-
We have updated our Community Code of Conduct. Please read through the new rules for the forum that are an integral part of Paradox Interactive’s User Agreement.
It used to be the case that if a seer scans an apprentice, he has the survive the whole night to claim him.
If I hadn't been too tired and went to be early after several late nights waiting for the deadline I would have been scared because this is the tune I picked as my update death music.
Sorry about that. We just wanted to get rid of as many unaccounted for people as we could with lynch-TIE, assassin, van Helsing and wolf hunt. You were just unlucky that you got the OEO.
Maybe it's just me but I don't allow scanners to claim apprentices unless they survive the night. I think they need at least a day to train their successor. Not sure how other GMs usually do it.
I think I was protected only on one night, the night when EURO died. The padre was sitting with me every now and then though.
It was your own fault! De Chat2 was the #5 suspect on our list and he should have been my 2nd backup hunt target instead of you but then I remembered that I promised you that you'd be the first to know if I had turned wolf and since I temporary turned wolf I thought it fun to pay you a visit.Hax said:
I'd like to introduce another johho rule of thumb I try to limit myself with when hosting. The number of important goodies should be 4 unless the game is smaller than 25 then it should be 3.
As important goodies I count seer, priest, starting seer/priest apprentices, van Helsing, GA, doctor and this kind of padre.
I normally don't count liar as quite that important because normally the rule set allows for only 3 scans and one kill, which is more in the medium goodie category. With this rule set I'd agree with madchemist I was like an important goodie since I could get 5 scans, 1 kill and some minor stuff.
I like a slightly weaker padre (that ends after finding a wolf) but to use as alternative to witness, not both at the same time. The padre used in this game was intended as a replacement for the doc.
So we had seven important goodies which is at least two too many for my taste.
You are welcome?
I got a really long list of everyone that had contacted the JL from Ithvan before he left. As far as I know it was complete with two exceptions, you were left off it and Marshall was shown as blessed instead of padre.
He claimed it had nothing to do with that when I asked him...
But in all fairness we did avoid the council and the rival triangle at first and only hunted both the other rivals when there really was nowhere else to look for baddies.
Yes, I seer scanned you the night before so you were one of the 100% certain good guys/gals.
It was surprisingly long actually, especially with regard to the starting baddies.
Now, now, it was Sleepy that forgot about the scan. I didn't scan DNC because she was terrible suspect but because on the night I claimed priest I wanted to scan one of the seer scanned players so it was either her, Ike or Hax. I can't excatly remember why I picked her of the three but I was in a real hurry that evening so didn't put too much thoughts into it.
And the girls thing was a joke, I must have killed Kaetje and Calamity lost of times and vice versa, not sure about al-Aziz though.
Ah, yes, that I remember. Was I still on about that so late into the game?
Sometimes I overthink things badly...
Why would that have mattered? We knew you were SA but EURO was so suspicious about you he wanted to scan you anyway.
EDIT:
I really like having OEO as hidden trait and I'm starting to warm up to the zealot. Still hate rivals.
Last edited:
In fact Euro's death was one of the reason I didn't trust you enough to contact you first day I was seer because of the worrying of you being turned the no-hunt night. You knew I was protecting you and I thought you had more protectors in the JL so I didn't understand how nobody was protecting EURO that night. Now I know you didn't have more protectors
Yep, your single angelic power was all the protection the JL had for the whole game...In fact Euro's death was one of the reason I didn't trust you enough to contact you first day I was seer. You knew I was protecting you and I thought you had more protectors in the JL so I didn't understand how nobody was protecting EURO that night. Now I know you didn't have more protectors
because he's not an idiot.
The hunt on you was the standing hunt order, so my death the fault of the random.org gods
That council analysis was all crazy though.
I had fun being a baddie on the council that had no idea who the wolves were.
If I wasn't working when Najs outed himself I would have been able to contact him too.
I had fun being a baddie on the council that had no idea who the wolves were.
If I wasn't working when Najs outed himself I would have been able to contact him too.
Yes, why didn't you? I took for granted you were in touch with the Reds and used that when I tried to find them. Was very surprised when I checked against Marshall's hunt pattern theory and found out you were eaten by them. Did we get that right BTW?
Also as usual I forgot to thank the GM for a good game, I had a blast and would have liked to see it continue for a little longer. OTOH I wanted to win the game before I got eaten...
Now I'm thinking... in my scan your result would be positive because you were lying, so I would have made an outing against you next day using gorgan probably, that could have been funny
Well, not really. But I never expected it to come down to my second backup.
Enough people knew I was lying about being a wolf. But the question for them would be if they could trust me when I said I was lying, which is sort of the opposite of what we usually discuss.Now I'm thinking... in my scan your result would be positive because you were lying, so I would have made an outing against you next day using gorgan probably, that could have been funny
Johho did have the leader on his side, so he'd not be lynchedNow I'm thinking... in my scan your result would be positive because you were lying, so I would have made an outing against you next day using gorgan probably, that could have been funny
No, he was lynched before he got a chance to be hunted.
Rov's outing made me super convinced that at least one of the baddies on the council were in contact with the reds, and I'm still surprised to look back and see that it didn't occur. In fact, @Gen. Skobelev, why didn't you contact the reds?
Johho did have the leader on his side, so he'd not be lynched
We were a lot of players, you need at least 50% of the votes and if gorgan makes the outing I don't think you could have so much votes against anybody else. The thing iis if Gorgan knew about Johho lying or not.
The council knew of both me and johho, so did Gorgan, Marshall and Audren. Gorgan even knew that the plan was for johho to claim wolf.
You were supposed to be lynched the following day as the last unscanned person anyway.