Speaking of propagandists, as the self appointed propaganda checker, I know we must have double checked the loyalties of the propaganda cupboard, but can we check the sanity of these people?
![WHAT.jpeg WHAT.jpeg](https://forumcontent.paradoxplaza.com/public/720418/WHAT.jpeg)
- 3
Based on the expansive date line I am optimistic that this has been a successful endeavor.Chapter 217: Striking Blows for ‘Freedom’ (1 to 26 November 1943)
Foreword
After the bloodbath that was Red October, Turkey was hoping to shorten and strengthen its line and start preparing for the next offensive – the invasion of Italy.
Music to our ears. Well, eyes.Air Damage Report. Gänserndorf 310 (completed); Eisenstadt 198 (completed); daily total of 508. The next Axis air attack would not occur until 10 November.
Not only have we moved well past that, if I'm not mistaken all of the territory taken in the follow-up offensive (post-German counterattack, ill-advised indeed!) is already in our hands and then some. Note that this is the Ukrainian offensive, not the more famous Operation Bagration which follows.OTL Event: Russia. On 4 November, the Second Battle of Kiev began on the Eastern Front. [Comment: well, we’ve moved well past that in this ATL, though we did start a year earlier than Barbarossa.]
Optimistic of them.News Report: Tokyo. The Greater East Asia Conference concluded in Tokyo on 6 November as Japan and its puppet states finished a two-day conference and issued a formal declaration of principles for the Japanese-occupied Greater East Asia Co-Prosperity Sphere.
An ill-advised strategic blunder frankly, expending all your force in a counterattack when what is needed is to pull back and hold a line is never a good idea.OTL Event: Russia. One week after the Red Army had recaptured Kiev, the German Wehrmacht began a counter-attack that would last for forty days before being abandoned.
I suspect the Presidents estimable predecessor would have ordered the Iowa t hold course, and insisted on jumping in and wrestling the torpedo himself! And perhaps won too? Fortunately, by this time sanity prevails.Although Dawson would be sentenced to 14 years of hard labour, President Roosevelt intervened and asked that he not be punished for the accident.
Hardly a mention of the momentous event, as that little town between Stolp and Lauenbourg at the tippy-top of the map is the first bit of pre-1936 German land we've now got control of I believe.17 Nov 43
By the early morning of the 17th, the rate of advance in Poland had picked up: Danzig and Warsaw were not only in Soviet hands, but the advance had passed beyond them. Lodz was now in danger of being cut off and occupied.
![]()
Makes sense, likely Stalin wants a buffer state and puppet regime to make managing the Poles less arduous, but also wants those valuable Baltic ports for himself.The day began with some truly momentous news: the biggest addition to the Comintern since Romania occurred at midnight, when Stalin declared the liberation of Poland, albeit with limited borders. For example, land annexed into Greater Germany but since liberated by Russia in and around Danzig was not included, nor that annexed by the Soviets in western Poland as part of the infamous 1936 pact with Germany. For now, anyway, the old government led by Paderewski would govern the new Federal Socialist Republic of Poland.
If anyone can give Kelebek a worthy foil, surely it is Louise Fletcher. The next movieverse to receive the TT treatment - or just a one-off to horrify the audience?“I see he gave the Dark One good sport during the trip,” noted one of Kaya’s secret policemen queasily as he supervised the poor man’s transfer to the Kelebek Ward at the Interior Ministry's clandestine ‘infirmary’ in Ankara, run by the severe ‘Big Nurse’ Ratched. Not too many inmates ever ‘flew away’ from there!
I'd say Italy, mainly to avoid spreading our forces too thinly although trying to claim Austria is not a bad idea to keep the front wider. We already have plans to invade Italy at multiple points so we may as well focus on one thing at a time here with our dwindling manpower and the much larger Red Army pushing towards Berlin. Ideally we can push as far as the Swiss border to lock down post-war borders, though again a claim on Austria ought to do this just as well.Oh and I have reason to think that a breakthrough into either italy or bohemia is imminent, as is a decision on which to prioritise.
Oops, will correct. The moving finger writes, then having writ, moves back to rewrite the incorrect bit!Also, double-check the date on that "infamous pact", I suspect a finger stretched a bit too far north in the writing of this installment...
The Dawson, having committed such a gaff, had all sorts of woerd stories attached to it. Like nearly sinking when it first launched, the crew being utterly insane, nearly killing the president again, etc etc.I suspect the Presidents estimable predecessor would have ordered the Iowa t hold course, and insisted on jumping in and wrestling the torpedo himself! And perhaps won too? Fortunately, by this time sanity prevails.
Is Chesty Puller on the US roster of possible generals? He did not get first star until Korea.Well, as a famous American said: "Hit hard, hit fast, hit often!" Certainly applies in this case.
Where's Chesty Puller? He should be here!
He's not that I can recall, because as you point out he didn't get his star until Korea. That said, he definitely should be on the deck with MAJ Loggins, probably as 1st Regiment's CO.Is Chesty Puller on the US roster of possible generals? He did not get first star until Korea.
No. But he'd presumably be in the amercian expeditionary force. And probably quite annoyed at having a pretty boring war. Patton is probably climbing the walls too.Is Chesty Puller on the US roster of possible generals? He did not get first star until Korea.
A quick wiki check indicates that, predictably, Paradox did not add him into the game. This may be because he only got promoted as far as Brigadier General, and the lowest rank for HoI3 generals is usually Major General. More likely, it is because Paradox is supremely lazy about their historical research for leaders as we all well know.For someone who knows the American general roster, I have a second general that I am curious about: General Augustine Warner Robins of the Army Air Corps. Gen. Robins died of a heart attack while on active duty in June 1940. General Warner is credited as the Father of Air Force Logistics. In 1942 one of his proteges worked with the local mayor to change the name of Wellston Ga. to Warner Robins Ga. so that the new base could be named after the general (today's Robins AFB). General Robins was a relative of George Washington. Both General Warner and General Puller were born in rural eastern Virginia within 20 miles of my home (as was Dr. Walter Reed). Robins and Puller probably have more interesting stories than some of the game generals.
Thank you very much. Do all of the generals even exist? I question anything that assigns greater skill level to Ike, Bradley and Patton than MacArthur. Probably on Robins was dying before war started as he was top five Army Air at time of death.A quick wiki check indicates that, predictably, Paradox did not add him into the game. This may be because he only got promoted as far as Brigadier General, and the lowest rank for HoI3 generals is usually Major General. More likely, it is because Paradox is supremely lazy about their historical research for leaders as we all well know.
No, speaking as someone who tried to locate every OTL commander from the US from 1936 in the game files, almost none of them exist. I don't even think that all of the OTL generals from 1941-45 exist, but there are piles of placeholders for sure.Thank you very much. Do all of the generals even exist? I question anything that assigns greater skill level to Ike, Bradley and Patton than MacArthur. Probably on Robins was dying before war started as he was top five Army Air at time of death.
Yes, a bit painful. The only way to do it is by editing the save file after the fact, which I did a bit of for Europe in my first Quick & Dirty game. I won't do any of that in-game, but might consider fixing a few things up for the 'post-war' settlement after I'm done with the game, but am rounding out the AAR.the polish liberation is kinda painful, not in the least because it is quite literally impossible to make the hoi3 poland the real 1946 poland
Will check that out when the game is fired up again for the December play-through.Can we see if we can use the acquire territory wargoal to either acquire Austria or France? Both would be an excellent staging point for a land invasion of italy
Noted, but wait until you see the wider picture of where things end up at the end of November. Also, Prague/Austria look a lot easier on the political map view than they do on the 'simplified terrain' mode!Oh and I have reason to think that a breakthrough into either italy or bohemia is imminent, as is a decision on which to prioritise.
Me, I vote Prague and the austrian alps, as the position allows us to split the germans from the italians, in a defensible location, while advancing into italy gives the germans time to reinforce the alps, and dig in.
![]()
I got the british propagandists to draw the image. Sorry
We shall see: when I took the plunge, I of course had no foreknowledge of how it would pan out. We shall find out together.Famous last words indeed.
The US AI isn't even thinking about a war strategy atm, let alone a post-war one!Well, here is the first concrete evidence of the new world order taking shape. Finland and Poland for Soviet Russia, and Slovakia and below for Turkey. If the US isn't thinking post war strategy yet, it needs to start.
What is clear is that the germans are certainly going to lose now, the question is what will happen to the rest of western Europe? If nothing changes, it looks red all the way from Poland to France, and down to Spain eventually. If the british do show up, perhaps they can liberate the low countries or France by themselves...somehow...but I don't think they'll get far even in an ideal world for them.
It's certainly looking as though our reckoning an update ago are correct: Russia takes Poland, Germany, the low countries and France as puppets. We take Slovakia, Hungary, the balkans, Italy and maybe Spain.
A very red, very unified europe.
Yes, time to get going again. But in this case, boot lather before bayonets!It's been some time since me and me boys seen some action! Vur Ha!
Ah well, that will be for the next generation to deal with.Oh no, when Soviets go through Slovakia into enemy held lands, the province control falls to them and not us as Slovakia's puppetmaster. Now that's a problem for the leadership increase prospects for the future. Also, for the cold war to come after this war and then the war with allies.
It may not happen at once, but it will happen!Yeeeehaaaaa! Come on don't run we'll just play!![]()
He looks young in the photo and if he was dodgy, it is a bit slack of Paradox to have put him in. Shocked and surprised (not)!By the way, very interesting but unsavory character in real life, and I don't get why Paradox put him in since he was a Captain or so during WW2. Of course, I won't complain about having too many generals since we have too few![]()
The long and winding road, that leads to their door ...Why Am I Taking This Long To Arrive?![]()
Naturally. For now, winning the war trumps everything else.So the land we took from the Germans go to new Poland, but the land Soviets took are theirs to keep! How very Stalinian of him!Well still, a liberation is a liberation so this is a win for the Polish!
Ah well, I'm pretty sure Germany proper will end up as a Soviet puppet in this ATL.Good call about this, and I was having wet dreams about Breslau lol
The new doctrine that doesn't come from the Education and Doctrine Command HQ in Ankara but I'm writing on the field. Doctrine name: March towards where the commotion is coming from, and shoot in that general direction when close by. Effect: Combat Reinforcement Chance +100%
Did try that earlier, but am now leaving them be, as they can either form a pocket for us to consume, or will be forced to pull back without a fight if Trieste is pressed hard. As noted in reply, can't puppet Italy (conquer goal set years ago, not reversible without file editing, which I won't do per house rules). So I just want to defeat them as efficiently as possible, using R.A.W. principles vs VPs but destroying any units that do get isolated.Maybe in the meanwhile we can take the 2 plains provinces south of Trieste? We're holding 2 provinces around them anyway so the front won't get longer. Unless we're purposefully leaving them there as a future pocket when the defenders of Trieste will flee into? Or will we puppet Italy so want their army as intact as possible?
Thanks! MP losses have moderated a lot, but it seems to be taking quite a while to refill the ranks.In the span of a single great episode, much has changed and we're consolidating, fast! I wish the manpower situation would also keep up, but alas for that we'd need a big break that never seems to be arriving any time soon.
Yes, where they're in the front line, but if not they'll just have to get what they can. For now, I'm prioritising more by where they are and what I want them to do next than their strength.About the nice but understrength divisions like the one with SPArt etc, are you prioritizing them? They should receive the trickle of reinforcements before the line divisions I think.
We could well lose it in terms of national ownership, but per the game assumption, in the end it doesn't matter too much so long as the faction keeps it. That said, I would like to take Austria if possible for the UGNR.I was thinking a Free South Poland and a Communist North Poland as IRL West and East Germany, but the sudden loss of those Polish provinces to the new Soviet puppet shook me. It indeed looks like Slovakia and below for Turkey. In fact, I'm worried we lose Wien the same way we lost South Poland.
Will also have to check out the Soviet war goals for Germany. I'd be pretty surprised if they didn't try to puppet Germany. The rotten star-stealers!I think as long as we stay in command of wien, and the soviets don't puppet germany, we should be fine
Though I want to send the soviets a very salty message, as they stole some of our stars!
As above, will check out more in the next ep.Some quick interim responses to a few points raised:
1. Conquer was the objective set way back when for Italy.
2. I’m pretty sure that as Austria was eliminated as a country on Anschluss, you can’t set a separate objective for them. There could be a regional objective setting that takes in Austria as part of Germany, will check. But even if there is, I wouldn’t set much store by it: in my Soviet game, they were all ignored when Japan and Manchukuo were puppeted by France, even though I’d already occupied the land and they were in a different faction.
We'll see. I hope for something but expect nothing.I'm putting my hopes in that since we're the same faction there's a better chance they honor the objectives of their ally, but who knows how the game engine will resolve it. Otherwise a lot of bloodshed would be for naught. More the reason to focus on Italy as it's a separate country. On the other hand, some manual editing might solve it between the war against Axis and the war against Allies.
At this point, given my experience of the fickle war goal settlement system, my eyes cross and a just wait for the game engine to make an even worse settlement than at Versailles!but as far as I can tell it only takes precedence if its land between you and your ally. so, if its say the soviet union, and slovakia adds a wargoal for western russia, it may lead to immense bordergore and suffering, should germany beat russia with the conquer wargoal
Probably right.I'm pretty sure Russia will view Austria the same as otl and not give a shit, and probably give it up to us if we ask. Maybe even if we don't...who knows?
I'm thinking anything north of Slovakia is staying with the Soviets, yes. Which to be fair, leaves us the whole of the former austro Hungarian empire sans polish regions, Italy, Spain, the med islands, and whatever bits of the Middle East and North Africa the comingern can prise away from the vichy French and the British...
Plenty to go around.
Soviets I'd say.Wait, so who takes the Czechs?
This is the idea, though the German AI has scrambled well against me along the way and may be able to slow the Soviets down if they switch attention back there.This was an excellent decision. Germany seems to have nothing left, and I think there are more Italians holding the entire front! Finland should be a nice steamroll for the massive northern Soviet army.
This is current thinking. Plus the amphibious option to help crack things open. And this time, the Italians won't be able to rely on a big German bail-out!I'm thinking some sort of breakthrough in the south is necessary. The Italians have done a very good job stopping your advance thanks to the mountains/hills. I'm not sure where a good breakthrough would be due to the poor terrain though. Possibly from northern Yugoslavia to Trieste?
Agreed. Being tough makes it more interesting. Though funnily enough, Italy (like France) has no bearing on the assigned Comintern war objectives, even though Spain does! I suspect this is part of the hard-wired WW2 re-enactment the vanilla game attempts to push things into.This is certainly the beginning of the end, but I suspect Italy will prove a tough nut to crack in the future.
Keep up the good work! Vur ha!
True enough.Depends what happens when it's all over but stalin has dibs, as he has with most of eastern Europe.
The only reason we have Slovakia now is because we were the ones who took it and puppetted it. I wasn't expecting to hold anything above Hungary.
We have gotten that goddamm propagandist! VUR HA!
Sanity check failed! Send for kelebek immediately, then off to Nurse Ratched for 'treatment'!Speaking of propagandists, as the self appointed propaganda checker, I know we must have double checked the loyalties of the propaganda cupboard, but can we check the sanity of these people?
Indeed it was, within limits.Based on the expansive date line I am optimistic that this has been a successful endeavor.
Music to our ears. Well, eyes.
We grind through the gears without mercy, even if progress is sometimes slow. As for bagration, the next chapter will show how it is going!Not only have we moved well past that, if I'm not mistaken all of the territory taken in the follow-up offensive (post-German counterattack, ill-advised indeed!) is already in our hands and then some. Note that this is the Ukrainian offensive, not the more famous Operation Bagration which follows.
One of very many they made - fortunately!An ill-advised strategic blunder frankly, expending all your force in a counterattack when what is needed is to pull back and hold a line is never a good idea.
Or tieing himself to the mast and damning them! Though in those days (Civil War New Orleans, iirc without checking), Farragut referred to fire ships.I suspect the Presidents estimable predecessor would have ordered the Iowa t hold course, and insisted on jumping in and wrestling the torpedo himself! And perhaps won too? Fortunately, by this time sanity prevails.
I did notice at the time. Let's see how much is in Soviet clutches by the end of November (just four game days away).Hardly a mention of the momentous event, as that little town between Stolp and Lauenbourg at the tippy-top of the map is the first bit of pre-1936 German land we've now got control of I believe.
Rationalising, yes. In game reality (as I know you know) the game made it German territory after the partition and can't remember it was ever Polish now, it seems.Makes sense, likely Stalin wants a buffer state and puppet regime to make managing the Poles less arduous, but also wants those valuable Baltic ports for himself.
Quite. Not sure yet whether it will get a fuller treatment, or just be limited to the Kelebek Ward at the Interior Ministry 'facility'.If anyone can give Kelebek a worthy foil, surely it is Louise Fletcher. The next movieverse to receive the TT treatment - or just a one-off to horrify the audience?
Am thinking along similar lines. Austria if it basically presents an open door to push on, but too much time and blood to fight for inch by inch, when MP is such an issue for Turkey and not for the Soviets.I'd say Italy, mainly to avoid spreading our forces too thinly although trying to claim Austria is not a bad idea to keep the front wider. We already have plans to invade Italy at multiple points so we may as well focus on one thing at a time here with our dwindling manpower and the much larger Red Army pushing towards Berlin. Ideally we can push as far as the Swiss border to lock down post-war borders, though again a claim on Austria ought to do this just as well.
Sounds like it. The first one I cited was strange enough and I'd never heard of it before.The Dawson, having committed such a gaff, had all sorts of woerd stories attached to it. Like nearly sinking when it first launched, the crew being utterly insane, nearly killing the president again, etc etc.
The historical veracity of these reports are...questionable. Good stories though.
You will see how both these propositions end up after the final four days of the month - soon! No spoiler in the meantime.This was a really good month. Turkey held the line, even gaining a little ground, and the manpower deficit actually stabilised, which is the first step to recovery. Once you get some of those new La-7's chasing away Axis bombers, the drain should be reduced, and Turkey's manpower situation will go into the green again.
It was always going to happen and Inonu had no real intention of getting in the way once the offensive in southern Poland was checked, Vienna came under heavy attack and manpower plummeted.As for the new Communist Polish state. It looks like Stalin has decided to put his stamp on Poland, and make sure that the Soviet Union gets to be the only game in town north of Slovakia. Considering the Turkish line is currently further west than the Soviet western front, I understand that the Politburo wants to make sure, the Soviet Union gets the spoils it deserves.
Per above, will see re Austria. With more MP it could be a good option, but ... Spain before Austria for Turkey in strategic/objective terms. We just don't have the men, materiel or strategic interest to go pushing north into Bohemoia - or elsewhere in Germany - now. But if Austria falls into our laps, we'll take, whether we can keep it after the war or not.Now to the question of Turkey's next objectives. It makes sense to take and hold the Austrian Alps, and even Austria, to cut the Axis front in two. (It might be wise to turn Austria into a puppet state once the war is over so that a buffer exists between the Soviet and Turkish spheres of influence. However, charging northwards into Bohemia will definitely increase friction with the Soviet Union and it is likely any and all means short of war will be used by the Soviet Union for it to control post-war Germany, rather than splitting it with Turkey. It will also continue to drain Turkey's manpower while not really contributing to the UGNR's goal of becoming a true Mediterranean empire. The question is, of course, how well the Italians and/or the Germans will react to a Turkish push into the alps. If the Wehrmacht struggles to man the line, a Turkish operation into Bohemia would drastically shorten the war.
I think Spain more than southern Germany really, given we must take Spain to end the war. Italy is a personal and RP objective. Not sure how much Finland will slow the Soviets down. In relative terms in the mid-term, perhaps, but it saves them having to redeploy there later (which might only happen after a DoW where they were out of position) and the forces in Karelia that did not stay to man the border would have taken a while to get to Poland-Germany anyway. Die cast now, hopefully it will shorten the war.Turkey might be able to present Stalin with a fait accompli by invading and staking a claim on Southern Germany all while physically blocking the Red Army from taking part of Italy, or Spain before the Turkish Army turns it's attention back towards the South. Another question we should maybe ask is what should happen to France. If Turkey doesn't strike into Bohemia, leaving the Red Army to mop up Germany on it's own, might a Turkish operation into Northern Italy, followed by a charge into occupied France, from the South, result in Turkey effectively controlling the entire Northern Mediterranean coast line, once it takes Spain out. Now, one might argue that it is possible for Turkey to achieve this even after a Southern German operation. The whole question is how fast Turkey can afford to advance considering the manpower situation, and how quickly the Red Army will get into and through Germany. In this respect, the Finnish DOW is likely to slow the Soviets down somewhat, allowing Turkey to grab more territory in places where Axis opposition is weak. And then there is the unlikely wild card of a British or American amphibious operation into Western Europe when Germany is at it's weakest.
In any case, the Austrian alps look great for a spring offensive,
Let's go into the mountains,
Per above, will do. It's nice that it's suddenly a topic of interest for us!I'd definitely see if Austria is a region that can be claimed. Best to have that buffer for the inevitable collapse into the tripolar world.
Hadn't heard of him before this mention. An impressive character.Is Chesty Puller on the US roster of possible generals? He did not get first star until Korea.
Well, with a recommendation like that ...He's not that I can recall, because as you point out he didn't get his star until Korea. That said, he definitely should be on the deck with MAJ Loggins, probably as 1st Regiment's CO.
Patton is probably guarding either the Canadian or Mexican border! I should check at some point. But the US Marines serving with the Turks have seen plenty of action, so Chesty shouldn't have been too bored, I hope.No. But he'd presumably be in the amercian expeditionary force. And probably quite annoyed at having a pretty boring war. Patton is probably climbing the walls too.
To be honest, they're probably much better utilised in Australia at this point, but we don't give a shit about the british empire so...
The man earned five Navy Crosses and a chestful of other medals, but never earned the Medal. So, he's a super wild character. I wish I had brought him up earlier; had I known that you weren't aware of him I would have.Hadn't heard of him before this mention. An impressive character.
Well, with a recommendation like that ...
Patton is probably guarding either the Canadian or Mexican border! I should check at some point. But the US Marines serving with the Turks have seen plenty of action, so Chesty shouldn't have been too bored, I hope.![]()
Well, he’s in now. Next time there will likely be a pic and maybe some alt-bio.The man earned five Navy Crosses and a chestful of other medals, but never earned the Medal. So, he's a super wild character. I wish I had brought him up earlier; had I known that you weren't aware of him I would have.
I just finished reading. Vur ha! To our brave air warriors and their decisive (albeit expensive) victories!
It does sound like fun. I have a dim memory of playing as Australia in HOI1 many years back and getting my fleet and troops to land in Japan by the end, but can’t recall any details now. I’d like to play Australia again (in HOI3 or even 4, which I’ve only played a little) and do an AAR about that ... but alas, too many ideas, too little time.So I thought to myself, I might give that Australia “Tokyo 1944” a try in blackice.
its currently 1943, but Tokyo in ‘44 is still too far away. As a consolation prize, I would like to note that all Aussie territory is completely safe, and I’ve sunk 1 page of Japanese ships, while they’ve sunk 3, 2 of which being very outdated destroyers, and 1 being a transport liner (by naval bomber) while the heaviest ships I’ve sunk was the Nagato (or was it the tone) and I have encircled and destroyed 120k men .
It’s a fun little campaign, and I unlocked the ca-15 kangaroo as my interceptor, which is pretty funny now I think about it, as well as somewhere over 12 heavy cruisers, 1 battleship, and two escort carriers. Australia’s actually pretty fun.
They really should, and the early indications show they have started to do so. If they did try to land in France or Italy, even with Germany as it is, they’d probably not get far, considering the dogs breakfast they made of Africa. A landing in Sicily would at least divert the Fascists and probably allow us to hasten our own plans. Which might include a landing in southern Italy to seal that off, trap whatever was south of us, then prosecute a war on two fronts. But we’ll be keeping a close eye on Spain, that’s for sure.I'm thinking the UK should really be focusing on the far East rather than sicily (not likely they are going to get anything in post war europe anyway).
We mea while are doing well, but the british action in sardinia is worrying. They may yet scoop France or Italy or even bits of both away from us before the end. If they do, it really messes with postwar strategy and getting at Spain for VP...better hope they send everything to India or Australia then.