• We have updated our Community Code of Conduct. Please read through the new rules for the forum that are an integral part of Paradox Interactive’s User Agreement.
Police states and wide scale repression are not cheap, especially when many of the areas you are trying to repress contain nationalities who in part define themselves as 'Not Turkish'. Worse, after the initial sugar rush of industrialisation and mobilisation Soviet economics tend towards stagflation or worse. Turkey has Persian oil, but the Soviets had the Caucasus' and Siberian oil and all it did was stave off the inevitable. I think Turkey's path would mirror Russias, a post-war boom of rebuilding and herding peasant farmers into factories and then a mire of stagnation, corruption and waste propped up by oil export revenue.

Of course Turkey could try and steer it's own course, but it (should be) far harder to escape the Comintern than enter. I would expect Soviet 'advisers' to fly into Ankara to correct the government should any Trotyskist counter-revolutionary splitters try to deviate from the true path of marxist-leninist-stalinism.

I am just making stuff up here but if Turkey went communist it would most probably be in the lines of MDD (Milli Demokratik Devrim - National Democratic Revolution) idea which developed in the second half of the 60s in the favorable conditions after the left wing coup of 1961. There was the actions by students against USA 6th fleet, the huge workers' revolt of 1970, and finally they came very close to seizing the power altogether in 1971 where a coup by MDD elements in the army (the head of the attempt, Cemal Madanoğlu is probably a colonel in your army in this timeline and probably rising faster than he would be in real life. I would recommend adding him as a general or staff at one point) failed at the last minute and there was a counter coup by the reactionaries which started the demise of left movements in Turkey until today.

MDD does not advise the takeover of all farms by the state and forming kolhozs. Instead it takes the land from the owners who are mostly extremely rich landowners and distribute it to people who are actually working on the land more or less equally. This would have prevented a lot of problems USSR experienced in real life. It would be more like a less state-capitalism China or a bigger scale Yugoslavia or a less rigid USSR.

my 2 cents.

EDIT: I found this english article. A long read but explains the left movements in early Republican era into modern era quite well

http://ydemokrat.blogspot.nl/2010/10/emergence-of-socialist-movements-in.html
 
Last edited:
  • 1
Reactions:
Thanks Professor M :). The GU is starting to approach the SU in size, scope and diversity, if not in power, population or economic capacity. Such rivalries are natural.
Just highlighting your narrative. We know your alternative Turkey is still bound my ambitions but do you find it odd, that your tale seems "nearly" a purer form of rivalry versus what we all must endure today watching the world stage?:)

Btw, regarding your two AARs in-action...man are you doing a bang-up job on both. The commitment and quality in both is extraordinary. Great work on both!
 
  • 1
Reactions:
Just highlighting your narrative. We know your alternative Turkey is still bound my ambitions but do you find it odd, that your tale seems "nearly" a purer form of rivalry versus what we all must endure today watching the world stage?:)

Btw, regarding your two AARs in-action...man are you doing a bang-up job on both. The commitment and quality in both is extraordinary. Great work on both!
Thank you my friend for the kind words. I’m enjoying them both, and hope they can give others some pleasure as they do me. :) On events: well, the time and alt-world of TT I guess lend themselves to a simpler view of things. The purposes then were clearer - though the situation dire (I hope it doesn’t get that bad again in our current world any time soon).

Your comment brought a line from Billy Joel’s Allentown to mind, and a feeling of lost simplicity, purpose, mixed with nostalgia and missed potential. I will adapt it to TT, as if being sung in the future about the deeds now being done in the war from the Turkish perspective: “Well our fathers fought the Second Great War; spent their weekends on the Bosporus Shore.” We will find out whether it ever really mattered at all! ;)
 
  • 1
Reactions:
Your comment brought a line from Billy Joel’s Allentown to mind, and a feeling of lost simplicity, purpose, mixed with nostalgia and missed potential. I will adapt it to TT, as if being sung in the future about the deeds now being done in the war from the Turkish perspective: “Well our fathers fought the Second Great War; spent their weekends on the Bosporus Shore.” We will find out whether it ever really mattered at all!
I'll be on the lookout.
 
  • 1
Reactions:
Vicky2 is the reputed economic simulator of the Paradox series. Since war on a grand scale isn't that likely (we hope) past the second world war, economics and politics take over again as the main movers in the world. It would be interesting to see if Turkey can survive beyond the war period that spawned it or if it quickly becomes a sick man of Euopre yet again.

Police states and wide scale repression are not cheap, especially when many of the areas you are trying to repress contain nationalities who in part define themselves as 'Not Turkish'. Worse, after the initial sugar rush of industrialisation and mobilisation Soviet economics tend towards stagflation or worse. Turkey has Persian oil, but the Soviets had the Caucasus' and Siberian oil and all it did was stave off the inevitable. I think Turkey's path would mirror Russias, a post-war boom of rebuilding and herding peasant farmers into factories and then a mire of stagnation, corruption and waste propped up by oil export revenue.

Of course Turkey could try and steer it's own course, but it (should be) far harder to escape the Comintern than enter. I would expect Soviet 'advisers' to fly into Ankara to correct the government should any Trotyskist counter-revolutionary splitters try to deviate from the true path of marxist-leninist-stalinism.

I am just making stuff up here but if Turkey went communist it would most probably be in the lines of MDD (Milli Demokratik Devrim - National Democratic Revolution) idea which developed in the second half of the 60s in the favorable conditions after the left wing coup of 1961. There was the actions by students against USA 6th fleet, the huge workers' revolt of 1970, and finally they came very close to seizing the power altogether in 1971 where a coup by MDD elements in the army (the head of the attempt, Cemal Madanoğlu is probably a colonel in your army in this timeline and probably rising faster than he would be in real life. I would recommend adding him as a general or staff at one point) failed at the last minute and there was a counter coup by the reactionaries which started the demise of left movements in Turkey until today.

MDD does not advise the takeover of all farms by the state and forming kolhozs. Instead it takes the land from the owners who are mostly extremely rich landowners and distribute it to people who are actually working on the land more or less equally. This would have prevented a lot of problems USSR experienced in real life. It would be more like a less state-capitalism China or a bigger scale Yugoslavia or a less rigid USSR.

my 2 cents.

EDIT: I found this english article. A long read but explains the left movements in early Republican era into modern era quite well

http://ydemokrat.blogspot.nl/2010/10/emergence-of-socialist-movements-in.html
Thanks for these comments and cross-referential ideas. I will see where things get to once this AAR finally ends (though that may be some time yet). Still not sure if you can convert backwards from HOI3 to Vicky 2, and can't research that for now, but at the least it has been an interesting diversion. :)

Thanks to all commenters in the lead up to, during and following the 'Cabinet Meeting Trilogy' of chapters. Hope I haven't missed any replies/questions along the way.

OK, now to the next chapter. This one reverts to the battlefield, though with a few asides. I've decided to keep this one together, though I could have broken it up into two (a largely Turkey-focused battlefield chapter and the usual monthly global strategic summary), which this time also marks one year since the invasion of Poland and the beginning of Great War Two. But I will keep it as one larger edition for completeness - some weekend/holiday reading! ;)

Thanks once again for any comments, large or small (even just a single sentence is welcome). Or even an 'agree' just to show you've read and didn't think it was too bad.

PS: And thanks to whichever readAAR bumped this AAR over the 30,000 views mark in the last day (and to those who contributed to the 29,999 views before that)! :):):):cool:
 
Last edited:
  • 1
Reactions:
Chapter 92: The Year the World Burned (16 August to 1 September 1940)
Chapter 92: The Year the World Burned (16 August to 1 September 1940)

1. Prologue

As the War Cabinet meeting concludes, Persephonee finds herself still Acting Editor of the Path to Glory 'news' (ie state propaganda) magazine. She is in need of an editorial for the next day’s edition. An anonymous letter has been provided by a mysterious source. The author seems to be classically educated and perhaps some insider bureaucrat in the foreign affairs or state security apparatus. There seems to be something almost Shakespearean about the language, she thinks to herself … [ahem!]

Anyway, the author has volunteered this piece for the PtG’s use and it seems just the kind of jingoistic pro-government bromide needed at this time. With just a little editing for the readership (she wouldn’t use the term ‘dumbing down’, out loud, anyway), it will do just fine. She has been very busy of late, trying to impress her Turkish employers in the hope of not only replacing BJ Guildenstern as the editor of the PtG, but indeed assuming his overall role as the chief consultant in the propaganda department. She is fully dedicated to this purpose, with a surprising fervour and determination: this has been noticed by her superiors. If this latest foray works well, she could be offered the position, at which time she has a few good ideas to throw into the mix. Including a name for the editor of the new pro-Comintern tabloid they are looking to launch soon.

Editorial for the Path to Glory, Edition XCII, 17 August 1940

Loyal Readers, Patriotic Turks! To mark our entry and continued success in the Great Liberation War to Defeat Fascism, we present this rousing tribute to the power and bravery of Turkey and the Union of Glorious National Republics. It describes the first days of the war and our march to meet the Fascist enemy. Read on, and let these words inspire pride and determination in the bosom of every citizen.

Now all the youth of Turkey are on fire,
And fancy clothing in the wardrobe lies:
Now thrive the armourers, and honour's thought
Reigns solely in the breast of every man:
They trade the plough now for the gun,
Following the example of our Glorious Leaders,
With winged heels, as if Turkish Hermes.
For now sits Expectation in the air,
And hides a bayonet from hilt up to the point
With liberation, glory and laurel wreaths,
Promised to the Milli Şef and his followers.
The Germans, advised by good intelligence
Of this most dreadful preparation,
Shook in their fear and with pale policy
Sought to divert the Turkish purposes.
O Turkey! model to your inward greatness,
Like little body with a mighty heart,
What might you do, that honour would you do,
Were all your children kind and natural!
But see your fault! Germany has in you found out
A nest of hollow bosoms, which he fills
With treacherous spies and Mafia gangsters.
One, Virgil Sollozzo called ‘The Turk’, and the second,
Muhtar, Captain of Polis, and the third,
Bruno of Tattaglia, in far off Sicily,
Did, for Fascist gilt, - Oh guilt indeed!
Confirm a Great Conspiracy with fearful Italy;
That by their hands our Glorious Milli Şef would die,
If hell and treason hold their promises,
Before he should head to the Front, and in Istanbul.
Linger your patience on; and we'll digest
The abuse of distance; force a play:
The sum was paid; the traitors were agreed;
The President set out from Ankara; and the scene
Was set, gentlefolk, in Istanbul;
Where this foul plot was laid to rest:
Two plotters righteously dead, the other still distantly abed;
And after to the Front the President was safely conveyed.
Two strikes and yet a third to be made dead!

EFShcc.jpg

Like a Winged Hermes do Turkish youths rush to the colours to defend the Motherland and fight Fascism!

This last will also serve as a public message to the Tattaglia clan and the Mafia more widely: designed to cow them and publicly proclaim that they will be “done slowly”, to force them into rash error or craven hiding. If Bruno did not already know it, he is a very obviously marked man.

---xxx---​

2. Contingency Plan Orange – Reorganisation

No sooner had Cabinet (16 August) decided on its plan to prepare for a possible strike in Hungary than forces began to receive their orders. Initially, the selected units for the new force were ordered to the assembly area in Timisoara, where one of the intended units – 8 Inf Div (Lt) – already waited. HQ 3 Corps would eventually be placed in command. Reallocation of corps commands across the front would occur once units were largely in place.

Fa6ayA.jpg

As discussed in Cabinet, 1 Cav Div (now basically an armoured division) and the pride of the army – the mighty 1 Inf Div – would join them, along with the more recently raised 12 Inf Div (Support). Normal movement would be used, to save supplies and ensure the units being moved would be ready to fight at any time along the way or on arrival. 1 Cav Div arrived in Timisoara on 25 August, HQ 3 Corps on 27 August and 1 Inf Div on 28 August, with 12 Inf Div still on the way (it would still be travelling at the end of the month).

Corps command reorganisations are carried out on the night of 28 August. On the south of the Yeniçeri Line, 3 Inf Div was reallocated to 2nd Corps, which is now spread with one division across five frontline provinces from the Adriatic north-east to Visegrad, where the corps boundary with 1st Corps will run. The only reserve is the reinforced Corps HQ itself. However, it is good defensive terrain and the front has been very quiet, so the risk will be run until a new reserve can be constituted.

JOs8VE.jpg

1st Corps is allocated 6 Inf Div (in Ada) and 9 Inf Div (in Kikinda), on the most active part of the line: north-east from Visegrad to the Romanian border. With two divisions defending Sabac (on the boundary with 2nd Corps) and two in the hotspot of Ada (10 Inf Div where will remain under 3rd Corps command for now), the only reserve is again the Corps HQ, located in Beograd.

20JwwN.jpg

HQ 3 Corps now has its full quota of divisions attached, although 10 Inf Div cannot yet be spared for offensive tasks and will need to man the defensive line in support of 1st Corps until more troops can be found to man it (or 15 Inf Div is returned from its duties in the Mediterranean).

Ub6oyA.jpg

And early on the morning of 1 September the impressive new Soviet-licensed tank destroyer brigade was raised in Kikinda and immediately sent to Timisoara, where it would join 1 Cav Div and reinforce to full strength.

7JQXeo.jpg

---xxx---​

3. The Second Battle of Ada

29 Aug 40

Staying on the Yeniçeri Line, soon after the corps reorganisations were completed, the Axis launched another attack on Ada, at 1am. It seemed this would be the focal point of their efforts! Things started off in a similar fashion to the earlier attack, with this time a Slovakian division leading the assault across the river from Srboban. Despite their superior leadership and tactics, the battlefield balance was very heavily weighted against the attackers, who are assaulting entrenched troops defending a river line. Given the relative lack of action on the Turkish front for the last few months and the importance of this engagement as a test of the plan to strip additional forces from the line for a possible attack in Hungary, there will be quite a detailed focus on this battle.

R73aEg.jpg

But only two hours later, the Slovakians were joined by two German infantry divisions, currently in reserve, with the attack now coming from three separate directions. This may prove a sterner test than in the first battle. At least the Plan Orange forces are concentrated nearby if support is needed (either a diversionary attack on the German 28th Inf Div in Senta or reinforcements for Ada).

fI37QQ.jpg

Alarmingly, by 8am both the German divisions have reinforced – very unlike last time, when the supporting divisions never did. This improves the Axis’ odds significantly. In addition, Hungarian aircraft have begun bombing the gallant Turkish defenders, causing 92 casualties in two comparatively light raids that day.

jsu2RZ.jpg

30 Aug 40

By 2am the next day, in the face of a gradually declining position, the Axis forces, commanded by the Slovakian MAJGEN Turanec [SK3], go all out with an attempt at a masterful breakthrough. The less experienced Turkish commander, MAJGEN Gürler [SK1], does his best to counter this with delay tactics.

zs3BZd.jpg

The battle rages all that day, but by 8pm the German 28th Inf Div withdraws from the battle and is in retreat from Senta. The Slovakian 2nd Inf Div has lost a lot of organisation but remain persistently committed to the battle. So far, the defence of Ada is looking solid, so no plans are made to send any reinforcements.

6cRd0I.jpg

31 Aug 40

The battle goes on and by 5am that morning, the Slovakians stubbornly remain in the battle and Italian aircraft join in, but the effort is now fading badly. In four Italian air raids over the next 24 hours, Turkish defenders sustain 449 casualties. In acknowledgement of the Slovakian efforts, visiting Slovakian President ('Vodca') Jozef Tiso is granted an audience with Hitler, who is hosting a meeting of the Axis leadership the next day to commemorate the anniversary of the launch of their war of aggression, a conflict which has now spread to become the Second Great War. This petty dictator is feted by Hitler now - but should beware if he ever comes before a Peoples' Court (either Soviet or Turkish) in the future!

6ASnCj.jpg

By 9am that morning the Slovakians are on their last legs and by 1pm they finally pull out of the battle, but hold their position in Srboban, leaving the command of the battle to German MAJGEN von Stülpnagel and his still relatively fresh 17th Inf Div. The Turkish 6 Inf Div has by now suffered some attrition, but still appears to be holding strong. With no other Axis reinforcements seen nearby, and despite continuing Italian air raids every eight hours, it looks like they will hold comfortably.

gNiBZT.jpg

1 Sep 40

By 7am on the anniversary of the start of GW2, the battle continues, with the Germans now trying shock tactics to try to blast their way through, but are making little headway.

---xxx---​

4. Operation Rodos Devi

16 Aug 40

The other operational decision to emerge from the recent Cabinet meeting was the plan to probe Rhodes in preparation for a possible invasion (Op Rodos Devi – ‘Colossus of Rhodes’). This would commence with an air phase, with the Navy and 15 Inf Div waiting in readiness should the circumstances seem propitious to do so.

15 Inf Div and the main fleet are already concentrated in Athens and ready for immediate loading and operations, as required. Orders are given for Hitay’s interceptor wing in Crete to maintain continuous air superiority patrols over Rhodes, while Örlungat’s tactical bombers are trying a new (for Turkey) tactic: they are going to hit the Italian airfield to try to damage facilities and impede the Italian’s naval bombers. The plan is to see how the air engagements pan out, then switch to ground preparation attacks later. Örlungat is using this operation as something of a battlefield testing ground – he will be very cautious before ordering ground attacks and a naval landing here. It also means, in an emergency, 15 Inf Div can still be sent by rail to the front if it is needed during the reallocation of forces there. By 12:00, the first airfield cratering raid on Rhodes is in progress.

D8tSI7.jpg

In four raids on 16 and 17 August, the Turks do around 40% damage to the airfield, reducing in from four to about two and a half wings repair capacity. But only two Italian wings are based there and the attrition on the Turkish TAC wing’s low organisation (unimproved by any doctrine advances) sees a rest ordered. These are mixed results, but interesting for the air force’s strategists.

j37tqg.jpg

20 Aug 40

There is a short air battle over Rhodes. Little damage is done on either side and no conclusive results are apparent.

nIoFd1.jpg

Given the Italian air sortie and after a few days of rest, Örlungat’s Blenheims resume cratering attacks on Rhodes the same day. A report from one such raid (on 21 August) is shown below.

vlr1Hj.jpg

23 Aug 40

Over the following three days 40% more damage is again done to the airfield, reducing (and noting repair efforts) its efficiency to about 1.75 wings at a time. But by the morning of 23 August organisation is again run down [to around 21 out of 34 maximum], so Örlungat again orders his bombers to rest. Once back up to strength, they will be directed to ground attack role to attempt a pre-invasion ‘softening up’.

28 Aug 40

As part of the general corps reorganisation, 15 Inf Div is reallocated from HQ 3 Corps to HQ 1st Army Group, in preparation for any naval landing.

31 Aug - 1 Sep 40

There is another inconclusive interception of Italian naval bombers over Rhodes on 31 August. And on the morning of 1 September, Örlungat reports the organisation of the tactical bombers is back to about 84% [28.5/34.0]. He won’t send them back in until they are back up to full strength, because once committed to ground attack they will be run to the point of exhaustion.

---xxx---​

5. Strategic Summaries

The monthly ACCC report is exchanged with the Allies and the usual reports from Comintern partners are compiled for a special ‘Anniversary of the Outbreak of GW2’ presentation to Cabinet members (provided on this occasion as a written dossier).

France

One year on, Germany has made slow but steady progress on the Western Front. Denmark, Holland and Belgium have been occupied, while a large slice of northern France is also now under the German jackboot. With the occupation of Troyes [2 VP] in the last fortnight, French surrender progress gradually climbs but is not yet at a critical level.

NE924A.jpg

France, overall situation 1 September 1940.

A more detailed map shows the tactical situation as reported by the French. Although there have again been no lightning breakthroughs, there are two principal areas of concern. First is the group of four provinces to the north-east of Paris that have been won by the Germans. This isolates Calais in the north and approaches ever closer to the capital itself, with the occupation of the forests of Arras, Amiens and Compeigne. The second area of concern is in the centre, where the Germans have taken the key city of Troyes and a wide band of provinces in a line south-east to Xertigny. This is an area of open terrain with few natural obstacles left. It also threatens to isolate the remaining strongly held portion of the Maginot Line.

GCZuDv.jpg

There has been no change in the situation in southern France, nor on Sardinia, where France has occupied Cagliari but advanced no further. But in the last two weeks, there has been some action in French North Africa, with a single Italian militia division having seized four Tunisian provinces unopposed.

Ppuq8Q.jpg

Tunisia, 1 September 1940.

Western Desert

This theatre has seen Britain basically hand over the whole campaign to the Iraqi Army, which appears to have the Italians completely on the run. Over the last two weeks they have thrown the Italians out of the key city of Tobruk [3 VP] and defeated them in Gazala, where two enemy divisions are in danger of being surrounded and bagged if the Iraqi 4th Inf Div can complete a flanking move into At Tamimi. Of course, with their French allies under the hammer, this begs the question of what the hell Britain is doing elsewhere!

gXdZAP.jpg

Hungary

Early in the preceding period, Romanian and Soviet forces were able to break through from Bekescsaba and advance as far as Szolnok on 24 August, prompting Inönü to add Budapest to the list of objectives Turkey has asked the Soviets to target (it was already a Romanian objective). But a strong Axis counter-attack soon saw Szolnok retaken on 25 August and then then rolled on to retake Bekescsaba by late on 31 August.

Along the front, provinces were swapped back and forth by Romania and Hungary – with the much-contested Debrecen yet again changing hands and back in Hungarian possession, meaning all the victory objectives in Hungary are again back in enemy hands. In the south, Senta was again seized by the Axis on 25 August, which (as we saw above) was then used as a base for flanking Ada a couple of days later. This also prompted the Romanians being asked on 27 August to defend Timisoara (which borders Senta), so that the contingency assault force can be freed up in case it is called into action.

By 1 September, the Soviets seem to have thinned out their forces present in Romania, which has undermined the earlier advances, given a large proportion of the Romanian Army is now headed to the Far East (another corps at least looks to have been put on trains towards the Far Eastern Front. Conditions there are not yet propitious for a major Turkish offensive.

hicvqK.jpg

Soviet Sector

Few provinces have changed hands on the Soviet Sector after another two weeks, but one of them is significant: the fortified city of Bialystock. To the north, a large Soviet attack seems to be going in on Tilsit and Gumbinnen, but the Soviets appear to be retreating along the Lithuanian SSR border. The see-sawing pattern of combat continues: clearly, without any armour in play, the Germans will find it hard to make any big gains here, even with the inspiration of Hitler’s Destiny propaganda still in force. It is a war of attrition that will hopefully break them in time.

However, with Bialystock lost, further south Bielsk Podlaski was taken, in turn threatening the important centre of Brest-Litovsk. Though it looks like a Soviet counter-attack is set to retake Bielsk Podlaski. In the Polish Salient over the Bug River, the Germans have managed to retake Jaroslaw and are attacking Bilgoraj – though Soviet snipers take a heavy toll in this close combat. More promisingly, a corps-sized Soviet assault is going in on Krasnystaw, led by a powerful medium tank division, fighting a division German SS Panzergrenadiers (among others). The German line is thin here, so it will be interesting to see if any real headway can be made in September.

YiZ18R.jpg

A large scale map shows the current front line across the entirety of the Eastern Front.

gqqLpz.jpg

Far East

The Romanian reinforcement vanguard is now half-way between the Aral Sea and Lake Balkash.

Be2WO6.jpg

The situation further east remains dire, with the Soviet Far Eastern forces still not out of danger of encirclement.

ej3Vpg.jpg

The main body of the Soviet Far Eastern forces remain in headlong retreat – which is just as well, given the danger they are in of being cut off by Japanese advances from Manchuria (Manchukuo) further west. There is a long way to relative safety yet.

0fY02j.jpg

---xxx---​

6. General

16 Aug 40

News Report: Washington DC, US. The Spanish Surrealist artist Salvador Dalí and wife Gala arrived in New York to escape the war in Europe.

yijKZF.jpg

Dalí photographed by Carl Van Vechten on 29 November 1939. Salvador Domingo Felipe Jacinto Dalí i Domènech, Marquis of Dalí de Púbol (b. 11 May 1904) is a prominent Spanish surrealist artist.

9B8L8y.jpg

Dalí’s extraordinary ‘Persistence of Memory’, painted in 1931.

17 Aug 40

News Report: Elwood, Indiana, US. Wendell Willkie makes a speech in his hometown of Elwood, Indiana formally accepting the Republican nomination for President. Willkie promises to return "to those same American principles that overcame German autocracy once before, both in business and in war, to out-distance Hitler in any contest he chooses in 1940 or after."

19 Aug 40

News Report: Washington DC, US. Gallup publishes the results of a poll asking Americans whether they approved of a proposal to sell 50 old destroyers to England. 62% approved of the idea, 38% disapproved.

23 Aug 40

News Report: London, UK. King George VI commands that the names of all Germans and Italians be stricken from the lists of British titles and decorations. The order affects Benito Mussolini, who had been made a member of the Order of the Bath in 1923, as well as King Victor Emmanuel III who had been a member of the Order of the Garter. No prominent Nazis are affected as few Germans hold any British titles.

24 Aug 40

News Report: Oxford, UK. A team of pathologists at Oxford University including Howard Florey, Ernst Chain and Norman Heatley publish laboratory results in The Lancet describing methods for the production of penicillin and the effects of its chemotherapeutic action on lab mice.

31 Aug 40

Naval Report. In the last two weeks, one more German submarine flotilla has been sunk, bringing the total since the war began a year ago to nine. No other naval units are reported sunk since 15 August.

---xxx---

7. Secret War

In Zurich, Vito and Sonny Ceylan debate the way ahead for the S.I.T.H. campaign against the Mafia in Sicily. Sonny chafes under his father's more conservative approach, but would not dare openly defy him. After the failed attempt by Luca Brasi to infiltrate the Tattaglia crime family, Cennet is also recalled to Zurich. Darth Kelebek takes advantage of the slow period to make one of his trademark ‘disappearances’ – to do who knows what. Rumours of him heading towards Mt Etna (conveniently located in Sicily, not far from the Tattaglia’s home base) for some kind of ‘rest cure’ cannot be confirmed. Apart from a cryptic remark about ‘fond memories of 1766’, as usual nothing is confirmed or denied.

qCLPeT.jpg

An artist’s impression of Mt. Etna’s eruption in 1766.

No spies were apprehended in the Glorious Union during this time – fortunate for them, given Kaya’s continuing ill-humour following the Cabinet meeting of 16 August. Had he caught one, he may have tried to rival the cruel ferocity of Kelebek’s interrogation techniques, such was his residual anger and rededication to maintaining harsh internal security and repression.

For their part, the Tattaglia’s also laid low for now, as too much violence can be ‘bad for business’. They also consider themselves to be secure in their Sicilian stronghold. Time will tell as to whether that is a safe assumption. They do not yet rise to any propaganda baits offered by the Turks: they disdain the efforts of those Turkish pezzonovante and their laughable literary barbs in the latest Path to Glory magazine. Verbally threaten a Sicilian? Amateurs! Though Bruno Tattaglia has recently doubled his security detail and now avoids public places.

---xxx---​

Coming Up: Has the French campaign become a ‘long slow wave goodbye’? Or do the Germans lack the numbers in the west to back up their panzer divisions and deliver a knockout blow before winter. The battle in Ada looks like it may soon be ended favourably, but will the Axis try again, there or elsewhere on the Yeniçeri Line? Will the Iraqi Army go all the way and toss the Italians out of Libya? Will the British Army do anything, let alone rescue their hard-pressed French allies on the Western Front? Probably not!

The situation in Hungary and on the Eastern Front looks like it will continue to be closely contested for the foreseeable future – but will an opportunity present itself for a Turkish offensive in coming weeks or months? And will the trigger be pressed for a full attack on Rhodes, or will the passage of time and innate caution prevent the risk being taken? And finally, can the Soviets rescue their beleaguered forces in the Far East and somehow stabilise a defensive line further west – where even the independence of Mongolia is in danger?
 
Last edited:
  • 1Love
Reactions:
Well, 1766 was nice as a getaway but 1815 remains my favourite so far. I Keep meaning to get back into it but alas, the national park keeps distracting me.

I think having a newsletter is a great idea! Kelebek can do a column, we can hear all the latest from the Soviets from friendly agents, a few wise words from the minister of the week (failing that, the minister of the interior each time) and lots of pretty pictures to distract the population!

The Hungarian front remains the theoretical weak spot for us to take advantage of, but saying that, turkey remains the theoretical weak spot for the axis. We might not see any movement in till France falls now. Or if Russia breaks through in the north and Hungary ends up surrounded in spite of everything...

Rhodes might be alright if we have that much power that we can isolate them from Italian reinforcements and slowly wear them down. Once it's ours, we'll have some more experienced units and air teams, and will have patched up the last real hole in our defence (short of a full scale naval invasion of all the axis working together).

Good read as always. Maybe I'll see you in the bARR downtown? It's just popped back into existence.

Oh, and well done on getting 30k views. Rememer the first time i got loads, on ffnet. The feedback here though makes the audience seen huge all the time though.
 
  • 1
Reactions:
VhqIKx.jpg

Start Year:
1936, standard Road to War
Difficulty: Normal
Version: Vanilla TFH 4.02
Cheats/Mods: "Prepare for War" event extended to 12 March 1937*
Style: Gameplay as alternate history, with screenshots

IJJUwo.jpg

President Kemal Atatürk entering the Grand National Assembly of Turkey in 1936.
Stormy and difficult times lie head. Especially in this alternate world of Turkish Glory.

Introduction

This is my first AAR. I hope (if enough dear readers sign on) for the AAR to be fun and inclusive. By that I mean I will welcome advice on both the game and readability as we go along and do my best to satisfy requests for info and the like. I will try to work on improving presentation etc. as I go along – as I say, the forum and this AAR gig are all new to me.

PS: now the AAR is well established, you may be looking at having a read but it taking quite a while to catch up. If you do, please feel free to make any comments on those earlier chapters if anything interests or amuses you along the way! I know I sometimes feel reluctant to do so in other AARs, but would thoroughly welcome it here, so you feel part of the conversation - always happy to get feedback or answer questions. :) [5 Nov 17]

Modification [*added 1 Feb 2017]

As a relatively new player, and not having tested this aspect before, I did not realise the "Prepare for War" event had a time limit of 300 days (I know, I didn't read the small print when I fired the event:oops:). It was only after I reviewed the end of the first game year (and saw neutrality reduction had ground to a halt) that I discovered the event had stopped, with Turkey's very high starting neutrality (90) not dropped to anything that would provide the kind of options the game and AAR were based on.

After reading up and (to continue the game as intended and not keep myself or readers waiting for years for anything to happen), I modified the 1 Jan 37 save file to reflect where neutrality would have fallen to had the Prepare for War event continued up to that point. I then extended it to end on 12 March 1937: this would leave a small residual neutrality level (ie not reducing it to 0), meaning that to declare war on a potential adversary there would still need to be some threat level there (not making it too easy, thus requiring some work to get a 'case for war').

Apart from playability, I think this is a reasonable scenario assumption in this case, as the premise is the Government is preparing the nation for war and would not simply stop preparing to do so at an arbitrary point. That's my justification anyway ;) (I hadn't wanted to make any changes to the base game, not even using custom game, unless I had to).

AAR Style

I might occasionally pose some strategic questions as a kind of informal War Cabinet: set the issue out, put a few initial pros and cons, seek advice, then make my own decision. I have chosen Turkey as it is large enough to have some potential, but small enough to be able to cope with some detailed AAR reporting and my preferred micromanagement game style (which you really need if you're going to succeed with a minor).

I will play and update turn by turn (as regularly as work/real life let me) so any game advice offered by you will be ‘real time’ for the next phase. You will not know any less than me about what happens next! I will undertake to let you know if I’m going to be away/offline for a while, as a courtesy.

I’ll try to apply a few ‘realistic touches’ if I can to strategy debates, operational reporting and world events as alternate history. A bit as if you were being provided confidential reports as government ministers being kept up to date on the war. But I won’t be pretending to be a Turk (which would be lame and probably a bit insulting), try to use the language (other than a few words translated for operational titles and the like) or get too cute with that kind of thing. You’ll have to imagine it as originally Turkish but translated into English!

As the AAR has developed I've also thrown in a bit of narrative storytelling and humour in between the 'serious stuff'.

If that sounds interesting/a little different, then I hope you will give me a go :).

Game Goals

Quite simple, only a few really:

1. I've made no pre-game decision yet on which faction to join, but I will eventually join one. So my first goal is to get my chosen faction to ‘win’ the game (the standard 12 objectives). That means I will try to be a good faction partner and will be active in trying to set its direction, as much as I can.

2. The Second goal is to secure as many VPs for Turkey as possible within that victory framework.

3. My third goal is a fall-back if my faction doesn't win: survive as a minor through to 31 Dec 1948 with as much as I can hold onto - which can sometimes be pretty desperate, hard fought and close run. But if at any stage another faction 'wins' (the 12 objectives) before the game times out, I will throw in the towel: beat is beat!​

Game Style

I’m usually happy to take as many Expeditionary Forces as are offered and I can support. I’m happy to go ahistorical (this is alternative history after all) but not ridiculously gamey. I will try to keep it in the spirit of the reasonable. I won’t reload from base saves if I do something silly and the AI takes advantage (it usually needs all the help it can get), or a calculated risk fails to pay off and disaster strikes - even if it means likely defeat. So be it – it might add a bit of excitement! I have also taken a"no tag" pledge, even for recalcitrant puppets!

Qualification: no tags to play the game or change anything about another country, but I have tagged later, just for selected screen shots for war reporting, consistent with storytelling and the kind of info you would eventually see in papers or get through other (liaison or intelligence) reporting. And for something to keep things more lively during those 'boring' periods of peace! ;)

So please follow: if you do, let me know if you are running any current AARs and will have a look at yours too.:)

Contents

Book One: The New Balkan War

Chapter 1: First Things First (1 January 1936)
Chapter 2: Early Days (1 January to 30 April 1936)
Chapter 3: Special Cabinet Policy Meeting (1 May 1936)
Chapter 4: The Hibernating Giant Begins to Awake (1 May to 31 August 1936)
Chapter 5: Armed Forces Reorganisation and Battle Plans (1 September 1936)
Chapter 6: Destiny Awaits (1 September to 31 December 1936)
Chapter 7: Prelude to War (1 January to 14 March 1937)
Chapter 8: War against Bulgaria - Operation Kleidion #1 (15 to 21 March 1937)
Chapter 9: War against Bulgaria - Operation Kleidion #2 (21 to 26 March 1937)
Chapter 10: Victory in Bulgaria (26 March to 4 April 1937)
Chapter 11: The ‘Shaky Peace’ (5 to 24 April 1937)

Chapter 12: War with Greece #1 "Operation Büyük Taarruz" (25 to 28 April 1937)
Chapter 13: War with Greece #2 – "The Salonica Pocket" (29 April to 5 May 1937)
Chapter 14: The “Three-Pronged Fork Memo" (6 May 1937)
Chapter 15: War with Greece #3 – "The Road to Larisa" (6 to 11 May 1937)
Chapter 16a: A Fork in the Road (12 May 1937)
Chapter 16b: Our Path to Greatness (12 May 1937)

Chapter 17: War with Greece #4 – "Four Battles" (12 to 17 May 1937)
Chapter 18: War with Greece #5 – “A String of Pearls” (17 to 21 May 1937)
Chapter 19: War with Greece #6 – "All In" (21 to 29 May 1937)
Chapter 20: War with Greece #7 – “Operation Minotaur” (29 May to 4 June 1937)
Chapter 21: War with Greece #8 – “Five Hours” (4 to 6 June 1937)
Chapter 22: War with Greece #9 – “Antici…….pation!” (6 to 29 June 1937)
Chapter 23: The Greater Turkish Republic (29 June 1937)
Chapter 24: 'Peace is Preparation for War by Other Means' (29 June to 6 July 1937)
Chapter 25: The Summer of Love and Hate (6 July to 18 August 1937)
Chapter 26: A Friendship Renewed (18 to 29 August 1937)
Chapter 27: The Apotheosis of Şükrü Âli Ögel (29 August 1937)
Chapter 28: Speak Loudly and Carry a Large Hammer (29 August to 30 September 1937)
Chapter 29: Using a Hammer to Crack a Nut (1 to 16 October 1937)
Chapter 30: Hammer and Anvil – Opening Blows (16 October to 3 November 1937)
Chapter 31: The Battle of Beograd – “Just Waiting for the Hammer to Fall” (3 to 9 November 1937)
Chapter 32: Breakout in Yugoslavia – “Caught Between the Hammer and the Anvil” (9 to 18 November 1937)
Chapter 33: War in Central Yugoslavia – “Going Hammer and Tongs” (18 to 24 November 1937)
Chapter 34: Pocketed! (24 to 29 November 1937)
Chapter 35: The Hard Yards (29 November to 3 December 1937)
Chapter 36: ‘A Mountain of Pain’ (4 to 9 December 1937)
Chapter 37: Split the Difference (9 December 1937 to 9 January 1938)
Chapter 38: Janus (9 January 1938)


Book Two: The Path to Glory

Chapter 39: 'The Path to Glory is Paved with Choices' (10 January 1938)
Chapter 40: Atatürk Declares “The Trains Will Run on Time” (10 to 31 January 1938)
Chapter 41: As Clear as Mud (1 to 28 February 1938)
Chapter 42: Springtime for Hitler (1 to 12 March 1938)
Chapter 43: The Wages of Sin (13 to 31 March 1938)
Chapter 44: The Invisible Men (1 to 30 April 1938)
Chapter 45: Mud, Blood, Mountains and Auditors (1 to 31 May 1938)
Chapter 46: ‘An Army of Lions’ (1 to 16 June 1938)
Chapter 47: Give and Take (17 to 30 June 1938)
Chapter 48: ‘A Ray of Hope for the World’ (1 to 31 July 1938)
Chapter 49: Triumph and Tension (1 to 31 August 1938)
Chapter 50: ‘Peace for Our Time’ (1 to 30 September 1938)
Chapter 51: ‘The Lights are Going Out’ (1 to 31 October 1938)
Chapter 52: Hibernation (1 November to 31 December 1938)
Chapter 53: Lancers and Liver Pills (1 to 27 January 1939)
Chapter 54: A New Sun Rises for Civilisation (28 January 1939)
Chapter 55: A Long Three Days in Ankara (29 to 31 January 1939)
Chapter 56: A Şik Figür, a sick President, a ‘Sick Man’ and a sick Pope (1 to 9 February 1939)
Chapter 57: A Funeral, a Festival, a Coronation and an Annexation (10 February – 31 March 1939)

Chapter 58: Time is a Thief (1 to 30 April 1939)
Chapter 59: Merry Month of May - Marx, Montenegro and Mafia Madness (1 to 31 May 1939)
Chapter 60: Blood Will Flow (1 to 30 June 1939)
Chapter 61: The Sun Shines while Storms Approach (1 to 31 July 1939)
Chapter 62: To be Red, or not to be? (1 to 30 August 1939)
Chapter 63: Special War Edition (31 August to 7 September 1939)
Chapter 64: Poland in Flames (7 to 14 September 1939)
Chapter 65: “Lepiej umrzeć stojąc”: Better to Die Standing (14 to 20 September 1939)
Chapter 66: Poland’s Agony (21 September to 3 October 1939)
Chapter 67: Wonderful, Wonderful Copenhagen! (3 to 31 October 1939)
Chapter 68: War in the Margins (1 to 30 November 1939)
Chapter 69: The Winter of Their Discontent (1 to 31 December 1939)
Chapter 70: Solidarity Forever! (1 to 31 January 1940)
Chapter 71: Cold Comfort for Finland (1 to 28 February 1940)
Chapter 72: Soviets March Forward in March (1 to 31 March 1940)
Chapter 73: Down and Dirty in the Dutch Dykes (1 to 30 April 1940)
Chapter 74: The Western War – The Low Countries (1 to 15 May 1940)
Chapter 75: Special War Cabinet Meeting (15 May 1940)
Chapter 76: Crescendo! (15 to 31 May 1940)

Book Three: The Great Liberation War

Chapter 77: Dreams and Nightmares (1 to 2 June 1940)
Chapter 78: Romanian Blitz (3 to 6 June 1940)
Chapter 79: The Drums of War (7 to 13 June 1940)
Chapter 80: Troubled Waters – Mediterranean Theatre (14 to 18 June 1940)
Chapter 81: “Going to Hell in a Hand Basket” – Other Fronts (14 to 18 June 1940)
Chapter 82: A Trial of Strength (19 to 30 June 1940)
Chapter 83: Intermezzo (1 July 1940)
Chapter 84: A Tug-of-War (1 to 16 July 1940)
Chapter 85: The Times - A View of the West (16 to 31 July 1940)
Chapter 86: Pravda - The Eastern Perspective (16 to 31 July 1940)
Chapter 87: In the Balance (1 to 15 August 1940)
Chapter 88: Decision Time – Cabinet Pre-Brief (15 August 1940)
Chapter 89: War Cabinet Meeting – ‘Contingency Plan Orange’ (16 August 1940)
Chapter 90: War Cabinet Meeting – Rhodes (16 August 1940)
Chapter 91: War Cabinet Meeting – Revenge (16 August 1940)
Chapter 92: The Year the World Burned (16 August to 1 September 1940)
Right I’m going in! Have been so enthralled by your Viking saga I’m going to get stuck in. Not something I’d usually do with 90 odd chapters to read but I love your style of storytelling. See you on the other side
 
  • 1Like
Reactions:
Right I’m going in! Have been so enthralled by your Viking saga I’m going to get stuck in. Not something I’d usually do with 90 odd chapters to read but I love your style of storytelling. See you on the other side
Thank you Asantahene, you have no idea how much I am thankful for your kind attention! You will see it changes in nature as it develops, bearing in mind it was my first AAR attempt :).

Please, if you do feel like making a comment along the way, as I say in the intro, don’t hesitate to do so. Happy reading :D.
 
  • 1Like
Reactions:
Right I’m going in! Have been so enthralled by your Viking saga I’m going to get stuck in. Not something I’d usually do with 90 odd chapters to read but I love your style of storytelling. See you on the other side

Be warned, our beloved AARthor goes on quite at length, and it may be many moons before you see the light of day once you begin! :p

It's worth it though, have fun!
 
  • 1
Reactions:
She is fully dedicated to this purpose, with a surprising fervour and determination: this has been noticed by her superiors. If this latest foray works well, she could be offered the position, at which time she has a few good ideas to throw into the mix. Including a name for the editor of the new pro-Comintern tabloid they are looking to launch soon.
I think Perse has been listening to her own propaganda too much. This is still 1940s Turkey, worse it is Soviet leaning 1940s Turkey. She is not going to get a senior job with any power, importance or responsibility, that is not he Soviet way and it definitely isn't the Turkish way. If she does get any promotion she will soon find that all the power has been given to her new (male, Turkish, old school Kermalist) boss.

Given she is still working for an obviously evil government, one so evil even an amoral drunk American refuse to work for, I really can't say I'm too upset about this. She may have value in the future though, I can see her becoming one of the text book "useful idiot" collaborators, serving as an example to others of what not to do.

Top work from the Iraqis in North Africa, I really thought the British AI would cock up badly and lose Suez, instead they have very effectively marshalled their minions. Hopefully this frees up forces for their next big intervention; counter-invading Germany via the Friesland Islands.
 
  • 1
Reactions:
I think Perse has been listening to her own propaganda too much. This is still 1940s Turkey, worse it is Soviet leaning 1940s Turkey. She is not going to get a senior job with any power, importance or responsibility, that is not he Soviet way and it definitely isn't the Turkish way. If she does get any promotion she will soon find that all the power has been given to her new (male, Turkish, old school Kermalist) boss.

Given she is still working for an obviously evil government, one so evil even an amoral drunk American refuse to work for, I really can't say I'm too upset about this. She may have value in the future though, I can see her becoming one of the text book "useful idiot" collaborators, serving as an example to others of what not to do.

Top work from the Iraqis in North Africa, I really thought the British AI would cock up badly and lose Suez, instead they have very effectively marshalled their minions. Hopefully this frees up forces for their next big intervention; counter-invading Germany via the Friesland Islands.
An interesting view on Perse's motivations and prospects - you may be proven right, or perhaps she will make her mark in a surprising way. At least her position as a British expat is now less precarious than it was before the entry by Turkey into the war, and the somewhat uneasy co-belligerency the two countries now share. Her longer term prospects are, as you have intimated, quite something else again.
 
  • 1
Reactions:
Well...If she can hold on till the 50s she will be able to hold immense rank in the secret services at least.

And I think the UK is being at least as pragmatic as Turkey is:
They are using their allies as meatshields to serve their own purposes.
They are using puppets to do most of their fighting.
Whilst they sit tight behind immense and powerful defensive lines.
And despite being continually underestimated and joked about, they have probably done the best out of the major powers so far, having lost very few men or resources.
Perhaps they might be more of a challenge than we anticipated?
 
  • 1
Reactions:
Antonescu is very pleased about the appearance of the Turkish 3rd Corps nearby the Romanian front. He is definitely not pleased about the recent lost Hungarian provinces as well as the amount of his troops on the way to fight the Japanese.

Btw: Is General Phleps still commanding any Romanian troops?
 
  • 1Like
Reactions:
To be honest I am kind of shocked that France still stands. If the Germans don't smash the French down soon I feel they are going to be in trouble. And what is the US doing in all of this?
 
  • 1Like
Reactions:
Btw: Is General Phleps still commanding any Romanian troops?
I will have to tag to them to find out: but they are a puppet, so that won’t give anything away gameplay-wise.

I wish there was something I could do about the illogical mass move of the Romanian army east (there is more on the wat than just that lead corps). Especially as they are meant to be my puppet, not Uncle Joe’s! :mad: But I guess he’s giving the orders now, having taken over leadership of the war, and that’s the price I have to pay for having them do the brunt of the fighting. :rolleyes:
 
  • 1
Reactions:
Well...If she can hold on till the 50s she will be able to hold immense rank in the secret services at least.

And I think the UK is being at least as pragmatic as Turkey is:
They are using their allies as meatshields to serve their own purposes.
They are using puppets to do most of their fighting.
Whilst they sit tight behind immense and powerful defensive lines.
And despite being continually underestimated and joked about, they have probably done the best out of the major powers so far, having lost very few men or resources.
Perhaps they might be more of a challenge than we anticipated?
Fair points in the main, and their help in that naval battle certainly improved feelings between the two countries. The concern is more about them letting France fall, when a few more troops would probably stabilise the situation - but that’s the game.;)

Perse has hidden strengths - and a lot of determination. She intends to make her mark, and at least she can tell herself she is now fighting the common Fascist/Nazi enemy.
To be honest I am kind of shocked that France still stands. If the Germans don't smash the French down soon I feel they are going to be in trouble. And what is the US doing in all of this?
Yes, France bends badly but isn’t breaking, though I fear for it. Apart from being in an OTL election campaign, the US is not doing much - and are probably a year or more away from joining the war - if they do. With the changed strategic circumstances I’m not sure when or whether that may happen. :confused: Last I checked, their neutrality was up around 60, with Turkey (at about 23) their biggest threat! Can’t imagine why they’d think we would attack anyone :rolleyes:o_O
 
  • 1
Reactions:
Thank you Asantahene, you have no idea how much I am thankful for your kind attention! You will see it changes in nature as it develops, bearing in mind it was my first AAR attempt :).

Please, if you do feel like making a comment along the way, as I say in the intro, don’t hesitate to do so. Happy reading :D.
I most certainly will. I’m going to try 5 chapters a day. Liking the early technical stuff so far. Quick question (as I don’t play this game) what does LS mean?
 
  • 1Like
Reactions:
Fair points in the main, and their help in that naval battle certainly improved feelings between the two countries. The concern is more about them letting France fall, when a few more troops would probably stabilise the situation - but that’s the game.;)

Perse has hidden strengths - and a lot of determination. She intends to make her mark, and at least she can tell herself she is now fighting the common Fascist/Nazi enemy.
Yes, France bends badly but isn’t breaking, though I fear for it. Apart from being in an OTL election campaign, the US is not doing much - and are probably a year or more away from joining the war - if they do. With the changed strategic circumstances I’m not sure when or whether that may happen. :confused: Last I checked, their neutrality was up around 60, with Turkey (at about 23) their biggest threat! Can’t imagine why they’d think we would attack anyone :rolleyes:o_O

We'd have to attack the British Empire or threaten the balance of power in Asia and the Pacific to get their attention and I highly doubt we'll ever do that. If we took over Africa and the Middle East they probably wouldn't care. They were producing the oil in those days and Africa was an exporter of resources, little more (to a generalised and racist degree, which is how the US public would have thought of it). Maybe if we were messing around with proper liberal democracies and making them communist but...well, that's the UK and...that's it, right now. Everything else is either fascist, under the fascists (and so we can liberate them and help build them back up with communism) or the French Republic, which is already so close to becoming communist that we only have to breath on them and they'll catch it.

So yes, unless we go after the British, their empire in Asia, the commonwealth or the Pacific, I doubt we'll get their attention. Until we go nuclear of course.
 
  • 1
Reactions:
I most certainly will. I’m going to try 5 chapters a day. Liking the early technical stuff so far. Quick question (as I don’t play this game) what does LS mean?
Leadership- used for research, generating spies, diplomats and officer levels for units. :)
 
  • 1
Reactions: