I think I'm going to go with the De Jure Kingdom option...so it's similar to what's happening at the moment, with the area no longer being a part of the Stormlands, but now it'll be a small Kingdom in order to make it more visually pleasing, and to allow the person holding it to have a title that shows their general importance in Westeros (plus, as noted, if it's now a separate realm, that should increase the chances of it reverting to the Iron Throne if the line dies out); much like what I'm planning to do with Dragonstone...yes, it should be a part of the De Jure Crownlands, but this way, it allows the Prince of Dragonstone to have vassals sworn to them, which should be an option for the Stannis start date.
I'm actually wanting to toy more and more with the pre-conquest Kingdom idea, and see if some of the Kingdoms can show up later in the game...for instance, Summerhall? This could be the planned Kingdom of the (Dornish) Marches that I'm planning to add with a new name, and it would certainly make sense, given that Summerhall was said to be built at the end of the Stone Way. I'm also thinking about my idea of revamping the Crownlands to add a "Kingdom of the Blackwater" in the place of the western Crownlands during the pre-Conquest date, and I have a new idea for what to do here with this Kingdom; firstly, I'll add a new culture group called something like "Blackwatermen" (ahistorical, but somewhat justified, given that the name for bastards from this region is Waters...and considering how much has been speculated so far with place names and historical figures, it really wouldn't be too much of a stretch), and change the culture of all the Crownland provinces held by the Riverlands to this culture. Secondly, I'll update the Conquest events so that when Aegon shows up and is able to pick just where he wants to make his capital, if he picks the option to settle at King's Landing, then the culture "Blackwatermen" will change to "Crownlander"; much like how Frankish becomes French in Vanilla (however, the Stormlander culture counties will remain unchanged; thus giving them a cultural link with Storm's End and thus making them sympathetic to Stannis). If he chooses to settle anywhere else, the "Blackwatermen" culture will remain intact, and the title of "Lord Paramount of the Blackwater" will become available for one of the Lords in the region. This way, we get a chance to use the "Lord Paramount of the Crownlands" title in some way (and also prevent the name from not making sense), we can have a Crownlander culture group in the game that actually covers the bulk of the Crownlands instead of just King's Landing, and thus give someone playing the Darklyns something to go for.
I'm actually wanting to toy more and more with the pre-conquest Kingdom idea, and see if some of the Kingdoms can show up later in the game...for instance, Summerhall? This could be the planned Kingdom of the (Dornish) Marches that I'm planning to add with a new name, and it would certainly make sense, given that Summerhall was said to be built at the end of the Stone Way. I'm also thinking about my idea of revamping the Crownlands to add a "Kingdom of the Blackwater" in the place of the western Crownlands during the pre-Conquest date, and I have a new idea for what to do here with this Kingdom; firstly, I'll add a new culture group called something like "Blackwatermen" (ahistorical, but somewhat justified, given that the name for bastards from this region is Waters...and considering how much has been speculated so far with place names and historical figures, it really wouldn't be too much of a stretch), and change the culture of all the Crownland provinces held by the Riverlands to this culture. Secondly, I'll update the Conquest events so that when Aegon shows up and is able to pick just where he wants to make his capital, if he picks the option to settle at King's Landing, then the culture "Blackwatermen" will change to "Crownlander"; much like how Frankish becomes French in Vanilla (however, the Stormlander culture counties will remain unchanged; thus giving them a cultural link with Storm's End and thus making them sympathetic to Stannis). If he chooses to settle anywhere else, the "Blackwatermen" culture will remain intact, and the title of "Lord Paramount of the Blackwater" will become available for one of the Lords in the region. This way, we get a chance to use the "Lord Paramount of the Crownlands" title in some way (and also prevent the name from not making sense), we can have a Crownlander culture group in the game that actually covers the bulk of the Crownlands instead of just King's Landing, and thus give someone playing the Darklyns something to go for.
- 1