• We have updated our Community Code of Conduct. Please read through the new rules for the forum that are an integral part of Paradox Interactive’s User Agreement.
At least the Alans were around the Pontic Steppe in the first half of the I millennium, so it is not completely true.

Also, I posted a book of an academic and a scientist, not of a facebook blogger. Academic Abayev was one of the most prominent iranists that wrote multiple books on Iranian languages and was an honorary member of academies of sciences of the Great Britain and Finland. So I think he really knew something about the Iranian peoples.

Yes, this is a theory and it does not mean he was 100% right, but still I would not throw such words as 'obvious nonsense' to this kind of sources.

Nevertheless, it does not change anything because the XIV century sources from the Ukrainian and Belarusian territory clearly distinguish 'г' and 'кг' to represent two different sounds (Gedimin was written as Кгедимин as the most obvious example).
The Slavic migration dates to 2 century after the Alans were pushed west or south by the Huns and more centuries away from any special interaction that would be exclusive to Southern East Slavs and this supposed remnant Iranian population which there is no evidence for.

This is putting the cart before the horse and no amount of appealing to authority changes that fact.

I don't care about the original point, just don't post obvious nonsense as if it supports your point rather than diluting it.
 
The Slavic migration dates to 2 century after the Alans were pushed west or south by the Huns and more centuries away from any special interaction that would be exclusive to Southern East Slavs and this supposed remnant Iranian population which there is no evidence for.

This is putting the cart before the horse and no amount of appealing to authority changes that fact.

I don't care about the original point, just don't post obvious nonsense as if it supports your point rather than diluting it.
Why is it an obvious nonsense when slavs came across iranian Burtasy in Severia Don-Volga interfluve?
 
  • 2Like
  • 1
Reactions:
The Slavic migration dates to 2 century after the Alans were pushed west or south by the Huns and more centuries away from any special interaction that would be exclusive to Southern East Slavs and this supposed remnant Iranian population which there is no evidence for.

This is putting the cart before the horse and no amount of appealing to authority changes that fact.

I don't care about the original point, just don't post obvious nonsense as if it supports your point rather than diluting it.
The northern extent of Iranian tribes was up to Severia and Polesia and nicely overlaps with (proto-)slavic area.
I live in the most northern region of Ukraine and we have a few of their kurgans here too from different periods.

Also the Don, Dnieper, Dnister river names all have Iranian origin and were accepted by the Slavs quite early (Don/Danu meant water or river in those Iranian languages, and each of these rivers contains d and n letters at the beginning, just for example, as well as Danube).

So we do not know exactly if Southern Rus took the h sound from the Iranian tribes or not and when exactly it happened, but some level of early contacts between the Slavs and Iranian peoples cannot be even discussed. If the Slavs accepted the names of the biggest regional rivers directly from the Iranians.
 
Last edited:
  • 4Like
  • 1
Reactions:
The northern extent of Iranian tribes was up to Severia and Polesia and nicely overlaps with (proto-)slavic area.
I live in the most northern region of Ukraine and we have a few of their kurgans here too from different periods.

Also the Don, Dnieper, Dnister river names all have Iranian origin and were accepted by the Slavs quite early (Don meant water/river in those Iranian languages, and each of these rivers contains d and n letters at the beginning, just for example, as well as Danube).

So we do not know exactly if Southern Rus took the h sound from the Iranian tribes or not and when exactly it happened, but some level of contacts between the Slavs and Iranian peoples cannot be even discussed.
The difference between Iranian presence before the 5th century and Iranian presence after the break up of Slavic is important, because it doesn't matter if the Slavic homeland was near Iranians. If the G>H shift was caused by Iranian contact before the Slavic migrations it would mean that ALL Slavs must have experienced that shift which is obviously not the case because you would need to argue that somehow the sound change was then reverted in some Slavic dialects which I don't think anyone actually thinks.

To even begin to argue for that theory you would need to show the presence of Iranic tribes on the Pontic Steppe after 600 CE, so that only the Southern Eastern Slavs would be influenced by them... and also maybe prove this Iranic influence beyond one cherrypicked sound change, in fact proven Iranian influence on East Slavic is fairly low:


"To the second period of Slavic-Iranian contacts belong specifically East Slavic lexical items of Iranian origin.Their number is modest"

Doesn't sound like the type of contact that would cause a sound shift of that level.

But it's better than none at all.
You don't need to explain sound changes, they just happen by themselves. If you wanted to explain sound changes in East Slavic I'd rather look at language that had far more impact on it and did so at a time where the sound changes would be exclusive to the dialect in question and not all of Slavic.
 
  • 3
Reactions:
I think Votians should be the majority in most of where 'Ingrian' culture is and a minority in some parts of North-Eastern Estonia and surrounding Ingrian areas. I assume Ingrian means Izhorian, and not anochronistically the Lutheran Ingrian Finns. Izhorians should mostly be around the Neva region but also migrating westwards into Votia.
Check the Estonian Wikipedia page for Vadjalased
 
  • 3Like
  • 1
  • 1
Reactions:
I think Votians should be the majority in most of where 'Ingrian' culture is and a minority in some parts of North-Eastern Estonia and surrounding Ingrian areas. I assume Ingrian means Izhorian, and not anochronistically the Lutheran Ingrian Finns. Izhorians should mostly be around the Neva region but also migrating westwards into Votia.
Check the Estonian Wikipedia page for Vadjalased

Totally agree, also found this map from “History of Neva region” by Zhukov. From east to west: izhorians, votians and «Чудца», they are probably Estonians

IMG_2839.gif
 
Last edited:
  • 4Like
Reactions:
Hello, and welcome to another Tinto Maps feedback review! This week, we will be taking a look at Russia, a very anticipated review (which Johan already advanced in some maps last week).

A note before we start on the area that we've covered in this update. We've focused it on the core Russian lands, plus the Kola Peninsula. This means we've not yet updated the lands of Vyatka and Perm, nor those ruled by the Golden Horde. These will be covered in the future Tinto Maps feedback post, probably the one for the Steppes and Western Siberia. With that said, let's take a look at the list of changes, and then start with maps!

ADDITIONS

Added the following:
  • Locations (153+ 55 Lakes + 6 Wastelands)
    • Andomsky Pogost
    • Ashevo
    • Azeevo
    • Badozhsky
    • Beloe
    • Berezhnyany
    • Bernovo
    • Bezhanitsy
    • Bibirevo
    • Bogorodskoye
    • Bogorodskoye (Pereyaslavl)
    • Bolshevo
    • Bor Volgo
    • Borisogleb
    • Brody (Tver)
    • Burga
    • Chelmuzhi
    • Chuzboy
    • Demyanovo
    • Drokov
    • Dubok
    • Dubrovna
    • Fomin Gorodok
    • Georgevskoye
    • Glukhovichi to Perevitska
    • Gorodechnya
    • Goroditse
    • Gruzino
    • Ilovna
    • Ivangorod
    • Izboishchi
    • Izdeshkovo
    • Izori
    • Karniki
    • Katyn
    • Khakhaly
    • Khatun
    • Khlepen
    • Kholm
    • Khotiml
    • Khotmyzh
    • Khotsy
    • Kinerma
    • Klepiki
    • Knyazhichi
    • Knyazhoye
    • Koi
    • Koloshma
    • Koponovo
    • Korenevo
    • Kosozhichi
    • Kozlov
    • Ktsyn
    • Kubenskoye
    • Kulotino
    • Kurba
    • Kuretsk
    • Kurmysh
    • Kuzhbal
    • Lezhnevo
    • Luda
    • Lyady
    • Lyakhovichy
    • Lyuban
    • Lyubichi
    • Lyubun
    • Lyubno
    • Maryovo
    • Megra
    • Megrino
    • Meletovo
    • Meshchersk
    • Mezhutka
    • Mikhailovka
    • Mikshino
    • Mikulino (Tver)
    • Moshok
    • Mushkov Pogost
    • Nadvoitsy
    • Nikolo Dor
    • Nikol'skoye
    • Nizhel'skoye
    • Nuorttijärvi
    • Obolensk
    • Odintsovo
    • Opalkova
    • Orekhovna
    • Ostrechiny
    • Pashozero
    • Petrovsk
    • Podberezye
    • Pogoreloye
    • Pogostishche
    • Poreevo
    • Pribuzh
    • (Krasnye) Prudy
    • (Serebryanye) Prudy
    • Pryazha
    • Przemysl
    • Pustosel
    • Putyvl
    • Radogosch
    • Rakitnya
    • Raznezhye
    • Revny
    • Rogachevo
    • Ropsk
    • Rozhalovo
    • Rzhavets
    • Rzheva Pustaya
    • Sevsk
    • Shal'skii
    • Shatur
    • Shchuchye
    • Shenga-Kurya
    • Shoptovo
    • Shui
    • Sol Velikaya
    • Spasskoye
    • Spasskoye (Lyskovo)
    • Starodub-Votsky
    • Sudai
    • Suikujärvi
    • Sumino
    • Svinort
    • Svir
    • Talitsa
    • Tervenichi
    • Tesov
    • Trufany
    • Ust Kuloy
    • Valday
    • Veliky Porog
    • Verba
    • Vereya
    • Vertyazin
    • Verzhavsk
    • Vetlitsy
    • Vichuga
    • Visokoye
    • Vlasovo
    • Vodlozero
    • Vognema
    • Volkona
    • Volodimerets
    • Voronizh
    • Vorotynsk
    • Vorotynsk (Novosil)
    • Vshchizh
    • Yeszk
    • Yorga
    • Zhulino
    • Zolotkovo
  • Lakes
    • Lake Bol'shoye Rovkul'skoye
    • Lake Chudzjavr
    • Lake Dvin'ye
    • Lake Engozero
    • Lake Galichkoye
    • Lake Gimoly
    • Lake Golodnaya Guba
    • Lake Goltsovoye
    • Lake Imandra
    • Lake Kamennoye
    • Lake Kenozero
    • Lake Kenozero (Near Ladoga)
    • Lake Kolozero
    • Lake Kolvitskoye
    • Lake Konchozero
    • Lake Kozhozero
    • Lake Kovdozero
    • Lake Kovzhskoye
    • Lake Kukkureozero
    • Lake Lednikovoye
    • Lake Leksozero
    • Lake Lindozero
    • Lake Lizhmozero
    • Lake Lokht'yarvi
    • Lake Lovozero
    • Lake Lyoksmozhero
    • Lake Maslozero
    • Lake Nero
    • Lake Notozero
    • Lake Nyuk
    • Lake Otradnoye
    • Lake Pal'vozero
    • Lake Peschanka-To
    • Lake Pleshcheyevo
    • Lake Pyaozero
    • Lake Seletsy
    • Lake Seliger
    • Lake Sergozero
    • Lake Shotozero
    • Lake Sredneye Kuyto
    • Lake Sumozero
    • Lake Suoyarvi
    • Lake Syamozero
    • Lake Tishkeozero
    • Lake Topozero
    • Lake Tulos
    • Lake Tungudskoye
    • Lake Umbozero
    • Lake Verkhneye Kuyto
    • Lake Volgo
    • Lake Vyalozero
    • Lake Vygozero
    • Lake Yelmozero
    • Lake Yenozero
    • Lake Zhizhitskoye
  • Wastelands
    • Divided many Wastelands in more pieces.
  • TAGs (15)
    • Fomin-Berezuesk
    • Galich-Mersky
    • Gorodets
    • Klin
    • Kozelsk
    • Novgorod-Seversky
    • Pronsk
    • Rylsk
    • Starodub
    • Suzdal
    • Tarusa
    • Uglich
    • Vladimir
    • Yuriev-Polsky
    • Zubtsov
  • Characters
    • fmb_fyodor_konstantinovich_krasny
    • glm_davyd_konstantinovich_rurik
    • glm_fyodor_davydovich_rurik
    • glm_ivan_fyodorovich_rurik
    • kch_mstislav_mikhailovich_rurik
    • kch_svyatoslav_mstislavich_rurik
    • kch_panteleimon_mstislavich_rurik
    • kch_vasily_panteleimonovich_rurik
    • kch_andrei_mstislavich_rurik
    • kzk_titus_mstislavich_rurik
    • mos_sophia_yuriovna_rurik
    • prk_alexander_mikhailovich_rurik
    • prk_mikhail_yaroslavich_rurik
    • prk_yaroslav_alexandrovich_rurik
    • rya_konstantin_romanovich_rurik
    • rya_yaroslav_romanovich_rurik
    • tve_konstantin_mikhailovich_rurik
    • trs_yuri_mikhailovich_rurik
    • trs_konstantin_yurievich_rurik
    • yrv_yaroslav_ivanovich_rurik
  • Dynamic Names
    • Added tons of Dynamic Names
CORRECTIONS

Renamed the following:
  • Locations (only corrections. Additionally renamed all locations to standardized form):
    • Aksentevo to Berezovets
    • Alexandrov to Alexandrovskaya Sloboda
    • Ardatovo to Sergach
    • Beloye to Lipno (Lipnaya Gorka)
    • Belinsky to Chembar
    • Bezhetsk to Gorodetsk
    • Bolshoy Dvor to Ozerevo
    • Bolshoye Ignatovo to Altyshevo
    • Cheltsa to Kobyl'e
    • Cherepovets to Cherepoves
    • Dalen Olina to Dalniye Zelenstsy
    • Demyansk to Demon
    • Dyatkovo to Foshnya
    • Grad Mersky to Galich
    • Hotoshino to Khotoshino
    • Kaduy to Nikol'skoye
    • Karhumagi to Karhumägi
    • Kashkaransj to Kashkarantsy
    • Kexholm to Korela
    • Kharkiv to Donetsk
    • Khoza to Zaostrovskoye
    • Kildon to Kiltinä
    • Koivisto to Beryozovskoye
    • Kolgaczich to Unezhma
    • Koporje to Kopor'ye
    • Korop to Melnya
    • Kovoda to Kovda
    • Kovrov to Rozhdestveno
    • Kurovskoye to Rogozh
    • Lahdenpohja to Kurkijoki
    • Laptevo to Lopasnya
    • Lekanstroj to Akkala
    • Liissila to Lisino
    • Likhoslavl to Mednoye
    • Limenda to Pyras
    • Lindoserskij to Lindjärvi
    • Lokot to Boldyzh
    • Loymola to Loimola
    • Luskoje to Staropolye
    • Lyudinovo to Fominichi
    • Mafelskoj to Maaselkä
    • Makaryev to Unzha
    • Malaya Shuika to Maloshuyka
    • Maly Arkhangelsky to Tagin
    • Markkova to Markobo
    • Maselskiij to Maselga
    • Mena to Snovsk
    • Michurinsk to Kozlov
    • Mökhö to Möhkö
    • Molouskoj to Mootka
    • Morshansk to Morsha
    • Nev to Nebolchi
    • Noginsk to Vokhna
    • Nöteborg to Oreshek
    • Nyen to Neva
    • Okulovka to Lyubytino
    • Onegaborg to Shuya
    • Onega Peninsula to Nyonoksa
    • Opoka to Zaplyusye
    • Oryol to Zvenigorod
    • Paaanajärvi to Paanajärvi
    • Padanskij to Puatane
    • Panoimskoj to Panoi
    • Parfino to Nalyuchi
    • Peszenskoj to Luujärvi
    • Petrovskoye to Izberdey
    • Petzinka to Pechenga
    • Pialiska to Pyalitsa
    • Pienika to Pieninka
    • Plaskoye to Gogol
    • Pochinok to Belik
    • Podporozhye to Vinnitsy
    • Podyuga to Charonda
    • Porchov to Porkhov
    • Poretskoye to Atrat
    • Prokhorovka to Muzhech
    • Riistina to Ristiina
    • Rugosenskoj to Rukajärvi
    • Sarai to Kazari
    • Seletskij to Sellinkylä
    • Sem Ostronoj to Semiostrov
    • Semtsejerskij to Semčojärvi
    • Serdobsk to Serdobinskaya
    • Seredyna-Buda to Znobov
    • Sergiyev Posad to Yanovo
    • Shakhanovka to Krasavino
    • Shenkursk to Vaga
    • Shugozero to Spirkovo
    • Sigovets to Vazhiny
    • Sokol to Arkhangelskoye
    • Soligalich to Sol' Galichskaya
    • Soma to Saarijoki
    • Sonoshinskoi to Sumsky Posad
    • Spasskij to Vygozero
    • Stanovoye to Ploskoye
    • Starababa to Olenitsa
    • Stupino to Koshira
    • Suenokele to Suonikylä
    • Svetenoes to Svyatoy Nos
    • Taldom to Dubna
    • Trelina to Tetrino
    • Tsareva to Vekshenga
    • Tunga to Tunkuo
    • Tutayev to Romanov
    • Tyrö to Martyshkino
    • Uhtua to Uhtuo
    • Ust-Shonosha to Tavrenga
    • Ustyuzhna-Zheleznopolskaya to Ustyuzhna
    • Vartsila to Värtsilä
    • Vashky to Vashki
    • Vaskina Polyana to Staraya Ryazan
    • Vesyegonsk to Ves Yogonskaya
    • Voigoma to Kriitina
    • Volnushki to Luchani
    • Volokolamsk to Volok
    • Volovo to Terbuny
    • Vyazniki to Yaropolch
    • Warshiga to Varzuga
    • Yagnitsa to Lukoves
    • Yegoryevsk to Vysokoye
    • Yershichi to Zaroy
    • Zadonsk to Teshevka
    • Zaozyorye to Ustye
    • Zaraysk to Rostislavl-Ryazansky
    • Zhizdra to Usty
    • Zhizhitsa to Zhizhets
Cultures
  • Reworked the spread of cultures in the region.
Raw Goods
  • Changed several Raw Goods as suggested.
Terrain and Vegetation
  • Total Review.
Locations
  • Redrew several Locations.

Countries
View attachment 1228092
View attachment 1228093
In the first screenshot you can see the wider picture of the region, while in the second, we have the Russian Principalities more in detail. The main change here, besides the additions, is that most of them are now under the Tatar Yoke. Speaking of that, two more screenshots, the first with the IO itself, the second with the lands ruled by Ivan I 'Kalita', Prince of Muscovy:

View attachment 1228097
View attachment 1228098
The second screenshot is taken playing as Novgorod, which has an elective system to pick its ruler, the current one being Ivan I 'Kalita'; you may see that Pskov and Orshek are subjects of Novgorod, while the other Principalities share with Novgorod a Personal Union under the aforementioned Prince of Muscovy.

Dynasties
View attachment 1228100
The map of Russia is much clear when you just take into account the ruling dynasties... :p

Societies of Pops
View attachment 1228101
A map mode that we hadn't revealed yet when we first presented Russia, as a few more below.

Locations
View attachment 1228103
View attachment 1228104
View attachment 1228105

Provinces
View attachment 1228106

Areas
View attachment 1228107

Terrain
View attachment 1228108
View attachment 1228109
View attachment 1228110
Russia is in general terms a cold, flat, and forested region. The climate has already been changed to the new standard (1901 distribution). Please let us know any further terrain suggestions for us!

Development
View attachment 1228111
View attachment 1228113
Another new map, the development one. There's a big difference between the core lands, and the outer ones.

Harbors
View attachment 1228114
A few interesting harbors here.

Cultures
View attachment 1228115
Some tweaks here, as we now have Bjarmian, Polatskian, and Smolenskian spreading over the Russian map. It's WIP, so suggestions are welcome.

Languages
View attachment 1228116
View attachment 1228117
View attachment 1228118
This is our current proposal for Russia, following the feedback received, although take it as non-final. First, there are two Languages, Russian and Ruthenian, both belonging to the Slavic language family. Each of them is divided into two different 'Dialects' (remember, this is a gameplay term, as they're closer to real-life languages), Novgorodian and Russian for Russian, and Belarusian and Ukrainian for Ruthenian. The later terms are a bit modern for 1337, but we wanted to show here clearly what linguistical spheres we wanted to portray; we will gladly receive suggestions to potentially change these names for more flavorish ones if you think so. Finally, the third map is the Court Language, as you may notice because of having Latin over the Livonian and Prussian lands.

Religions
View attachment 1228124
Not many changes in the religious map mode. The main one is the portrayal of 'Finnish ancient religion' ('Suomalainen muinaisusko'), which we've called in-game 'Muinaisusko'; please let us know if you like this name, as well.

Raw Materials
View attachment 1228128
View attachment 1228129
I suggest you to make an exercise, and find the differences with the original Tinto Maps...

Markets
View attachment 1228130
Not many differences, but I thought that a bigger picture wouldn't hurt, as taking a look at another endonym possible with our new flavor system, 'Moskva'.

And that's all for today! We'll be reading your feedback to our feedback review (feedback loop!), and replying to your questions, as usual. The next Tinto Maps will be this Friday, the 13th, about Central America. Aaand, we will be able to have one more Tinto Maps Feedback post before the Christmas break, the one devoted to Levant and Egypt, next Monday, the 16th! Cheers!
why are there sunni majority in the middle of Lithuania? is it a bug?
 
Lipka Tatars were settled in Lithuania during Vytautas rule, not earlier so it indeed looks like a bug
According to the linked page, the first ones settled even before then, but should be Tengrist rather than Sunni
 
  • 1
Reactions:
I did not make a deep research, just briefly noticed that Wiki wrote about the first settlers at the beginning of the XIV century.
And a valid point here that they should be probably Tengri, not Sunni.
But yes, quite doubtful they were a majority back then.
 
Last edited:
  • 2Like
  • 1
Reactions:
The lenited g could have risen on its own like in Czech/Slovak, been borrowed from Iranian languages, or have been a “lazy” allophone of hard g for centuries and just happened to start dominating around 700-1300. Or any combination of the three working together.
Point is, it was definitely there before Ukrainian and Belarusian split between 1550 and 1700, and evidence points to it being there in 1337.
In any case, one sound does not define a language - there are other reasons for separating Russian and Ruthenian - and going down this argument was unnecessary semantics.
 
  • 2
Reactions:
Hello, and welcome to another Tinto Maps feedback review! This week, we will be taking a look at Russia, a very anticipated review (which Johan already advanced in some maps last week).

A note before we start on the area that we've covered in this update. We've focused it on the core Russian lands, plus the Kola Peninsula. This means we've not yet updated the lands of Vyatka and Perm, nor those ruled by the Golden Horde. These will be covered in the future Tinto Maps feedback post, probably the one for the Steppes and Western Siberia. With that said, let's take a look at the list of changes, and then start with maps!

ADDITIONS

Added the following:
  • Locations (153+ 55 Lakes + 6 Wastelands)
    • Andomsky Pogost
    • Ashevo
    • Azeevo
    • Badozhsky
    • Beloe
    • Berezhnyany
    • Bernovo
    • Bezhanitsy
    • Bibirevo
    • Bogorodskoye
    • Bogorodskoye (Pereyaslavl)
    • Bolshevo
    • Bor Volgo
    • Borisogleb
    • Brody (Tver)
    • Burga
    • Chelmuzhi
    • Chuzboy
    • Demyanovo
    • Drokov
    • Dubok
    • Dubrovna
    • Fomin Gorodok
    • Georgevskoye
    • Glukhovichi to Perevitska
    • Gorodechnya
    • Goroditse
    • Gruzino
    • Ilovna
    • Ivangorod
    • Izboishchi
    • Izdeshkovo
    • Izori
    • Karniki
    • Katyn
    • Khakhaly
    • Khatun
    • Khlepen
    • Kholm
    • Khotiml
    • Khotmyzh
    • Khotsy
    • Kinerma
    • Klepiki
    • Knyazhichi
    • Knyazhoye
    • Koi
    • Koloshma
    • Koponovo
    • Korenevo
    • Kosozhichi
    • Kozlov
    • Ktsyn
    • Kubenskoye
    • Kulotino
    • Kurba
    • Kuretsk
    • Kurmysh
    • Kuzhbal
    • Lezhnevo
    • Luda
    • Lyady
    • Lyakhovichy
    • Lyuban
    • Lyubichi
    • Lyubun
    • Lyubno
    • Maryovo
    • Megra
    • Megrino
    • Meletovo
    • Meshchersk
    • Mezhutka
    • Mikhailovka
    • Mikshino
    • Mikulino (Tver)
    • Moshok
    • Mushkov Pogost
    • Nadvoitsy
    • Nikolo Dor
    • Nikol'skoye
    • Nizhel'skoye
    • Nuorttijärvi
    • Obolensk
    • Odintsovo
    • Opalkova
    • Orekhovna
    • Ostrechiny
    • Pashozero
    • Petrovsk
    • Podberezye
    • Pogoreloye
    • Pogostishche
    • Poreevo
    • Pribuzh
    • (Krasnye) Prudy
    • (Serebryanye) Prudy
    • Pryazha
    • Przemysl
    • Pustosel
    • Putyvl
    • Radogosch
    • Rakitnya
    • Raznezhye
    • Revny
    • Rogachevo
    • Ropsk
    • Rozhalovo
    • Rzhavets
    • Rzheva Pustaya
    • Sevsk
    • Shal'skii
    • Shatur
    • Shchuchye
    • Shenga-Kurya
    • Shoptovo
    • Shui
    • Sol Velikaya
    • Spasskoye
    • Spasskoye (Lyskovo)
    • Starodub-Votsky
    • Sudai
    • Suikujärvi
    • Sumino
    • Svinort
    • Svir
    • Talitsa
    • Tervenichi
    • Tesov
    • Trufany
    • Ust Kuloy
    • Valday
    • Veliky Porog
    • Verba
    • Vereya
    • Vertyazin
    • Verzhavsk
    • Vetlitsy
    • Vichuga
    • Visokoye
    • Vlasovo
    • Vodlozero
    • Vognema
    • Volkona
    • Volodimerets
    • Voronizh
    • Vorotynsk
    • Vorotynsk (Novosil)
    • Vshchizh
    • Yeszk
    • Yorga
    • Zhulino
    • Zolotkovo
  • Lakes
    • Lake Bol'shoye Rovkul'skoye
    • Lake Chudzjavr
    • Lake Dvin'ye
    • Lake Engozero
    • Lake Galichkoye
    • Lake Gimoly
    • Lake Golodnaya Guba
    • Lake Goltsovoye
    • Lake Imandra
    • Lake Kamennoye
    • Lake Kenozero
    • Lake Kenozero (Near Ladoga)
    • Lake Kolozero
    • Lake Kolvitskoye
    • Lake Konchozero
    • Lake Kozhozero
    • Lake Kovdozero
    • Lake Kovzhskoye
    • Lake Kukkureozero
    • Lake Lednikovoye
    • Lake Leksozero
    • Lake Lindozero
    • Lake Lizhmozero
    • Lake Lokht'yarvi
    • Lake Lovozero
    • Lake Lyoksmozhero
    • Lake Maslozero
    • Lake Nero
    • Lake Notozero
    • Lake Nyuk
    • Lake Otradnoye
    • Lake Pal'vozero
    • Lake Peschanka-To
    • Lake Pleshcheyevo
    • Lake Pyaozero
    • Lake Seletsy
    • Lake Seliger
    • Lake Sergozero
    • Lake Shotozero
    • Lake Sredneye Kuyto
    • Lake Sumozero
    • Lake Suoyarvi
    • Lake Syamozero
    • Lake Tishkeozero
    • Lake Topozero
    • Lake Tulos
    • Lake Tungudskoye
    • Lake Umbozero
    • Lake Verkhneye Kuyto
    • Lake Volgo
    • Lake Vyalozero
    • Lake Vygozero
    • Lake Yelmozero
    • Lake Yenozero
    • Lake Zhizhitskoye
  • Wastelands
    • Divided many Wastelands in more pieces.
  • TAGs (15)
    • Fomin-Berezuesk
    • Galich-Mersky
    • Gorodets
    • Klin
    • Kozelsk
    • Novgorod-Seversky
    • Pronsk
    • Rylsk
    • Starodub
    • Suzdal
    • Tarusa
    • Uglich
    • Vladimir
    • Yuriev-Polsky
    • Zubtsov
  • Characters
    • fmb_fyodor_konstantinovich_krasny
    • glm_davyd_konstantinovich_rurik
    • glm_fyodor_davydovich_rurik
    • glm_ivan_fyodorovich_rurik
    • kch_mstislav_mikhailovich_rurik
    • kch_svyatoslav_mstislavich_rurik
    • kch_panteleimon_mstislavich_rurik
    • kch_vasily_panteleimonovich_rurik
    • kch_andrei_mstislavich_rurik
    • kzk_titus_mstislavich_rurik
    • mos_sophia_yuriovna_rurik
    • prk_alexander_mikhailovich_rurik
    • prk_mikhail_yaroslavich_rurik
    • prk_yaroslav_alexandrovich_rurik
    • rya_konstantin_romanovich_rurik
    • rya_yaroslav_romanovich_rurik
    • tve_konstantin_mikhailovich_rurik
    • trs_yuri_mikhailovich_rurik
    • trs_konstantin_yurievich_rurik
    • yrv_yaroslav_ivanovich_rurik
  • Dynamic Names
    • Added tons of Dynamic Names
CORRECTIONS

Renamed the following:
  • Locations (only corrections. Additionally renamed all locations to standardized form):
    • Aksentevo to Berezovets
    • Alexandrov to Alexandrovskaya Sloboda
    • Ardatovo to Sergach
    • Beloye to Lipno (Lipnaya Gorka)
    • Belinsky to Chembar
    • Bezhetsk to Gorodetsk
    • Bolshoy Dvor to Ozerevo
    • Bolshoye Ignatovo to Altyshevo
    • Cheltsa to Kobyl'e
    • Cherepovets to Cherepoves
    • Dalen Olina to Dalniye Zelenstsy
    • Demyansk to Demon
    • Dyatkovo to Foshnya
    • Grad Mersky to Galich
    • Hotoshino to Khotoshino
    • Kaduy to Nikol'skoye
    • Karhumagi to Karhumägi
    • Kashkaransj to Kashkarantsy
    • Kexholm to Korela
    • Kharkiv to Donetsk
    • Khoza to Zaostrovskoye
    • Kildon to Kiltinä
    • Koivisto to Beryozovskoye
    • Kolgaczich to Unezhma
    • Koporje to Kopor'ye
    • Korop to Melnya
    • Kovoda to Kovda
    • Kovrov to Rozhdestveno
    • Kurovskoye to Rogozh
    • Lahdenpohja to Kurkijoki
    • Laptevo to Lopasnya
    • Lekanstroj to Akkala
    • Liissila to Lisino
    • Likhoslavl to Mednoye
    • Limenda to Pyras
    • Lindoserskij to Lindjärvi
    • Lokot to Boldyzh
    • Loymola to Loimola
    • Luskoje to Staropolye
    • Lyudinovo to Fominichi
    • Mafelskoj to Maaselkä
    • Makaryev to Unzha
    • Malaya Shuika to Maloshuyka
    • Maly Arkhangelsky to Tagin
    • Markkova to Markobo
    • Maselskiij to Maselga
    • Mena to Snovsk
    • Michurinsk to Kozlov
    • Mökhö to Möhkö
    • Molouskoj to Mootka
    • Morshansk to Morsha
    • Nev to Nebolchi
    • Noginsk to Vokhna
    • Nöteborg to Oreshek
    • Nyen to Neva
    • Okulovka to Lyubytino
    • Onegaborg to Shuya
    • Onega Peninsula to Nyonoksa
    • Opoka to Zaplyusye
    • Oryol to Zvenigorod
    • Paaanajärvi to Paanajärvi
    • Padanskij to Puatane
    • Panoimskoj to Panoi
    • Parfino to Nalyuchi
    • Peszenskoj to Luujärvi
    • Petrovskoye to Izberdey
    • Petzinka to Pechenga
    • Pialiska to Pyalitsa
    • Pienika to Pieninka
    • Plaskoye to Gogol
    • Pochinok to Belik
    • Podporozhye to Vinnitsy
    • Podyuga to Charonda
    • Porchov to Porkhov
    • Poretskoye to Atrat
    • Prokhorovka to Muzhech
    • Riistina to Ristiina
    • Rugosenskoj to Rukajärvi
    • Sarai to Kazari
    • Seletskij to Sellinkylä
    • Sem Ostronoj to Semiostrov
    • Semtsejerskij to Semčojärvi
    • Serdobsk to Serdobinskaya
    • Seredyna-Buda to Znobov
    • Sergiyev Posad to Yanovo
    • Shakhanovka to Krasavino
    • Shenkursk to Vaga
    • Shugozero to Spirkovo
    • Sigovets to Vazhiny
    • Sokol to Arkhangelskoye
    • Soligalich to Sol' Galichskaya
    • Soma to Saarijoki
    • Sonoshinskoi to Sumsky Posad
    • Spasskij to Vygozero
    • Stanovoye to Ploskoye
    • Starababa to Olenitsa
    • Stupino to Koshira
    • Suenokele to Suonikylä
    • Svetenoes to Svyatoy Nos
    • Taldom to Dubna
    • Trelina to Tetrino
    • Tsareva to Vekshenga
    • Tunga to Tunkuo
    • Tutayev to Romanov
    • Tyrö to Martyshkino
    • Uhtua to Uhtuo
    • Ust-Shonosha to Tavrenga
    • Ustyuzhna-Zheleznopolskaya to Ustyuzhna
    • Vartsila to Värtsilä
    • Vashky to Vashki
    • Vaskina Polyana to Staraya Ryazan
    • Vesyegonsk to Ves Yogonskaya
    • Voigoma to Kriitina
    • Volnushki to Luchani
    • Volokolamsk to Volok
    • Volovo to Terbuny
    • Vyazniki to Yaropolch
    • Warshiga to Varzuga
    • Yagnitsa to Lukoves
    • Yegoryevsk to Vysokoye
    • Yershichi to Zaroy
    • Zadonsk to Teshevka
    • Zaozyorye to Ustye
    • Zaraysk to Rostislavl-Ryazansky
    • Zhizdra to Usty
    • Zhizhitsa to Zhizhets
Cultures
  • Reworked the spread of cultures in the region.
Raw Goods
  • Changed several Raw Goods as suggested.
Terrain and Vegetation
  • Total Review.
Locations
  • Redrew several Locations.

Countries
View attachment 1228092
View attachment 1228093
In the first screenshot you can see the wider picture of the region, while in the second, we have the Russian Principalities more in detail. The main change here, besides the additions, is that most of them are now under the Tatar Yoke. Speaking of that, two more screenshots, the first with the IO itself, the second with the lands ruled by Ivan I 'Kalita', Prince of Muscovy:

View attachment 1228097
View attachment 1228098
The second screenshot is taken playing as Novgorod, which has an elective system to pick its ruler, the current one being Ivan I 'Kalita'; you may see that Pskov and Orshek are subjects of Novgorod, while the other Principalities share with Novgorod a Personal Union under the aforementioned Prince of Muscovy.

Dynasties
View attachment 1228100
The map of Russia is much clear when you just take into account the ruling dynasties... :p

Societies of Pops
View attachment 1228101
A map mode that we hadn't revealed yet when we first presented Russia, as a few more below.

Locations
View attachment 1228103
View attachment 1228104
View attachment 1228105

Provinces
View attachment 1228106

Areas
View attachment 1228107

Terrain
View attachment 1228108
View attachment 1228109
View attachment 1228110
Russia is in general terms a cold, flat, and forested region. The climate has already been changed to the new standard (1901 distribution). Please let us know any further terrain suggestions for us!

Development
View attachment 1228111
View attachment 1228113
Another new map, the development one. There's a big difference between the core lands, and the outer ones.

Harbors
View attachment 1228114
A few interesting harbors here.

Cultures
View attachment 1228115
Some tweaks here, as we now have Bjarmian, Polatskian, and Smolenskian spreading over the Russian map. It's WIP, so suggestions are welcome.

Languages
View attachment 1228116
View attachment 1228117
View attachment 1228118
This is our current proposal for Russia, following the feedback received, although take it as non-final. First, there are two Languages, Russian and Ruthenian, both belonging to the Slavic language family. Each of them is divided into two different 'Dialects' (remember, this is a gameplay term, as they're closer to real-life languages), Novgorodian and Russian for Russian, and Belarusian and Ukrainian for Ruthenian. The later terms are a bit modern for 1337, but we wanted to show here clearly what linguistical spheres we wanted to portray; we will gladly receive suggestions to potentially change these names for more flavorish ones if you think so. Finally, the third map is the Court Language, as you may notice because of having Latin over the Livonian and Prussian lands.

Religions
View attachment 1228124
Not many changes in the religious map mode. The main one is the portrayal of 'Finnish ancient religion' ('Suomalainen muinaisusko'), which we've called in-game 'Muinaisusko'; please let us know if you like this name, as well.

Raw Materials
View attachment 1228128
View attachment 1228129
I suggest you to make an exercise, and find the differences with the original Tinto Maps...

Markets
View attachment 1228130
Not many differences, but I thought that a bigger picture wouldn't hurt, as taking a look at another endonym possible with our new flavor system, 'Moskva'.

And that's all for today! We'll be reading your feedback to our feedback review (feedback loop!), and replying to your questions, as usual. The next Tinto Maps will be this Friday, the 13th, about Central America. Aaand, we will be able to have one more Tinto Maps Feedback post before the Christmas break, the one devoted to Levant and Egypt, next Monday, the 16th! Cheers!
1744035467573.png
1744035749305.png


There is a problem with Ustye province having a location too far away from all the others
And the province of Ystyug (misspelled Ustyg) is extremely oddly shaped. I think Pyshchug, Nikolsk and Vokhma should be part of Orlov province or a separate one rather than part of Ustyug
 
  • 5
  • 2Like
  • 1
Reactions:
View attachment 1278010View attachment 1278012

There is a problem with Ustye province having a location too far away from all the others
And the province of Ystyug (misspelled Ustyg) is extremely oddly shaped. I think Pyshchug, Nikolsk and Vokhma should be part of Orlov province or a separate one rather than part of Ustyug
Also Ustye a bad choice for province name. It is literally just mouth of the river.
 
  • 3
  • 1Like
  • 1
Reactions:
View attachment 1278010View attachment 1278012

There is a problem with Ustye province having a location too far away from all the others
And the province of Ystyug (misspelled Ustyg) is extremely oddly shaped. I think Pyshchug, Nikolsk and Vokhma should be part of Orlov province or a separate one rather than part of Ustyug
Another problem is Shenkursk province. The actual location of Shenkursk is NW from Ileza (with a long hypenated native name) and belongs to Ustye province.
 
  • 2
  • 1Like
Reactions:
View attachment 1278010View attachment 1278012

There is a problem with Ustye province having a location too far away from all the others
And the province of Ystyug (misspelled Ustyg) is extremely oddly shaped. I think Pyshchug, Nikolsk and Vokhma should be part of Orlov province or a separate one rather than part of Ustyug
Also Ustye a bad choice for province name. It is literally just mouth of the river.
It's a mondegrin.
There is a local river called "Ust'ya" (Устья). A separate provincial entity is a historically correct observation: it was called "Ustya volosts". Allegedly, the province didn't extend this far North (didn't reach the Dvina river).
But Shenkursk province: it looks like it was usually called Vaga province instead. Shenkursk is consistently mentioned as a smaller administrative division than Vaga. This way, the borders won't need re-drawing: Vaga location will be included in Vaga province. One caveat: there might be other Vaga places in the world already.

This webpage contains a book with a few relevant maps:
1322158655_4ff9.jpg

1322158821_bc38.jpg
 
  • 1
Reactions:
It's a mondegrin.
There is a local river called "Ust'ya" (Устья). A separate provincial entity is a historically correct observation: it was called "Ustya volosts". Allegedly, the province didn't extend this far North (didn't reach the Dvina river).
But Shenkursk province: it looks like it was usually called Vaga province instead. Shenkursk is consistently mentioned as a smaller administrative division than Vaga. This way, the borders won't need re-drawing: Vaga location will be included in Vaga province. One caveat: there might be other Vaga places in the world already.

This webpage contains a book with a few relevant maps:
1322158655_4ff9.jpg

1322158821_bc38.jpg
Yes! I have also came by it a few times

1744112864845.png
1744112831563.jpeg


Personally, I believe it's better to make one province there called Vazhskaya zemla (or Vaga)

Here is my proposal for a border. Ust Kuloy (Kuloy today) should also be part of it
1744114929877.png

tbh, the location density there is too big, and developers should tolerate making provinces out of a lot of locations as that land was poorly delimited and poorly settled (or just make locations bigger)

About the Dvina river - I believe all of it was called Zavolochye or Podvinye (Dvinskaya zemla, Northern Dvina)

And I was incorrect with it there
Zavolochye is located incorrectly

View attachment 1228225

View attachment 1228224

What is called the Pomorye area is the correct Zavolochye
View attachment 1228226
A meaning of Zavolochye changed to be similar to Podvinye in the 13th century

Perhaps Podvinye is a better naming choice to not complicate matters
 
Last edited:
  • 2Like
  • 1
Reactions: