• We have updated our Community Code of Conduct. Please read through the new rules for the forum that are an integral part of Paradox Interactive’s User Agreement.

Tinto Maps #10 - 12th of July 2024 - Syrian Levant & Egypt

Hello everyone, and welcome to another Tinto Maps! We’re back after celebrating the most important victories over Germany and France since the 30 Years War a hard week of work, and we’re ready to share with you the region of the Syrian Levant & Egypt (actually, we’re revealing a bit more of what those regions would be, to cover the complete extension of the Mamlūk Sultanate). Let’s go!

Countries:
Countries.png

The Mamlūk Sultanate is the main power of the region, a situation achieved after the defeat of the Mongols at the Battles of Ain Jalut and Marj al-Saffar, and the fall of Acre, the last stronghold of the Crusader states in Outremer. The latter's legacy is still handled by the Kingdom of Cyprus, ruled by Hugues IV of Lusignan. Apart from that, we can see the realm of Candia, a subject governed by the Serene Republic of Venice, and some Arabic tribes, such as the Hutaym and the Anizah. Oh, and also, to the south-west, you might have noticed some oases ruled by either the Mamluks, or Fezzan; I opted for not coloring the wastelands, as usual, but also the corridors, a type of terrain present in other GSGs, that we have in Project Caesar. I’ll talk more about them under the ‘Locations’ section of the DD, but I just want to note one more thing: the connection down the Nile is a regular one, with a border existing between the Mamluks and Makuria (the country that controls the small chunk of land at the very south of the image).

Dynasties:
Dynasties.png

The Bahri Mamluks have ruled the Sultanate since they deposed the Ayyubids, almost a century before the start of the game. It could maybe be a bit more accurate to depict Sultan al-Nasir Muhammad as an ibn Qalawun (‘of the lineage of Qalawun’), but the dynastical dynamics of the Mamluk rulers are not so easy to portray, so we opted for the moment to better use Bahriyya. Apart from that, you may also see the neighboring dynasties, such as the already-mentioned House of Lusignan, or the Hethumian of Cilicia.

Locations:
Locations 1.png

Locations 2.png

Locations 3.png

Locations 4.png
Here you can see the locations of the entire region, and also closer chunks behind the ‘Spoiler’ button. The most interesting feature to talk about is that of the corridors, something that some of you might remember from ‘Imperator: Rome’, but also something new to the rest. The corridors are empty locations, with no population or resources, but that allows connection between the locations at their sides, for some mechanics that we’ve already mentioned (market access, control), and some others that we haven’t (army movement). This is the way that we’ve chosen to portray the Saharan corridors, that allow for a connection between the Maghreb and the Mashreq, and Western and Central Africa. There are also some regular locations over those corridors, with population, resources, etc., that can be controlled by countries, which portray the desert oases that made for important outposts in the different Saharan routes. Not all the connections are throughout corridors, though; outside of the image, the Nile River valley allows for regular locations all the way down from Egypt to Nubia, the last location held by the Mamluks being that of Aswan, while the first held by Makuria, not shown in the screenshot, being Qasr Ibrim. We will talk more about Nubia and Ethiopia in a future Tinto Maps.

Provinces:
Provinces.png

Usual provinces mapmode; please let us know of any spelling or naming suggestions that come to your mind.

Areas:
Areas.png

A new mapmode that has been requested in previous Tinto Maps, and that we’re now incorporating.

Terrain:
Climate.png

Topography.png

Vegetation.png

The climate is dominated by a mix of Mediterranean, Arid, and Cold Arid. The topography of the region is quite flat, with some hills and mountains on Mount Lebanon and Anti-Lebanon, Mount Sinai, and the verge of the Arabian plateau; and some marshland over the Nile Delta, of course. Regarding the vegetation, desert and sparse vegetation dominate most of the region, with some woods and forests over Levant, and the Nile fertile farmlands, the bread basket of the Eastern Mediterranean.

Cultures:
Cultures.png

Here starts the fun… Those countries ruling over the Middle East will face the challenge of managing several different cultural minorities. Libyan, Egyptian, Sa'idi, Bedouin, Ḥijāzī, Najidi (the green one to their right), Levantine, and Iraqi (the light blue at the top right of the picture) are all different regional cultures of Arabic-speaking people. Something interesting is that most of Bedouin pops are tribesmen, instead of peasants, portraying their traditional social organization. Coming to important minority groups, Coptic people are quite important in Egypt, accounting for about 10% of the population of the Mamlūk Sultanate. The other important minority are the Syriacs, as they also account for another 10% of the population, and are a cultural majority in a few locations. Apart from those, there are also Armenians, Kurds, and Turkomans on the divide between Anatolia, Syria, and Jazira, Alawites Shiites in Syria, Mizrahi Jews all over the region, Samaritans in Palestine, and Greeks in Crete, Cyprus, and some in Alexandria. Oh, also the Saharan cultures of the Eastern Berbers and the Toubou over some of the Saharan oases.

Religions:
Religion.png

More fun. In this region, we have:
  • Sunni Muslims
  • Miaphysite Christians
  • Orthodox Christians
  • Shia Muslims
  • Catholic Christians
  • Druzes
  • Jews
  • Nestorian Christians (the ‘label’ we’re using to depict the Church of the East)
  • Samaritans
  • Yazidi

Relating these religions to the previous cultures, we can tell you most of the Arabic-speaking cultures are Sunni Muslims, with some Shia Muslims in Syria and Lebanon. Most of the Coptic are Miaphysite, adhering to the Patriarchate of Alexandria, although some of there still follow the Orthodoxy of Constantinople. The Syriacs are also religiously divided, with some being Nestorians (the current name we have to cover the confessions related to the Church of the East), some Miaphysites, some Orthodox, and even some Catholics in Lebanon. And then we have some cultural-religious minorities, such as the Alawite Shiites, the Druzes (which are of Levantine culture), the Mizrahi Jews, the Samaritans, and the Yazidi (which are of Kurd culture).


Raw Materials:
Raw Materials.png

There are some materials that are more unique to this region, such as the Dates in the arid fringes. The Nile Valley and Delta are incredibly fertile, having plenty of different crops: Wheat, Rice, Legumes, Sugar, Cotton, Fiber Crops (=Linen), etc. Livestock, Wool, and Horses are also important resources for the people across the region. There are also some metals present in the region, such as Copper in Cyprus and around the Red Sea, Iron, Tin, some Lead, and some interesting sources of Alum.

Markets:
Markets.png

The main market centers of the region are Alexandria (yeah, it’s there! I’ve already reported its weird name-wrapping and one of our programmers is going to take a look at it) for the Mashreq, Damascus for the Syrian Levant and Mecca for the Hejaz.

Country and Location Population:
Country Population .png

Location Population 1.png

Location Population 2.png

Location Population 3.png
The population of the region points to Egypt being its powerhouse, with several million people being supported being the Nile Valley and Delta. Apart from that, the Syrian Levant has a very decent population, making the Mamlūk Sultanate a dreadful rival to have in 1337. The arid fringes make for a way more difficult food production and population sustainability, making them more of strategic value, by their position, resources, etc.

And that’s all for today! Next week @Johan will show you Scandinavia, the very first map that was crafted for Project Caesar! Cheers!
 
  • 175Like
  • 54Love
  • 7
  • 4
  • 4
  • 1Haha
Reactions:
If you guys do make "camels" into a good like some people have suggested, I'd recommend naming it "camelids" so it can include South American camelids like the llama and alpaca. You could perhaps even name it "beasts of burden", so it can also include asses, certain kinds of oxen, etc. maybe even elephants which are their own good.

I have to disagree with the naming of Bedouin culture (the one north of Hejaz), while yes Bedouin is a culture, but the name means pastoral or Nomadic, in this case, its a way of life. A Hejazi or Najdi can be Bedouin or not (being a city dweller). Separating Bedouin from the other Arabian cultures paints a picture that Hejazis or other Arabians as not "Bedouin" while many are.
As stated, it seems like they looked at a map of Arabic dialects and assumed "Egyptian Bedawi Arabic speaker = Bedouin", when in fact that region should be split between Hejazi, Levantine and Lower Egyptian culture.
 
Last edited:
  • 1Like
Reactions:
Posting this on behalf of @settstones, who for whatever reason cannot. He has offered a great many suggested improvements to the Palestine region.

The main change needed to the map is just significantly more provinces tbh. Here they’ve gone from 5 to 10 in Lebanon (“Sidon” split to Saida and Sur, Jbeil from Beirut and Tarablus, Baalbek split into four) and from 8 to 12 in Palestine (“Acre” into ‘Akka, Haifa and Qaysaria, Jenin from Safad and Nablus, Al Majdal into Yafa and Ramleh). Location density here is still lower than in most of Western Europe, and pops per location isn’t significantly lower. Lebanon is split into the Mount Lebanon and Beqaa, with Sur and northern Palestine into the Galilee, though I’m still not sure what to do with the rest of Palestine. There could be a coast/uplands Philistia/J&S divide, but that is (A) not so historically accurate (Jaffa and Caesarea were never part of Philistia iirc, and it wasn’t really a regional divide acknowledged much by anyone throughout the period) and (B) quite politically charged? If that’s not impolite to say. Names in Arabic, old French and Greek for Arab or Muslim states, Crusaders and Romans, and my best estimates as a Palestinian for Musta’arabi Hebrew in case of any Jewish tags. English names for our benefit, though they can be used as a localisation for English occupation. I do not know Greek, so the localisations are probably too modern and inaccurate.

I do think it’s inaccurate to take the actively depopulated development level of the region as an indication of how dense it should be simulated, since the depopulation of the coast and relative underdevelopment of the West Bank, Megiddo &c was an active policy choice that the player could (and probably would) choose to not undertake, especially if they’re playing from Jerusalem rather than Cairo or Constantinople.

I am not Lebanese, so if there are any inaccuracies, it is not my fault, and you shouldn’t say anything about them or I’ll cry.

pal1_locations.png

New locations and provinces overlaid on the current ones.

pal2_goods.png

Goods production.

pal3_terrain.png

Foliage, terrain and climate zones.

pal4_language.png

Possible name localisations for (modern) English, Arabic, Greek (Byzantine where possible), old French and Hebrew (medieval, as much as I could estimate).

Attached is a list of the location changes, with explanations where appropriate. I've spoilered it because it's quite lengthy.
Mount Lebanon
"Lubnan, Livanos, Liban"

Tripoli
"Tarablus, Tripolis, Tripoli"
Medi Hill Forests
Second largest city today, very important throughout the period to the Muslims, Latins and Byzantines. Centre of a crusader polity.

Byblos
"Jbeil, Vyvlos, Byblos"
Medi Mountain Forests
Also very important to Crusaders and Muslims alike.

Beirut
"Beirut, Virytos, Baruth"
Medi Mountain Forests
Obviously.

Deir el-Qamar
"Deir El Qamar, Deir Elcamar"
Medi Mountain Forests
I’ve put silk down here as silk was harvested in the environs and was a very important export.

Sidon
"Saida, Sidonas, Sagette"
Medi Plateau Forests

Coele-Syria
"Beq’aa"

Hermel
"Hermel"
Medi Flat Grasslands

Baalbek
"B’albek"
Medi Flat Farmlands

Bar Elias
"Bar Elias"
Medi Flat Grasslands

Hasbaya
"Hasbaya"
Medi Mountain Forests
Honestly all the Beqaa being one location is silly. Three locations needed minimum, for the Mount Hermon (Hasbaya), and for the ethnoreligious and geographical differences between the upper and lower valley. Baalbek could be split between Bar Elias and Hermel, though whichever location the town ends up should be renamed Baalbek. I’ve put four here to match the location density of the coast, and to better represent the granularity of Lebanon’s religious divides.

Galilee
"Al Jalil, Ha Galil, Galilaia, Galilée"

Tyre
"Sur, Sur, Tyros, Tyre"
Medi Plateau Woods
Very important for the crusader/byzantine larp, indispensable. Fourth largest city today, historically always one of the largest in the Levant.

Acre
"‘Akka, ‘Akko, Akras, Acre"
Medi Hill Woods
Likewise w/ the larp lol. Always an important Palestinian city, populated throughout the period and a centre of a later Ottoman sanjak.

Safad
"Safad, Sefat, Saphant, Saphet"
Medi Hill Farmland
Holds a large Jewish community iirc. Could be Tiberias for the larp, but Safad was significantly more important throughout the period. Obviously, the region around the Jordan and Tiberias deserve to be distinct from the uplands of the Galilee. Very fertile flatlands, thougghhhh I think I have them as hills :0

Haifa
"Haifa, Haifa, Hepha, Caiphas"
Medi Plateau Grasslands
Very important port city, of course. Indispensable.

Palestine?
"Filistin, Palestina, Palestina, Palestine"

Caesarea
"Qaysaria, Qaysaria, Kaisareia, Caesarea"
Medi Plateau Forests
At this point largely forested and depopulated in contrast to the environs of Jaffa and Nazareth, and centre of a crusader lordship, so worthy of distinction.

Jenin
"Jenin, Jenin, Ginae, Grand Guerin"
Medi Plateau Woods
Jenin was more important throughout the period than Nazareth [Nasira, Nasrat, Nazara, Nazareth], but the latter could be picked for the larp value. Muslim majority, has a very large Christian minority.

Nablus
"Nablus, Shekhem, Neapolis, Naples"
Medi Plateau Woods
Important city to both the Crusaders, Mamelukes and Ottomans, and housed a large Christian and small Samaritan minority. If only one location per name is permitted, it could be called Naplouse, though I don’t know how historically accurate that’d be.

Jaffa
"Yafa, Yafo, Ioppa, Japhe"
Medi Plateau Grasslands
Grows to be the most important city in Palestine besides Jerusalem by the end of the period, and Jerusalem’s pseudo port. Famous for its oranges, hence the fruit, though iirc they were only cultivated in large sums after 1800. The location represents Jaffa and Lydda, both important cities, though Lydda in this period is overshadowed by Ramleh and Jaffa.

Jerusalem
"Al Quds, Yerushalayim, Ierosolymia, Jherusalem"
Medi Plateau Woods
Obviously.

Ramla
"Ramlah, Ramlah, Ramla, Arimathea"
Medi Plateau Grasslands
Centre of a crusader lordship and Ottoman district. One of the largest cities in Palestine throughout the period; consistently populated. This location could rather be Ashkelon [‘Asqalan/‘Ashqelon/Askalon/Ascalon], as it is more centred, though of course throughout the period it was called Al Majdal, and not at the modern Ashkelon’s site. Cloth was produced here in great quantities, but I don’t know of an exact trade good that would fit that. Buildings should reflect this.

Hebron
"Al Khalil, Hebron, Chevrona, St Abraham"
Medi Plateau Sparse
Covers both the Judaean Hills and Desert. Very important religiously for all Abrahamic religions, so indispensable as a location. Sparse Mediterranean is a compromise between the hot desert of the Judaean Wilderness and the relatively irrigated Hills. A later Ottoman District. Holds a large Jewish minority.

Gaza
"Ghazzah, Azzah, Gaza, Gaza"
Arid Plateau Sparse
Only the southern part of the location is arid, though the region wasn’t so well irrigated throughout the period, so arid and sparse as a compromise.

Beersheba
"Bi’r As Seba’, Be’er Sheba"
Arid Plateau Sparse
Could do with being a desert, though the northern region by Ramleh and Hebron have enough rainfall.
 
  • 8Like
  • 5
  • 4
  • 3Love
Reactions:
Posting this on behalf of @settstones, who for whatever reason cannot. He has offered a great many suggested improvements to the Palestine region.

The main change needed to the map is just significantly more provinces tbh. Here they’ve gone from 5 to 10 in Lebanon (“Sidon” split to Saida and Sur, Jbeil from Beirut and Tarablus, Baalbek split into four) and from 8 to 12 in Palestine (“Acre” into ‘Akka, Haifa and Qaysaria, Jenin from Safad and Nablus, Al Majdal into Yafa and Ramleh). Location density here is still lower than in most of Western Europe, and pops per location isn’t significantly lower. Lebanon is split into the Mount Lebanon and Beqaa, with Sur and northern Palestine into the Galilee, though I’m still not sure what to do with the rest of Palestine. There could be a coast/uplands Philistia/J&S divide, but that is (A) not so historically accurate (Jaffa and Caesarea were never part of Philistia iirc, and it wasn’t really a regional divide acknowledged much by anyone throughout the period) and (B) quite politically charged? If that’s not impolite to say. Names in Arabic, old French and Greek for Arab or Muslim states, Crusaders and Romans, and my best estimates as a Palestinian for Musta’arabi Hebrew in case of any Jewish tags. English names for our benefit, though they can be used as a localisation for English occupation. I do not know Greek, so the localisations are probably too modern and inaccurate.

I do think it’s inaccurate to take the actively depopulated development level of the region as an indication of how dense it should be simulated, since the depopulation of the coast and relative underdevelopment of the West Bank, Megiddo &c was an active policy choice that the player could (and probably would) choose to not undertake, especially if they’re playing from Jerusalem rather than Cairo or Constantinople.

I am not Lebanese, so if there are any inaccuracies, it is not my fault, and you shouldn’t say anything about them or I’ll cry.

View attachment 1167101
New locations and provinces overlaid on the current ones.

View attachment 1167102
Goods production.

View attachment 1167106
Foliage, terrain and climate zones.

View attachment 1167107
Possible name localisations for (modern) English, Arabic, Greek (Byzantine where possible), old French and Hebrew (medieval, as much as I could estimate).

Attached is a list of the location changes, with explanations where appropriate. I've spoilered it because it's quite lengthy.
Mount Lebanon
"Lubnan, Livanos, Liban"

Tripoli
"Tarablus, Tripolis, Tripoli"
Medi Hill Forests
Second largest city today, very important throughout the period to the Muslims, Latins and Byzantines. Centre of a crusader polity.

Byblos
"Jbeil, Vyvlos, Byblos"
Medi Mountain Forests
Also very important to Crusaders and Muslims alike.

Beirut
"Beirut, Virytos, Baruth"
Medi Mountain Forests
Obviously.

Deir el-Qamar
"Deir El Qamar, Deir Elcamar"
Medi Mountain Forests
I’ve put silk down here as silk was harvested in the environs and was a very important export.

Sidon
"Saida, Sidonas, Sagette"
Medi Plateau Forests

Coele-Syria
"Beq’aa"

Hermel
"Hermel"
Medi Flat Grasslands

Baalbek
"B’albek"
Medi Flat Farmlands

Bar Elias
"Bar Elias"
Medi Flat Grasslands

Hasbaya
"Hasbaya"
Medi Mountain Forests
Honestly all the Beqaa being one location is silly. Three locations needed minimum, for the Mount Hermon (Hasbaya), and for the ethnoreligious and geographical differences between the upper and lower valley. Baalbek could be split between Bar Elias and Hermel, though whichever location the town ends up should be renamed Baalbek. I’ve put four here to match the location density of the coast, and to better represent the granularity of Lebanon’s religious divides.

Galilee
"Al Jalil, Ha Galil, Galilaia, Galilée"

Tyre
"Sur, Sur, Tyros, Tyre"
Medi Plateau Woods
Very important for the crusader/byzantine larp, indispensable. Fourth largest city today, historically always one of the largest in the Levant.

Acre
"‘Akka, ‘Akko, Akras, Acre"
Medi Hill Woods
Likewise w/ the larp lol. Always an important Palestinian city, populated throughout the period and a centre of a later Ottoman sanjak.

Safad
"Safad, Sefat, Saphant, Saphet"
Medi Hill Farmland
Holds a large Jewish community iirc. Could be Tiberias for the larp, but Safad was significantly more important throughout the period. Obviously, the region around the Jordan and Tiberias deserve to be distinct from the uplands of the Galilee. Very fertile flatlands, thougghhhh I think I have them as hills :0

Haifa
"Haifa, Haifa, Hepha, Caiphas"
Medi Plateau Grasslands
Very important port city, of course. Indispensable.

Palestine?
"Filistin, Palestina, Palestina, Palestine"

Caesarea
"Qaysaria, Qaysaria, Kaisareia, Caesarea"
Medi Plateau Forests
At this point largely forested and depopulated in contrast to the environs of Jaffa and Nazareth, and centre of a crusader lordship, so worthy of distinction.

Jenin
"Jenin, Jenin, Ginae, Grand Guerin"
Medi Plateau Woods
Jenin was more important throughout the period than Nazareth [Nasira, Nasrat, Nazara, Nazareth], but the latter could be picked for the larp value. Muslim majority, has a very large Christian minority.

Nablus
"Nablus, Shekhem, Neapolis, Naples"
Medi Plateau Woods
Important city to both the Crusaders, Mamelukes and Ottomans, and housed a large Christian and small Samaritan minority. If only one location per name is permitted, it could be called Naplouse, though I don’t know how historically accurate that’d be.

Jaffa
"Yafa, Yafo, Ioppa, Japhe"
Medi Plateau Grasslands
Grows to be the most important city in Palestine besides Jerusalem by the end of the period, and Jerusalem’s pseudo port. Famous for its oranges, hence the fruit, though iirc they were only cultivated in large sums after 1800. The location represents Jaffa and Lydda, both important cities, though Lydda in this period is overshadowed by Ramleh and Jaffa.

Jerusalem
"Al Quds, Yerushalayim, Ierosolymia, Jherusalem"
Medi Plateau Woods
Obviously.

Ramla
"Ramlah, Ramlah, Ramla, Arimathea"
Medi Plateau Grasslands
Centre of a crusader lordship and Ottoman district. One of the largest cities in Palestine throughout the period; consistently populated. This location could rather be Ashkelon [‘Asqalan/‘Ashqelon/Askalon/Ascalon], as it is more centred, though of course throughout the period it was called Al Majdal, and not at the modern Ashkelon’s site. Cloth was produced here in great quantities, but I don’t know of an exact trade good that would fit that. Buildings should reflect this.

Hebron
"Al Khalil, Hebron, Chevrona, St Abraham"
Medi Plateau Sparse
Covers both the Judaean Hills and Desert. Very important religiously for all Abrahamic religions, so indispensable as a location. Sparse Mediterranean is a compromise between the hot desert of the Judaean Wilderness and the relatively irrigated Hills. A later Ottoman District. Holds a large Jewish minority.

Gaza
"Ghazzah, Azzah, Gaza, Gaza"
Arid Plateau Sparse
Only the southern part of the location is arid, though the region wasn’t so well irrigated throughout the period, so arid and sparse as a compromise.

Beersheba
"Bi’r As Seba’, Be’er Sheba"
Arid Plateau Sparse
Could do with being a desert, though the northern region by Ramleh and Hebron have enough rainfall.
I'd make "Judaea & Samaria" two provinces and split the Palestinian Coast province between them, Tarablus could also be made part of the Latakia area I think (in which case the area should be renamed to "Tarablus"). "Jenin" could be called "Ein-Ganim" in Hebrew, which is the name of a Biblica location identified with the city, but just "Jenin" is also fine for the time period since the city is called that in Hebrew even today. Beersheva should definitely be grouped with Judaea, it's generally considered the southernmost Judaean town before it gives way to the Negev.
 
Last edited:
  • 1
Reactions:
updated map suggestion (density look different to other areas tho)
Jaffa is a forest, flatlands, mediterranean, lumber
Ramla is sparse, flatlands, mediterranean, wheat
Jericho is desert,flatlands, arid, sulfur
Haifa is woods, hills, mediterranean, fish
Acre is sparse, flatlands, mediterranean, cotton
Jenin is sparse, hills, mediterranean, olive
Jerusalem is woods, hills, mediterranean, olive
the provinces are
Palestinian coast(Acre,Haifa,Jaffa,Ramla,Gaza)
Judea(Jerusalem,Hebron,Jericho,Beersheba)
Samaria(Nablus,Jenin,Safed)

palastina provinces.png
 
  • 2Like
Reactions:
This region should be controlled by
Tubu, not Fezan, the population of this region should be mostly pagan. It is also written that the population of this region had its own sultan who ruled from Tazirbu.
I propose adding an additional oasis to the Tazirbu region.
Rebiana Oasis
It seems that the Buzaymah oasis should also be in the game because there is a village in this region.
Zrzut ekranu 2024-07-28 125017.png
Dynasties.png

Zrzut ekranu 2024-07-28 130728.png


I also propose to create a new province of Bedroa which will include all the oases.

quote:

In 1154 al-Idrisi described a place identified by Lewicki as the oasis of Kufra. Al Idrisi writes that the place was once flourishing and peopled, but was by that point in ruin, its wells dry, its herds returned to the wild.[6] In the late 15th century, Leo Africanus reported an oasis in the land of the Berdoa, visited by a caravan coming from Awjila. It is possible that this oasis was identical with either the Al Jawf or the Tazirbu oasis, and on early modern maps, the Al Kufra region was often labelled as Berdoa based on this report. Berdoa possibly corresponded to the Toubou, a Nilo-Saharan speaking tribal people indigenous to the region.
Provinces.png

Zrzut ekranu 2024-07-28 133501.png

map.libya.&.egypt.1.jpg
 
Last edited:
  • 5Like
Reactions:
I really hope they split up the mamluks into more vassal states, the unified and centralized nature of the current map is completely ahistorical. It would be quite disappointing to see them make german cities with populations of 10-20k people into full tags, but ignore vast and influential vassal states. The levant in particular was split into a hanful of quite strong vassal states, and an internal power struggle between the Mamluks and Ayyubid governors of Syria was still present.
View attachment cpzxxmxl8yl71.png
 
  • 1
  • 1Like
  • 1
Reactions:
After the Nasrid census (Rawk) in 1315 A.D., the provinces of Egypt were divided as follows:

12 in lower Egypt:
1. Cairo and its environs
2. Qalyubia
3. Sharqiya
4. Daqahliya and Murtahiya
5. Damietta and its environs
6. Gharbiya
7. Monoufiya
8. Ibyar and Jazirat Bani Nasr
9. Beheira
10. Fuwah and Muzahimatayn
11. Nestrawiya
12. Alexandria and its environs

And 9 in upper Egypt:
1. Giziya
2. Atfihiya
3. Fayumiya
4. Bahnasawiya
5. Ashmounayn
6. Manfaloutiya
7. Asyutiya
8. Akhmimiya
9. Qusiya

Siwa oasis, as well as the Northern coast of Egypt (the region historically called Marmarica) was under Alexandria administratively, while the Oases of Bahariyya and Farafra (which were collectively called the Bahnasa oases) were under the administration of Bahnasawiya, and Kharga and Dakhla were under the administration of Asyut, Qoseir was under the administration of Qusiya

A guy called RETF made a map of depicting this census a while back, and while some things need fixing, it generally gets the idea across:
خريطة_الدولة_المملوكية_في_القاهرة_و_الدول_التابعة_لها_في_عهد_السلطان_الناصر_ناصر_الدين_محمد_بن_قلاوون_1315_م.png


As well as making two Google MyMaps maps of individual villages, although it was made 2 or 3 years ago so it could be improved:
https://www.google.com/maps/d/u/0/edit?mid=15fpKKzAOpyLsnV3TPSTtTAD4iFC2IdaD&usp=sharing
https://www.google.com/maps/d/u/0/edit?mid=1xMPFFhMn9C3YrFCP9mGuWORZ2OFukXvR&usp=sharing

Finally, Fezzan didn't own all of those oases in the Libyan east

The main sources for what I am saying are primarily Yahya Ibn Jay'an's "Al-Tuhfa Al-Saniyya bi Asmaa" Al-Bilad Al-Misriyya" and Mohammed Ramzi's "Geographical dictionary of Egypt"
 
Last edited:
  • 4Like
Reactions:
Came back with some recs and map proposals for Egypt and the southern Levant! It's a bit of a maximalist position, but I also tried to not to have any locations that were too small.

NileDelta.png

I scoured the depths of Arabic Wikipedia for this! Also based off of this map.

Province by Province:
  • Nestrawiya (4 locations - Rosetta, Burullus, Baltim, Damietta)
    • Just adding Baltim here to break up Tidah and also keep the coastal regions separate
  • Gharbia (5 locations - Fuwwah, Kafr el Sheikh, El Mahalla el Kubra, Samannud, Sherbin)
    • Tidah -> Kafr el Sheikh; couldn't find info on Tidah and this town was one of the centers of the Gharbia province
    • Added Sherbin - an ancient town (Smabehdet) that was also mentioned as part of the province of Gharbia. Could probably fold into Samannud if not worthy
  • Beheira (5? 6? 7? locations)
    • Added El Mahmoudiyah - but should be under its old name of Balhib probably - not a lot of good options beteen Fuwwah and Damanhur
    • I think I identified Kharibta here - as Kom Hamada/Kharbata/Khribita - not sure what name is best though
    • Added Tarrana to split up Kharibta; Dates back to the Ancient Egyptian period, but seems to have lasted through the Ottoman period
    • Hauf Ramsis - not 100% sure what this is referring to; the Monastery of St. Mary the Virgin of the Eastern Akhmim Mountain is right on the border of this location though. Or could be removed?
    • There are a number of monasteries in the Wadi El Natrun - a location to cover them could be added SW of the Tarrana location; the Monastery of Saint Pishoy is maybe the most famous?
  • Menoufia (4 locations)
    • Added Tanta - technically part of the Gharbia province until the French occupation; picked up in importance after Ahmad al-Badawi settled there in the 13th c.
    • Added Menouf - the name sake of the province; arguably should be added even if the Menoufia province isn't
    • Added Zifta - an important regional trading center for textiles; got a big endowment in the 1670s
  • Daqahlia (3 locations)
    • Added Dakahla/Daqahla - the namesake of the province
    • Added/moved Tanis here - not a lot of options for this area of Egypt
  • Sharqia (3 locations)
    • Added Mit Ghamr - right across the river from Zafta; noted as a regional center of the Sharqia (and sometimes Daqahlia) province
  • Al Jifar (4 locations)
    • Tannis should probably be Tinnis (May have been mixed up with Tanis?) Or potentially, Farama/Pelusium. I lean towards the latter.
  • Cairo (4 locations- Qalyub, Cairo, Giza, Helwan)
    • Added Helwan - founded during the 7th c.
MiddleEgypt.png

  • Bahnasawiya (5 locations) - a combo of Bahnasawiya, Atfih and Faiyum provinces
    • I couldn't find info about the Busir province south of Giza (or really read the full name); Busir made me think of Abusir/Busiris but I couldn't find one within these location borders.
    • Added Beni Suef; El Bahnasa/Oxyrhyncus is in the Minya location
    • With this and the some of the further south provinces; the eastern bank of the Nile is very sparsely settled - I kept them here for consistency, but might be worth removing or merging into their western counterparts.... unless something fun is happening with rivers/the Nile :)
  • Ashmounein (4 locations - Minya, Ashmounein/Hermopolis, Manfalut, Akoris) (Ashmounein + Manfalut provinces)
    • Tabna -> Akoris; couldn't find info on Tabna; Akoris dates to Ancient times
UpperEgypt.png

  • Asyut (5 locations - Asyut, Sohag, Akhmim, Girga, Buwit) (Asyut + Askhmim provinces)
    • Added Sohag - big medieval city
    • Al Balyana -> Girga; bigger, more important city
    • Buwit - not a lot of great choices here tbh; see above Bahanasawiya statement
  • Qusiya (7 locations)
    • Faw -> Qena; more important city?
    • Qus - Wanted to fit Qift in there, but I don't think it's feasible alas
    • Added Luxor, formerly Thebes
Not pictured here, but I've turned Matruh, Sallum and Alexandria into an Alexandria province.

Other quibbles: Saint Anthony location doesn't include the Monastery of Saint Anthony; nor does Faran include Wadi Feiran. I'd also move Nekhel and the other wastelands into the El Tih province; since Nekhel is right in the El Tih ranges!

Sharat.png


  • Sharat - should not extend so far north
    • Could add Qatraneh east of Al Karak - a waypoint for Hajjgoers
    • Could split southern Sughar/Zoara into Shoubak; Udhruh is also a major settlement here, but is pinned between Ma'an and Shoubak, so not super feasible alas
LowerLevant.png

  • Gaza (3 locations, representing the Gaza Sanjak)
    • Add Ramla, the second-most important city in the sanjak after Gaza
    • Also keeps a nice coastal/inland division
  • Jerusalem (3 locations)
    • Don't think there's enough room here for Jericho
  • Shomron/Samaria (3 locations - Nablus, Lajjun, Qalansawe)
    • Add Lajjun - center of Lajjun Sanjak and the domain of the Turabay Dynasty (which was recently the featured article on Wikipedia!); Jenin is also an important settlement here and the center of the sanjak was eventually moved here by the Turabays
    • Add Qalansawe - a dark horse choice compared to the fan favorites of Caesarea and Haifa, but Qalansawe has the benefit of not being destroyed at the beginning of the game; noted as part of hte estates of Baibars in the 13th century and part of the liwa of Nablus in the 16th.
      • Haifa wasn't really (re-)founded until the mid 1700s, Caesarea wasn't refounded until the 19th-20th century really
  • Ajloun (4/5 locations)
    • Add the Ajloun location - center of the Sanjak of Ajloun; dates to at least the 12th c.
    • Added Mafraq - first settled in the 4th c. BCE; was a pilgrim stop on the way to Mecca; got its current name in the Ottoman period, before that was called Fudain.
    • (not shown here but) Add Hisban and/or As-Salt.Hisban was the the capital of the Wilayat Balqa during the first half of the 14th c.; then it was transferred to Amman in 1356, and then back to Hisban in the 15th century before going to As-Salt under Ottoman rule starting in 1516. All 3 of these cities might be overkill, but 2 could probably fit comfortably
  • Galilee (3 Locations)
    • Add Tiberias - a nahiya of the Sanjak of Safed; covers the lower Galilee region. Nazareth is also in this location, but seems to have been a smaller town, even considering Tiberias's ups and downs during the period of the game
  • Hawran (4 locations)
    • Moved Nawa south to its location, which left some room in the Golan area for 1-2 settlements; I chose:
      • Fiq - a Caravanserai town since the 13th c., and
      • Al-Harra - name dates to the 6th century; both Fiq and Al-Harra are noted in the Ottoman-era documents as being part of the Hawran sanjak
  • Jabal Druze (4? locations) - Jabal Hawran during the time period I believe
    • Salkhad was a huge location, and the actual city wasn't even really in it. Could probably drop the northeastern third of this province and just have the As-Suwayda, Bosra, and Salkhad provinces, but if not then you could add Shahba to reduce the size of Salkhad.
    • Not part of this province technically, but further breaking up Salkhad, you could add Azraq - which had a castle since the 13th century and was a strategic fortified oasis town.
Lebanon.png


  • Shām/Shaam:
    • Could add Qatana or Al-Kiswah to break up the Damascus location if desired. The former was a Nahiya of the Sanjak of Damascus; The latter was visited by Ibn Battuta and was a noted stopping place on the road to Mecca.
  • Lebanon/Mount Lebanon (6 locations):
    • Added Byblos - seemed to survive the crusades well since it surrendered voluntarily and thus was not destroyed; its fortifications were restored in the 13th c.
    • Added Tyre/Tebnine - Tyre has the name recognition but in bad shape at the start of the game. Its fortifications destroyed and it "sank into obscurity" at the end of the 13th c. Ibn Battuta found it in ruins in 1355. It was not rebuilt until starting in the 17th century.
      • Tebnine on the other hand was a nahiya center of the Safed sanjak - If Tebnine is chosen, this location could potentially go to Safed provinces instead of Lebanon
  • Beqaa Valley (2? locations):
    • a bit small as far as provinces go, but Lebanon is otherwise looking pretty big
    • Also helps keep a coastal v. inland division
    • Would carve either Hasbaya or Rashaya out of southern Baalbek - they were both Nahiyahs of Damascus Sanjak; I might go with Hasbaya, since it was the capital of the Shihabs
    • In the north, you could squeeze in another location potentially - Hermel and Laboueh seem like the major settlements there, but neither stand out particular to me (although Hermel has its cool pyramid thing)

Unrelated to the map, just reiterating the call for Alexandretta/Iskenderun. As well as noting that the Idlib and Kilis locations do not seem to include their respective namesakes, and that Harran could be added in the southern half of the Urfa province since it seems to have been used as a fort by the Mamluks and was a nahiya under the Ottomans.
 
  • 4Like
  • 3Love
  • 1
Reactions:
Since someone mentioned it in the post I made:


I wanted to provide some extra info on the Mamluks. I am still reading the book, so the post will be editted, once I am done with it, but there are a few points, I would like to mention. More about it in the post I linked, but in short:

1. Mamluks were highly unstable. At the begining of the EU5 timeframe, a great leader and popular Mamluk leader is about to die, which results in decades of power-struggles.

2. Black death numbers are explicitly mentioned. 900 000 according to an arab contemporary historian, but the author notes that it is most likely exaggerated. The author does however note that some areas were depopulated to the point that people couldnt attend any farms and that the region required centuries to recover the population.

3. Nile flooding or the absence of the Nile flooding was quite devastating.

4. Mamluks were mainly kipchak turks. From the late 1380th onwards, this changes to mainly circassians, which may or may not include turks/tatars. All Mamluks would however receive at least until 1380th a "turkish education" (getting turkish names, speaking in the Kipchak turkish language. Not knowing arabic was very apparent and common for Mamluks).
 
  • 3
Reactions:
A few small notes before the update gets done mostly in Cyrenaica:
-Barqa should be a vassal of the mameluks rather than start under their direct control (much like Medina)
-Neither Awjila, Maradah, Al jawf nor Tazirbu should be under the control of Fezzan.
Al Jawf and Tazirbu should definitely be unowned provinces
Awjila I would give to Barqa
Maradah is the more debatable one but I would go for keeping it unowned at start. Alternatively you could give it to either Barqa or to the Banu Talis emirate of Banu Walid (which should be a nation at game start).