• We have updated our Community Code of Conduct. Please read through the new rules for the forum that are an integral part of Paradox Interactive’s User Agreement.
This remained a moot point.
I like this as both meanings of moot point apply. There is still a debate about whether the position in Europe can be turned around in 1946 so that meaning woks. But given the Allies are losing everywhere else (and the AI is determined to throw away it's troops in doomed amphibious landings it doesn't support) eventually the enemy will be able to bring their overwhelming superiority into play, so it is all a bit irrelevant as per the other meaning of moot point.

A small literary bright point amongst the usual looming doom.
 
  • 3Like
Reactions:
Poland has something approaching its entire eligible male population in service, in reserve, dead or wounded.
 
  • 2Like
Reactions:
A closer look at northern Mexico showed how far both sides had reduced their numbers in recent days.
It's strange this front is so thin. The Allied divisions are probably all in transport, but the Americans should be close by.
The inevitable happened after midnight: Iranian capitulation.
At least the threat of their capitulation is over. And if you retake the empty province connected to Pakistan, the Allies should be in a better position. The Poles should still pull out though and get ready for the Russian offensive.
While the main line in Western China was generally holding, Tibet looked to be in trouble and the southern pocket was under attack from three sides.
It might be a good idea to pull back to Northern India. Tibet and China are both going to fall, but you can at least keep the Himalayas open for an Allied retreat.
AA production, bringing that to eight but with efficiency that was still below 50%.
How fast is the efficiency increasing by?
 
  • 2Like
  • 1
Reactions:
Moscow's most vocal complainer would be rendered mute this month. Thanks
I think the traditional method for rendering complainers mute in Moscow (whether it was Stalin or Trotsky) was a Makarov 9mm behind he ear! o_O Tough times for the Allies, anyway. Though hope not yet abandoned.
I like this as both meanings of moot point apply. There is still a debate about whether the position in Europe can be turned around in 1946 so that meaning woks. But given the Allies are losing everywhere else (and the AI is determined to throw away it's troops in doomed amphibious landings it doesn't support) eventually the enemy will be able to bring their overwhelming superiority into play, so it is all a bit irrelevant as per the other meaning of moot point.

A small literary bright point amongst the usual looming doom.
Glad you found a silver lining there! :D We'll see if the comings days bring any more ... though that's unlikely to come from well-supported landings, methinks! :rolleyes:
Poland has something approaching its entire eligible male population in service, in reserve, dead or wounded.
In game terms I don't think it's quite that bad (though am no expert on this mechanic in HOI4). We still have a couple of levels of legislation to go before we start scraping the bottom of the barrel and there are currently more reserves waiting than we have men fielded in the Army.
It's strange this front is so thin. The Allied divisions are probably all in transport, but the Americans should be close by.
This the suspicion. Only a few have been spotted tootling around the Atlantic so far. Maybe some will wind up on the Canadian front some time soon, but other than AI silliness I'm not sure why the Allies aren't being monstered in Mexico. :confused:
At least the threat of their capitulation is over. And if you retake the empty province connected to Pakistan, the Allies should be in a better position. The Poles should still pull out though and get ready for the Russian offensive.
Yes, things didn't go as badly as they might have. I'm still a little torn about risking the quick collapse of the Iranian front by pulling everyone out too early. The distraction is good and it keeps them a long way away from the front that really matters - or using the freed troops to march on the Suez Canal. But we will be pulling back steadily I think. My outline concept will be to thin out, reinforce Iraq a bit, maybe leave the mountain divisions in Iran until the last minute and send about half of the 4th Army back to Europe to provide a battle-hardened reserve for the coming trials.
It might be a good idea to pull back to Northern India. Tibet and China are both going to fall, but you can at least keep the Himalayas open for an Allied retreat.
I have so little left around that end of the front I don't think they'd make that much difference, though maybe the mountain divisions might end up withdrawing that way eventually.
How fast is the efficiency increasing by?
As at 1 September, increasing by 0.345% per day.

Op6XDq.jpg


Thanks for the comments, the next monthly session is played through and the first half of the month will be up shortly: quite an interesting session, so again it merited two episodes I thought.
 
  • 1Like
  • 1
Reactions:
Chapter Eighty-two: A Change of Seasons (1 to 15 September 1946)
Chapter Eighty-two: A Change of Seasons
(1 to 15 September 1946)


=======​

North America

Mexico remained quiet for the first half of September 1946, as the leaves started to change colour in the northern hemisphere autumn. But in Canada, some of those troops that had left the Mexican front seemed to have finally reinforced the Canadian front, where the US was now making gradual progress.

kh2feB.jpg

A week later, a couple of US divisions had closed up to the Rio Grande and were attacking along the Gulf Coast. The Allies were holding strongly though there was a gap in the line to their north-west.

iP804m.jpg


=======​

The Black Sea and the Middle East

The big news at the start of the month was the declaration of war by the Soviets on Turkey on the morning of 1 September 1946. They must have become impatient with Turkey giving access and support for the Allies in recent weeks. This brought another 47 divisions and 1,600 aircraft into the field and extended the active front from the Black Sea to the Persian Gulf.

dwU06z.jpg


zmvtNv.jpg

Turkish troops launching an early attack over the Armenian border towards Yerevan, 1 September 1946.

In Crimea, the British were ashore in Yalta at midday on the 2nd while the Germans attacked Sevastopol from the sea.

eTMWRR.jpg

A day later the Allies were ashore in a number of places, but no ports had been taken and the lodgements were not strong.

CcJVd5.jpg

On the Georgia-Turkey front, the Turks had almost pushed across the Armenian border west of Yerevan.

4dJOER.jpg

The next day Turkish forces had pushed forward into Armenia and northern Kurdistan and were holding both strongly.

a1nIcP.jpg

There was more good news along the Tigris, where the British had evicted the Soviets from their bridgehead over the great river. 16 DP, which had been holding in reserve, went forward quickly to reinforce them, given the likelihood of a counter-attack.

GsJbbe.jpg

In Less favourable news, the ensuing days saw the poorly supported landings in Crimea largely been rolled up, while a heavy Soviet presence had assembled around the Kerch-Krasnodar beachhead, which also remained without port access and thus unsupplied.

WXSFww.jpg

Six days later, the expected Soviet counter-attack along the Tigris had been launched and the Allies were having difficulty holding despite the Polish reinforcements and General Haller taking over command.

MvWpFU.jpg

26 and 29 DPs were therefore shuffled north-west to see if they could help hold the key river line, given Basrah was now very strongly held by the Allies.

A day later the defenders had managed to turn the momentum around, even before 26 DP had arrived. But in Crimea and across the Kerch Strait, all Allied beachheads had been eliminated. That distraction had not been properly supported and had now failed.

On the Tigris, the arrival of 26 DP on 15 September decisively turned the battle in the Allies’ favour and victory would follow the following evening, resulting in heavy Soviet casualties. An separate attack on Baghdad was also in the process of being defeated.

2abQNX.jpg


=======​

Iran

The Poles took a more defensive posture in Iran in the first half of September, assisting the Allies with fighting a slow delaying defence that continued to occupy large amounts of Soviet troops and would see them forced to attack in difficult terrain against entrenched positions.

X0usbx.jpg

By 7 September, the front remained largely static as the rear areas were gradually brought back under control after the previous month’s Iranian capitulation. A screen of Polish units bolstered the Allied front lines while previously retreated divisions rebuilt or defended depth positions.

But the next day, things had begun to turn as Soviet pressure increased along the front. The one area the Poles had not helped garrison was being driven back in the centre near Fars and would soon fall. And in the east, south of Birjand, a strong Soviet attack was making headway against principally Polish defenders.

E19HIf.jpg

Somewhat belatedly, the depth divisions in the east, still not properly recovered, began spreading out into wider depth positions in response to these imminent Soviet advances.

Later on 8 September the battle turned for the worse in north-east Kerman, triggering withdrawals all across the line in the east. In north Kerman, a number of delaying attacks would have to be defeated over the next few days, starting on the morning of the 9th, before they could safely withdraw.

sU8dUm.jpg

In north-east Kerman, the Poles were unable to disengage until the evening of the 9th.

By 14 September, the Soviets had ground forward as the Poles fell back and tried to avoid getting cut off.

pOERVK.jpg


=======​

Asia-Pacific

From 1-3 September, three Soviet attacks on Yarkand were heavily defeated (total of 85 Allied and 4,700 Soviet casualties).

On Okinawa the Manchurian-Korean defence was holding up against the Japanese whose supplies were beginning to run down.

JoFZPq.jpg

The Japanese landings in New Guinea were now running roughshod over the Allied defences in bad news for the Australians, in particular.

hRtzPf.jpg

In Western China and Tibet, the Allied position was also deteriorating and the pocket now had only two divisions left fighting.

9bRFIR.jpg

After the Allies continued to easily brush off attacks on Yarkand, 22 DPG boarded the trains and headed towards the mountains of eastern Iran.

Wjwwuz.jpg

The Western China pocket had been eliminated and Lhasa captured by 15 September, leaving Tibet on the brink of capitulation.

MTw51m.jpg


=======​

The Eastern Front

Another big change from the month before was the ‘reactivation’ of the Eastern Front. In recent days, the Allies had pushed forward strongly from Estonia, taking Pskov by 2 September.

Ls7iAZ.jpg

But the main source of this burst of activity was somewhat unexpected: on 3 September a massive Czech-Yugoslav Autumn Offensive was launched all across the line. And initial progress was quite promising in many of these battles, though that was often the case early in attacks.

cx2Cg2.jpg

Three days later, while many of these battles had started to turn against the Allies, the offensive was still largely in progress – a higher rate of sustainment than most such operations in recent months. This was partly explained by the sheer number of Czech and Yugoslav divisions in Poland and Byelorussia. And in one place, the offensive would take ground south of Minsk by that evening.

fBjFJr.jpg

A day later, the offensive continued but seemed to be getting worn down in most places by the Soviet defenders.

ugy082.jpg

In Archangelsk, the situation had not really changed during the first week of September.

rM2KjG.jpg

By 8 September, the offensive was still going, despite the resistance, though the Soviets had attempted counter-attacks in a few locations.

zO7b0k.jpg

While in Crimea, as we saw above, the fighting was still in progress at that stage.

By the morning of 11 September, the offensive had largely ended in Byelorussia – but mainly because its first phase had been completed, making surprisingly wide gains.

swDLgX.jpg

And they were mainly being held. Salihorsk had been isolated with the attack making some progress. At this point Poland committed to assist the Czech-Yugoslav push in this specific case as it would help advance the line towards Mozyr, where the impending coup was going to be based.

Initially, one tank and one infantry division were committed to the assault at 0700hr on the 11th.

PniYug.jpg

But even with this assistance and Roman Abraham taking over command with improved tactics, the momentum had edged towards the defenders by the end of the day. With plenty of reserves on both sides however, the fight would not be over any time soon. The Poles resolved to ‘stay the course in Salihorsk’.

Three days later the fight for Salihorsk was still evenly balanced and the Allies had managed to take a sliver of land along the Romanian border. In most places, the Allies were trying to consolidate what they had gained earlier in the month.

sDNxTy.jpg

For the Poles, except at Salihorsk, they largely held back, not moving forward into the newly occupied territory in Byelorussia and defending in place if necessary where they were still on the front line. They were in most instances preserving their strength for their own coming offensive and relying on this current one to do a bit of softening up against the Soviets.

The grim battle in Salihorsk continued to ebb and flow, narrowly in one side’s favour and then the other. The fighting on 15 September was a case in point with more troops being thrown in at 1300hr to tip the fight in the Allies’ favour before things turned to the Soviets’ advantage eight hours later as divisions from both sides fell away from the combat. Abraham still had the tactical edge on his new opposing commander.

vEXhfF.jpg


bVyoJ4.jpg

“The Hell of Salihorsk”, a painting in the Polish National Gallery depicting the horrors of hand-to-hand fighting in ‘the cauldron’, which would continue well into the second half of September 1946.

=======​

Industry and Government

With rubber processing improved on 7 September (allowing a decrease in one trade to add a civilian factory back for construction), Poland sought to improve its night-fighting gear next, for all the hard combat that lay ahead.

QWf0pm.jpg

Another recommendation of the Jakowski Review related to the tweaking of a couple of military appointments within the government. Field Marshal Rydz-Śmigły would double up to serve as the chief military theorist (he was simply a bit better than the man he replaced).

olK8BS.jpg

Józef Zajac would take over as Chief of Air Force for a few months before the Winter Offensive to improve doctrine research, with Ludomił Rayski slotted to resume the appointment once air combat resumed.

On 14 September the new military factory was completed, being allocated to AA production (now 9 factories at 42.77% efficiency). At that time, 22 civilian factories were available for construction tasks, with the new factory in Lódz the top priority. This was followed by rail works for the Eastern Front, then repairs from combat damage (which should decrease somewhat now that the ‘C-Y Autumn Offensive’ had pushed the front line forward in many areas.

cW5mCP.jpg
 
Last edited:
  • 3Love
  • 1
Reactions:
A very disconcerting update, bits of it could almost be considered positive. Where is the unrelenting doom and misery one associates with Bullfilter AARs?

It is a good thing the Allied AIs are determined to waste troops in doomed amphibious invasions, or the entry of Turkey into the war could really have made a positive difference.
 
  • 3Haha
Reactions:
A very disconcerting update, bits of it could almost be considered positive. Where is the unrelenting doom and misery one associates with Bullfilter AARs?

It is a good thing the Allied AIs are determined to waste troops in doomed amphibious invasions, or the entry of Turkey into the war could really have made a positive difference.

The overall world state is still really depressing.
 
  • 2
  • 1Like
Reactions:
  • 2Haha
Reactions:
Oh I don’t know, it’s just the WW2 ones: ever heard a happy, merry carefree story about WW2, win or lose? ;)
 
  • 1Like
Reactions:
A closer look at northern Mexico showed how far both sides had reduced their numbers in recent days.

This is really confusing. If the Allies are drawing down forces because of their problems in Eurasia, the Americans should be seizing the opportunity to strike deep into Mexico. Conversely, if the Americans are pulling forces back for unknown reasons (perhaps a large amphibious operation) the Allies should be taking advantage. It feels like both AIs have made a gentleman's agreement to leave this front on the backburner for now...

And a new Allied diversion had begun in the Black Sea, with early reports of attempted Allied landing in the south of the Crimean Peninsula. These first landings were being led by French units under General Pierre Hoch.

Then by midnight on the 31st, three British divisions were ashore east of the Kerch Strait, with the other four landings on northern Crimea still under way and new direct assaults on Sevastopol and Odessa had begun.

Its looks like the Allies mounted a really big amphibious operation around the Crimean peninsula but the Soviets were prepared for it. Although a few divisions managed to get ashore in various places I suspect most were repelled by the defenders.

In Less favourable news, the ensuing days saw the poorly supported landings in Crimea largely been rolled up, while a heavy Soviet presence had assembled around the Kerch-Krasnodar beachhead, which also remained without port access and thus unsupplied.

But in Crimea and across the Kerch Strait, all Allied beachheads had been eliminated. That distraction had not been properly supported and had now failed.

Too few divisions managed to get ashore and those that did were out of supply. Unfortunately, this has to be chalked up as a costly failure. :(

And in the last few days, the situation had deteriorated significantly in Birjand as the constant Soviet pressure, including air support, finally saw the defence fade by the afternoon of the 23rd, with just the mountain specialists of 21 DPG left in the fight.

But the Allies were unable to rescue Shiraz before the defence faltered on the afternoon of the 27th and then failed a day later with the city falling into Soviet hands.

The inevitable happened after midnight: Iranian capitulation.

I really had hoped Poland's valiant efforts could have prevented this outcome. I imagine the Iranian surrender will have some kind of adverse effect on the Allied supply situation, so I expect the Soviets to keep on pushing forward. I think the Poles should now try to keep the line of retreat open and just make sure they don't get cut off themselves. What is the status of Pakistan? Is it possible for the Allies to fall back towards India or are the Iranian ports critical?

The big news at the start of the month was the declaration of war by the Soviets on Turkey on the morning of 1 September 1946. They must have become impatient with Turkey giving access and support for the Allies in recent weeks. This brought another 47 divisions and 1,600 aircraft into the field and extended the active front from the Black Sea to the Persian Gulf.

This is a big plus for the Allies! Trotsky would have been better served having Turkey as a neutral country (albeit one providing the Allies with material support) than as a belligerent. Rather like Hitler and the US in OTL, I feel.

The Japanese landings in New Guinea were now running roughshod over the Allied defences in bad news for the Australians, in particular.

I just knew the Allies would mess this one up. Now there's a serious risk of further ports falling into the hands of the Japanese and making this campaign a lot longer and harder. Arghh!! :mad:

But the main source of this burst of activity was somewhat unexpected: on 3 September a massive Czech-Yugoslav Autumn Offensive was launched all across the line. And initial progress was quite promising in many of these battles, though that was often the case early in attacks.

By the morning of 11 September, the offensive had largely ended in Byelorussia – but mainly because its first phase had been completed, making surprisingly wide gains.

I am quite impressed the Czech-Yugoslav offensive was able to advance the front so successfully. I figured the Soviets would stop them in their tracks. This could be an indication the Soviets are over-stretched and have neglected this theatre. If so, this bodes well for the Polish winter offensive. :)

The Poles resolved to ‘stay the course in Salihorsk’.

At first I thought supporting the Salihorsk offensive was a good idea but I am beginning to have doubts as it drags on. Is it worth the cost?
 
  • 1Like
Reactions:
The big news at the start of the month was the declaration of war by the Soviets on Turkey on the morning of 1 September 1946.
Big news indeed! Now you just need Romania. Hopefully, your Middle Eastern troops can help with any potential breakthroughs in the Caucasus.
In Less favourable news, the ensuing days saw the poorly supported landings in Crimea largely been rolled up
If they had just waited a few months for the USR to be distracted by Belarus (or the C-Y operation), they could've done some real damage.
By 14 September, the Soviets had ground forward as the Poles fell back and tried to avoid getting cut off.
More bad news here. The Allies seem unable to hold.
And in one place, the offensive would take ground south of Minsk be that evening.
Progress! If the Allies can keep this ground by the time the coup rolls around, then the Soviets will be hard-pressed to not lose ground somewhere (either against Turkey, Poland, Estonia, or in Arkhangelsk).
 
  • 2Like
  • 1
Reactions:
PS:
To paraphrase Wodehouse; It is never difficult to distinguish between a Bullfilter AAR and a ray of sunshine
@El Pip: Your Filterness, you are like a stream of bat’s piss.

@Bullfilter: What?

@El Pip: It was one of TBC's.

@TheButterflyComposer: It sodding was not! It was Diskoerekto!

@diskoerekto: I…I merely meant, Your Filterness, that you shine out like a shaft of gold when all around is dark.

@Bullfilter: Oh, well said. You must come up to the Palace some time.
 
Last edited:
  • 2Haha
Reactions:
Pip's always stirring and disko is always getting away.
 
  • 2
  • 1Haha
Reactions:
Imageshack.com (which hosts all my images) seems to be down just now. Was working earlier - can't log into it and none of the images seems to be showing up. Is that just me, or the same for everyone?

Edit: whatever the problem was, it now seems to have been corrected, the server is up again and the images have reappeared (for me, anyway).
 
Last edited:
  • 1
Reactions:
So, remaining comment feedback follows as the second half of the September 1946 session is done and ready to publish and my image server is back up again.
Will the Soviets declaring war on Turkey and bring Gen. @diskoerekto to the front tip the Middle East to the allies? (Digging deep to find positive news.) Thanks
I liked that! Yes, positive news there is, especially in Poland-Byelorussia-UKraine and this helps too, even if it is a bit grim elsewhere. If only the Soviets could be defeated, I think a 'narrative peace' with the US and a modus vivendi with the MAB could be had, certainly as far as Poland and its war aims are concerned. But time will tell, and will yet be long in the telling :(
A very disconcerting update, bits of it could almost be considered positive. Where is the unrelenting doom and misery one associates with Bullfilter AARs?

It is a good thing the Allied AIs are determined to waste troops in doomed amphibious invasions, or the entry of Turkey into the war could really have made a positive difference.
On the game-related bits: the situation remains with some prospects for Poland at least, especially given the surprising success of the C-Y offensive and the entry of Turkey into the war, which should ensure the Middle East can at least hold and draw away considerable 4th Int forces. The surprising longevity of the Mexican and Canadian is also useful in keeping the US distracted and in North America. Not getting bases in Europe from which to drop A-bombs on the Allied heartland!
:eek:

Is wanting the enemy AIs to stuff up to the same extent as the Allies too much to ask, I beseech you rhetorically? :D
The overall world state is still really depressing.
In general, yes. Just a few shafts of gold shining out when all around is dark! :D
This is really confusing. If the Allies are drawing down forces because of their problems in Eurasia, the Americans should be seizing the opportunity to strike deep into Mexico. Conversely, if the Americans are pulling forces back for unknown reasons (perhaps a large amphibious operation) the Allies should be taking advantage. It feels like both AIs have made a gentleman's agreement to leave this front on the backburner for now...
I know, I have the same general confusion and feeling. Still, it is important but peripheral to immediate Polish priorities (even with that EF corps over there now). We will seek to focus on what we can really control while chipping in where we can elsewhere, mainly to keep the Soviets as distracted as possible in the ME and Iran. The MAB we've essentially given up on: Europe first!
Its looks like the Allies mounted a really big amphibious operation around the Crimean peninsula but the Soviets were prepared for it. Although a few divisions managed to get ashore in various places I suspect most were repelled by the defenders.
Plenty of attempted landings by the Germans, British and French but mainly isolated, single division affairs, unlike their more robust invasion of Georgia. A pity it wasn't properly sustained, but par for the course :rolleyes:
Too few divisions managed to get ashore and those that did were out of supply. Unfortunately, this has to be chalked up as a costly failure. :(
Indeed.
I really had hoped Poland's valiant efforts could have prevented this outcome. I imagine the Iranian surrender will have some kind of adverse effect on the Allied supply situation, so I expect the Soviets to keep on pushing forward. I think the Poles should now try to keep the line of retreat open and just make sure they don't get cut off themselves. What is the status of Pakistan? Is it possible for the Allies to fall back towards India or are the Iranian ports critical?
You will have seen since that the immediate effect was less than feared and the supply situation seems largely unaffected, with ports and the land line to India still open, if a bit wobbly for a brief period. Still tying down Soviet divisions and costing them troops in combat and attrition, so probably still worth supporting for now, if it keeps those troops from intervening on the Eastern Front.
This is a big plus for the Allies! Trotsky would have been better served having Turkey as a neutral country (albeit one providing the Allies with material support) than as a belligerent. Rather like Hitler and the US in OTL, I feel.
I visualised it as him deciding to attack them in a fit of pique, or perhaps learning they were about to declare war themselves and deciding to beat them to the punch. Either way, it is some good news when we really need some.
I just knew the Allies would mess this one up. Now there's a serious risk of further ports falling into the hands of the Japanese and making this campaign a lot longer and harder. Arghh!! :mad:
Not sure if they can regain New Guinea a second time ... and the US has had some amphibious plans (according to the standard warnings) for intervening in Australia for a while, too :(
I am quite impressed the Czech-Yugoslav offensive was able to advance the front so successfully. I figured the Soviets would stop them in their tracks. This could be an indication the Soviets are over-stretched and have neglected this theatre. If so, this bodes well for the Polish winter offensive. :)
I was pleasantly surprised as well! When I checked, I think the two of them combined had as many or more divisions on the front than Poland! And Yugoslavia is ranked as a major power these days, as well. And it also suggests that keeping up the pressure on those other fronts and using Polish troops to help do so may actually be a reasonable investment after all (not to mention the time and cost of repatriating them to the Fatherland if we did withdraw them to support the Winter Offensive. I remain in two minds about it, but am now a little more inclined to leave them in place than I was just a few weeks ago.
At first I thought supporting the Salihorsk offensive was a good idea but I am beginning to have doubts as it drags on. Is it worth the cost?
We shall have to see in the next update, though I was still wondering myself at that point. Possible pros and cons ...
Big news indeed! Now you just need Romania. Hopefully, your Middle Eastern troops can help with any potential breakthroughs in the Caucasus.
That would be useful too - especially if it happens when the Soviets are already heavily distracted elsewhere and lengthening the front (and adding in the Romanian divisions) helps rather than hinders.
If they had just waited a few months for the USR to be distracted by Belarus (or the C-Y operation), they could've done some real damage.
Quite. Silly AI!
More bad news here. The Allies seem unable to hold.
Another doomed front, it seems.
Progress! If the Allies can keep this ground by the time the coup rolls around, then the Soviets will be hard-pressed to not lose ground somewhere (either against Turkey, Poland, Estonia, or in Arkhangelsk).
This is he hope - they're doing a lot of the softening up work we'd assumed we'd have to mainly do ourselves. Hence the Poles willingness to help a little. If they can keep that pressure up in the coming few months, it will provide a good launching pad.

Thanks everyone for the comments and support! Will see if I can find a few more rays of sunshine to light up the dark recesses of this grin alt-WW2! ;)
 
  • 2
  • 1Like
Reactions:
Chapter Eighty-three: A Blanket of Dead Leaves (16 to 30 September 1946)
Chapter Eighty-three: A Blanket of Dead Leaves
(16 to 30 September 1946)


JM5sZk.jpg

A Polish 9TP light tank advances to the front during the massive Battle of Salihorsk, September 1946.

=======​

The Americas

The US managed to push a division over the Rio Grande on 16 September, through a large gap in the Allied line but they did not seem to be following it up in any strength.

zVpg1O.jpg

However, northern Mexico remained largely quiet for the rest of the month. It was on the diplomatic front that things hotted up. On 27 September, President Truman dropped a ‘news bomb’ with the announcement of the formation of a new US-led faction.

Xx3xIy.jpg

Many Caribbean, Central and South American nations joined the Treaty of Reciprocal Assistance (TRA) – but not the key powers of Brazil or Argentina, nor Bolivia, Venezuela, Paraguay or Peru.

By 28 September, all US resistance on the Yucatan Peninsula had ended, with thousands more American prisoners crowding south-east Mexican POW camps.

A few days after the TRA was concluded, the first three members joined the war as active combatants on the US side – though no others did before the end of the month.

lnpuRV.jpg

The closest of these new participants to the main front in Mexico was Honduras but it did not share a land border with the Allies.

zzrzwj.jpg

As the month ended, the 7th Army had not been involved in any further combat [the irony of Sosabowski commanding German troops gets me every time]. The US incursion over the Rio Grande had been ejected, though troops under Mexican command were trying to get back over again.

6iphKh.jpg

The modest US build-up in eastern Canada continued to squeeze the Allied enclave in the west, while a previously promising Allied counter-offensive on its south was now starting to go against the attackers.

hxgL83.jpg


=======​

The Black Sea and the Middle East

This sector was also comparatively uneventful during the second half of September. Fighting continued, but little ground traded. Two fresh Soviet attacks on the perimeter of the Georgian enclave were in progress on 27 September and three along the Turkish border, with all being resisted strongly by the Allies at first.

Along the Tigris, another Soviet attack had been repelled on 26 September, while another between it and Basrah had almost been defeated.

xlWiIA.jpg

Early on the 28th, 718 Infanterie Division finally landed in Beirut and was transferred to 4th Army, ordered across to provide an operational reserve for the Tigris defensive line.

By the end of the month, the Georgian province just north of Batumi had been retaken by the enemy, though with Turkey now in the war this loss was only a minor setback.

VQUT6o.jpg

The line through Turkey and Kurdistan remained unchanged since the 16th, with substantial Allied reinforcements bolstering the Turkish divisions at the front.

=======​

Iran

Similarly, the situation in Iran had almost stabilised by mid-month. In the east, a Polish spoiling attack in north-east Kerman was launched to save the still-disorganised Polish division that had just arrived in east Kerman to come under Soviet attack.

ihkTMs.jpg

This worked within five hours and was then persisted with until the Poles won in north-east Kerman as well that night.

More widely, by the end of the 16th the areas behind the lines had all been reoccupied by the Allies, while the Poles continued to advance to retake north-east Kerman.

kT04P3.jpg

Two weeks later, Soviet advances in the north and the Poles in north-east Kerman, the front line in Iran was more regular as the Poles once again helped to secure that north-eastern sector, the Allies holding the rest of the line strongly enough.

FAeWN2.jpg


=======​

The Asia-Pacific

The Japanese invasion of New Guinea seemed to be expanding easily by the evening of 16 September. They still only controlled one port of entry but the Allied defence was being fragmented.

u31pfc.jpg

The fight for Naha on Okinawa continued, with another Manchurian division having been shipped in to bolster against the Japanese attack, which had become badly disorganised and was running out of supplies.

The Japanese had spread further through New Guinea in just five days as the Allied defence looked to have largely collapsed.

RqPmMZ.jpg

Things got worse for the Allies with the capitulation of Tibet on 22 September.

XyaUi0.jpg

Across the Middle East and Iran, the Allies had largely stabilised the front by the end of September but the position in Western China and Tibet had continued to worsen.

ubJHgf.jpg

And in New Guinea the ports of Lae and Rabaul had fallen to Japan and Port Moresby was surrounded, being held by a lone French division. The Allies still held Jayapura in West Papua.

MCQIff.jpg

While on Okinawa, the Japanese had given up their attack and languished, out of supply, in the north of the island. Though the Allied presence was back down to two divisions, one of them very disorganised and they did not appear to be pressing a counter-attack.

agCsgx.jpg


=======​

The Eastern Front and the USR

As it had in the first half of the month, the fighting on the Eastern Front remained the most significant and busiest theatre in the sprawling global war. Within an hour of each other, the Poles led large defensive victories against the Soviets in the Khmelnytskyi sector, where over 14,000 enemy soldiers fell attacking prepared positions, for around 2,200 Allied casualties. The southern sector currently sat largely on the defensive on 16 September.

NDlZeu.jpg

The vicious fighting for Salihorsk continued with two more Polish divisions – 52 and 90 DP – being thrown into the fight at 1700hr on 17 September as others tired and pulled out of the attack, putting it back in the balance. Poland now fielded most of the divisions in contact in Salihorsk.

XFvSZh.jpg

This initially gave the Allies the upper hand, but by 2300hr the pendulum had once more swung back the Soviet’s way. Some survivors of the battle would later recount how bodies lay on the ground in many places like ‘a blanket of fallen leaves.’

On 20 September, the C-Y offensive resumed across much of the front while the terrible fight for Salihorsk had swung back in the Allies’ favour. Over that day and the next, two more large Allied defensive victories (as usual, the only ones statistics were available for as they involved Polish divisions) were won in the Khmelnytskyi sector.

rc8jjh.jpg

Up in the north, the Allies had driven a surprising spearhead through the south-western Soviet perimeter, however Polish observers were concerned that this spearhead had been driven into the most remote part of the line and risked becoming isolated.

VVIy9T.jpg

Around Salihorsk, the new C-Y offensive had managed to take the province to its north and after a tricky start was now holding the newly gained ground, further isolating the Soviet defence. The Battle in Salihorsk would swing from evenly poised on the night of the 22nd through to a clear Allied advantage by the following morning as one of the recently amalgamated cavalry divisions was brought up and thrown into the meat-grinder.

b2ZmaE.jpg

One of the great battles of the war to date would carry on for another two days before General Roman Abraham could claim victory on the morning of 25 September. Over 20,000 men from both sides would never leave that bloody patch of ground alive. For the Allies, of course many of those casualties were not Polish, though thousands had fallen.

The news was not as favourable in the north. As the Poles had feared, the ill-advised Anglo-German breakout had been isolated and surrounded by the time the victory in Salihorsk was being grimly ‘celebrated’.

8FNyKW.jpg

Salihorsk was duly occupied by the Poles later that morning, with a brief Soviet counter-attack easily defeated an hour later. By the 26th, the C-Y formations to the north were trying to push forward but without enough strength to seriously threaten the next line of Soviet defences.

B90557.jpg

Two days later, the C-Y second phase offensive continued, though most of its attacks were beginning to peter out and the Soviets were trying to counter attack in a few places, having reclaimed the small enclave along the Romanian border seized earlier in the month.

aO8mr0.jpg

Of great interest were a couple of Turkish divisions that had appeared on the Eastern Front, keen to make a contribution there even as many Allied units had been assisting their own defence against the Soviets in eastern Turkey.

A quaint piece of diplomatic news was received on 28 September, when Trotsky annexed their supposed small ally, Tannu Tuva. This was cynically framed as resulting from a ‘request by the Tuvan parliament’. No-one was taken in by that statement!

ojxjeJ.jpg

By 30 September the Allied pocket south of Archangelsk had been further compressed and isolated; their sad fate was clear.

Dgzenp.jpg

As the month ended, the second C-Y push was largely over, though a couple of attacks continued. The Soviets were attempting a limited counter-offensive but that was being held solidly for now. It seemed another landing was being attempted in Crimea, to little effect. Estonia had remained largely quiet and unchanged since mid-month.

RosqTx.jpg

Promisingly, the hard-won gains of the C-Y offensive and the Polish effort in Salihorsk remained secure, providing a potential springboard for the planned operation that was now less than three months away.

v3CMNA.jpg

And the KBK had finally arrived after its long journey from China, then Iran and all the way to southern Poland. They merged with the other remaining cavalry brigade to join Abraham’s 1st Army as the KDK: the Kresowa Dywizja Kawalerii.

=======​

Industry and Technology

Poland developed the doctrine for paratroopers on 28 September, with researchers next working on upgrading the engineering equipment integral to all line infantry divisions.

HDnfZR.jpg

All the recent fighting in Salihorsk had resulted in a shortage of light tanks, with a deficit of 24 vehicles by 28 December. This oversight began to be corrected with a factory switching from medium to light tank production, which had been suspended when it was thought the stockpile was sufficient. It was a timely reminder of the likely attrition of armour in the coming offensive: production would likely need to be ramped up in the coming weeks to rebuild the stockpile, if possible into a surplus by December.

Just a few days later the deficit had been reduced to 15 (perhaps some equipment trickle-back had been at play). The AA deficit had been reduced well below 900 and there were now 17 operational jet fighters to hand, though not yet deployed.

1b9QgI.jpg


=======​

Summary

In Eurasia and Africa, the three main factions controlled almost all the nations, with relatively few neutrals left.

hh43EQ.jpg

The German elections had been held during September (the date was unclear) and against all expectations Adenauer’s democratic Zentrum party had retained government, despite being the third most popular party. How he managed to contrive this (some kind of coalition, or just luck of the draw) was unknown but there was considerable relief in the UK and Poland as a result.

cNF0fA.jpg

Konrad Adenauer sworn in for another term as German Chancellor, September 1946.

The monthly casualty analysis showed Allied losses outweighing those of the enemy during September, though not by an enormous margin. Poland had lost only 12,430 men on all fronts in combat during the month, despite some hard fighting in Salihorsk and eastern Iran. Of those, 10,400 had fallen to the Soviets, with an estimated 49,900 of them being killed by Polish troops [given their casualties to Polish action are now only recorded in increments of 100k, this was estimated by subtracting those attributed to others from their overall total].

KkGGU2.jpg

Polish reserve manpower had risen by around 100,000 during the month, while the estimated Soviet reserve had decreased by approximately 280,000 over the same period, after they suffered an estimated 330,000 casualties, the Czechs in particular taking a large share of the total so far. This gave the Polish High Command some limited optimism for their prospects in the winter, even if the Allied effort in the Americas, the Middle East and Asia Pacific remained concerning.
 
  • 3Love
  • 1
Reactions:
A few days after the TRA was concluded, the first three members joined the war as active combatants on the US side – though no others did before the end of the month.
This is bad for the Allies in general. The AI is probably going to waste many divisions in naval invasions against these new participants, and not use them against any of the majors where they're needed.
As the month ended, the 7th Army had not been involved in any further combat [the irony of Sosabowski commanding German troops gets me every time]. The US incursion over the Rio Grande had been ejected, though troops under Mexican command were trying to get back over again.
Do you have any plans to send those German troops into the gaps in Texas? At best, you could cause a breakthrough. At worst, you occupy some empty tiles and distract the US.
Things got worse for the Allies with the capitulation of Tibet on 22 September.
If you have any troops left in Sinkiang, it might be time to send them to the mountain passes in northern India before the MAB gets there.
The vicious fighting for Salihorsk continued
Is Salihorsk a supply hub?
By 30 September the Allied pocket south of Archangelsk had been further compressed and isolated; their sad fate was clear.
At least the Allies are in supply and the Soviets aren't. So, when the Allies lose here, it will still be a long, painful process for the USR.
 
  • 2Like
  • 1
Reactions:
Harry, Give Trotsky to the Devil and join the allies. Thanks
If only! Even just be neutral ... alas, no chance of that happening for now, I'd say (not being an expert on how peace mechanics work in HOI4).
This is bad for the Allies in general. The AI is probably going to waste many divisions in naval invasions against these new participants, and not use them against any of the majors where they're needed.
A pity if they do., but it at least keeps things 'interesting' as the player, relying on the imperfections of our allies' strategies!
Do you have any plans to send those German troops into the gaps in Texas? At best, you could cause a breakthrough. At worst, you occupy some empty tiles and distract the US.
Not for now - though it could be a thing for a couple of them, so long as it doesn't create a weakness in the more heavily western half of the front. I think any breakthrough we make would attract unwanted attention, but I'll keep it in mind.
If you have any troops left in Sinkiang, it might be time to send them to the mountain passes in northern India before the MAB gets there.
No, last division pulled out of there a while back. Up to the rest of the Allies there now :confused:
Is Salihorsk a supply hub?
No, just a 1vp town - not even on a rail line (which, thanks for having reminded me) I'm starting to build now it looks like being a jumping off point for the winter.
At least the Allies are in supply and the Soviets aren't. So, when the Allies lose here, it will still be a long, painful process for the USR.
Hopefully. Still, losing three divs like that was both careless and unnecessary :rolleyes:
 
  • 2
Reactions: