gannan south-west to Ganzi had all been retaken by the MAB.

Western China seems to be proving difficult. The Allied gains in July seemed promising, but now they've mostly been rolled back... and we're not used to seeing Polish divisions being driven to breaking point either! :(
 
  • 1
  • 1Like
Reactions:
The AI's choice of target is bewildering - I figured they were going after St. John's... o_O
Yes, some choices are more obviously logical than others ... they clearly wanted to do something to hit the French! And to be charitable, maybe they wanted it as a base for subsequent operations and it was eaiser to attack than some other targets <shrugs>
This is Bulgaria you're talking about, so it will probably manage to turn the world on its head... somehow. :eek:
The world keeps turning on its head, even if Bulgaria is not the instigator - this time. :D After all, this ATL is 'Poles Apart' from OTL, as I'd hoped it would be when this kicked off. ;)
That's a big result in Indochina, especially as this is where the MAB appeared to be strongest. :)
Yes, these were good times there as the pendulum swung again.
The Americans seem to be keen on mopping up all the Allied outposts in the vicinity, which might not be a bad move. What I don't understand is why Mexico hasn't been called into the fray yet?
This comes out later, as I wondered about the same thing. It was not that they weren't being called ... they just weren't responding to the calls!
Erich von Manstein defending British Malaya against the Japanese is not something you see every day!
Indeed not. And there are some even stranger such examples later!
Western China seems to be proving difficult. The Allied gains in July seemed promising, but now they've mostly been rolled back... and we're not used to seeing Polish divisions being driven to breaking point either! :(
Yes, supply attrition and constant MAB human wave attacks eventually take their toll. It then becomes a matter of rotating units to the rear for resupply and recovery. Same in Indochina later, too.

To All: the December play session ended up being a bit of a blockbuster, so it will be presented in two parts, the first of which will be up shortly.
 
  • 1Like
  • 1
Reactions:
Chapter Forty-Six: They Did WHAT!? (1-14 December 1944)
Chapter Forty-Six: They Did WHAT!?
(1-14 December 1944)


Ly2B7p.jpg

Posters for the wartime US Presidential Election of 1944. Roosevelt was attempting a comeback against Wendell Willkie, who had led the US into the war against the Allies

=======​

US Election – 7 November 1944

Unreported in the last chapter, the US had held its presidential election on (presumably) 7 November 1944 (the OTL date). In a result that surprised many, the American electorate punished President Willkie for dragging the US into war against the Allies, which the Czechs had joined just three days before.

2ATOyZ.jpg

[No announcement about this and didn’t check at the time, so I only discovered the change of President when I checked the US diplomacy page later in December, for reasons that become obvious below.]

However, the change in leadership had made no difference to the war, which continued as it had done before. Norway had then joined the Allies on 9 November, followed by Mexico on the 20th. Roosevelt had inherited a war that had spread to two fronts within two weeks of his election [of course, the HOI mechanic has him taking power immediately, rather than the long transitional period the US had in OTL]. Though Canada was by now in dire trouble.

=======​

Polish Air Force Report as at 30 November 1944

As the month of December 1944 started, the Polish Air Force presented a summary of its own deployed aircraft holdings (many were being kept in reserve stocks for now) and Allied air deployments in Asia.

hdiwCd.jpg

Both the Western China and Qinghai air zones had around 150 TAC bombers (including an RAF wing) conducting ground support missions, with mission efficiency high in Qinghai (generally closer to its targets) than in Western China, where some of the bombers were still operating from Urumqi. Japan provided air superiority for the MAB over Manchuria, when that zone was active, while France did so in South East Asia.

=======​

1-5 December 1944: Dark Days

On 1 December, the Allied Far East Command provided an intelligence estimate of relative naval strengths in the Asian Theatre. If these figures were to be believed, the MAB (primarily the Japanese Peoples Navy) held naval supremacy throughout the region.

QH1mHn.jpg

On land, the last border skirmishes in Manchuria were still tapering off after the ceasefire, with a couple of battles in progress in both Western China and Indochina.

At home in Poland, two new militia divisions were deployed into General Marian Kukiel’s 3rd Army, now stationed in north-east Poland. The new formations were sent to join them: the Polish High Command had decided the situation in Canada was too precarious for an intervention.

G6fWph.jpg

In Mexico, there was already a significant Allied presence. And to make a real difference there, it may be necessary for an entire Army to be sent: a risk Poland was not willing to take with the Soviet threat still extant.

In Asia, the main battle during the first few days of December was resolved in the North Tonkin Coast, where the Allies successfully repelled another strong MAB attack on the morning of 2 December (Allies 640, MAB 1,730 killed).

In Western Canada, the Allies no longer held a port on the continental West Coast and the one corridor to the coast there was precariously held, given the number of divisions stuck inland from it. This presented a significant vulnerability for encirclement and surrender.

Js1I2E.jpg

The US invasion of Newfoundland continued, with another American division joining in. But the Allies in this case were still holding on strongly.

ggP3uy.jpg

But in eastern Canada the situation had deteriorated. The American landing north-west of Halifax, where they had captured a port, was being reinforced and now contained an entire corps of US Army divisions.

70tzm7.jpg

Speaking of Halifax, it was now the new provisional capital of Canada – which meant that Montréal had finally fallen to the enemy. And by 3 December, the long-feared Canadian capitulation occurred.

a9Hkbe.jpg

This left the remaining Allied combatants even more isolated in pockets in western, central and eastern Canada, where a provisional administration still operated out of Halifax, though with no Canadian troops left in the field.

In the north-east, by the evening of the 4th three distinct pockets had formed. The largest was west of Quebec, where 19 Allied divisions were trapped, with no port access as Quebec had been lost on the capitulation (though not yet garrisoned by the US).

k5unYb.jpg

Another 14 divisions were trapped along the St Lawrence and to the south-east, again now without any port access. Finally, there were currently just three divisions defending the Halifax area, which had been cut off from the rest by an American lodgement on the isthmus connecting the new Free Canadian capital from the rest.

In the west of Canada, by early on the 5th 26 divisions were now trapped, with a couple more off shore in Victoria, which had a port to service it. Finally, 18 more Allied division were encircled in the centre, unsupplied and under attacks which they were losing.

xbBfm0.jpg

In total, up to 77 remaining Allied divisions were in danger of destruction in the mess that the Canadian Expedition had become.

A small piece of good news came later that morning, with the defeat of the American invasion of Newfoundland. Over in Western China, a decreased number of smaller battles had been fought. The South Africans had held East Jiuquan after the Poles had been forced to retreat at the end of November. A they now headed back to the rear for much needed resupply and reinforcement, the mainly recovered 18 DP was sent up to help their comrades.

E4qW3q.jpg

In Guyana, the French were trying to retake Paramaribo, but the cross-river assault was not going well and would ultimately fail.

JnTWmZ.jpg


=======​

6-11 December 1944: Pandemonium

A little over two days after the Canadian surrender, the situation in Mexico was largely quiet. The heavy concentration of Allied forces in the north-west seemed unwilling to attack the consistent but relatively thin US lines in front of them. Just one battle was in progress, a US attempt to cross the Rio Grande in the centre.

HHAQiI.jpg

In Asia, the last week had seen very few battles resolved involving Polish troops. After a couple of small defensive battles were won in Gannan on the 2nd, the only other battle results had been on the North Tonkin Coast, where the Allies had repulsed four MAB assaults from 2-6 December in which a total 990 Allied and about 4,650 MAB troops had fallen.

On 8 December, General Manteuffel was trying to execute a breakout along the St Lawrence from the Quebec pocket after the Allies had failed to secure the port of Québec before the Americans had occupied it.

XkoBgR.jpg

Another two attacks had been defeated in Tonkin in the last couple of days, now the only action involving Polish troops in Asia for over a week. The MAB were certainly determined to take it!

zhYAzv.jpg

By the afternoon of 9 December, Manteuffel’s breakout had failed and the US had reached the south bank of the St Lawrence, creating another smaller pocket to its west, where the Belgian defenders were about to be defeated, further isolating the Québec Pocket from possible relief or escape.

s1QElH.jpg

The situation in western and central Canada was not greatly changed: hanging on in slowly deepening desperation, without any mainland port to enable resupply.

ut1Cct.jpg

The Mexican Front was becoming more active now, with more Allied attacks, those in the far south-east of the line showing the most promise.

WwHAGe.jpg

The creeping doom in eastern Canada continued on 10 December, made worse by the build-up of even more forces in the US lodgement in the rear of the forces that had been defending the St Lawrence so stoically over the last few months.

olytjP.jpg

In the west, by the 11th the last Allied coastal foothold had just been lost and, though a counter-attack was being launched, its prospects were not good.

R7BE0U.jpg

But this news was vastly overshadowed by frantic reports emanating from Mexico. Fighting had broken out everywhere between the Allies in country and Mexican forces suddenly batting for the other side!

TXYxJH.jpg

No real details were available on how this had happened or why a supposedly democratic-led government had overthrown another and then joined the MAB, but a coup had overthrown the Mexican Republic and created the United States of Mexico! A new political faction (!?) of the PAN led by Álvaro Cervantes had taken over, reinstating elections and taking Mexico back into the MAB.

UdndFK.jpg

They had also granted the non-factional US military access, while now pockets controlled by various Allied expeditionary forces from Germany, the UK, Yugoslavia and Belgium had formed across the country.

7odMue.jpg

The US and newly installed United States of Mexico government signed a military access agreement in Washington D.C. immediately upon the execution of the coup on 11 December 1944. Even though the UMS were formally aligned with the MAB, there must have been some degree of collusion beforehand with the UMS delegation already in the US capital and for access to have been granted so quickly.

In the south, significant groups of Allied forces had already started fighting the Mexican renegades. The Germans retained control of two larger pockets on the north-west and south-east of the border with the US.

SZWmMp.jpg

But the overall result was chaos and the collapse of an effective southern front, even as their comrades marooned in Canada fought a life and death struggle against all odds. In the most important theatre of the war, within a week the entire Allied position had imploded, while the deadlock in Asia dragged on.

In the Foreign Ministry in Warsaw, when the Minister Beck heard of this catastrophic news of Mexican perfidy, he simply exclaimed: “They did what!?” He asked for some insight into how this may have happened, but little was found.

Back at the end of November, the Mexican Republic under Miguel Cervantes had seemed in complete control. Elections had been abolished and his administration was attempting to suppress resistance during the ongoing but dormant civil war against Plutarco E. Calles’ PNR, who had earlier seen Mexico on the side of the Communists before they had been ousted with Allied help, bringing Mexico into the Allied faction and most recently into the war against the US.

RUaig4.jpg

The only clue was maybe the low stability of Miguel Cervantes’ regime, perhaps exacerbated by their recent reluctant entry into the war against the US, maybe made worse by the recent collapse of Canada. Whatever the cause and mechanics of this new Mexican Revolution, the Allies now had to deal with its consequences.

=======​

11-14 December 1944: Quiet Desperation

Elsewhere, there was confusion caused where deployed Mexican expeditionary contingents ‘turned traitor’ and either fighting broke out with co-located Allied divisions or they seized ground where they were unopposed in far off territory.

Crucially, this delivered the MAB a gift in the North Tonkin Coast, a focal point of MAB efforts all month so far. A locally based Mexican division went rogue right in the middle of the latest MAB attack. In confused fighting and reporting, a large defensive battle was supposedly lost early on the 11th, though by that night the Allied (mainly Polish) defenders were still fighting on against an attack by 6 PLA divisions attacking from the west and north.

DRzrm2.jpg

In southern Indochina, an intra-provincial battle was under way to eliminate two more rogue Mexican divisions trying to take the port there.

AvfVQr.jpg

Meanwhile, up in the north 18 DP had arrived to reinforce the South African defence of East Jiuquan, a battle the Allies would win the following day.

b9wfm1.jpg

And a poorly-planned British invasion attempt on Wake Island using Nationalist Chinese troops was in the process of being defeated by a far stronger US garrison.

wSIiQz.jpg

A day after the coup in Mexico, the UMS was already in some trouble after the remaining Allied forces there had occupied a third of their key cities.

o4SeOH.jpg

Two more Allied attempts to retake the North Tonkin Coast after its occupation by the MAB would be fought out over coming days, both ultimately failing by the 17th, with heavy Allied and even heavier MAB casualties.

IQfubu.jpg

The St Lawrence Pocket had been further isolated by midday on the 14th as Allied formations were forced to retreat from its peripheries. The US Army was now on the outskirts of Halifax and attacking, though so far the defence was holding there, where they at least had access to supplies.

av2zUc.jpg

The Québec Pocket was also being squeezed further shut.

jZF1hO.jpg

In western Canada, the attempt to re-establish contact with the Pacific Coast had failed, but a thin line of communications had been restored with the troops in the centre, stretching across to the western shore of Hudson Bay.

vxqYkV.jpg

So stood the situation as the first two eventful and – for the Allies – disastrous weeks of December 1944 ended. A month that had begun with some hope had gone downhill ever since. At least the Poles were happy they had not committed troops to either of the hot messes that had eventuated in Canada and Mexico.
 
Last edited:
  • 3Like
  • 3Love
Reactions:
Well done US, they've essentially won their war now. Pretty much all over with everyone committed to China already.
 
  • 2
Reactions:
Honestly I think the war in general is just lost now - the US actually has the army and navy needed to invade Europe, just needs to island hop until it reaches Britain.

Pretty much I think. Mexico would have fallen anyway, but it might have bought enough time to finish or stalemate China.

Now? The US is free to just straight invade the UK. And if they go, everyone else goes.
 
  • 1Like
  • 1
Reactions:
Every time I think the story of this AAR has stabilized, the ai throws a curveball that just proves me wrong. If I had thought to make a bingo card for likely events in this story, ‘Mexico executes Order 66’ would most likely never have been on there.
 
  • 2
Reactions:
What a mess.
 
  • 3
Reactions:
Well done US, they've essentially won their war now. Pretty much all over with everyone committed to China already.
I think the Allies had more committed in Canada and Mexico by far compared to Asia, but now look likely to lose more than half of them outright soon, with the others in jeopardy. Which is even worse! It does look difficult now, though I have no idea how effective an American campaign against a fully united Europe (with French and German backing, plus Poland and the other Allied powers) is likely to be - nor how the naval war is really going.
Honestly I think the war in general is just lost now - the US actually has the army and navy needed to invade Europe, just needs to island hop until it reaches Britain.
Could be, but I don't know HOI4 well enough to have a gut feel about it myself. And per above, not sure how much help the other Allies will be, if any: they do still have a lot of forces back in Europe.
Pretty much I think. Mexico would have fallen anyway, but it might have bought enough time to finish or stalemate China.

Now? The US is free to just straight invade the UK. And if they go, everyone else goes.
As above - will see I guess. Mainly up to the rival AIs, with whatever Polish assistance might be provided. Which is kinda fun and evens out the AI disadvantages a fair bit.
Trotsky to the Allies! FDR join allies on a Mexican shuffle? Thanks
:D If only! Not going to happen though either wat, is it, with the way factions play in HOI?
Every time I think the story of this AAR has stabilized, the ai throws a curveball that just proves me wrong. If I had thought to make a bingo card for likely events in this story, ‘Mexico executes Order 66’ would most likely never have been on there.
Yes, at least it has spiced things up again! We just need Trotsky chiming in to make it a truly global war. I like the 'Order 66' reference. I keep replaying the scenes in my mind's eye. :D
What a mess.
Agreed! Which makes it more fun at least.
 
Last edited:
  • 1
  • 1Like
Reactions:
Chapter Forty-Seven: Tequila Sunset (15-31 December 1944)
Chapter Forty-Seven: Tequila Sunset
(15-31 December 1944)


=======​

15-20 December: Mexican Chaos

The situation in Mexico was starting to resolve somewhat by 15 December, four days after the chaotic Mexican betrayal of the Allies. The main Allied pockets in the north were an the east and west of the border with the US and run by the Germans. Other smaller pockets in the hinterland remained isolated and vulnerable to Mexican and US encirclement and destruction.

1xkAUZ.jpg

In the south, by the evening of the 16th the main British-controlled enclave was centred on Mexico City and controlled the main rail line and key towns between Guadalajara in the west and Puebla in the east. Another adjacent pocket based on the Gulf port of Veracruz contained a concentration of 13 assorted Allied divisions, where a number of them were attacking a UMS division to the south-east which separated them from the next British pocket at Villahermosa.

79IRpM.jpg

In the west, the Yugoslavs controlled Puerto Vallarta, splitting Mexico into northern and southern halves.

Over in southern Indochina, the Mexican holdouts had been defeated and surrendered. Most of the Allied forces there had since taken ship. They were bound for other spots in the region where ‘Montezuma’s Revenge’ had struck.

One of these was in northern Malaya, where a small renegade Mexican formation (more brigade-strength) had occupied Khota Bahru and by early on 18 December was (unsuccessfully) attacking a French division to its south.

YCOwBu.jpg

Other Allied troops were headed to the island of Flores in the Dutch East Indies, running the gauntlet of Japanese sub packs to help dislodge an unknown number of Mexican troops who had apparently taken over its port when ‘Order 66’ had been executed a week before.

PJHRNy.jpg

There was better news from Sulawesi, where the Allies had swung back onto the offensive again, though it looked like their momentum may be once again winding down.

8dNbEz.jpg

By the end of 19 December, the French had retaken Khota Bahru and the Mexican 4a Brigada was isolated on the coast to its east.

In Western China, only one battle was in progress at Lanzhou on the morning of 20 December, otherwise things had become somewhat quieter, with no major battles involving Polish troops being recorded in the last week.

917itC.jpg

The last five days had not been kind to the Allies in eastern Canada, where the two remaining Quebec and St Lawrence pockets were being systematically compressed by the Americans. A number of position had been lost in the last day or so, with divisions retreating to the last redoubts in either one.

B9uAoo.jpg

The Allies were still in supply and holding in Halifax, where the exiled Canadian government had relocated. The American attack on it had been beaten off, but a counter-attack was bogging down.

QO5lEo.jpg


=======​

22-25 December: A Game of Enclaves

The largest battle involving the Poles in the last week had been on the Tonkin Coast once again, where a major MAB attack had been heavily repulsed by the morning of the 22nd.

HZc5T1.jpg

Using a view that delineated forces and held territory by faction instead of country, the situation in northern Mexico seemed to be deteriorating a little for the Allies in the north-west corner, with the mainly German and Belgian formations there being pressed in by the Americans. However, the Allied position in the north-east seemed to have improved somewhat. Other pockets in between remained isolated but not yet collapsing.

zH21yt.jpg

In southern Mexico, the Allies were expanding their holdings steadily with strong attacks on the remaining UMS positions in the south progressing well.

Jdg2pW.jpg

But ground had been lost in the jungles of French Guyana, where the US had forged across the river defences south of Cayenne, where the Allies were trying to counter-attack.

sOZJ0O.jpg

In eastern Canada, the Québec Pocket had been virtually eliminated, with the last three retreating Allied divisions doomed to surrender as their last stronghold fell by the early afternoon of 22 December.

Ri6C16.jpg

The remnants of the St. Lawrence Pocket were not much better off, where the last five trapped Allied divisions had almost reached the end of their endurance.

Halifax was the last holdout, where the Allied counter-attack was still making little progress but reinforcements seemed about to make port.

X8esqW.jpg

Things were also grim in the centre and west of Canada, where the Allied formations on the Hudson Bay were once again cut off. It looked like many tens of thousands of isolated Allied soldiers were doomed to death or captivity there and further to their west.

7SMo9r.jpg

Two days later, the German-run enclave based on San Diego and Tijuana remained under heavy American pressure, but seemed to be holding fairly strongly for now as it was attacked from three directions.

FzgeUs.jpg

The other enclaves in the central north remained isolated and unsupplied, but not under immediate threat; German troops controlled the provisional UMS capital of Juarez.

kDSzTF.jpg

On Christmas Day 1944, the Americans had closed in on British Labrador, which remained lightly defended for now.

nGtyTX.jpg


=======​

26-31 December: Swinging Fortunes

Early the next day, the chaotic and short-lived United States of Mexico collapsed barely two weeks after the disastrous coup of 11 December. There was no new replacement government, with German, British and Belgian zones being secured while the last remnants of the failed UMS were mopped up and the US probed Allied positions in the north.

sPb9aX.jpg

But the damage had been done and the long-term viability of the Allied position in Mexico was far from certain. Especially once the US had completed their own mopping in Canada.

The transfer of notional control over all Mexican territory not occupied by US forces in the north suddenly opened lines of communication between Allied pockets again, with hope supply lines would follow. But large gaps remained in the Allied position, while the US salient were either daggers aimed at the heart of the Allied lines or exposed to isolation and pocketing themselves.

ppOUbI.jpg

The Allies had many divisions in southern Mexico, where five UMS holdout divisions had set up a provisional government in Tuxla Gutiérrez. It would not last long.

tdwMiI.jpg

The Polish heavy fighter programme was finally completed on 27 December, with an extended range version of the new PZL.65 Lis being developed and production begun of Poland’s first long range fighter, which would hopefully one day become the escorts for their tactical bomber fleet.

7EJBQU.jpg

Research was also completed on improved rubber processing and switched to the next AA model. On the aircraft front, the decision was taken to start developing Polish experimental rocket technology, with the principal purpose of developing new models of jet-powered aircraft.

The ever-inventive Japanese opened a new amphibious assault on the north coast of New Guinea on 27 December. The British garrison defending the port were holding well in the initial attack.

n2fWz2.jpg

Things continued in fairly familiar patterns for the next few days around the world. By early on the 30th the American attack on Labrador had begun as Allied forces allow built up there, in one case launching an unsuccessful counter-attack – as temperatures and snow fell.

vMBDRH.jpg

While the Japanese assault in New Guinea had been defeated by the night of the 31st, the two divisions nonetheless managed to deploy into the jungle either side of their target, with out a supply source but otherwise intact, the British defenders exposed. And another Japanese landing had been made in West Papua.

ky1DkS.jpg

At least the Allies had secured northern Malaya and Flores by then, but it was not clear whether they would be sent over to deal with the Japanese landings in Papua and New Guinea.

=======​

Theatre Summaries

In Asia, as 1944 came to an end fighting had picked up again along the still deadlocked Western China front and also on the narrow Indochina front.

PO49Ns.jpg

The Allies persisted in their difficult attack in Sulawesi, with both attackers and defenders approaching exhaustion and none of them in good supply.

oSxNgz.jpg

The Allies had re-established control over much of Mexico but fighting continued in the south and one US attack in the north.

6lXFCy.jpg

In northern Mexico, the situation was still fluid, though the Allies seemed to be re-establishing their lines as supply began to seep through to previously isolated formations.

n1nEKb.jpg

The remaining Mexican units in the south had been split into two pockets, with Tuxla Gutiérrez occupied by the British.

mE2ABr.jpg

The Allied counter-attack south of Cayenne in Guyana had failed, with both sides, in roughly even numbers, eyeing each other off.

DXOQwe.jpg

Halifax held on, having been recently reinforced.

GRRPNK.jpg

Fighting still continued in central and western Canada, where the situation remained similar to that of recent days and the cut-off Allied divisions hung on grimly.

1wOXfV.jpg

Poland’s 3rd Army had redeployed to northern Poland, in two reserve groups, one in Wilno designed to reinforce a possible attack or intervention in Belarus, the other further back in Grodno, ready to reinforce any Allies attacked in the Baltic Republics or to reinforce a possible eastern push.

iINFDi.jpg

In the south, where the main strength of the USR’s western armies was deployed, the front line was being screened while mainly mechanised reserve forces were ready to respond to attacks. Further reinforcements for that sector may also be called on.

uRZv07.jpg

There was no appetite for sending any further expeditionary forces either to the east, or to America.
 
  • 4Like
  • 3Love
Reactions:
Some good some bad. A lot would be different if you didn't have to worry about the Soviets.
 
  • 4
Reactions:
Chapter 45 Feedback:
Then, as a bolt from the blue, came the announcement late on 20 November 1944: the newly admitted Czech, of all people, had now induced Mexico to join the war on the side of the Allies!
Great job from the Czechs for proving themselves immediately! Although, as others have said, it may already be too late for Canada.
While in Sulawesi, the Germans had destroyed the Japanese beachhead and restored the supply lines for the troops still advancing in the west of the peninsula, where good ground had been gained during the month. The Japanese invasion of the Bismarck Island had been repelled as well.
Also, it looks like the war in Sulawesi may finally be concluded.
Is HoI like a CK Holy War where the defender says go home for I am now your religion?
Not really, I believe. Once you're in a faction, you generally stay in it, no matter what your politics (so Canada and France stayed in the Allies even after going Communist).
Generally, war is a winner take all affair. There is a white peace function, but the AI almost never accepts it. And there are a few scripted peace deals (like winning against Japan as China, or Italy as Ethiopia) that force a limited peace. But this is usually not an option.

And I think you can only leave a faction if you are at peace. Which is why France/Canada haven't left yet. Canada could also still be a puppet of the UK, which means they can't leave their overlord's faction.
---
Chapter 46 Feedback:
Unreported in the last chapter, the US had held its presidential election on (presumably) 7 November 1944 (the OTL date). In a result that surprised many, the American electorate punished President Willkie for dragging the US into war against the Allies, which the Czechs had joined just three days before.
Interesting. I don't think this does anything to help the Allied cause, but it does add to the feeling of ahistorical chaos.
Speaking of Halifax, it was now the new provisional capital of Canada – which meant that Montréal had finally fallen to the enemy. And by 3 December, the long-feared Canadian capitulation occurred.
Really bad. At least Mexico still holds...right...right?
In the Foreign Ministry in Warsaw, when the Minister Beck heard of this catastrophic news of Mexican perfidy, he simply exclaimed: “They did what!?” He asked for some insight into how this may have happened, but little was found.
A pretty understandable reaction given the circumstances.
The only clue was maybe the low stability of Miguel Cervantes’ regime, perhaps exacerbated by their recent reluctant entry into the war against the US, maybe made worse by the recent collapse of Canada. Whatever the cause and mechanics of this new Mexican Revolution, the Allies now had to deal with its consequences.
Part of the mechanics for Mexico is that if your stability is too low, then a civil war can erupt. So Mexico entering the war might've tipped them over the necessary threshold.
---
Chapter 47 Feedback:
There was better news from Sulawesi, where the Allies had swung back onto the offensive again, though it looked like their momentum may be once again winding down.
Dang. Really looked like something might be happening there.
There was no new replacement government, with German, British and Belgian zones being secured
A justified decision given how uncooperative Mexico was to help in the first place and then they collapsed immediately after joining.
The British garrison defending the port were holding well in the initial attack.
I have no idea who Tyrone Venetiann is, but I like his name and portrait :D.

The war overall is not looking good. Though is probably still salvageable unless a certain bear joins the fight.
.
 
  • 1
  • 1Like
Reactions:
September/October:

But it turned out the subs had acted as scouts for a massive carrier task group that struck the convoy later that day. By the evening of the 5th, ten of the British destroyers had joined 3 transports at the bottom of the ocean.

Not good. Unfortunately the RN has to carry the naval war against both the IJN and the USN. We probably can't rely on the Allies winning control of the sea lanes in this scenario, so the question may be whether the RN can manage to stay in the fight?

Of some interest, it was noted at this time that the Canadian government, like that of France, had turned to Communism! Even as the country inched towards capitulation.

Ah, this does perhaps explain Willkie's intervention...

Around this time, it was also noticed that the quite large number of Mexican expeditionary troops that were serving in Indochina were disengaging from the front line and heading to the ports in the south. This was beginning to thin the Allied lines and impair their momentum, just as the Chinese and Japanese Communists were reinforcing their line at the narrowest neck of Indochina.

In the circumstances, I can't argue with the Mexicans wanting to withdraw their troops from Asia.

Things were deteriorating slowly but steadily in Canada, as the American’s managed to divide it in two by reaching Hudson Bay on the coast of Northern Ontario at midday on the 7th.

Then black news arrived on the night of 11 September, when it was confirmed that the Canadian capital of Ottawa, on the front line on the ‘wrong side’ of the main Allied river defensive line in the North-West Sector, had fallen.

The Allies generally appear to have the Americans outnumbered but it's the Americans who are making the running. Logistics in Canada, especially in the west, seem to be hampering the Allied cause.

The British still persisted with their monthly call to Manchuria for another border clash, which lasted from 19 to 21 September, with the usual non-result.

One day Manchuria may surprise everyone by NOT negotiating a ceasefire...

The long-standing campaign in Belarus had seen the pro-Polish BSA narrowly overtake the Communists as the most popular party. And Belarus remained a Soviet puppet state. But some in the Foreign Ministry wondered if a coup might be possible and, if it was successful, whether this would serve to prise Belarus out of the Soviet grip, or their puppet status and membership of the 4th International would remain unchanged.

Interesting, but it might not be advisible to provoke Trotsky?

Behind the front in China, Polish logisticians decided that a linking rail line from Jiuquan all the way south-east to northern Golog may assist with the movement of men and supplies between the two sectors. Major works were queued to construct it and the supply hub in Ganzi was slowly built.

The Chinese front definitely needs more Polish logistics expertise! :)

At this point, with Mexico still not in the war, Poland decided to call them into the war as Canada faced dire peril.

Frustrated with Mexico’s unwillingness to join the war against America while Canada slowly succumbed, the Polish Foreign Ministry investigated further. The Mexicans had a pretty reasonably concern about the great danger posed by their northern neighbour, despite the many thousands of Allied troops that had arrived to reinforce their border.

It looks to me that opening a second front against the US is just what the Allies need. It's not as though there's a shortage of troops on the Mexican side of the border (although the supply situation may be questionable) and it is probably in Mexico's own interest to intervene now - or risk Canada falling! :eek:

The months of expensive human wave attacks did see the MAB casualty rate beginning to catch up with that of the Allies, inflated by their early losses when China first fell.

The MAB doesn't seem to care about the human cost of these incessant attacks - perhaps they reckon their manpower is inexhaustible?

Some Polish advisers were starting to wonder whether sending over a largely mechanised expeditionary force may be of benefit, though the risks to the troops there and of depleting the defence against a possible Soviet attack also had to be considered.

Well, keeping the homeland secure is always important, but I am going to suggest pulling out of China and throwing in Poland's lot in the defence of Canada instead. What happens in China is of secondary importance compared to the risk of the Americans first dominating North America and then projecting their power against Europe.
 
  • 2Like
  • 1
Reactions:
Some good some bad. A lot would be different if you didn't have to worry about the Soviets.
True. Mind you, the Allies have always thrown plenty of troops at most of the other theatres. I think it's not so much numbers as player-directed intervention that has led to some of the dubious results they have got in Asia and now North America. Still, it makes it a more even match when its mostly AI v AI.
Chapter 45 Feedback:
Great job from the Czechs for proving themselves immediately! Although, as others have said, it may already be too late for Canada.
Good point on both counts. Even more so when we see what happens next! :eek:
Also, it looks like the war in Sulawesi may finally be concluded.
One might hope so. But remember, chaos is this AAR's middle name. :D
Generally, war is a winner take all affair. There is a white peace function, but the AI almost never accepts it. And there are a few scripted peace deals (like winning against Japan as China, or Italy as Ethiopia) that force a limited peace. But this is usually not an option.

And I think you can only leave a faction if you are at peace. Which is why France/Canada haven't left yet. Canada could also still be a puppet of the UK, which means they can't leave their overlord's faction.
That's my impression - from someone whose played only 2 or 3 HOI4 games over as many years! o_O
Chapter 46 Feedback:
Interesting. I don't think this does anything to help the Allied cause, but it does add to the feeling of ahistorical chaos.
Agreed on both counts. FDR now comes in to take charge when things have turned firmly in the US' favour.
Really bad. At least Mexico still holds...right...right?
Yep, getting worse and worse, day by day.
A pretty understandable reaction given the circumstances.
:(
Part of the mechanics for Mexico is that if your stability is too low, then a civil war can erupt. So Mexico entering the war might've tipped them over the necessary threshold.
They had already been in civil war on and off for years. This latest stability drop must have triggered another revolution, perhaps?
Chapter 47 Feedback:
Dang. Really looked like something might be happening there.
Oh, something is indeed happening there...
A justified decision given how uncooperative Mexico was to help in the first place and then they collapsed immediately after joining.
The Allies will likely try pouring troops in, but that didn't work so well in Canada (where I had thought it might have worked, but clearly not).
I have no idea who Tyrone Venetiann is, but I like his name and portrait :D.

The war overall is not looking good. Though is probably still salvageable unless a certain bear joins the fight.
Yes, I don't think I found anything in a quick google search, iirc. And no, the war seems to be getting worse and worse, even though the Allies can still field many more troops than their respective adversaries in overall terms. They just can't seem to be able to apply them properly. Maybe though, the US might have some equivalent problems if they do try a cross-Atlantic sortie against, essentially, the EU?

Unless Trotsky comes in on the side of the MAB, of course, in which case 'conflagration' may be to soft a description!
 
  • 2
Reactions:
Replying separately, to avoid feedback spoilers:
September/October:
Not good. Unfortunately the RN has to carry the naval war against both the IJN and the USN. We probably can't rely on the Allies winning control of the sea lanes in this scenario, so the question may be whether the RN can manage to stay in the fight?
Certainly not around the Northern US shoreline, though the cross-Atlantic convoy route seems generally untroubled for now.
Ah, this does perhaps explain Willkie's intervention...
Maybe! Narrative-wise, anyway. I suspect in game mechanics the Canadians are just collateral damage. They are Communist and many speak French, after all.
In the circumstances, I can't argue with the Mexicans wanting to withdraw their troops from Asia.
Yes. We will get a better view of their intentions a bit later ...
The Allies generally appear to have the Americans outnumbered but it's the Americans who are making the running. Logistics in Canada, especially in the west, seem to be hampering the Allied cause.
Yes, this had surprised me a little. I'd thought with all those European troops coming in and the US still having to garrison the Mexican border, that the Allies would have done better than they had to this point. :(
One day Manchuria may surprise everyone by NOT negotiating a ceasefire...
:p I suspect the cycle is stuck on rinse, pause, repeat!
Interesting, but it might not be advisible to provoke Trotsky?
Could well be. My thought is to leave it until maybe thins are desperate and/or Trotsky decides to intervene anyway? Or would a coup after a war starts and Belarus joins be useless (in terms of flipping them from the 4th International)?
The Chinese front definitely needs more Polish logistics expertise! :)
We keep trying, and without it the front may well have collapsed before now. But there are just so many of them ...
It looks to me that opening a second front against the US is just what the Allies need. It's not as though there's a shortage of troops on the Mexican side of the border (although the supply situation may be questionable) and it is probably in Mexico's own interest to intervene now - or risk Canada falling! :eek:
Yes, these were the calculations. You will be very interested to see how that all pans out ... ;)
The MAB doesn't seem to care about the human cost of these incessant attacks - perhaps they reckon their manpower is inexhaustible?
Exactly. And their on or near their home turf, which I guess should be assisting them.
Well, keeping the homeland secure is always important, but I am going to suggest pulling out of China and throwing in Poland's lot in the defence of Canada instead. What happens in China is of secondary importance compared to the risk of the Americans first dominating North America and then projecting their power against Europe.
You will see what Poland decides, as November and December have been played through and written up.
 
  • 2
  • 1Like
Reactions:
Well that was overall quite grim, disappointed in Canada buckling like that while merely sighing in Mexico. Different expectation I suppose.

The one plus is that with Mexico now under Allied occupation it might be a more stable base to build from, though as has been noted things are probably a bit too late as the US will likely have got iself organised by now particularly as it is free from the demonic dead hand of WW.
 
  • 3
  • 1Like
Reactions:
Well that was overall quite grim, disappointed in Canada buckling like that while merely sighing in Mexico. Different expectation I suppose.

The one plus is that with Mexico now under Allied occupation it might be a more stable base to build from, though as has been noted things are probably a bit too late as the US will likely have got iself organised by now particularly as it is free from the demonic dead hand of WW.

Yes, everyone should read Imperial Cheese to see how it's REALLY done in North America.

Edit:

Ah, 2 people read that AAR and get the joke.

For everyone else, this sort of war happens all the time in HOI4.

So much so that it canoncially already happened twice in Tomorrow belongs to me, before the HOI4 portion has even starred!
 
Last edited:
  • 2Haha
  • 1Like
Reactions:
Well that was overall quite grim, disappointed in Canada buckling like that while merely sighing in Mexico. Different expectation I suppose.
It certainly was. I had expected somewhat better of both too, especially since the EU was shipping dozens of divisions to both fronts, even if the Mexican one proved so hard to make active. Then imploded spectacularly soon after.
The one plus is that with Mexico now under Allied occupation it might be a more stable base to build from, though as has been noted things are probably a bit too late as the US will likely have got iself organised by now particularly as it is free from the demonic dead hand of WW.
Yes, the Allies should be able to consolidate somewhat, one would think, and various pockets in Canada fight on, in some cases with some strength yet, but you'd have to think their shelf life is limited. Given the performance in Canada, one would be pessimistic about Mexico, though at least it is a narrower front that may be less prone to one side or the other swarming through gaps, as has happened in the north.

From the demonic hand of WW to the very nearly dead one of FDR! He's not exactly taking on a third term in the peak of health!
Yes, everyone should read Imperial Cheese to see how it's REALLY done in North America.
:D
Edit:

Ah, 2 people read that AAR and get the joke.

For everyone else, this sort of war happens all the time in HOI4.

So much so that it canoncially already happened twice in Tomorrow belongs to me, before the HOI4 portion has even starred!
I'm privileged to have had my own zany North American adventure in this, my first serious game of HOI4! A small sample, but it seems to bear out the hypothesis.

To All: a short 'bonus material' chapter follows on the dispositions of the Royal Navy as 1945 begins. A few of us have been wondering, so the Poles submitted a request for a detailed briefing. ;)
 
  • 2
Reactions: